alternatehistory.com

I think that neo-Paganism and Pagan Reconstructionism of any kind is sort of cool, in its dedication to bring the ancient polytheisms of Europe back to life. Today, the neo-Pagan movement is confined to groups so small that the average person never heard of such a movement, from the most hardcore reconstructionist ones to the most eclectic ones (mainstream Wicca's on this side of the spectrum, while Nordic and Baltic reconstructionism is on the other, despite the fact that even the most purist neo-Pagans have their divisions). Your challenge is to make "revived" forms of Paganism at least well-known religious minorities in Abrahamic countries, kind of like Jehowah's Witnesses or Buddhists are OTL. If i had to say the most favourable times for Paganism to rise again, they would be the Renaissance (probably Venice, they burned less people there) and the Romantic era...
Top