Shuffling the Canon - A Shuffled Disney Canon TL


I'm starting an unshuffled Disney TL that'll be a side project until this TL is completed.
 

I'm starting an unshuffled Disney TL that'll be a side project until this TL is completed.
It will certainly be nice to look at as this TL continues.
 
Dumbo (2005)

In a studio Christmas party in 2001, Mark Dindal (a somewhat new director at Disney) first proposed a film following the likes of 1949's Chicken Little, but with a modern twist. It was said that Michael Eisner despised the idea and almost shut down Dindal's suggestion, but the project was greenlit after some persuasion. While not directly based of the Henny Penny fable, the film titled "Dumbo" would take inspiration from said fable and its 1949 adaptation. In the middle of 2002, it was decided that the film would be entirely CGI, being the first Disney film to do so.The script was also changed two more times before the final release in 2005.

In a small town, a young kid named Jimbo is accident prone and is an outcast of his school. One day, Jimbo discovers a hungry pack of wolves preparing to attack his town, he warns the townspeople but nobody believes him, making him the laughingstock of the town and giving him the nickname "Dumbo, the World's Dumbest Child". Jimbo's father Joe, not wanting to be involved with Jimbo's controversies, socially distances him from Jimbo. Only Jimbo's friends, the fat kid Buck and the short kid Tim, somewhat believe him. During a relay race at school, Jimbo, Buck and Tim miraculously wins the game and are declared heroes before immediately getting teased and shunned again.

At night, Jimbo discovers the pack of wolves once more, preparing to strike at the mayor's house. Jimbo warns the mayor but is disregarded, all the noise wakes up the rest of the neighbourhood and Jimbo is ridiculed again. The pack of wolves finally strikes and the town in sent into a frenzy. Jimbo discovers that the pack of wolves were only looking for their missing cub Woolie, he brings Woolie to the wolf pack and all is well. The wolves return to the forest and Jimbo is hailed hero of the town, giving him the nickname "Dumbo, the World's Dumbest Hero"

"Dumbo" premiered on October 30th 2005 and released nationwide on November 5th. While the film would be a mild box office success thanks to heavy advertising, the film was universally panned and bombed horrendously in terms of reception. Critics bashed the film for its lackluster plot, claiming that the film should've sticked to one singular story instead of jumping between various storylnes. Jimbo's dad was criticised for his overly antagonistic character, while Tim caused Disney to receive huge backlash as he had offensive resemblances to an autistic person. The only praise came from the CGI animation, which was quickly seen as dated as early as 2009. "Dumbo" became a huge stain in the Disney Canon and Disney fans today are currently holding a petition to remove "Dumbo" from the Disney Canon altogether.

The next film would be a step up, sort of.
I don’t know whether to laugh or cringe at how awful this version of Dumbo is 😭💀 I think it may somehow be an even worse version of OTL’s Chicken Little, which I didn’t think was even possible lol 🤣😂💀
 
I don’t know whether to laugh or cringe at how awful this version of Dumbo is 😭💀 I think it may somehow be an even worse version of OTL’s Chicken Little, which I didn’t think was even possible lol 🤣😂💀
I mean seriously. At least no one IOTL is petitioning to remove Chicken Little or Home On The Range from the WDAC and they at least have some fans, even if not many. This seems to be hated by literally everyone ITTL because of how bad it is.
 
I don’t know whether to laugh or cringe at how awful this version of Dumbo is 😭💀 I think it may somehow be an even worse version of OTL’s Chicken Little, which I didn’t think was even possible lol 🤣😂💀
Turns out it was possible. "Dumbo" actually got removed from the Disney Canon temporarily in 2016, but got re-added by 2019.
 
Aladdin (2007)
Aladdin (2007)

Before Disney's second CGI film, there was the traditionally animated Aladdin which was somewhat of a success. The idea of adapting the Arabic folktale dates back to 1950, when Walt first considered an adaptation of Aladdin before learning of MGM's own adaptation. "Aladdin" was brought up again in 1988 by Howard Ashman before Michael Eisner shot down the idea before it even started. An adaptation finally came to fruition in 2003, after Don Bluth created a 55 page long script and showed it to Eisner. Impressed by his work, Michael Eisner changed his mind and greenlit the project. Although Eisner would step down and replaced by Bob Iger shortly after the release of "Dumbo", Aladdin continued production and was released in 2007.

