Reshuffling the Hand You Were Dealt - Republican Party Edition

SASH9Cx.png

Statesman... Isn't the Shuffling the Deck Idea a bit tried?

Maybe, but I like innovating.

So what's this exactly, then?

Take all of the GOP Presidential Nominees from 1948 to 2012, and reshuffle the order they were nominated.

So... The Presidents might be different from OTL?

Exactly, but the Republican Candidates are the same as IOTL. Democrats, not necessarily the same case.

That certainly is a twist on the Shuffling Idea.

And if people like it, I might do the same thing for the Democrats.

So is this a TLIAW or something?

Nope. I'm not going to give myself a time constraint, but it should be set up in a similar manner. Well, sort of. I'm going to have updates per election and for the Presidencies between the elections, sort of like how it is done in a lot of Shared World Election Games.

I see The Seventies is no longer in your signature.

That is correct. I couldn't seem to push through to get that out. But This Great Stream of History is still running! Check it out, we have a Democratic President Reagan!

You done with your self plug?

Yup. Time to move onto this project. Hope you enjoy. :)
 
Last edited:
1948 Presidential Election
genusmap.php


General Dwight D. Eisenhower/Governor Dwight H. Green (Republican) - 359 Electoral Votes (52.8%)
Secretary of Commerce Averell Harriman/Senator Alben W. Barkley (Democratic) - 144 Electoral Votes (43.6%)
Governor Strom Thurmond/Governor Fielding L. Wright (Dixiecrat) - 28 Electoral Votes (2.8%)

With Senator Robert A. Taft’s sudden death in the summer of 1947 in a tragic car accident outside of Washington D.C., it appeared as if the fight for the Republican Nomination would be between former nominee Thomas Dewey and General Douglas MacArthur, who had a surprising strong amount of support in the primaries and whom many in the party felt could successfully beat Truman, with many weary of denominating Dewey.

As this was developing, the Northeastern Establishment within the Republican Party sought to deny MacArthur the nomination, but sought out a candidate other than Dewey. While California Governor Earl Warren was touted as a possibility, it was General Dwight D. Eisenhower that many felt could best go toe to toe against MacArthur at the Republican National Convention. But the General was hesitant. After mulling it over for over a week in May of 1948, he called up President Truman and informed him that he would be seeking the Republican Nomination for President (Truman had previously offered to step aside for Eisenhower to take the Democratic Nomination for President). Once at the Convention, it took over a dozen ballots, but eventually General Eisenhower would secure the nomination.

From there, it was up to him to pick a Vice President. Leaving the decision of Vice President largely up to his team, including Thomas Dewey himself, the honor would go to another Dwight, Governor Green of Illinois who had notably fought the Chicago Machine in his career. Together in the General Election, the Republican Ticket would face off against Commerce Secretary W. Averell Harriman and Senator Alben W. Barkley, as well as a bolting of Southern Democrats who rallied behind Governor Strom Thurmond and Governor Fielding Wright.

In the end, the Republican moderate-to-liberal platform that emphasized General Eisenhower’s ability to handle foreign policy, particularly in the post WWII age that the country was entering. Combined with Harriman’s ultimate lack of connection with the average voter and many Southern Democrats voting for either Thurmond or Eisenhower, the election of 1948 would prove a relatively easy victory for the Republicans.
 
Last edited:
"Dealth"? Sounds ominous. :p

A novel idea! Dewey in 1952 is going to be interesting (unless you're going to have him stay even longer that that...)
 

Japhy

Banned
Why would the Republican Establishment turn on Dewey?

EDIT: Besides it merely being a shuffle. Lord Roem and Meadow in the original and Thande in the first American adaptation at least offered reasoning for the POD.
 
Why would the Republican Establishment turn on Dewey?

EDIT: Besides it merely being a shuffle. Lord Roem and Meadow in the original and Thande in the first American adaptation at least offered reasoning for the POD.

Explanation shall be better offered in the next update. I just wanted to get this rolling tonight.
 
