Pravoslavie, samoderzhavie, narodnost: Imagining a Fascist Russia

"Had the Whites won the war, Fascism would be a Russian word."

- quote attributed to Leon Trotsky

This is going to be a somewhat short timeline focused on something a lot of people really like to discuss both on AH.com and in other alternate history outlets - a Fascist, or, well "Fascist" Russia, how it might have come into being after World War I and what it might have looked like. It's a fairly common concept in alternate timelines on this site, usually taken as a quick alternative to the USSR for having a totalitarian Russian state, often with little thought put into it, and it is often discussed, usually in terms of how totalitarian it would be and what its war goals would look like. Often, it's seen as the natural result of a White victory in the Russian Civil War. However, there hasn't really been a timeline which explores "Fascist" Russia as its central concept, at least not one which is distinctively "Russian" (instead of being just Nazi Germany with a Russian paintjob).

I've decided to try writing something in this field and see if it sticks.

The POD with which this scenario is acquired (the Brusilov Offensive being a complete success and knocking A-H, and soon the rest of the Central Powers) is not the focus of the timeline and I personally believe that the Brusilov Offensive wouldn't have been catastrophic to the Central Powers even if it was completely successful, but that doesn't really matter here.

I'm here to theorycraft a post-WWI fascist Russia, not take on WW1 military analysis, although you're welcome to comment on that if you're interested.

Pravoslavie, samoderzhavie, narodnost
(Orthodoxy, Autocracy, Nationality)

a Fascist Russia timeline

On three in the morning on March 3rd, 1917, with the Armistice of Compiegne, the guns went silent. From the flat plains of Belgium to the endless depths of the Russian countryside, cheers could be heard amongst the millions of men in the trenches, for the Great War, the single bloodiest and most brutal conflict in everyone's lives, was over at last.

For the Russian Empire, whose army was arguably one of the main culprits of the ultimate Entente victory in the conflict thanks to the genius mind of General Alexei Brusilov and the valiant actions of its soldiers in the so-called Brusilov and Evert Offensives, smashing the core of the Austro-Hungarian army in Galicia and putting significant enough pressure on the German positions in the East to cause their ultimate downfall alongside parallel Western offensives, this was was Pyrrhic victory. Just the military casualties alone speak for themselves - almost two million military deaths of all causes, three million wounded, millions more mentally scarred during the years of conflict. The German and Austro-Hungarian invasion of Russia's Western provinces resulted in a severe refugee crisis - hundreds of thousands, if not millions, had fled or were forcefully displaced to the East, their presence was causing significant ethnic and demographic pressure, and the logistics of returning them to their bombed, ravaged, destroyed homes fell all on the Empire's shoulders.

The Great War, initially sees by Tsar Nicholas II and his cabinet as a potential way to "distract" the Russian population from poverty and anti-Tsarist agitation by rallying them around a common enemy, had also resulted in significant changes in Russian society, many of which the Tsarist government would have probably found undesirable, or potentially didn't even anticipate. As the commander in chief of the Russian Imperial Army aside from his monarch duties since September of 1915, Tsar Nicholas II could claim fame from Russia's ultimate victory in the Great War - even if his duties were largely ceremonial and much of the day-to-day matters of the armed forces were handled by the Tsar's chief-of-staff, Mikhail Alexeyev - however, on the other hand, this also meant that the Tsar, and by extension the government of the Russian Empire as a whole, was directly associated with all of the failures and grievances which the people might have with the war and its results (although arguably, the Tsar being away at the front and unable to govern, leaving the day-to-day matters of the state to his wife Grand Duchess Alexandra and a conservative cabinet led by ever changing Prime Ministers). For many both in the front and back at home, the thought of this having been a conflict for Serbia or for pan-Slavic unity had long since been forgotted, and the one thing most people really knew was that it took away their husband's life, that it took away their home, or that it took away their arm or leg. On the other hand, a "faction" just as large as the "losers" of the war were those who believed that it did not go far enough. The Russian military, having swept into Galicia and passed the Carpathians after heavy resistance, stopped there instead of spewing itself forth into the Hungarian Plain, the commanders of the units stationed content with watching the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in slow motion. As for the matters north, because of bloody stalemate after bloody stalemate in the swamps of Belarus and beaches of the Daugava, the Imperial Russian Army did not even reach the prewar border before the German Empire capitulated at last. Those who were convinced that the Great War was a crusade against the Teutons, a repetition of the Battle of Grunwald or the Battle on the Ice, were disappointed to witness not a glorious victory and the white-blue-red flying on the Brandenburg Gates, but a whimper, a disappointment. This stance on the end of the Great War would turn a lot more relevant once the peace negotiations after the Armistice of Compiegne would begin.

Russia's internal socialist movement, having been fairly miniscule before the outbreak of the Great War as many of its main leaders and activists had been arrested nine years earlier, was no longer a mere toddler which the Tsarist government could safely ignore. While most political forces in the Russian Empire actively endorsed the Great War and rallied behind the Tsar and his cabinet from 1914 until the very end, socialists such as the two splinter factions of the far-left Russian Social Democratic Labour Party, the Bolsheviks and the Mensheviks, as well as the left internationalist faction of the Socialist Revolutionary Party, had opposed the conflict from the very start, or at the very least spoke strongly against it as the conflict progressed and more and more blood was shed. This was fairly out of line line with the other socialist and social democratic parties in the other major participants of the war, many of which endorsed a "social chauvinist" stance, abandoning their previous pacifist principles to support the ongoing war. Throughout the war, all of these parties - but most notably the Bolsheviks, the most radical and active of the far-left movements within Russia, carried forward by the charisma of their leader Vladimir Ulyanov "Lenin", who had, in fact, been allowed to return to Russia from exile in Switzerland with the permission of the Germans - harnessed the dissatisfaction with the war weariness and the poverty and starvation which the mobilization of the Empire resulted in. Perhaps ironically, the actions of these "peace-callers" would soon start to turn violent, workers and peasants across the country trying to get their point across through strikes, protest actions and often bloody riots. The radicalization of the Army played an important role as well - many of the soldiers serving in the Imperial Russian Army had grown completely disillusioned both ways, and as revolutionary activity began to take place in the defeated German and Austro-Hungarian empires, they got to chance to witness it first hand and, once demobilized, return with a new outlook. Of course, this radicalization went both ways - plenty of Russian soldiers returned home believing themselves to be heroes and having their nationalism reinvigorated, which came into stark contrast with the poor situation back home.

