Repair This! A HMS Repulse Timeline

These torpedo hits on top of earlier shell damage don't help one bit. Prinz Eugen taking two torpedoes will likely doom that ship. On top of earlier shell hits, especially from HMS Repulse, she's a smaller ship in general compared to Bismarck.

It's not just speed either, their ability to maneuver successfully is going to be impacted pretty badly. The British might have the option of launching a second strike before closing for another surface action.

One thing though, I'm kinda surprised that the Fulmar fighters where not used to strafe the German ships. They could have knocked out some AA mounts, forced crew members to take cover, and made things slightly easier for the Swordfish.
 
These torpedo hits on top of earlier shell damage don't help one bit. Prinz Eugen taking two torpedoes will likely doom that ship. On top of earlier shell hits, especially from HMS Repulse, she's a smaller ship in general compared to Bismarck.
Yep, shes not long for this Earth. I guess Admiral Hipper stole Prinz Eugens luck in this timeline.
One thing though, I'm kinda surprised that the Fulmar fighters where not used to strafe the German ships. They could have knocked out some AA mounts, forced crew members to take cover, and made things slightly easier for the Swordfish.
I didn't see any mention of this OTL thats why i didn't include it. Would have made sense if they did though.
 

Driftless

Donor
Under the circumstance of this later skirmish, might Lutjens use PE as a sacrificial lamb to help the Bismark break off? It sounds as though PE is going to struggle to keep up anyway
 
although the Fulmar fighter escorts ran out of fuel on the trip back to the carrier and were forced to ditch.
The Fulmar had an endurance of nearly 4 hours and a range of 800 miles. The Swordfish on normal fuel load carrying a torpedo only had a range of 525 miles.
 
Not sure on the Fulmars ditching. I could see them not launched (Bismarck won't have fighter cover) or being used in a bombing role shortening their range but not fail to return from a fighter role.

I see Prinz Eugene turning to try and allow Bismarck to escape. She is slow and unable to maneuver after two torpedoes and a few shell hits.

Bismarck will have their own problems after a torpedo hit. Especially in terms of maneuver but maybe also a little speed.

I note that victorious launched her strike at the historical time. I would have expected an earlier launch or maybe a later launch as Bismarck has been slowed.

Also I note Hood is still with Tovey. Given that she is taking Repulse's historical role she may need to retire shortly due to fuel.
 
Last edited:
Also I note Hood is still with Tovey. Given that she is taking Repulse's historical role she may need to retire shortly due to fuel
That’s the thing, I would like Hood to be there but idk how Hoods fuel consumption and capacity compare to Repulses. I mean I could butterfly it away but I don’t want to do that unless there’s no other way to explain it.
 
That’s the thing, I would like Hood to be there but idk how Hoods fuel consumption and capacity compare to Repulses. I mean I could butterfly it away but I don’t want to do that unless there’s no other way to explain it.
I think ws8b was rushed out to get away ahead of a German breakout or Repulse was planned to be with ws8b and left the convoy when the convoy was assembling.

Either way i believe Repulse didn't have a full load of fuel. It took a long time to refill the fuel of capital ships. Given that Hood was larger and had longer range I guess you could say that they started fueling her earlier.
 
Has anyone seen the movie Sink the Bismarck, because the Victorious not only plays herself but also plays the Ark Royal.
 
