Rumsfeldia: Fear and Loathing in the Decade of Tears

Status
Not open for further replies.
At this point, I'm not sure if I would want the country in one piece, let alone.

I'm not saying a civil war is a good thing, but if American society could get this horrible, if the middle class and corporate America could get so rapacious, I'm not sure the USA would be worth saving.

The new President Denton allowed an innocent Senator to be dragged away for voicing his opinion. Despite his current regrets, he only has them now that he's comfortably in power, not when it mattered. More importantly, none of the rest of Congress, aside from Senators Bentsen and Pell, lifted one finger to help Pryor.

If your remember Ben Franklin's phrase about national security, I would emphasize the part about "not deserving of freedom or security". At this point, I don't think a united America deserves anything but the "holy, righteous ways" they'll get with the CVs.

Okay, that is slightly masochistic. On the other hand, the fact that a leading presidential candidate in OTL 2016 is a quasi-Zhirinovsky with an authoritarian personality who proposes George Lincoln Rockwell-style ethnic cleansing might be influencing you a bit too much!
 
At this point, I'm not sure if I would want the country in one piece, let alone.

I'm not saying a civil war is a good thing, but if American society could get this horrible, if the middle class and corporate America could get so rapacious, I'm not sure the USA would be worth saving.

The new President Denton allowed an innocent Senator to be dragged away for voicing his opinion. Despite his current regrets, he only has them now that he's comfortably in power, not when it mattered. More importantly, none of the rest of Congress, aside from Senators Bentsen and Pell, lifted one finger to help Pryor.

If your remember Ben Franklin's phrase about national security, I would emphasize the part about "not deserving of freedom or security". At this point, I don't think a united America deserves anything but the "holy, righteous ways" they'll get with the CVs.

What the fuck does that have to do with an America without Rumsfeld?
 
I have a question for Where Are They Now?

Grover Norquist is a rather (in)famous conservative figure noted for saying he wanted government to be small enough to drown it in the bathtub, how has he developed in this timeline?
 
I have a question for Where Are They Now?

Grover Norquist is a rather (in)famous conservative figure noted for saying he wanted government to be small enough to drown it in the bathtub, how has he developed in this timeline?

Probably disillusioned with how his dream came out.
 
John Denver - balladeer of the American diaspora

Bernie Sanders - a democratic socialist in Rumsfeld's America - isn't that the equivalent of a snowball in Hell? My guess, he went for a hike in Northern Vermont one day and kept going north until he came to a town where all the locals were speaking French. After that he joined the NDP, or came back to join the WTP.

Howard Zinn - See Bernie Sanders. Most likely teaching in Canada.

Chris Hedges - WTP activist and writer

Rick Perlstein - Yes I've read Nixonland and The Invisible Bridge, can't wait for his accounts of Wallace and Rumsfeldia :) Right now he's a teenager in Fox Point with parents who are establishment Republicans (a survival measure if not a true belief).

John S. Rumsfeld - yes, another Rumsfeld. Only this one is so pissed-off with people associating his name with the other guy that's he an active supporter of President McCloskey.

Adam Curtis (documentary filmmaker) - anti-Tory Libertarian filmmaker.

John Hughes - in California trying to revive Hollywood

Johnny Carson - I'd say that he might have originally been a supporter of Rumsfeld but now he is supporting President McCloskey

James May - auto journalist; writing about the revived British auto industry

Jeremy Clarkson - BBC presented

Richard Hammond - high school I'd say

Michael Palin - I commented on the Pythons before, but you are correct that 80Days, Pole-to-Pole, Sahara and Brazil are impractical ITTL. He could do one on the trans-Siberian, the Orient Express, maybe Iran. He's probably become a train lover.

Shoko Asahara - still a top drawer nutter. Probably under close surveillance by the revived Kempeitai

Abbie Hoffman, Jerry Rubin - I seem to recall killing one of these guys in FLG'72 sometime around 1975. The survivor would be involved with the WTP. Both committed suicide OTL, I can imagine that Rumsfeldia would drive them even deeper into depression.