As Russian soldiers marched into the formerly German occupied territories of the Empire, they saw that the situation here had changed just as radically as it did in Petrograd or Moscow. Though initially they carried no interest in cooperating with the peoples in the territories they occupied, as the Great War drew to a close, the desperate German government offered an olive branch to the Poles, Lithuanians and Latvians in occupied territory, promising postwar independence in exchange for loyalty and support. A provisional Polish state, a regency for the Kingdom of Poland under the leadership of Waclaw Niemojowski, had already been established in German-occupied Russian Poland, although it had little real power and was mostly just for show, whereas in Lithuania, though no statelike structure was established, the Vilnius Conference held in late 1916 and endorsed by the German occupation authorities called for the swift establishment of an independent Lithuanian state. The returning Russians arrived to territories which had their nationalism fully invigorated and populations which had been sick of requisitions, war and uncertainty, and the first thing on their mind were independent states led by one of their own, be it Pole, Lithuanian or Latvian. Though the reoccupation of Lithuania was mainly calm, as no large-scale local resistance units had formed by the time when the armistice was signed, the Polish units within the Central Powers armies, like the Polnische Wehrmacht or the Polish Auxiliary Corps, refused to stand down, demobilize or flee to Germany and instead stood their ground in Poland. Jozef Pilsudski, one of the chief leaders of the Polish Legions, released by the German authorities from imprisonment during the last weeks of the war to boost the morale of Polish units, now assumed control as the temporary Naczelnik of a forming Polish state. The subsequent Russian reoccupation of Poland is considered by some to have been a new Polish uprising and a Russo-Polish war by others, but the result of it was obvious from the beginning - within weeks, the Imperial Russian Army took control of the country's main cities and began reestablishing order in the countryside, the disparate Polish Legions were defeated one after the other, and Pilsudski himself arrested again. As it became increasingly clear, however, that not only Poland and the other Western regions will not be easily stabilized, but that Russia will be tasked with occupying new territory formerly held by the German and Austro-Hungarian empires, which would be even less happy with the Russian modus operandi, few believed that the current harsh integrationist position on the Western regions is the way to the future. Increased autonomy for the Poles had been promised by the Tsar's government at the very beginning of the war, to prevent the Poles from becoming a fifth column, with the formation of the Polish National Committee and endorsement of the so-called "Blue Army" under Jozef Haller in France. Something would have to be done about those promises, after all.

640px-Nicholas_II_with_his_family_in_Yevpatoria.jpg


Tsar Nicholas II returns to Petrograd on March 5th, 1917

Tsar Nicholas II returned from his wartime headquarters in Mogilev to a capital which was on the verge of revolution. The victory in the Great War and the return of the monarch did little to alleviate the main concerns which the people had - the mass poverty and starvation which had set place on the country during the exhausting conflict, the increasingly worse labor conditions and radicalizing socialist movement, and a completely dysfunctional government. During the Tsar's service in the front, most of the day to day matters of the government were handled by his wife, Grand Duchess Alexandra, who had shown herself to be completely inept in these matters and managed to alienate almost every single deputy in the Imperial Duma one way or another. As had been stated, "in the seventeen months of the 'Tsarina's rule', from September 1915 to February 1917, Russia had four Prime Ministers, five Ministers of the Interior, three Foreign Ministers, three War Ministers, three Ministers of Transport and four Ministers of Agriculture. This "ministerial leapfrog", as it came to be known, not only removed competent men from power, but also disorganized the work of government since no one remained long enough in office to master their responsibilities." The Prime Minister at the time of Nicholas II's return, holding office since January of the same year, was Prince Nikolai Golitsyn, a 67 year old protege of Alexandra and, because of his advanced years, inept in handling the ongoing crisis. The Progressive Bloc within the Duma, composed of the Progressists, Kadets, splinters of the Octobrists and various Nationalist parties, as well as individual members, held the majority, and they demanded the dismissal of Prime Minister Golitsyn in exchange for a "government of public confidence", which would have the approval of the bloc and be able to address the immediate concerns of the Empire's radicalized population through structural reforms. The Tsar returned to Petrograd aboard a train and immediately set for the Tauride Palace - supposedly, his associate Baron Woldemar Freedericksz offered to show himself to the crowds and organize a military parade to celebrate the victory in the war, but the Tsar declined, citing security concerns. The Imperial Duma had only one thing on its mind - replacing Prime Minister Golitsyn with someone more palatable to reforms. Yielding to the pressure had been encouraged by the rest of the Romanov family, too - including Grand Duke Paul, Grand Duke Cyril and Grand Duke Dmitry, who, encouraged by Chairman of the Duma Mikhail Rodzianko, had signed a manifesto recommending the introduction of a constitutional system in Russia.

To say that the Tsar was reluctant would be an understatement - especially because the Great War, which was supposed to strengthen the institution of the Tsar and potentially allow the restoration of the autocracy of the past, was what would finally bring down the authority of the Tsar to that of a mere constitutional monarch. However, he was playing with a weak hand. As Rodzianko would inform in a telegram about the situation in the Capital, "there must no delay - any procrastination would be amount to death". The capital was nearing a state of anarchy, workers in Petrograd's largest industrial plant, the Putilov Factory, had gone on strike on this very same day, and while constitutionalism may be enough to appease some of the protesters, if the Tsar were to decline, they would move on to demanding a monarchy instead. With the choice of either maintaining the 300 year olf Romanov dynasty of watching it collapse in flames, the Tsar made the choice to remove Prince Golitsyn from his position and, in his place, appoint one of the main leaders of the Progressive Bloc, the historian Pavel Milyukov, belonging to the Constitutional Democratic Party, as the new Prime Minister. Milyukov and his party, the Kadets, were considered to be the premier liberal faction in imperial Russian politics, though the beginning of the war shifted them more to the right, openly advocating for the continuation of the conflict, using nationalist rhetoric to whip up support and calling for annexations in the following peace treaty (Milyukov himself had even ended up nicknamed "Milyukov of the Dardanelles" for his vocal support for the annexation of the Bosphorus Straits). Milyukov's appointment was endorsed by the rest of the Progressive Bloc, including the Kadets, Progressives and left Octobrists, while the Trudoviks and the rest of the Octobrist faction, as well as independent nationalist deputies, were ambivalent.

