Rollercoaster: The 1976 US Presidential Election
1976 Democratic Nomination
After the massive defeat of the moderate Muskie/Sanford ticket in 1972, it soon became apparent that in the battle for the nomination of 1976, that it would be a fight between the Conservative and Liberal factions of the party. The campaign effectively began in 1974, as many candidates began actively fundraising for their respective campaigns then. This resulted in a smaller pool of candidates than that of the 1972 campaign but also a much more interesting race.
Governor George Wallace of Alabama
Representative Mo Udall of Arizona
Senator Lloyd Bentsen of Texas
Senator Henry “Scoop” Jackson of Washington
One of the surprising events in the race for the Democratic Nomination was that Representative Shirley Chisholm, who finished a strong third in the 1972 nomination, who instead of running a second time for the Presidency of the United States, went after the coveted New York Senate seat against incumbent James L. Buckley. It was also during the 1976 campaign, that the Democrats featured a record number of primaries and caucuses as it became necessary to win the primaries to clinch the nomination.
One of the candidates who understood the newfound importance in campaigning in the early primary states was that of Representative Mo Udall of Arizona. After scoring impressive wins in the early contests of Iowa and New Hampshire, Udall’s chance of steamrolling to the convention was cut short by the “Comeback” victory of Senator Jackson’s campaign in the form of wins in the states of Massachusetts and Vermont on March 2nd. This would result in a long battle for the nomination, with Senator Jackson using the Labor and Jewish communities as a base while Representative Udall used that of upper-class liberals. This left Senator Bentsen and Governor Wallace to fight it out in the South. By the time the convention rolled around in New York City, although Senator Jackson carried a large percentage of the delegates, he did not hold enough to clinch the nomination.
Delegates for Scoop Jackson during the 1976 Democratic National Convention
Senator Henry “Scoop” Jackson
States Delegations: Massachusetts, Vermont, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Nebraska, Michigan, Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, Montana, Rhode Island, California, North Dakota, Maine, New Jersey, Ohio, New York, Virginia, Alaska and Washington.
Senator Lloyd Bentsen
States Delegations: Florida, North Carolina, Georgia, Maryland, Arkansas, Kentucky, Tennessee, Louisiana, Oklahoma, New Mexico, Colorado, Missouri and Texas.
Representative Morris Udall
State Delegations: Iowa, New Hampshire, Wisconsin, Washington D.C., Connecticut, Delaware, Kansas, Utah, Hawaii, South Dakota, Minnesota, Wyoming and Arizona.
Governor George Wallace
State Delegations: Illinois, West Virginia, Mississippi, South Carolina, and Alabama.
After a few rounds of close balloting between Senator’s Jackson and Bentsen, Scoop would clinch the nomination by peeling a few states away from Mo Udall. Many within the Convention hall believed the logical choice to ensure unity in the party for the fall, would be for Jackson to choose a Southerner. Several names were floated as being potential running mates; Senator Lloyd Bentsen of Texas, former Senator Fred Harris of Oklahoma, Governor Reubin Askew of Florida, Senator Dale Bumpers of Arkansas, Governor Jimmy Carter of Georgia or even Representative Barbara Jordan of Texas. In spite of this, Senator Jackson chose his close friend, the Liberal Governor of New York Daniel Patrick Moynihan to be his running mate. Although most of the Southern Delegates thought of it as a slap in the face, they begrudgingly supported the ticket after Senator Jackson delivered a strong acceptance speech in which he said
“America, I have known this man for years and let me tell you that you can trust Pat to be your Vice President!”. The Jackson/Moynihan polls numbers surged after the convention yet those numbers would begin to slip as the general election campaign would closer than that of the Democratic primaries.
1976 Republican Nomination
Vice- President John Anthony Volpe made it very clear by March of 1975 that he would be seeking his party’s nomination for the Presidency of the United States in 1976. The Moderate to Liberal wing of the party support for the Vice President was insurmountable, as Volpe was able to catch valuable endorsements from former Governor Nelson Rockefeller of New York, Senator Edward Brooke of Massachusetts, Senator Richard Schweiker of Pennsylvania, Minority Leader Gerald Ford of Michigan and even former Vice President Nixon. However, some on the Conservative wing were uneasy with idea of nominating the Vice President, Yet any attempt to run against the former Governor of Massachusetts was swatted down by President Reagan who is quoted to have said “
Though shall not speak ill of a fellow Republican.” As Vice President Volpe swept through the primaries, President Reagan would actively support his candidacy as well as other Republican Congressional candidates on the campaign trail.