Bobby Seale - AAFP and WTP activist. Possible warlord of Chicago.

Sophia Loren - Starring in Europe and happy to be there (after paying her back taxes in Italy)

Islam Karimov - Soviet Minister of Nationalities

Simon Schama - He took a break from writing Citizens to write a groundbreaking account comparing the administrations of Wallace and Rumsfeld to the Gracchi, Julius Ceasar and Augustus around how excessive populism leads to strongman government and the destruction of Republican government, then and now. A best sellers (well, outside of Rumsfeldia, anyway). They even allowed him to publish it in Russian in the USSR, and in an experiment, allowed Schama to keep (most of) the Soviet royalties.

Richard Curtis (screenwriter) - the real Blackadder

Tom Lehrer - nervous breakdown

Sam Walton - discount store operator and Rumsfeld corporate supporter - but lucky for him he gave lots of money to the CV as well.
 

bookmark95

Banned
What the fuck does that have to do with an America without Rumsfeld?

What I mean to say is I feel the CVs would be the ultimate karma for those who stood by as their neighbors and political representatives were dragged off.

I feel that Jeremiah Denton deserves to be dragged off himself for letting a US Senator (Mark Pryor) be removed for opposing Rummy's policies.
 
What I mean to say is I feel the CVs would be the ultimate karma for those who stood by as their neighbors and political representatives were dragged off.

I feel that Jeremiah Denton deserves to be dragged off himself for letting a US Senator (Mark Pryor) be removed for opposing Rummy's policies.

Perhaps in the future, when or if there is a truth and reconciliation period for this TL. For now, he's what you got.
 

bookmark95

Banned
"Where are they now?"

Ann Richards

Barbara Jordan- I'm guessing she is the chairperson of We The People in Texas

Dick Lamm- Last I heard he was still Governor of Colorado, but I wonder if Rummy singled him out as a target. Lamm was the man denied the Vice Presidency, and he probably would oppose Rumsfeld's corporatism. Lamm also drafted the nation's first abortion law and OTL supported physician assisted suicide, so Rummy would indict him in order to gain support of conservative Christians. If Rummy didn't target him, the CVs certainly would. On the another hand, I assume he would be safe in Colorado, which could easily become a Libertarian stronghold.

Trey Parker and Matt Stone- I imagine them being young Libertarian activists out in Colorado. I'm betting that the Libertarian strongholds offer the last bit of create freedom left in the lower 48.

Tom Tancredo

Paul Laxalt

Harry Reid

Nolan Bushnell

Daniel Inouye- What's happen to him now that his state has seceded?

Richard Shelby-

John Stennis-

Gary Johnson- He was mentioned in FLaG as having become a major Libertarian Party figure.

Al Sharpton

Bob Hoskins

John Engler- I bet he ditched the Republican Party right now.

The McCloksey Seven- Have they been locked up in an asylum?
 
Cambodia will come under pressure to clean-up its act from its neighbours, and if not I can see this happening with South Vietnam being the invader, with support from Thailand and Malaysia (among others). An alternative would be a military coup supported by the neighbours followed by a junta under their influence.

Whether they like each other or not, Thailand, South Vietnam, Malaysia, Singapore, the Phillippines and perhaps even Indonesia all have a interest in trading as well developing their defence infrastructure. They may even see the need for a form of common market to support their developing economies. They have a strategic interest in preserving Bangladesh, Myanmar, Laos and North Vietnam* as buffers against the chaos in China and India (much as Ryzhkov promotes the rump PRC and North Korea as buffers so he doesn't have send his military into the morass that is ITTL China and sink his economy in the process).

One of the key strategic infrastructure projects would be a Bangkok to Saigon roadway (and/or railroad) which would not only serve business interests but provide a southern defence link across the region. Cambodia being in the middle, would necessarily have to be brought into the scheme under a tamed government.

All of the developing nations would also be good customers of the British and French arms markets and may even be looking at what the new Japanese armaments industries have to offer.

* So the South Vietnamese President Ngô Quang Trưởng promotes a policy of Ostpolitik (or Nordpolitk) with his Northern neighbour aimed at more than just a possible reunification.
 