On the next day, March 6th, Tsar Nicholas II, with the elite loyalist Preobrazhensky Regiment activated and moved into the city both for the monarch's personal safety and to begin reestablishing order in Petrograd, made a public appearance outside of the Tauride Palace, for the first time since the end of the war. There, the monarch announced the end of the Great War for good, the appointment of Pavel Milyukov as the new Prime Minister, as well as announced several promises of reforms and actions which shall be taken in the immediate future, in what will later be etched into history as the "Armistice Promises". These included:
- the abolition of the Basic Laws of 1906 and the drafting of a new Constitution which would adhere to democratic and pluralistic principles;
- the swift demobilization of the Army and the extension of suffrage to soldiers and officers for their effort in the Great War;
- the implementation of freedom of unionize, work safety regulations, and a welfare system modelled after the Imperial German, or "Bismarckian" model;
- the abolition of restrictions and discriminatory policies for other nationalities and faiths of Russia, such as Poles and Jews;
- a "righteous and just peace" after the Great War, which will include significant territorial and reparatory concessions from the defeated Central Powers to pay for the Russian blood shed in the conflict.
The speech was promulgated through newspapers, posters and mounted news carriers across the entire country. The reactions to the Armistice Promises were mixed, but overall positive - though the far left and the far right were both dissatisfied, the former believing that anything but the abdication of "Nicholas the Bloody" is too little concessions, while the latter thinking that too many concessions had been given to the left in what should be a moment of glory for the Russian Empire. For the first time in two years, public authorities across Russia's cities and countryside recorded a semblance of stability, as many of the striking workers either returned to factories completely or at least took their protests less violently, while the end of the war finally got many to take an easier breath and consider the future with optimism.

This returning stability, alongside with units being freed from the front and now available for operations in the country, gave Nicholas II the confidence to consider a repeat of the response to the Revolution of 1905 - granting promises to the unruly nation and then sending in the army when their guard is down to eliminate the leadership of the revolutionary movement - except with even less of a delay between the protests and the elimination. The Imperial Duma did not even want to consider such an act, however, and even discussing such a possibility got a number of the deputies in the parliament to call treason and demand abdication, though such demands were quickly shut down by the silent majority. The truth is, however that even the fiercely anti-violence deputies knew that despite the Armistice Promises, the situation in the country was still far from stable, and even in this slightly calmer state, an armed overthrow of the Tsarist regime was not a distant possibility. With radical far-left leaders such as Vladimir Lenin and Leon Trotsky continuing to run rampant across the country's cities, calling for the establishment of a "proletarian dictatorship" across Russia, there was little hope for a reconciliation and a military response would be necessary eventually. On the other hand, the Russian people were well aware of what happened in 1905 and had no desire to be betrayed like that ever again. The loyalty of the army units which would be used to sweep the country of socialist demagogues was up for debate as well. Still, however, Tsar Nicholas II was adamant, and as the Basic Laws had not been repealed yet, he opted to use his powers of releasing emergency decrees in times of crisis in use. On March 16th, in the Duma, Nicholas II began reading out an ukaze, declaring the implementation of martial law in all of Russia's major cities and ordering 30 divisions from the front to be moved to the Russian heartland to start eliminating threats to the Tsarist government and the stability of the state, but before he could even finish reading out the declaration, he was met with mass shouting from the parliamentarians and a verbal declaration by Prime Minister Milyukov that he and his government will all resign if this decree sees the light of day. Only a few dozen extreme right deputies, led by Alexei Khvostov, didn't disagree with the decree, most of them merely ambivalent, and intimidated by such resistance, the Tsar withdrew his order.

This is where the persona of General Lavr Kornilov, a Russian military commander of Siberian Cossack origin and the commander the Petrograd Military District, comes into play. Seeing the inability of the Tsarist government to take immediate action against the ongoing unrest in Petrograd and knowing of the failed ukaze which would have allowed him to start rounding up the Bolsheviks and Mensheviks in the city one by one, Kornilov opted to take matters into his own hands, and, the divisions under his command bolstered by soldiers returning from the front as well as the reaffirmed loyalty of the Imperial Guards and Tsar's Escort Cossacks stationed in the military region, the general ordered a move on the capital to begin a mass offensive against the ongoing strikes, riots and protests in the city. Within a week, known as the "Red Days of March", over three thousand suspects were arrested, almost a hundred shot during skirmishes within the city and many more injured or forced to disperse to the underground. Among the people arrested was much of the higher leadership of the Bolshevik faction of the fallen RSDLP, including Vladimir Lenin, Leon Trotsky, Nikolai Bukharin, Joseph Stalin and Lev Kamenev, while many others successfully escaped the city to the east. The Tsar, who had returned to his residence at Tsarskoye Selo after the debacle in the Duma, intrepreted the events in the capital as a coup at first and had already begun reaching out to his Chief of Staff, General Mikhail Alekseyev, to begin organizing resistance against "an ongoing republican coup in Petrograd". Alekseyev, however, opted to take a careful approach to the events in Petrograd and did not immediately send troops, both out of fear of rebellion among his soldiers and also because he hardly considered Kornilov to be a republican revolutionary. The Duma in the Tauride Palace, on the other hand, was surrounded by Kornilov's soldiers, and several of the deputies who were in session at the time recount a moment when several Cossack soldiers led by one of Kornilov's proteges, Mikhail Levitov, burst into the main chamber and ordered the Duma to disperse, the deputies only being saved from such a fate by a messenger suddenly reaching the colonel that "the time is not there yet".

