RomaniaWank Plausibility POLL

Please, rate "RomaniaWank" TL.


  • Total voters
    52

Zagan

Donor
Again about the Buttlerfly Effect
This is from http://wiki.alternatehistory.com/doku.php/alternate_history/butterfly_effect
Reasons for such a liberal, or at least a moderate approach can be found in literature and writing stories: Henry VIII on an airship is more exciting than English King You've Never Heard Of on an airship. Alternate History in stories works much better if the reader can spot familar themes - people, nations or events. That is also why the liberal approach is so well liked in popular literature.

This is from the wiki of this site. It is what new members are supposed to read before starting to write a new TL.
 
Themes that are supposed to REFERENCE otl, not stay the same. there is a big difference between keeping events the same as otl and making references to otl. That Henry would be a different person, all that would stay the same would be the king name. You could make him a similar person in his personality or actions, but then you would have to write a (could be brief) history of his life and actions to justify that. If you want to justify a huge Romania wank, you have to start from the ground up, and by that far back it would be easy enough to find a legit way for a huge Romanian kingdom, and SOME more assimilation. If you don't explain why we will automatically assume you meant stuff went otl because you did not give us a legit reason not to.

Unfortunately there are many alt history BOOKS that are completely and totally asb, and probably should be considered fiction. Watch out when reading books of alt history, unless they are from the man turtledove himself or somebody that you know writes well.
 

Zagan

Donor
Thank you for your votes.

This Poll had done its job.

I am informed that 40% (at the time of this post) of you think that my TL is "ASB".

Version 2 will be more realistic.

Thank you again for your time to read it and write comments. (well... except those kind of comments)
 
I hope you will do a better job this time.

To be honest, the reason why I was so harsh is because THERE IS NO ROMANIA TLS ON THIS SITE, and the one I found turned out to be such a screw-up in the end that I got kinda mad, so sorry about that. If you do a better job in the new version I will try to help as I see fit with place names and such.
 

Zagan

Donor
I hope you will do a better job this time.

To be honest, the reason why I was so harsh is because THERE IS NO ROMANIA TLS ON THIS SITE, and the one I found turned out to be such a screw-up in the end that I got kinda mad, so sorry about that. If you do a better job in the new version I will try to help as I see fit with place names and such.

I am sorry. That will not be possible.
You were rude to me that I will never accept anything from you. No help, no advice, nothing from you ever.
And I insist that you never again read anything I write, much less comment on it.
There are other hundreds of people you can start to annoy. Just leave me alone or I will report the offending posts and the overall harrassment.
 

CalBear

Moderator
Donor
Monthly Donor
I hope you will do a better job this time.

To be honest, the reason why I was so harsh is because THERE IS NO ROMANIA TLS ON THIS SITE, and the one I found turned out to be such a screw-up in the end that I got kinda mad, so sorry about that. If you do a better job in the new version I will try to help as I see fit with place names and such.

I am sorry. That will not be possible.
You were rude to me that I will never accept anything from you. No help, no advice, nothing from you ever.
And I insist that you never again read anything I write, much less comment on it.
There are other hundreds of people you can start to annoy. Just leave me alone or I will report the offending posts and the overall harrassment.

Oh for crissake!

There is an ignore function. Please use it rather than snipe at each other like this.

Thanks.
 

Zagan

Donor
Oh for crissake!
There is an ignore function. Please use it rather than snipe at each other like this.
Thanks.

Ok. Advice followed.
I consider this unfortunate discussion over.
I will look over my own business.
Thank you.
 

Zagan

Donor
You may consider this poll closed.

It was useful for me and helped me make up my mind.
Now, that I arrived to a conclusion, it is no longer necessary.

Thank you again.
 
Top