John Denver - balladeer of the American diaspora

Bernie Sanders - a democratic socialist in Rumsfeld's America - isn't that the equivalent of a snowball in Hell? My guess, he went for a hike in Northern Vermont one day and kept going north until he came to a town where all the locals were speaking French. After that he joined the NDP, or came back to join the WTP.

Howard Zinn - See Bernie Sanders. Most likely teaching in Canada.

Chris Hedges - WTP activist and writer

Rick Perlstein - Yes I've read Nixonland and The Invisible Bridge, can't wait for his accounts of Wallace and Rumsfeldia :) Right now he's a teenager in Fox Point with parents who are establishment Republicans (a survival measure if not a true belief).

John S. Rumsfeld - yes, another Rumsfeld. Only this one is so pissed-off with people associating his name with the other guy that's he an active supporter of President McCloskey.

Adam Curtis (documentary filmmaker) - anti-Tory Libertarian filmmaker.

John Hughes - in California trying to revive Hollywood

Johnny Carson - I'd say that he might have originally been a supporter of Rumsfeld but now he is supporting President McCloskey

James May - auto journalist; writing about the revived British auto industry

Jeremy Clarkson - BBC presented

Richard Hammond - high school I'd say

Michael Palin - I commented on the Pythons before, but you are correct that 80Days, Pole-to-Pole, Sahara and Brazil are impractical ITTL. He could do one on the trans-Siberian, the Orient Express, maybe Iran. He's probably become a train lover.

Shoko Asahara - still a top drawer nutter. Probably under close surveillance by the revived Kempeitai

Abbie Hoffman, Jerry Rubin - I seem to recall killing one of these guys in FLG'72 sometime around 1975. The survivor would be involved with the WTP. Both committed suicide OTL, I can imagine that Rumsfeldia would drive them even deeper into depression.

Bobby Seale - AAFP and WTP activist. Possible warlord of Chicago.

Sophia Loren - Starring in Europe and happy to be there (after paying her back taxes in Italy)

Islam Karimov - Soviet Minister of Nationalities

Simon Schama - He took a break from writing Citizens to write a groundbreaking account comparing the administrations of Wallace and Rumsfeld to the Gracchi, Julius Ceasar and Augustus around how excessive populism leads to strongman government and the destruction of Republican government, then and now. A best sellers (well, outside of Rumsfeldia, anyway). They even allowed him to publish it in Russian in the USSR, and in an experiment, allowed Schama to keep (most of) the Soviet royalties.

Richard Curtis (screenwriter) - the real Blackadder

Tom Lehrer - nervous breakdown

Sam Walton - discount store operator and Rumsfeld corporate supporter - but lucky for him he gave lots of money to the CV as well.

The fates of Simon Schama and Michael Palin are interesting:cool:.
 
Southern Asia is one of the places that somehow managed to be better off TTL compared to OTL. I wouldn't be surprised indeed if France and Britain revive their links with the region as part of the Commonwealth and Francophonie. French language will also have a much higher status and prestige in former Indochina TTL than OTL.

I can't help but think that in a way this timeline puts the "West" (if one include the Soviets there in a civilizational sense) in a much stronger strategic position relative to OTL all things considered. Sure the United States have been severly weakened. But Europe is somehow better off, the Soviet Union is better off economically. China as is out of the picture as any kind of competitor. A fragmented India will never become a force to reckon with and some of the leftover states will struggle with huge issues like the caste system etc on their own.

TTL 2010 is almost a rehearsal of OTL 1910, Europe dominant, Japan and America rising or re-rising and everyone else bar some exceptions is too poor to matter.
 
What I mean to say is I feel the CVs would be the ultimate karma for those who stood by as their neighbors and political representatives were dragged off.

I feel that Jeremiah Denton deserves to be dragged off himself for letting a US Senator (Mark Pryor) be removed for opposing Rummy's policies.

But you said...

At this point, I'm not sure if I would want the country in one piece, let alone.