Indeed, it is believed that Kornilov, though declaring himself to be merely acting on the behalf of the civilian government and restoring order in Petrograd, had the intention of, to put it more bluntly, "remaining there permanently". The General was already not much of a fan of the Duma, and the proposed future constitutional reforms of the Empire would have satisfied him even less - meanwhile, the possibility of a more iron fisted leadership, with or without the Tsar as the head of state, would have been a lot more preferable to him. As March drew to a close and Petrograd turned quiet at last, only with the occasional corpse being carried away from the littered streets, the country entered a crisis of leadership. Nobody - neither the foreign states watching nor the Russians themselves - knew who was in charge of Russia anymore. Kornilov still believed that he was just a garrison commander doing his duty, and attempted to contact the Tsar through telegram, but to no avail. The Tsar remained in Tsarskoye Selo, fearing that returning to Petrograd would be a death sentence. The Imperial Duma was practically waiting for the commander to declare himself the supreme dictator. The STAVKA was operating under barebones knowledge of what's happening in Petrograd. In this situation, the decisive factor was Alexei Brusilov, one of the most famous and prestigious commanders in the Imperial Russian Army, whose former deputy Kornilov once was, who, independently of the STAVKA and the Tsar's orders, contacted the garrison commander through telegram, requesting to stand down and hand the reins of power back to the civilian government. Kornilov acquitted, a response which Brusilov forwarded to his superior Alexeyev. From there, everything went a lot more simply - a few divisions were sent to Petrograd, the Tsar returned from Tsarskoye Selo and immediately ordered Kornilov's arrest for acting without orders and planning a coup d'etat.

This is where problems arose. The "Kornilov Affair" led to a clash between the military and the civilian government. Alexeyev and Brusilov were both in favor of Kornilov's removal and arrest, but many junior officers, NCOs and soldiers weren't - they saw him not as a traitor, but as a hero, who prevented a Bolshevik overthrow of the Tsar and eliminated these enemies of the state. Kornilov professed the same thing, stating that overthrowing the government was never one of his wishes. The Duma wanted Kornilov to be locked behind bars or even executed for treason, having been firmly scared for life by the entire Kornilov Affair. And as this process was taking place, radical socialists across the entire Empire began to take up arms and cry betrayal, declaring that the Kornilov Affair was completely staged by the Tsarist government to acquit themselves of any responsibility for the Red Days of March, and trying to pull a repeat of 1905. Tsar Nicholas II, hacing been personally scorned by what he initially believed to have been a coup d'etat against his already fragile rule, and yet not trying to appear like he is on the side of the socialists, took the option of compromise - stripping General Kornilov of his command and titles and putting him under house arrest in Rostov, under close supervision. It was a compromise which satisfied completely no one - socialists and the Duma were enraged by what they perceived to be a mere slap on the wrist for the butcher of Petrograd, while the far-right elements within the Army and the greater society saw this as a betrayal of a man who, in their eyes, saved the Russian Empire from a Bolshevik takeover.

Regardless, with the initial instability slowly put under control, the government of Pavel Milyukov could finally begin normal operation, swiftly establishing itself as one of the most productive, if short lived, governments since 1905. In a short time period, pressed by the concerns of alleviating mass unrest and regaining full control over the country, the Milyukov cabinet pushed through several decrees and law projects through the Duma and the cooperative, if reluctant Tsar Nicholas II. One of the first acts of the cabinet was the lifting of alcohol prohibition, implemented by the Tsar during the Great War as an attempt to boost morale and production effciency, but ending up laughably backfiring as the revenue of the government sharply fell due to loss of alcohol tax. The restrictions on the press and the freedom of speech during and before the Great War, once the Bolshevik insurgency calmed down and the threat of the action backfiring became less likely, were lifted, although with some reservations in specific, "anti-government" instances. The implementation of demobilization took place, over two million soldiers returning from the front and from occupation zones in Germany, Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire to their families and jobs, and in accordance to the Armistice Promises, an amendment to the Basic Laws of the Russian Empire was passed allowing military personnel to participate and vote in national and local elections. The proposed ban on capital punishment, however, was more controversial. Tsar Nicholas II opposed it vehemently, vetoing any attempts by the Duma to implement such a policy, while far-right politicians within the Duma whipped up internal opposition within the Progressive Bloc, especially from the Octobrist faction of the alliance. A possibility of the Progressive Bloc dissolving completely was discussed, but the Progressives and Kadets, knowing that the only coalition alternative would be a loose right-wing coalition led by the Octobrists, opted to instead cut their losses and drop the motion for good, making up for it with basic labor code reforms to appease the still unruly working classes of the Russian Empire. Prime Minister Milyukov also contacted the Polish National Committee and offered Roman Dmowski of the National Democrats which had fled to Russia during the Great War to form a provisional "autonomous" Polish government for a future debate of a Finland-style status within the Russian Empire.

640px-William_Orpen_–_The_Signing_of_Peace_in_the_Hall_of_Mirrors%2C_Versailles_1919%2C_Ausschnitt.jpg


The signing of the Treaty of Versailles, December 1917

The Paris Peace Conference, aimed at putting a final end to the Great War and decide the order of the postwar world, opened on May of 1917, with representatives from dozens of nations either being invited or coming at their own accord to represent the interests of their state, either large or small, at the negotiations table. The Russian delegation to Paris was led by Prime Minister Pavel Milyukov and Foreign Affairs Minister Pyotr Struve, carrying the orders of Tsar Nicholas II on what they are required to campaign on in the negotiations. Still carrying sympathy for his cousin Kaiser Wilhelm II, who was currently desperately trying to manage a rapidly deteriorating German state, revolutionary activity popping up in Kiel, Berlin and Bavaria, the Tsar did not wish to see the German Empire completely dismantled, but, knowing the wishes of his people and the Armistice Promises, held high expectations for the Russian negotiators. The Russian Empire's primary interests were the redrawing of borders in Eastern Europe, extending the Russian Baltic coastline by acquiring East and West Prussia, achieving a bulwark against future German aggression in the form of an extended Russian Poland and the removal of the "Polish salient" by extending the border westward. This would mean the acquisition of Posen, Danzig and East Prussia, though gaining the resource rich Upper Silesia was also up for consideration. The Ukrainian brethren in East Galicia, though firmly opposed to Russian rule and wishing to see an independent Ruthenian state, need to join Mother Russia, and so does Lesser Poland and Krakow, the medieval capital of the Kingdom of Poland. The Austro-Hungarian Empire needs to be dismantled, a Czecho-Slovak state aligned with Russian interests established, Austria barred from ever unifying with Germany, Romania expanded into Transylvania, and Serbia allowed to form the state of Yugoslavia. The Ottoman Empire, having undertaken a mass slaughter of Russia's Orthodox brethren, must pay for these sins - Russia must be allowed to annex Armenian-majority territory of the Empire, an independent Kurdistan established, the Turkish state cut to pieces, and the ever so sought Dardanelles and the Bosphorus Strait acquired to grant Russia access to the Mediterranean at last. Russia's interests in the Balkans must be recognized by all of the world's powers, and with no Austria-Hungary to challenge it anymore, this "backyard" should extend from Fiume to Constantinople. And finally, Germany must accept the guilt for the war and pay an indemnity to the Russian Empire, or else.