President Ronald Reagan in support of the Volpe/Baker ticket at a campaign stop in Kentucky.
By the time the Republicans made in to the Kansas City Convention in August, Vice President Volpe already had more than enough delegates to clinch the nomination, and therefore nominated by acclamation. The only question was to whom, the Vice President would call to be his running mate. Only one thing was for certain, that it would be a Conservative Southerner many pundits concluded, as it would be a way for the Volpe campaign to capitalize on the “fumble” made by Senator Jackson. Potential Running Mate names which were on the Vice President’s short list included; former Governor John Connally of Texas, Attorney General Howard Baker of Tennessee, Senator George H.W. Bush of Texas, Agriculture Secretary Robert Dole of Kansas, or even Defense Secretary John Tower of Texas. Ultimately, Vice President Volpe decided to pick from within the Reagan Administration and chose the popular Attorney General Howard Baker of Tennessee as his running mate. Baker seen as a Conservative to some and a moderate to others is seen as strong pick and one who would be willing to work along side Volpe in his promise for “
A gentler nation.”
The 1976 General Election
With a strong Economy, victory in the War in Vietnam and the beginning steps of a détente between the Soviet Union, many Political Pundits declared that the consensus was that Vice President Volpe could possibly win a landslide victory against the “Senator from Boeing”. However, the Republican ticket would soon realize that the “fighting Democrats” under the leadership of Scoop Jackson would not go quietly into that dark night. Scoop continued to work the campaign strategy, which had won him the nomination by focusing in on his hawkish foreign policy views, and moderate to liberal views on social issues. He campaigned on a recurring theme that the Republicans were softening up on the Soviet Union by wanting to expand detente and often hinted to Jewish Audiences, that under a future Volpe administration would be likely not to valiantly support Israel and it’s dealings in the Middle East. On Domestic Policy, many saw Jackson as the true “successor” to President Reagan as he would continue the 37th President’ policy of opposition to busing…this would later turn out to have dramatic effects on Jackson’s poll numbers as it would hurt him amongst minorities and upper class liberals in the Northeast but also win over a previously cautious white working class, who was largely seen as the tossup chunk of the electorate in this election. Senator Jackson would also find that his one-on-one campaign style translated best to voters in his home region of the Pacific West Coast and in the South but it didn’t really stick well to voters in the urban centers of the North. He mainly sent his running mate, Governor Daniel Patrick Moynihan of New York to the Northern states in which he was rapidly loosing support in which the Governor many times on the stump said. “
Henry Jackson is proof of the old belief in the Judaic tradition that at any moment in history goodness in the world is preserved by the deeds of 36 just men who do not know that this is the role the Lord has given them. Henry Jackson is one of those men.”
Senator Henry Jackson and Governor Daniel Patrick Moynihan at a Campaign stop in Tampa, Florida
Vice President Volpe on the other hand, ran on what is now called the “Rose Garden Strategy” as he promoted his involvement in the many accomplishments of the Reagan Administration as well as reminded voters of Senator Jackson’s lukewarm stance of Civil Rights and his strong support for Japanese Interment Camps in WWII. The former Governor of Massachusetts would also campaign on the need for wider ethics oversight in the Federal Government in a fashion similar to that of the Church Committee. Vice President also ran on his support for the ERA and a widening of research into alternate fuel sources to power the nation’s growing Amtrak system. He also proved to be an avid supporter of NASA and the manned space flight program, as he reminds voters of the tremendous feet of the American’s Second Skylab space station as the launch point for a future mission to Mars by the early 80’s. The Volpe/Baker campaign would also be memorable in its differences between their opponents on the other side, for relying heavily on surrogates to the brunt of campaigning, to show the image of a “unified” Republican Party in contrast to Senator Jackson’s rather fractious coalition. Heavy hitter’s such as Senator Edward Brooke of Massachusetts, former Vice President Nixon and even President Reagan himself were seen often with the two candidates on the trail as they crisscrossed the nation.