In ancient Arabia, a travelling merchant tells the story of Aladdin to sell a magic lamp. Aladdin is a street urchin who runs into the fair princess Jasmine who is disguised as a commoner, Jasmine is upset about the law which requires her to marry a prince instead of who she really loves, and falls in love with Aladdin after saving her from street thugs. Meanwhile, the sultan's advisor and wicked sorcerer Agrah desires to rule the land. Knowing that Aladdin is the one who is destinied to enter the Genie Cave, Jafar arrests Aladdin and demands that he retrieve the lamp and bring it to him. However, once Aladdin does get the lamp, Jafar banishes him in the cave, but not before Aladdin grabs the lamp and becomes the Genie's master.

Aladdin uses the lamp to become a wealthy prince, but in turn causes Jasmine to lose her affection for Aladdin. Jafar seizes this oppoturnity to woo Jasmine and gain power, but after Jasmine expectedly rejected him, Jasmine is locked up and Jafar prepares to strike Aladdin and seize the lamp for himself. Jafar unexpectedly succeeds and Aladdin loses the lamp. Aladdin quickly rushes to the palace, where he finds Jasmine locked up and Jafar in the sultan's place. Using his street smarts, Aladdin outsmarts Jafar and defeats him, turning him into a genie and trapping him in a lamp forever. Aladdin uses his last wish to undo all his wealth and the sultan lifts the law, allowing Aladdin and Jasmine to wed.

"Aladdin" premiered on March 23rd 2007 and released nationwide on March 30th. The film was a box office failure as people felt that Disney had fallen off after the disaster of "Dumbo". However, the people who did see it praised the film, especially its characters and memorable songs. Aladdin ended up as a box office hit in its 2011 re-release and over time, people have regarded the film as an underrated masterpiece, usually ranked No.1 on a Dark Era tier list.
 
Regarding Aladdin:

1. Robin Williams still voices the Genie.

2. Only "Friend Like Me" from OTL makes it to TTL's version, "A Whole New World" would be saved for the next film.
 
Strange World (2008)
Strange World (2008)

For Disney's second CGI film, Don Bluth came up with a tale revolving around space exploration. The project was greenlit in 2000 but was going nowhere, Don Bluth didn't know how to progress and the film was stuck in a development hell until 2006. It was then when Bluth remembered about a trip to Tokyo which inspired him to complete the script. Having learnt the mistakes from Dumbo, the CGI was greatly improved (although it is still dated by today's standards) and the film was completed and released in 2008.

Hideki, a young teenage boy wants to explore Japan and its surroundings. At the same time, Hideki wants to woo his crush Sakura at school, he would get the chance at a school dance but miserably fail. Meanwhile in the Under World, the empreor Zokudo seeks to rise from the under world and take over Japan. Zokudo's underlings prepare a portal in form of a sinkhole, intended for Zokudo to travel to the surface. Instead, Hideki accidentally falls into the portal and lands into the Under World, prompting him to explore this newfound area.

Hideki meets the friendly monster child named Yaki, who introduces him to the under world in the form of "A Whole New World". Yaki also warns Hideki of Zokudo and his evil plans, Zokudo appears as if he had been mocked. Zokudo traps Hideki and Yaki in a cage and travels to the surface, where he intends to wreck havoc upon Japan. With the help of a few rebellious underlings, Hideki and Yaki escape just in time to find Sakura in the hands of Zokudo. Hideki rescues Sakura and banishes Zokudo back to the under world, where his underlings overthrow him after so many failed attempts. Sakura accepts Hideki and the two are permitted to return to the Under World any time they like.

"Strange World" premiered on November 17th 2008 and released nationwide on November 21st. The film was a box office success and earned generally positive reception. The CGI was praised for its great improvement compared to "Dumbo" before it, and the soundtrack became the highest selling movie soundtrack disc of the 2000s, with "A Whole New World" being praised. While not as good as "Aladdin" which released the year before "Strange World", the film remains a fan favourite of many, even if it is flaws in some ways.

The next film however, would be a dissapointment to many.
 
