From AH.com Discussion "Batman V. Superman discussion"
Kalki said:My god, the trailer is dark. Seriously, there's no color anywhere! I know Zac Snyder wanted to harken back to the Siegel-Shuster/"social realist" version of the character, but those stories were also very colorful and lively. This is just dark and depressing. I know some fans aren't overly fond of the Weisinger era Superman, but that was the iconic version of the character, the one that helped define the character. When you take that away, and you try to put some overly dark, depressing "realist" elements in there, well, I can't honestly say that the film will be in the spirit of Superman. And if he is going to fight Batman, he needs a different aesthetic to contrast with Batman.
NestorMakhno said:I don't read comics. What does "Weisinger era" mean?
Kalki said:Sorry, Mort Weisinger was an editor at ADC, who took over Superman in the late 50's, at the beginning of the Silver Age of Comics. He essentially created the modern version of the character. You know, the rainbow Kryptonites, Brainiac (and most of his rogues gallery), Super Girl, and Krypto the Super Dog. He took advantage of the revolution against strict rationalist thought in comics during the Silver Age, and created a more whimsical version of the character. And that version was very successful. I prefer that version over the Siegel-Shuster one. Perhaps, as a Brit, I don't have sympathy for the politics in those 30's books, but the Superman of the Silver Age simply had more fun, especially since they weren't limited by that dreary tendency in Yank fiction called "Social Realism." that pervaded the early books.
GreenAvenger said:Look, I know over there, you think that Socialist Realism was some rule, that requires communist proselytizing and the suppression of fantasy, but if you look at those stories, there is a sense of optimism and hope, the way that ordinary people stand alongside Superman, and fight against the evils of world. Hell, the Weisinger Superman was more socialist leaning than the original. You know, "Superman, Cappie Smasher" . Yeah, they weren't rationalist, but they still were heavily socialist in message. In fact, they were more communist in tone. Alan Moore said it best when he said "Weisinger took the concepts of Siegel and Shuster, and took them to their logical extreme, turning a 'Super-socialist; to the greatest Communist hero."
That said, yes, this trailer is way too dark. Superman stories, no matter the person writing, was still bright and colorful. It's hard to reconcile this with Superman, even with the presence of Batman. Hell, speaking of Moore, Snyder's "Watchmen" had more color and brightness to it, and it was far darker than Superman (though, ironically, that story was very Silver Age in aesthetic, if not tone.)