Religious United Indian Subcontinent

Will a Religious homogeneous Subcontinent be better for the region ?

  • Yes

    Votes: 29 63.0%
  • No

    Votes: 17 37.0%

  • Total voters
    46

Albert.Nik

Banned
Let's see, the religious population of subcontinent - 63% Hindus, 33% Muslims, 4% Everyone else

And the linguistic diversity - 1,700 languages

It is easier to have one religion 90% than one language dominate the area
I asked only about religious cum ethnic homogeneity. Linguistic you can keep as it is.
 

Albert.Nik

Banned
Indian subcontinent also has hundreds of ethnic divisions, the only type homogeneity we can see would be religious homogeneity
I don't think it is possible to have religious homogeneity without relative Ethnic homogeneity. I'm not saying total.
 
Of course, even in OTL India, Hindus are from diverse ethnic and culture group yet stay in a single country
That's by desing. They were divided to be that way, there used to be a lot of hindus in pakistan and far more muslims in northern india. Without otl conflict with Pakistan there is no garanty that hindus would be so united in their national identity. The earlier the POD, the more likely is a linguistical ethnogenesis.
 

Srihari14

Banned
That's by desing. They were divided to be that way, there used to be a lot of hindus in pakistan and far more muslims in northern india. Without otl conflict with Pakistan there is no garanty that hindus would be so united in their national identity. The earlier the POD, the more likely is a linguistical ethnogenesis.
That is probably somewhat true, without an enemy, India might not be united, But assuming thing go like OTL, That void can easily be replaced by communist china
 
Top