Hints for the remainder of the Disney Canon:

2011: Many consider the film as underrated both ITTL and IOTL
2012: Weather is a major element
2013: A folktale
2014/2016a/2022: Based of a book
2016b: A hated film IOTL
2018: Does not take place in Europe
2019: Takes place in Europe
2021a: Known for its comedy both ITTL and IOTL
2021b: Animals are the main focus
2023: Music is an element in this film, may or may not be a major one
 
The Fox and the Hound (2009)
The Fox and the Hound (2009)

If there was one thing nobody expected from Disney, it was a package film long after the wartime era. "The Fox and the Hound" were originally developed as two seperate films, both dating back to the Renaissance Era. In 1994 after "Melody Time", Howard Ashman brought in a collection of books from Roald Dahl, and after drawing out of a hat, chose "Fantastic Mr Fox". At the same time, a script starring a wannabe superhero was in production, directed by Don Bluth. However, both films were stuck in a production quagmire and was going nowhere. Taking inspiration from the Wartime Era, Bob Iger proposed to merge both projects into a package film, mixing both traditional animation and CGI together. "The Fox and the Hound" was completed and finally released in 2009 after 15 years in development hell.

The film's two segments are "Fantastic Mr Fox" and "The Super Hound", with Jim Carrey (who had previously voiced Captain Hook) serving as a framing device by introducing the two segments.

The first segment was "Fantastic Mr Fox" done with traditional animation. Based of the Roald Dahl book, Mr Fox lives in his underground burrow where he steals chickens from Boggis, Bunce and Bean's farm every night. The trio ambushes him one night but only manages to shoot off his tail, Mr Fox and his family dig deep underground to avoid the farmers, who wait for Mr Fox to pop his head out and catch him. Mr Fox and his family begisn to strave, and need immediate access to food. Mr Fox burrows to the farm and steals poultry, but runs into the Badger, Weasel, Mole and Rabbit families on their way back. To compensate for their starvation, Mr Fox hosts a grand dinner party and starts an underground tunnel city, where the farmers would never be able to catch them. Now the animals would never go hungry again.

The second segment was "The Super Hound" done with CGI. An original tale by Don Bluth, the story tells the tale of Copper, a hound dog who works as an actor. Believing he's a superhero, a cliffhanger episode causes Copper to believe that the world is in grave danger. Copper rushes off the "save the day", but gets knocked onto a plane headed to New York City. There, Copper discovers that his superpowers are not real and meets up with a stray cat named Mittens. Mittens agrees to guide Copper back to Hollywood, and in their journey, Copper learns that there is more to life than being a superhero or an actor. When he gets back to Hollywood, Copper is tasked with saving the studio which has caught on fire, proving himself to be an actual hero.

"The Fox and the Hound" premiered on November 25th 2009 and released nationwide on December 11th. Expectedly, reception was mixed and the response to the two segments were polarised. While audiences praised the "Fantastic Mr Fox" segment, "The Super Hound" segment was criticised for its weak plot and its overall presentation. "Fantastic Mr Fox" was no doubt the crown jewel of the entire film, but that wasn't without its own controversies. Wes Anderson's own adaptation of "Fantastic Mr Fox" had released a few weeks prior, and both parties accused each other of plagarism and even resulted in a lawsuit. Fortunately, the lawsuit went nowhere and the case was closed, with animation historians ruling the controversy as just a mere coincidence.

"The Fox and the Hound" would not be the last package film however, that honor would go to the studio's next film...
 
The second segment was "The Super Hound" done with CGI. An original tale by Don Bluth, the story tells the tale of Copper, a hound dog who works as an actor. Believing he's a superhero, a cliffhanger episode causes Copper to believe that the world is in grave danger. Copper rushes off the "save the day", but gets knocked onto a plane headed to New York City. There, Copper discovers that his superpowers are not real and meets up with a stray cat named Mittens. Mittens agrees to guide Copper back to Hollywood, and in their journey, Copper learns that there is more to life than being a superhero or an actor. When he gets back to Hollywood, Copper is tasked with saving the studio which has caught on fire, proving himself to be an actual hero.
I did not think that TTL's The Fox and the Hound would have the same plot as OTL's Bolt. That being said, what will happen in TTL's version of Bolt instead?
 
2011: Atlantis: The Lost Empire
2012: Bolt
2013: The Princess and the Frog
2014: The Sword in the Stone
2016a: 101 Dalmatians
2016b: Brother Bear
2018: The Jungle Book
2019: The Hunchback of Notre Dame
2021a: The Emperor's New Groove
2021b: Lady and the Tramp
2022: Meet the Robinsons
2023: Make Mine Music
The Princess and the Frog has already been done in 1942.
 