I'm not saying a civil war is a good thing, but if American society could get this horrible, if the middle class and corporate America could get so rapacious, I'm not sure the USA would be worth saving.

The new President Denton allowed an innocent Senator to be dragged away for voicing his opinion. Despite his current regrets, he only has them now that he's comfortably in power, not when it mattered. More importantly, none of the rest of Congress, aside from Senators Bentsen and Pell, lifted one finger to help Pryor.

If your remember Ben Franklin's phrase about national security, I would emphasize the part about "not deserving of freedom or security". At this point, I don't think a united America deserves anything but the "holy, righteous ways" they'll get with the CVs.

In response to this

Drew did mention earlier that this TL was meant to show, however bad the Bush '43 years were, they could've been far, far worse.

You know, I was thinking about another piece, where Drew talked about how the extensiveness of the TL allows for mini-PODs to form within the larger narrative. I was thinking about what the country would look like, if Hugh Carey had won in 1980, rather than Rumsfeld, and Rumsfeldia was completely averted. Sure, the country might not have completely recovered, but at least it would still be one piece.

How are the two related? Why would you want America to fall apart even if Rumsfeldia never happens?
 

bookmark95

Banned
But you said...



In response to this



How are the two related? Why would you want America to fall apart even if Rumsfeldia never happens?

Maybe I'm being too vague.

I don't want America to fall apart.

But if the US could get this bad, and if the CVs utterly wreck it, my pity would be small because the vast majority of Americans allowed things to slide to this point.
 
Maybe I'm being too vague.

I don't want America to fall apart.

But if the US could get this bad, and if the CVs utterly wreck it, my pity would be small because the vast majority of Americans allowed things to slide to this point.


As I've said in the past, the chickens are coming home to roost. Many innocents will get caught up in the CV madness, but if a two-time Rumsfeld voter and longtime supporter of Rumsfeldism in general, who expressed relief every time one of those "America-hating liberal bastards" had a nervous breakdown, or was giddy at the sight of already-poor people becoming completely destitute while they hid behind a gated community, if they suddenly find themselves working 12 hour days in the hot sun picking crops, their home appropriated by the local pastor, or hauled before a Holy Tribunal for the crime of not expressing enough adulation for the joys of living the way "God" intended, then they would have no sympathy from me. They sowed the wind, and now they reap the whirlwind.
 
If we're going to do the whole "American Rome" analogue as Gore Vidal did, then perhaps the real "American Augustus" won't be FDR, but Richard Nixon. I seriously wonder what the restored USA will look like as a political entity. If there's such an outcome anyway...
 

bookmark95

Banned
As I've said in the past, the chickens are coming home to roost. Many innocents will get caught up in the CV madness, but if a two-time Rumsfeld voter and longtime supporter of Rumsfeldism in general, who expressed relief every time one of those "America-hating liberal bastards" had a nervous breakdown, or was giddy at the sight of already-poor people becoming completely destitute while they hid behind a gated community, if they suddenly find themselves working 12 hour days in the hot sun picking crops, their home appropriated by the local pastor, or hauled before a Holy Tribunal for the crime of not expressing enough adulation for the joys of living the way "God" intended, then they would have no sympathy from me. They sowed the wind, and now they reap the whirlwind.

Thank you for articulating my thoughts better than I could. (But I also think a person who voted twice for CV is not going to enjoy the CSA very much either).

But I also hope that Americans, humbled by the utter collapse of their country, will learn from their mistakes a build a more progressive country,
 

bookmark95

Banned
If we're going to do the whole "American Rome" analogue as Gore Vidal did, then perhaps the real "American Augustus" won't be FDR, but Richard Nixon. I seriously wonder what the restored USA will look like as a political entity. If there's such an outcome anyway...

Popular votes will be a part of the Constitution. It's the wackiness of the Electoral College that allowed Rummy to slither into power with less than 40 percent of the vote.

Limits on presidential power.

Stronger states' rights, except no Jim Crow.
 
I wonder if there will be any sort of European/European-Asian Marshall Plan to help the post-civil war American states (those areas not collapsed into entire madmaxism, anyway) rebuild.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top