Eisenhower Four years earlier huh! I love these Presidential Timelines. :D

You never know what they are going to throw out at you!
 
life19500417eisenhower.jpg


Eisenhower Administration 1949-1953

When it leaked to the Republican Establishment that Thomas Dewey was hoping that Dwight Eisenhower would run for President, many feared he wouldn’t be as committed to winning as he was four years earlier and began looking to other options, including California Governor Earl Warren and Leverett Saltonstall (though both were cautious in light of the rumors that Eisenhower might run to defeat his rival MacArthur). Once Eisenhower was running, however, Dewey would prove to the General he was still seriously committed and was made the first ever Presidential Chief of Staff, largely in charge of helping Eisenhower run the White House and the nation.

Post-Depression and Post-War America proved to be quite the economic powerhouse, with very little turbulence. This stability allowed the minutiae and small affairs in running the economy to be handled quite effectively by Eisenhower’s Cabinet, leaving the President to deal with what his expertise was in, foreign policy. Bringing in the Eisenhower Doctrine pushed back aggressively against the Soviet Union throughout his term to try to roll back the influence of Communism.

In his first year as President, Eisenhower would oversee the founding of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, which was viewed as widely popular in America. 1949 would also see the Soviet Union testing its first nuclear weapon, which would result in President Eisenhower to push for an increase in Defense spending despite resistance in Congress. It is, however, important to remember that, although the Republicans had retaken control of the White House, McCarthyism continued to expand under President Eisenhower. After the conviction of Alger Hiss, Eisenhower even seemed to many to show support for rooting out Communism in the American Government, elevating the national star of Richard Nixon even higher by making him United Nations Ambassador in the summer of 1950.

On June 25, 1950, Kim Il-sung's North Korean People's Army invaded South Korea, starting the Korean War. The North Koreans easily pushed back their southern counterparts, nearly overwhelming all of South Korea in only a few weeks. Eisenhower called for a naval blockade of Korea and air patrols over the peninsula, only to learn that due to budget cutbacks, the U.S. Navy and Air Force could not enforce these actions to the extent he had hoped. On the advice of Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr, Eisenhower urged the United Nations to intervene. With the Soviet Union boycotting the United Nations over the issue of which China would be seated, it was easy to gain authorization. President Eisenhower was quick to ask Matthew Ridgway to lead the forces in Korea.

By August, U.S. Troops began pouring into the Korean Peninsula led by General Ridgway, with a massive bombing campaign led by General Curtis LeMay. This joint effort led to a massive victory against the inferior military of North Korea, pushing the Korean Communists into a state of exile within the borders of the People's Republic of China. Eisenhower authorized American reinforcements to entrench themselves along the border while Secretary Lodge and Ambassador Nixon worked tirelessly with General Ridgway and the South Koreans to set up a united Korean Government.

In late October, joint attacks by the Chinese and exiled North Koreans saw a minor collapse and retreat of the American frontline, as well as extensive raiding of the northernmost supply lines. Furthermore, Eisenhower’s failure to back down in Korea would see the Soviet Union hastily return to the United Nations to prevent something like what had happened here from happening again. While the South Koreans still had an overall gain in territory, these surprise attacks would see the Democrats make up in the Mid Term Election what they had lost in 1948, which would only provide further Congressional barriers to President Eisenhower.

In 1951, when the Chinese began building up forces alongside the North Koreans – this time with suspected Soviet armaments – President Eisenhower introduced the tactic of brinkmanship (suggested to him and executed through UN Ambassador Nixon). The President threatened the use of nuclear weapons if the Chinese did not stop the buildup, with Nixon suggesting at the very least the United States was considering constructing strategic missile bases on the island of Fermosa with the Republic of China. The tactic worked, and the People's Republic of China backed down, allowing Korea to be largely unified under a joint South Korean-U.S. Military Government by the summer of 1951.

After his success in Korea, President Eisenhower pushed for the creation of the Interstate Highway System, modeled off of the German Autobahn, which he pushed as being essential to American interests in the Cold War. Congress would finally pass the authorization for it in early 1952. However, much of his economic legislation would largely continue to be tied up in Congress for being strongly anti-labor, which essentially left President Eisenhower to the will of the Democrats when it came to domestic policy.

