Sir John Valentine Carden Survives. Part 2.

The Australian War Museum states that the armour for the Type 95 Ha-Go varied between 6mm to 12mm. So, effectively tissue paper as far as a 25-pounder, firing an 11.5kg shell with up to 900g of HE filling, is concerned.

Yeah that would burst them like an over ripe tomato hurled at a wall. And really no tank in WW2 would like getting slapped by a 25lb HE shell. Even if it does not go through the armour the shock damage would be unpleasant for the crew inside.
 
With the way the war in North Africa about to be over for the time being I have to wonder if the the shortages in this case will be lessened to a degree. I mean with active operation effectively stoped in Europe till the Invasion of Italy and the Med effectively turning into a British and Commonwealth lake thanks to the Victories at Crete, effective destruction of the Italian navy at cape Matter Pan as well as Taranto, not suffering the reverses in NA they did holding and still holding Benghazi which means they can fly extra air craft into Malta as well as provide extra cover to say nothing of taking the Libyan ports.
Well they have Misrata, which is over 150 miles closer to Malta than Benghazi. Of course, once North Africa is secure, their attention can turn to other places, such as seizing Rhodes and the Dodecanese, and also the Pelagie Islands, and eventually Pantelleria.

A lot of pressure will come off in Europe which means it ,gives them a lot more time to fix the supply issue and work on developing and improving what they have already since they won’t be having to supply a front that ate up material like NA did. Though the Far East will be starting soon most of the supplies will probably come from India and ANZAC.
And Canada, thought it's somewhat more distant.

Not to knock a great post, but the OTL AP round for the 25pdr (which "only" weighed 20 pounds) was solid. like most WWII AP rounds. So unless the CAC have been doing some warhead research on the side, the big risk with 25pdr AP is that it just adds extra firing ports/ventilation holes to a Japanese tank without necessarily contacting anything vital on the way through.
I don't think they'd bother with AP, HE would insta-kill it anyway. Honestly, the HE rounds would probably use the tank as shrapnel.

Also, where are the Aussies fighting that the Japanese are fielding their good tanks against them? OTL the Chi-Ha medium tanks appeared in small numbers in Malaya/Burma and the Marianas, but the go-to Japanese tank for the Southwest Pacific (when they had any at all) was the dinky little type 95 Ha-Go light tank. Though with a max armour thickness of 25mm (gun mantlet only), the Japanese definition of "medium tank" was somewhat diverged from everyone else's. (Wikipedia doesn't list armour thickness for the Ha-Go, presumably out of pity).
Well the Aussies will be fighting in Malaya.

AFAIK Ha-Go had 12mm armour in vertical projections.
Ah, 'tin-cans on tracks'.
 
Well they have Misrata, which is over 150 miles closer to Malta than Benghazi. Of course, once North Africa is secure, their attention can turn to other places, such as seizing Rhodes and the Dodecanese, and also the Pelagie Islands, and eventually Pantelleria.
Yep, though, given that the Commando and Marines have been training up for that, it will probably be their bailiwick, at least initially, since they have amphibious tanks ready to iron out the kinks for that sort of operation. Though I think with the Greek Islands, they can afford to take their time with them to a degree since they are effectively trapped right now, so they can practice getting it squared away.
 

marathag

Banned
Ah, 'tin-cans on tracks'.
IJA Tanks were Fun-sized, like this Type 94
1658673032496.png
 
new zealand..... the bob semple
Did exactly what it was built for. Show the public the New Zealand government was doing all it could with what it had to defend against an unlikely Japanese landing.

Well yeah, a country with barely any industry, and a total population smaller than most national capitals isn't going to be producing many armoured vehicles, is it?
New Zealand built hundreds of Universal Carriers.
 
new zealand..... the bob semple
New Zealand also designed a tank far superior to the Semple: The Schofield Tank. It was still total crap by mid-WW2 standards, and it never entered service, but it WAS a better design than the Semple. Still, not a bad effort for a country that had never built a tank before and was starting from scratch, during a wartime invasion threat. For comparison, just examine the crappy "armoured" vehicles the British hastily pressed into service during the post-Dunkirk invasion panic, and the Brits HAD experience building tanks & armoured cars.

 
Last edited:
Top