Chapter 5
It was evident to Lutjens and Captain Helmuth Brinkmann that Prinz Eugen was not long for this world. The torpedoes had already flooded the forward boiler room forcing it to be evacuated, coupled with damage from the hit to amdiships from Norfolk this caused irreparable damage to Prinz Eugens machinery. As a result Prinz Eugen couldn’t maintain speed with Bismarck and was a liability to Lutjens by this point. Brinkmann, however, was not planning on going down without a fight. With Lutjens best wishes, Brinkmann ordered Prinz Eugen to turn towards the British fleet, Brinkmann vowing to “fight on to the last man and shell, long live the Fuhrer, long live the 3rd reich”

For a ship that was heavily damaged, Prinz Eugen came out swinging. Since the last engagement with Repulse and Norfolk, her damage control teams had restored “Bruno” turret to operation and “Anton” turret was also operational, albeit jammed 45 degrees to port. She also managed to surprise Admiral Wake-Walker by her sudden abrupt turn, throwing the British forces off their feet for a moment. Within moments Prinz Eugen fired at HMS Norfolk which was now the leading ship in the British formation. A salvo of 8 inch shells rained down on Norfolk, straddling the British cruiser. The next salvo found its mark, two 8 inch shells slammed into Norfolks forward superstructure, killing Admiral Wake-Walker and the majority of his staff, as well as Captain Alfred J. L. Phillips. Another salvo came in, 2 shells straddling the ship and a 3rd impacting the top of “A” turret, knocking it out and nearly starting a fire in the handling rooms below. By this time however, Norfolk was already fring back, using secondary rangefinders or turret rangefinders, since the main rangefinder and radar set was smashed to bits. Prince of Wales and Repulse were also sending salvos down range, 14 inch and 15 inch shells rained down all around and hitting the Prinz Eugen. A salvo of 14 inch shells obliterated Prinz Eugens forward superstructure and bridge, this was followed by 15 inch shells destroying “Caesar” and “Dora” turrets. By 3:30 AM, Prinz Eugen was a burning, sinking wreck. 20 minutes later the German heavy cruiser capsized, soon followed by an explosion as the fires breached the magazines.

While Prinz Eugen had been busy with the British, Bismarck had attempted to slip away. Fortunately one of Wake-Walker's final acts was to order HMS Suffolk to split off from his force and continue to shadow Bismarck, just before Prinz Eugens shells started raining down around him. So Suffolk, with the help of radar, shadowed Bismarck from a relatively safe distance.

Earlier, after his first engagement with Repulse and PoW, Lutjens had reported to Berlin his status, including how the British ships had damaged his ship and how they were harassing him, making it difficult to return to Nazi controlled waters. The loss of Prinz Eugen only made matters worse. Needless to say, Hitler, upon receiving bad news after bad news, was not pleased. Launching into a legendary irate rant about the ineptitude and cowardice of the Kriegsmarine. Especially when it was evident that the possibility Germanys newest battleship may be very well lost on her maiden voyage.
 
HMS Repulse looking at the battle: "There's something wrong with our bloody Admirals today."
To be fair, if you told the British Admiralty "For every two Admirals you kill, the Germans lose a Battleship and a Heavy Cruiser," they'd organise the Firing Squads themselves.
 
That’s the thing, I would like Hood to be there but idk how Hoods fuel consumption and capacity compare to Repulses. I mean I could butterfly it away but I don’t want to do that unless there’s no other way to explain it.
I think Hood has significantly greater range than Repulse

Hood 1931: 5,332 nautical miles (9,875 km; 6,136 mi) at 20 knots (37 km/h; 23 mph)

3,650 nmi (6,760 km; 4,200 mi) at ?????
 
It settled then, Hood will take the place of OTL Rodney alongside KGV.
And Prince of Wales, Norfolk, and Repulse head back to the UK(and maybe eventually the US) for yard time(and probably much need AA upgrades in the case of at least Repulse)and Rodney proceeds to the Boston Naval Yard for a much needed multi month refit without stressing her machinery in the meantime
 
I would be wary of using pre war range, speed and fuel numbers for Hood. She was an asthmatic old lady held together by the willpower of the engineering team.
While not nearly enough she had enjoyed a short 6 week refit between Jan and March to repair her machinary issues she had experienced while bullying the French navy

So while yes she was certainly in poor shape and desperately needed a deep refit her machinary had recently (with regards to the POD) received a dose of TLC
 
Top