Despite this Congressional-Presidential sparring, the country seemed to be on the up and up, and headed into the 1952 Election the Republicans were confident they would secure a second term in the White House.
 

Japhy

Banned
Honestly I'd be lying if I said I thought that was sufficient reasoning for these. Just because you're playing with a standardized premise doesn't mean you don't have to put effort into realism or explanations. "Dewey magically decides Ike would be better and that 1944 wasn't a ticket to get to run again later" doesn't actually make sense as a PoD. There has to be a reason.

In the original Churchill was killed in a wartime accident. In Thande's American one LBJ won his first senate race. There has to be an actual divergence.
 
Honestly I'd be lying if I said I thought that was sufficient reasoning for these. Just because you're playing with a standardized premise doesn't mean you don't have to put effort into realism or explanations. "Dewey magically decides Ike would be better and that 1944 wasn't a ticket to get to run again later" doesn't actually make sense as a PoD. There has to be a reason.

In the original Churchill was killed in a wartime accident. In Thande's American one LBJ won his first senate race. There has to be an actual divergence.

Robert Taft was killed in 1947. Bricker didn't want to be seen as if he was jumping the gun, which allowed MacArthur to gather a lot of conservative support (minus the isolationists) which scared many into thinking, including Dewey, that he might take the nomination. With that, Eisenhower remains sort of silent on the question of the draft movement that gets started for him as per OTL, so Dewey "magically" thinks and hopes Eisenhower might be serious. The POD is not Dewey, but Taft, as was stated in the first update.
 
1952 Presidential Election
genusmap.php


President Dwight D. Eisenhower/Vice President Dwight H. Green (Republican) - 421 Electoral Votes (56.4%)
Governor Averell Harriman/Senator Robert Kerr (Democratic) - 110 Electoral Votes (42.6%)

Headed into 1952, the Democratic Party had a strong feeling that they could not beat President Eisenhower, which would cause a severe lacking in the amount of candidates that would show their head to run for the nomination. As a result, Tennessee Senator Estes Kefauver would come to dominate the Democratic Primaries. However, many in the Party Machine were fearful of Senator Kefauver and his progressive policies, despite them proving relatively popular in the primaries. And so the Democratic Party would once again turn to Averell Harriman, now Governor of New York, to lead the ticket once at the Convention. Joining Harriman would not be Senator Barkley like four years earlier, but instead Senator Robert Kerr of Oklahoma, who was a noted work-horse among his colleagues.

President Eisenhower would once again be nominated for President by the Republicans, this time quite easily. On the matter of the Vice President however, Ike had considered dropping Dwight Green (instead giving him a cabinet position, such as Attorney General) in favor of notable anti-communist Congressman Walter Judd, but the idea would eventually be killed by his advisors.

Headed into the General Election, Harriman would criticize Eisenhower on his complacency with McCarthyism as well as his “dangerous” and “reckless” use of brinksmanship in Korea, while also criticizing his overly pro-business domestic policy proposals as being harmful to the average American. Eisenhower, on the other hand, would largely leave his campaign up to the team he had assembled around him, with UN Ambassador Nixon and Secretary of State Henry Cabot Lodge defending his foreign policy aggressively in public and Vice President Green defending their domestic policy, with Eisenhower only making the occasional speech to excite the American people and remind them that he was a national hero.

Once election day rolled around, the results didn’t surprise much of anyone. Eisenhower handily won reelection, once again defeating Averell Harriman, with his coattails seeing a number of Republican victories across the country.
 
History_Eisenhower_Suez_Canal_Crisis_Speech_SF_still_624x352.jpg


Eisenhower Administration 1953-1957

Dwight Eisenhower’s second term as President would prove much more controversial than his first term at the time, although modern historians tend to rank him fairly well in what he was able to accomplish. Much like his first term, it was widely dominated by foreign policy, though he was able to make quite a few changes domestically, such as establishing the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare and the appointment of Earl Warren to be Chief Justice of the Supreme Court (who would oversee the ruling in Brown v. Board of Education).