The Adventures of Lady and Mr Tramp (2010)
The Adventures of Lady and Mr Tramp (2010)

For the studio's next film, Don Bluth wanted to emulate the style of the golden age, more specifically the 1940s. Like "The Fox and the Hound", the film was originally developed as two seperate films, but got merged together half a year before its release. The first segment was a loose adaptation of "Little Women", which was stuck in a development limno as Bluth felt the film to be too boring and dull. The second segment was a original film inspired by the "Rhapsody in Blue" segment from Melody Time, the animation wasn't sophisticated enough to qualify as a feature film, and Bluth merged both projects together into one after "The Fox and the Hound" released.

The film is seperated into two traditionally animated segments, "Lady" and "The Tramp", with Jiminy Cricket from 1950's "Pinocchio" serving as a framing device by introducing each segment.

The first segment "Lady" tells the story of Meg, a young woman living in rural Kansas with her three sisters. Because of her being clever and wise, she is nicknamed "The Lady" by everyone in her family. As Meg's father leaves Kansas for a job in the big city, Meg is tasked with keeping her sisters in control, feeding the animals at the barnyard and serving her mother, who is gravely ill. Through her adventures, Meg builds resilience to whatever comes her way, and builds a strong relationship with her sisters. Eventually her mother is cured and her father returns home with stocks of cash.

The second segment "The Tramp" takes place in depression-era America, where a lonely jobless Tramp is hunger-stricken and poor. Tramp wanders around the city trying to find a job and keep himself alive for the time being, but runs into street thugs and police officers. Eventually, the Tramp loses all hope and sits down near a street lamp, but when he spots an ad for a job, he is overjoyed. The Tramp is emploed and soon begins to earn enough for food.

"The Adventures of Lady and Mr Tramp" premiered on November 14th 2010 and released nationwide on November 24th. Being another package film, reception was mostly negative but it still earned some praise, which was mostly for "The Tramp". The second segment was praised heavily by those who liked the film, even questioning why it wasn't a full length feature as it was originally produced as. As for the first segment, audiences criticised "Lady" for being too boring and a blantant attempt to modernise a classic novel. "Lady" would be mostly forgotten about today while "The Tramp" would be reissued as a seperate featurette throughout the decade.

Many wondered if Disney would continue to make package films, and many wondered if Disney would ever return to classic storytelling ever again. Fortunately, Disney did indeed return to its roots, and boy did they deliver...
 
2000s Animation Recap
The 2000s marked an end to the Disney Renaissance, but not animation overall. The industry continued to flourish throughout the decade, with multiple new studios forming and closing:

Warner Bros: As the company overall started becoming more corporate, so did the animation studio. With the animation division returning to its former glory by the 1990s, Warner Bros began seeking to purchase more IPs and outsourcing studios, such as Cartoon Network in 1999 and Nickelodeon in 2004 (they bought it from Paramount which we'll get to soon). As for the films themselves, Warner Bros consistently pumped out hit film after hit film, but this came with a cost: They knew audiences would flock to theaters to see a Warner Bros film no matter what, that and their rival Disney releasing mediocre films such as 2005's Dumbo made it all the more apparent for Warner Bros to apply the "quantity over quality" approach.

MGM: MGM was doing quite well in the 2000s. Their films had consistent quality with only one bad film fromt the entire decade, that being 2007's "The Legend of Skull Rock". Meanwhile, MGM began shifting focus to home video, DVDs had just became the norm as the millennium clocked in. Tom and Jerry media sold immensely, and MGM knew that this would be a new source of revnue. There isn't really much to say about MGM, their films performed a lot better than Disney's but that's about it.

Paramount: "Ice Age" released in 2001 to critical acclaim, blasting Disney's "Winnie the Pooh Tooh" out of the box office. Seeing the film's success, Paramount purchased Blue Sky Studios and absorbed its assests into Paramount's own animation division. "Ice Age" became Paramount's new cash cow franchise, only second to Popeye and Hoppity. A sequel to said film was released in 2006 and a follow-up to that was released in 2009, with more installments to come. However, Paramount would lose one of their most important broadcasting divisions "Nickelodeon" to Warner Bors in 2004 after a hefty purchase, but it wasn't too harsh as Paramount already had a new studio at their hands. "Ice Age" ensured that Paramount would thrive for the next few decades.

Dreamworks Animation: Like Paramount with "Ice Age", Dreamworks's new film "Shrek" released to critical acclaim and quickly became Dreamworks's go-to mascot. Katzenberg was satsified and greenlit a sequel to "Shrek", while also starting development on "Madagascar", a film set in deep Africa. Within only a span of ten years, Dreamworks had became a key player in animaion, with almost all their films beating out Disney by a landslide. It seemed like smooth sailing from here on out.
 
Top