How well did it go to achieve these, admittedly, ambitious goals in the Conference? Some passed through, some did not, others were not even discussed. In many cases, Russia stood on a similar camp as France, the two countries having suffered the brunt of the costs of the war and thus wishing to see a harsh treaty imposed on the Germans. This was in direct opposition to the United Kingdom and the United States, the latter of which had joined the war at its last inch on January of 1917, after the Germans took on the last-ditch attempt to turn the tide in their favor by implementing unrestricted submarine warfare. Both of them did not want to see Germany turned to dust, considering them to be a prospective trading partner and, just in case, a potential check on Franco-Russian power. The war guilt clause and reparations both passed, as did the ban on unifying Germany with Austria, while most of the Russian claims in Eastern Europe were accepted with little discussion - after all, all of those territories were already practically in Russia's hands, there was little which Russia could do about them regardless. The rest was where problems started to pop up, however. The Western Allies fervently opposed granting Russia a "blank cheque" on all of the Balkans, fearing overwhelming Russian influence in Eastern Europe. This was the moment when Greece, fearing future Russian domination, began cozying up ever closer with the British, while even Serbia began taking worrying glances towards apparent Russian imperialism in the region. Despite all which the Russians claimed on the necessity for them to control the Bosphorus, the British and French delegations were having none of it, instead demanding and eventually forcing through an international demilitarized zone for the straits. Not that it mattered, anyway, as none of the Entente had the ability to project power there on any short notice, and the nationalist government in Turkey led by Mustafa Kemal and his clique were quick to disregard any demands which the Entente might have had on the former Ottoman Empire...

The Russian delegation returned to their homeland on the beginning the next year, bringing an unsatisfactory treaty which did not address all of their concerns and a request for Russia to apply as one of the founding members of the League of Nations, a supranational organization with the declared clause of promoting peace and diplomatic cooperation across the planet. Debates on whether the treaties of the Paris Peace Conference - Versailles, Trianon, Sevres - made up for the millions of Russians lost in the Great War began to take place immediately - and quickly enough, the public opinion began to slowly steer towards "no, they were not". In the end, all which Milyukov and Struve brought was the annexation of several unruly border regions - so unruly that, for example, the Russian occupation authorities in the West already had to fight off mass Freikorps uprisings in East Prussia and Danzig - and a promise of reparations to cover the costs of the war. Reparations which might not even come like the Russians wanted them to, as the German government suddenly began to hyperinflate its currency to pay for those reparations with worthless Reichsmarks... This was when the far right of the Russian political spectrum activated, most notably the Black Hundreds, fanatical supporters of the Tsarist regime, nationalism and autocracy led by a shrewd and charismatic, though restless and poorly regarded extremist politician, Vladimir Purishkevich. The Black Hundreds, which had almost died out by 1914, but gained a second lease at life in the final stages of the Great War, celebrating the glorious victory against the Teutons and fighting the Bolshevik traitors through their own tactics, this being riots and mob assaults - and under Purishkevich's leadership, they whipped up a storm, denouncing the peace as nothing more than a "temporary armistice", demanding Kornilov to be restored to his position and war against Germany removed to march as far as the Rhine so Russia can take all which it needs.

The resentment against what was often perceived to be a "peace without victory", escalating violence in Russian-occupied East Prussia, an inability to receive the reparations needed to start rejuvenating the Russian industry, and the failure of Milyukov's own desire to see the Bosphorus in Russian hands, the Prime Minister opted to resign for good, filing in his departure on March 11th, 1918. Tsar Nicholas II chose an another member of the Kadet party, the criminologist, journalist, and progressive legislator Vladimir Nabokov, who had served as Milyukov's Minister of Justice during his one-year tenure. Nabokov was seen as acceptable to the left wing of Russian politics, having cooperated with them in the past for pushing through progressive reforms and having served as the Milyukov cabinet's mouthpiece to the Socialist Revolutionaries and RSDLP, and thus his appointment was approved by the majority of the Duma.

Though Nabokov was far from the head of government Purishkevich would have wanted to see replace Milyukov, his cabinet's fall could and was considered a victory of his - he did not get to enjoy it for long, however, as he soon departed from politics himself. Not through retirement, no, but through the power of the bullet. During a routine Black Hundredist rally in the streets of Moscow, Purishkevich suddenly saw himself felled by several bullets fired by Fanny Kaplan, a member of the radical wing of the Socialist Revolutionaries, severely injuring the politician, and leaving him dead in a hospital bed a few days later. The shots of the assassination rang across the entire nation, prompting mass violent backlash by far right elements across Russia, attacking and assaulting suspected radical socialists, until these actions finally found a stop at the hands of the police - however, with the loss of one of their main leaders, the Black Hundreds found it unable to maintain their momentum despite the initial surge during the Paris Peace Conference, haemorrhaging most of its membership and the majority of its members dispersing within a few months.

In that way, it could be said that Purishkevich's death set back the Russian far-right movement - however, it would be a mistake. Because nature does not tolerate a vacuum, and the fall of the Black Hundreds would soon only pave a way to a different, a much more refined and revolutionary movement, which, unlike the Hundredists, was more than just a mob of angry right-wing thugs.