Very early in his second term, Joseph Stalin would die and a power struggle would emerge in the Soviet Union. In the end, it would be Nikita Khrushchev who would become the new leader of the USSR, which would eventually begin the split between the Soviet Union and the People’s Republic of China (a relationship already strained by the American victory in the Korean War).

Despite the relative victory in Korea, however, it would be the country that still dominated Eisenhower’s Presidency, as the presence of the United States military came uneasy to many who had lived in the North. Eisenhower would not withdraw the forces, however, causing tensions between the Korean-led elements of the new government and the United States military. As his Presidency wore on, the American people began to question why the military was still in the country, particularly as Kim Il-sung would seek permanent asylum in Moscow, abandoning his claims to lead Korea, in 1955. This question over the military in Korea would come to a climax when an aerial reconnaissance pilot would go down in Manchuria in early 1955. Originally, Eisenhower claimed the pilot had merely flown off course by accident, but an investigation would prove that the U.S. military was actually hosting a sustained surveillance effort in Northern China, which resulted in the Chinese capture of an American Airman.

In his second term, beyond Korea, the Eisenhower Doctrine and the attack on communism continued in full force. The 1953 Iranian Coup and Operation Ajax would see a socialist Prime Minister, though democratically elected, thrown out with the monarchy given more power in government. The “Fermosa Resolution” would give the President much sway in providing aid to the Republic of China, still recognized as the original China.

Perhaps most notably aside from Korea, however, was President Eisenhower’s decision to send in American troops to support France in keeping down Communism in Indochina, made in early 1954. While at first this decision was well liked by many Americans, as Korea continued to unease people, the American public also seemed to turn against the President for his sending more American troops into harm’s way. Though the majority of the American involvement came in the form of supplies and air support, the mere fact that there were American Marines in Southeast Asia was enough to draw the President’s actions into question.

This situation was not helped by the Army-McCarthy hearings, which occurred after Joseph McCarthy accused the Army of hiding Communists and Communists sympathizers, with a particular emphasis that many might be going to Korea or Indochina to defect. This attack solidly broke up any rapport that the President seemed to have with McCarthy (and indeed, he almost fired Ambassador Nixon over the events that transpired). Despite this, however, many in the public still associated the two men together, and when Senator McCarthy was censured it damaged the image of the President as well.

During his second term, President Eisenhower was able to work on much better terms in Congress than he had in his first term, particularly in 1953 and ’54. He would use this better working relationship to pass a number of laws that would seem to benefit businesses, much to the dismay of the Democrats and Labor Unions, even sparking strikes in 1953 and 1955 over what the President was calling for in domestic policy. And though many pushed him to tackle the issue of Civil Rights, particularly in his second term, his biggest contribution to the movement would be in his Supreme Court appointments.

In 1955, President Eisenhower would suffer a severe heart attack that nearly would take him out of office and the world. While he would recover, he and his doctors would handily rule out a bid for a third term, despite his eligibility to do so under the nuances of the 22nd Amendment. With this decision, many in his Administration expected Vice President Green would step up to run for the Party, but he insisted he had no real interest in the position. Thus, going into the election, the Republicans would be severely divided.
 
Alright, let's see who's eligible to run in 1956:

Thomas Dewey
Richard Nixon
Barry Goldwater
Gerald Ford
Ronald Reagan - Possibly still a Democrat ITTL at this point

I'm going to bet on Dewey in 1956.
 
Last edited:
Alright, let's see who's eligible to run in 1956:

Thomas Dewey
Richard Nixon
Barry Goldwater
Ronald Reagan - Possibly still a Democrat ITTL at this point

I'm going to bet on Dewey in 1956.

It has to be Dewey. He'll be dead in the water politically soon.
 
Alright, let's see who's eligible to run in 1956:

Thomas Dewey
Richard Nixon
Barry Goldwater
Ronald Reagan - Possibly still a Democrat ITTL at this point

I'm going to bet on Dewey in 1956.

If Reagan was elected to Congress in 1950, he stays a Democrat and most likely does not run for President.
 
Top