Vice President Volpe along with former Vice President Nixon and Massachusetts Senator Edward Brooke on the campaign trail
By the time of the Two Presidential debate and sole Vice Presidential debate came around in late October, Gallup Polling had the modern day Horatio Alger and the Senator from Boeing at an absolute tie. During the first debate on Domestic Policy, many viewers saw it as a close win for Vice President Volpe, as both candidates seemed to have a lot of knowledge on the different aspects of Domestic Policy including a heated discussion between the two on comprehensive Healthcare reform. In the only Vice Presidential Debate, Attorney General Baker is thought to have beaten Governor Moynihan’s aristocratic presence with some down home Southern Charm and is seen by many as the best man to assume the Presidency if needed be. In the final debate over Foreign Policy, Senator Jackson seemed to out hawk the current President compared to the détente focus of the Vice President. It is also during this debate that Senator Jackson delivered the strongest message to the American people when he said “
I believe that international terrorism is a modern form of warfare against liberal democracies. I believe that the ultimate but seldom stated goal of these terrorists is to destroy the very fabric of democracy. I believe that it is both wrong and foolhardy for any democratic state to consider international terrorism to be 'someone else's' problem.... Liberal democracies must acknowledge that international terrorism is a 'collective problem.”
The lack of a defining moment in the debates kept the race to close to call, as it became clear on the night of November 2nd, 1976 that whomever won the Presidency, that they would do so without a mandate and barely the necessary amount of votes in the electoral college. As the results came pouring in, things did not look so good in the Northeast for the Jackson/Moynihan ticket as it became apparent that Rockefeller Republicans in the region would support “their Hometown” candidate and support Vice President. Senator Jackson would only walk away with electoral votes from the states of Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Delaware, D.C., and his running mate’s home state of New York on fairly decent margins. In the Industrial belt, Senator Jackson would not fair much better as news came in that Volpe would take the states of Winsconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois as which proved that big labor support was not enough to switch working-class whites to the Democratic column in what was largely seen as good economic times. However, the Volpe/Baker team took solace in the fact that it would be a long night as results from the South came pouring in, and that Jackson would be able to count on electoral votes from Maryland, West Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Louisiana, Arkansas, and Missouri. The picking of Attorney General Howard Baker would prove not to be in vain as he would be able to add Virginia, Kentucky, Mississippi, and his home state of Tennessee to the Republican column, with Texas still too close to call.
In the Midwest, Vice President Volpe and his campaign would follow up their string of losses in the South with a sweep in the region. Senator Jackson would only take the longtime Democratic state of Minnesota, yet Vice President Volpe would soon feel the same as he would only walk away with the state of Alaska in the Pacific West as Senator Jackson narrowly carried the states of Oregon, California, and Hawaii along with an impressive win in his home state of Washington. With the electoral count essentially tied with Volpe at 257 electoral votes to Jackson at 255 electoral votes, it is said that whoever won Texas’s precious 26 votes could in fact clinch the Presidency. The state would not be called until early the next morning, by only a margin of only 5,600 votes that Vice President Volpe had won the state and thus won the election. Many Historians now agree that had Senator Jackson had simply chosen a Southerner for a running mate; he could have easily won the election. Senator Jackson decided not to contest the results from Texas and declared that “
The American People have made their decision and I stand by it and accept John Anthony Volpe as my President.” The 67 year-old President elect personally thanks Senator Jackson for the gracious concession and promised true bipartisanship in his new administration that would reflect the need for Democrats and Republicans to work together but more so to more effective in working with the Democratic Congress.
John A. Volpe/Howard Baker, Jr. 283 electoral votes
Henry "Scoop" Jackson/Daniel Patrick Moynihan 255 electoral votes
The 1976 Congressional elections
With the narrow victory of Vice President Volpe also came a sincere lack of coattails by the man who was to become the 38th President of the United States. There was no real change in the balance of the chamber as it remained in Democratic Hands 62 to 37. One of the two startling changes to the chamber however came in the form of two new African American members to the Senate. Representative Shirley Chisholm with the support of New York Governor and failed Vice Presidential running mate Daniel Patrick Moynihan defeated several well-qualified candidates in the Democratic primary and beat the incumbent Senator James L. Buckley on a five percent margin to become the nation’s first African American female to become a Senator. The other African American Senator would come in the form of Tom Bradley, law and order Mayor of Los Angeles since 1969, eked out a narrow victory over Republican candidate S.I. Hayakawa mainly due to his support of Senator Jackson’s candidacy. In the House, the Democrats would gain only one seat from the Republicans leaving the allocation at 292 Democratic seats to 144 Republican seats.