And it would fly to take Russia by storm.
 
There's probably a fair chance the Vohzd is probably going to start killing Jews, Germans, Poles, Ukrainians, Balts, Finns, assorted Caucasian and Turkic peoples by the metric ton.
Well, for all we know, the Vozhd is going to be largely civic (or at least, cultural) in his nationalism like the Russian State in Kaiserreich.
 
Well, for all we know, the Vozhd is going to be largely civic (or at least, cultural) in his nationalism like the Russian State in Kaiserreich.
The problem, for starters, is that with the cultural part is that Russia is going to tell the Poles and Ukrainians, just for starters, that they're doing the whole Slav thing "wrong".
 
On the Orthodox Christmas of 1918, more specifically on January 6th, Moscow saw the formation of a part discussion club, part political think tank, attracting many of the city's intellectuals and notable public figures. Named "Rodina" ("Homeland"), it was a project envisioned by Vladimir Mayakovsky and Velimir Khlebnikov, two leading members of the Russian Futurist movement and former associates of Russian Social Democratic Labour, at least before the party compromised itself during the Bloody Days of March and the following anti-socialist crackdowns, forcing the two restless young artists to look towards a new ideology of salvation. Russian Futurism, composed of youthful, energetic artists and writers following the tenets of their Italian peer's Filippo Marinetti's "Futurist Manifesto", espousing the rejection of the past, a celebration of speed, machinery and violence, and advocating for modernization and cultural rejuvenation, was inherently incompatible with the traditional Tsarist autocracy of the pre-1905 period, nor did it view the attempts at establishing liberal constitutionla democracy any more favorable - Mayakovsky, Khlebnikov and others, with the downfall of Communism, which could have served as an outlet for their ideas, now became the fertile ground for a new, modern right-wing ideaology to build itself on top of. The Rodina debate club, though composed of people from varying backgrounds, be it demobilized soldiers and officers, or artists, or intellectuals, or restless members of the Russian nobility, eventually started coming to similar conclusions. The Great War and the years after it have shown that neither traditional Tsarism nor liberal democracy can withstand the threat of revolutionary, degenerate socialism and make up for the scorn which the Russian nation has received in the Paris Peace Conference. Russia has become the laughing stock of Europe, no longer the mighty nation which vanquished Charles XII and Napoleon, but merely a second fiddle to the Western powers of France, the United Kingdom and the United States - and this arose from the short sighted, conservative views of the dysfunctional government, most likely manipulated and held back by the "international Jewry", failing to grasp the necessity for structural reform and immediately industrialization. Surely, even if Russia may be a part of the Entente now, this status quo will not remain in the future - and the Rodina is doomed to be partitioned by the Western powers within twenty years if it doesn't become an industrial superpower. The concept of "palingenesis" - a national rebirth, a restoration of Russian glory and its status as a great power from the ashes which the 19th century and the following Great War left it in. The assassination of Vladimir Purishkevich in late March of the same year at the hands of the radical socialist Fanny Kaplan severely shook the Rodina club, and the less than satisfactory response of the Nabokov government to the assassination, it trying to avoid breaking ties with their allies in the left-wing of Russian politics and thus acting reluctantly, as well as the influx of many former Black Hundreds members into the ranks of the club, convinced many that the only option left was to turn this into an actual political platform.

However, this was not where either Mayakovsky or Khlebnikov made the final decision - the foundation of the so-called National Patriotic Union "Rodina" (Narodno-Patrioticheskiy Soyuz "Rodina") was instead the brainchild of Mikhail Tukhachevsky and Boris Brasol. Boris Brasol was a Ukrainian-born Russian jurist, who had actually been a Marxist in his teenage and young adult years, but took an extreme turn towards the extreme right in the years following the Revolution of 1905 and especially while leading up to the Great War, turning into a member of the Black Hundreds when he became increasingly convinced that the Bolshevik Party was an international Jewish conspiracy against the Russian nation, similar to what is detailed in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. A participant in the famous blood libel case against Menahem Beilis, a Jewish citizen of the Empire accused of ritual murder, and later a veteran of the Great War, at least until 1916, when he was sent to the United States for a short period of time as a war correspondent, he had the notoriety among his fellow members of the Rodina as a well spoken and learned, if sometimes abrasive and highly radical member of the party. Mikhail Tukhachevsky was an impoverished Russian noble who had gone through a career of military service as an officer in the Imperial Russian Army in the Great War and the years preceding it. However, the war itself was not very pleasant to the officer - though showing bravor and clear military talent in the first stages of the war, he was captured by the Germans on February 1915 and held as a prisoner of war for almost two years, where, after his fifth attempt to escape from captivity, he finally managed to return to his homeland. During his time as a prisoner of war, Tukhachevsky shared a cell with a French fellow, Captain Charles de Gaulle, who, in his memoirs, would later report on the Russian as a highly eclectic man - prone to nihilist beliefs, hard to talk out of something, and referring to Germans and Jews as "dogs who spread their fleas throughout the world". The return to Russia and the demobilization of the Imperial Russian Army following the Armistice of Compiegne practically left Tukhachevsky on the street, which turned him towards the path of being a political agitator living off his veteran's pension - and, though initially with some difficulties, he turned out to be really good at that, as if "electrifying" his opponents during debates and speeches and showing promise in dealing with the organization and logistics of running a mass political party, despite his surprisingly young age (only 25 years old in 1918). The NPS established itself with a 20 point political program, an eclectic mix of extreme Russian nationalism (opposing the terms of the Treaties of the Paris Peace Conference, limiting migration in and out of the country, restricting citizenship only to East Slavs) and corporatism, with instances of populist socialism (implementing increased controls of the economy, land reform, establishing state-controlled trade unions and a universal education system), and began operation on April 2nd, 1918. Brasol swiftly became the chief ideologue of the party, helping write public speeches and debate preparations for his peers, while also, alongside a fellow member Nikolay Ustryalov, a young Slavophilic professor of law harboring dreams of a "Eurasian" Russian Empire, neither European nor Asian but standing as the perfect middle ground of these two distant worlds, worked on ironing out further party policy regarding specific issues. The youthful Tukhachevsky became the face of the party, making himself known to Russian society through nigh-constant travel from city to city and from district to district, making speeches about the "bloody peace" of the Versailles which left Russia with squat, the dangers of both radical socialism and liberal demoracy and the need, nay, necessity of strong, competent rule which can lead Russia to a new era of a national golden age- which gave plenty uneasy reminders of socialist demagogues such as Lenin or Trotsky.

