I wonder has the Great Pacific War reversed most of the Post-Klein era changes to the USN? Having two competing US Navies in the form of the USN and USCG has to have bitten the US in the ass and the pressures of the war probably meant that the distinction between the Coast Guard and Navy ceased to relevant
Yep, the USA undid most of that during the war itself. The USCG and the USN were temporarily merged together, and they're trying to figure out what to do with them now that the war's over.
Typically, though, that's not how politics operate. There are a huge raft of concerns to be considered beyond the simple calculus of economies of scale and military spending. Politicians in New Zealand would be loathe to give up the powers of a national government to become a province of a much larger country. Australians don't want to assume the national debts of the NZ government. Maori New Zealanders don't want to be treated like Aboriginal Australians. And so on.
I suspect military and economic cooperation will continue to increase - but voluntary unification is an immense and difficult political step. So often we see this glossed over in TLs - "1947: New Zealand and Australia unify into the Glorious People's Republic of Oceania" - without any consideration of the political and cultural realities that would allow such as step. Look at European integration - despite strong economic and political drive, it's taken many decades to get to where they are today, and with plenty of backsteps along the way. Look at the slow unification of Germany. Look at Italy. Look at Puerto Rico and the United States.
History isn't a board game and countries aren't just territories on a map.
I think EBR has done a magnificent job of representing those realities while building from the cartoonish foundations of the Draka series, and I don't know why he'd stop now.
Well thank you.
The way I see it, New Zealand and Australia have pretty strong independent national identities and while some kind of Australasian Union wouldn't be impossible in a TL with the right divergence and butterflies, that's not really the situation here. The Tasman twins are pretty scared, what with the USA turning inwards and Japan and India next door, but a tight Australasian alliance isn't any noticeably weaker than an Australian Union would be.
There's not much that I can say here without giving things away, but this is some nice analysis.
I suspect the silver lining for the US is that they will have the superior economic ands political system in the long run. The Drakian bondage-based system is hardly conducive to dynamic free enterprise and innovation, not to mention the immense economic and political cost of repression...
Without question.
The Drakian economic system will
never be as efficient or as innovative as the American one. It's telling that Drakia technology isn't known for being advanced ITTL, it's known for being robust and easy to repair (because it has to function from the Sahara Deseret to the Central African jungle) and that Drakia has only managed to compete with the rest of the world technologically by being very fast to adopt
other countries' discoveries.
Starting Atlantropa would likely be a casus belli with France and Italy, and by extension the Rexist bloc and possibly the USA (which protects France) as well...
Yeah. And while the Pan-Europeans aren't in any position to start a war with Drakia, Drakia's not interested in starting a new war with Europe at the moment.
I realize this is an often debated topic with some believing that war drives innovation and as highlighted here "discoveries". The obvious counterargument here is that discoveries are equally made in peace times, if not more so, because people can experiment more freely. Dorknought provided some interesting data supporting the notion that wars kill innovation
here.
It is certainly an interesting topic to debate.
My view is that war drives innovation in the short-term because governments are willing to sink large amounts of funding and resources into exploring avenues of scientific research, and developing new inventions into mature technologies because they're desperate for the next war-winning weapon. Naturally an increased investment in science yields returns. In the long-run however, remaining on a war footing limits the free sharing of ideas needed for science to flourish, and it limits the number of potential researchers and scientists by diverting able-bodied citizens into the military.
The faster technological advancement ITTL is in large part due to having war-time level investment in research during peacetime without the same degree of censorship and secrecy (a higher degree over all, but not as high you normally see during wars).
What percentage of Drakia is citizens? And where are they concentrated?
Good question. I'll try to remember to address that when we get around to discussing the Empire post-war.
Chapter 31 is coming, by the way, hopefully early next week.