Early on, the National Patriotic Union received an unexpected ally in the form of the former Socialist-Revolutionary writer and terrorist Boris Savinkov. Hailing from Kharkiv and having the portfolio of an unfinished degree in law in Petrograd University, Savinkov had initially toyed with the idea of Marxism much like Brasol thanks to meeting prominent left-wing intellectuals like Nikolai Berdyaev and Anatoly Lunacharsky while exiled to Vologda, but while he also ended up dismissing the ideology for not fitting his worldview, unlike Brasol, he did not end up being thrown to the far right, instead becoming a member of the agrarian and left-wing SRs, leading the radical and militant wing of the party known as the Fighting Organization. In fact, though this is rarely mentioned in media and historiography, both contemporary and from the interwar period, but much of the initial membership of the National Patriotic Union was composed of former supporters of Bolsheviks, Mensheviks and the Mezhraiontsy - for example, many of the Red Guards, paramilitary organizations rallied by workers' deputies and engaging in revolutionary activity during 1917 and 1918 across Russian cities, would later end up absorbed by the youthful, militant wing of the NPD, the so-called "Voluntary Militia". Plenty of them had singled up for the Guards not because of some ideological loyalty, but simply to express their dissatisfaction with the current state of affairs in Russian society the only way they knew how, through violence. The "Voluntary Militia" - which, as many of its members would end up wearing the green uniforms of the Imperial Russian Army with the symbol of the Archangel Michael, the tryzub, on their arms because unused uniforms were plentiful and most of the demobilized soldiers had a set, would earn the colloquial name "Greenshirts" - provided a way to express this dissatisfaction and frustration, the members of the militia being assigned tu guard meetings of the NPD, spread the news about the Party across Russian society and, occasionally, get into clandstine and sometimes open clashes with remaining Reds. Savinkov, after having been kicked out from the Socialist Revolutionaries because of his terrorist tendencies and bad blood with the Tsarist government (after all, Savinkov was implicated in the murder of Grand Duke Sergei Alexandrovich, the uncle of Tsar Nicholas II, in 1905 - though he was no longer actively persecuted by the government due to have spent over ten years in exile, the SR leadership saw his presence as a liability), jumped ship to the National Patriotic Union, offering his talent as a leader of the Fighting Organization and helping put both the organization of the party and the structure of the Voluntary Militia in order. By late summer of 1918, Savinkov had become the second most important man in the party, second only to Tukhachevsky, who remained as the movement's icon and most loyal mouthpiece - however, he hardly fit in with the modus operandi of the Rodina movement. Savinkov was firmly in the left wing of the party, considerably less emphasizing the necessity for Russia to reacquire its great power status and promote the Russian ethnicity as the sole leading force of Russia, and instead focusing more on the relationship between the worker and peasant and one end and the Tsarist government and the aristocracy on the other. Unlike most other members of the party, who were ambivalent towards the monarchy and the Russian Orthodox Church, while Savinkov was completely against it, and, in addition to that, while he paid lip service to anti-semitism during his speeches, denouncing them as the rank and file of the capitalist and aristocrat class, he never went further (after all, his second wife, Yevgeniya Ivanovna, was Jewish herself) which put him at odds with the Black Hundredist faction of the party. He did not pay much mind to it, however. A savvy political operator, Savinkov believed that he was only here to take advantage of a yet another splinter faction of the Black Hundreds which he believed he could take over and use as a vehicle to enter national power.

Immediately, the National Patriotic Union fell under the watch of the Tsarist government - initially, however, few paid much attention to it. Splinters of the Black Hundredist movement and other various right-wing nationalist organizations were aplenty in postwar Russia, and though the NPD may have had a few more notable members among them and was somewhat more shouty, it couldn't claim to be anything but one of many.

Tukhachevsky.jpg
Savinkov.png

Brasol.jpg
Ustryalov.jpeg


Mikhail Tukhachevsky, Boris Savinkov, Boris Brasol and Nikolai Ustryalov

350px-Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-H28740%2C_St._Petersburg%2C_Er%C3%B6ffnung_der_Parlamente.jpg


Tsar Nicholas II's opening speech before the Fifth Duma of the Russian Empire

The liberal government of Vladimir Nabokov was not meant to last - with the suspension of elections during the war lifted, new elections to the Imperial Duma were held on July of 1918. Before the election could even be announced, however, worries were starting to overtake the State Council and the Tsar himself that with the increasingly revolutionary atmosphere in the Empire, radical left parties such as the Socialist Revolutionaries and the remnants of the Social Democratic Labour Party, if in coalition with the Mensheviks, could form a majority in the Fifth Duma and thus use legal procedures to attempt to abolish the monarchy or seek the establishment of Soviet rule. Though some advisors to the Tsar, such as Alexander Protopopov, the former Minister of the Interior during the last years of the war, believed that the reserve powers of the monarch under the Basic Law would be enough to prevent such an outcome, the linging promise of a new constitution for the Russian Empire kept Nicholas II wary of such an occassion. If the left wing acquires a majority in the Duma, their ideas will reflect in the Constitution, that was not denied by anyone. Faced with such a dilemma, Tsar Nicholas II and the conservative elements in the Duma and the State Council proposed the project for the Electoral Law of 1918, which, according to the text of the document, would remain in power until a new Constitution drafted a new system for electing the members of the bicameral parliament. In essence, it enshrined the reforms already pushed through by the Milyukov cabinet such as extending the voting franchise to soldiers, but with a few notable additions which changed up the political scene. The current complicated system of electing deputies from each social class, with the aristocrats and bourgeoisie weighted in favor, remained, though with a slightly larger share given to the lower and middle classes; and, in addition, all of the manifestos and campaigns of the participating parties and independent electoral lists would be checked and any party found advocating for the abolition of the Tsarist regime would be barred from participating. The second tenet caused an outrage among Russian society - the RSDLP and other far-left parties boycotted the election, the Socialist-Revolutionaries thretened to do the same and the leader of the Trudoviks in the Duma, Alexander Kerensky, declared that "if this filthy document passes, a million angry workers will knock to the door of the Duma tomorrow". They didn't, however, and eventually pragmatism prevailed - the SRs modified their party program to remove any mentions of the position of the Tsar, which alienated many of their supporters, but enabled them to compete. The RSDLP maintained their boycott. With the moderate left acquitting to the Tsar's terms and the radical left boycotting, this freed up millions of potential voters, the majority of them angry, frustrated, pent up with anger for their lack of a comfortable life and rising poverty, and while quite a few of them dispersed across the moderate left parties, many found their home in the National Patriotic Union, whose ideology was an eclectic fusion of nationalism and socialism and appealed to many.

The Rodina movement, officially ambivalent on the position of the monarchy and the Russian Orthodox Church - though the left wing of the party was hostile towards both of those concepts, believing that the rebirth of the Russian nation can only be achieved through the eradication of the old semi-feudal system which continued to hold it back, the party's right, mostly hailing from former Black Hundreds and retired military men, viewed the two institutions a lot more positively and as potential beacons of stability in these trying times - had no problem adhering to the Electoral Law and the election of 1918 became its first real test in national politics. Guided by Tukhachevsky, Savinkov and Brasol, the party took a highly active stance towards electoral campaigning, wielding its small, but loyal and energetic assets, mostly composed of demobilized soldiers, officers and former Red Guards, to utmost efficiency with door-to-door campaigning and nigh-constant speeches by the more savvy members of their ranks made in many of the Empire's largest cities, like Moscow, Petrograd, Kiev and others, where they denounced the Peace of Versailles as a "peace without victory", demanded an end to what they called shambles of liberal democracy, promised wide-reaching reforms for all of the nation's social classes and a rebirth of the Russian nation from the ashes like a phoenix, sought for General Lavr Kornilov to be released from his arrest and all of his titles returned for the heroic defense of Russia against the Bolshevik scourge, and demanded actions to be taken against the Empire's Jewish population, who they believed were the root cause behind Russia's suffering in the Great War and its aftermath, sucking the Russian people dry of their hard earned wealth and resources and sponsoring the traitorous socialist movement which nearly led the Empire to collapse in 1917. The presence of the National Patriotic Union brought an interesting variable to the mix in the generally predictable Russian Duma elections, as for the first time, the established political parties in Russian politics - the Kadets, Octobrists and Progressives - faced opposition not just from the left wing, but also from a strong force in the far right wing of the spectrum.

The election itself, taking place on September 5th, 1918, saw significantly stronger showings for the center right, most chalking it up to the Kadets and Progressives having been in power in the lead up to the election and thus receiving the blunt of the blame for the less than satisfactory year after the Great War concluded. Out of the 450 seats in the State Duma, 119 were taken by the center-right, constitutional monarchist Union of October 17, while around 120 more were collected by various nationalist, right-wing and independent lists, local candidates and minor parties. The other side of the spectrum was deeply divided - the Constitutional Democrats, drawing most of their support from loyal voters in the intelligentsia and the upper middle class, collected 60 seats, while the Progressives and the Trudoviks, both of whom received a significant share of what used to be socialist and far-left voters, overperformed compared to 1912 and became significant parties in their own right. The Socialist-Revolutionaries, on the other hand, having participated in elections and not boycotted them for the first time in their history, struggled to win many seats due to intense opposition from all the other major parties and voting district machinations by the Tsarist government, only garnering 15 of them in the end. Meanwhile, in the nationalist faction of the Duma, on the right wing of the political spectrum, five deputies which won under the banner of the NPD sat - Boris Brasol, Nikolai Ustryalov, Pavel Krushevan, Mikhail Levitov and Konstantin Yurenev, all of them from urban districts, most notably Moscow, which was starting to turn into a stronghold for the Russian extreme right. Though no electoral sweep, it was certainly better than many had expected, even within the party itself, and the won seats in the Fifth Duma placed the Rodina movement on the political map of the Russian Empire.

With the Octobrists achieving a plurality of the seats once again, and supported by most independent nationalist and right-wingers, the latter usually aristocrats, as a preferable choice over an all-left coalition, the party submitted its first proposal for Prime Minister - Alexander Guchkov, the long time leader of the Octobrist party, a former Chairman of the State Duma and a moderate conservative with close ties to the Zemstvo system, which, as the party hoped, would be enough to keep the liberal parties such as the Kadets complacent while also being acceptable to the Tsar. Though Nicholas II considered options of his own, such as Alexander Protopopov to force a Kadet victory, or Mikhail Rodzianko, the incumbent Chairman of the State Duma, who had once already replaced Guchkov in 1911 for being too much of a "Young Turk", but eventually acquitted, figuring that the Octobrists would be easy to control and in line with the Tsar's position on most issues.
 
Incredibly hyped for this; Russia (and Eastern Europe in general) TLs are pretty rare on this site, and you're an excellent writer, so let's see where this goes!
 

StuGium

Banned
Russian Futurism, composed of youthful, energetic artists and writers following the tenets of their Italian peer's Filippo Marinetti's "Futurist Manifesto", espousing the rejection of the past, a celebration of speed, machinery and violence, and advocating for modernization and cultural rejuvenation

Anthem of the Russian Futurist Movement:


but on a more serious note, the work you put into this really shows.
 
Incredibly hyped for this; Russia (and Eastern Europe in general) TLs are pretty rare on this site, and you're an excellent writer, so let's see where this goes!
Anthem of the Russian Futurist Movement:


but on a more serious note, the work you put into this really shows.
Thank you, thank you!

It's been a while since I've worked on a TL, and I decided to try my hand at something which is both very common in the AH community and yet has seldom been explored in dedicated timelines, with plenty of cliches and misinterpretations arising as a result. Glad you all like it.
 
Top