Post Jacksonian American Monarchy

Have the United States become a Monarchy by 1900
PoD is the end of Jackson's 2nd term

Rules are as follows:
*British Conquer US and Install puppet Monarchy or re assert British crown not allowed. Same applies to other foreign powers.


* As a whole, the population Generally supports the Monarch by 1900.

* Bonus points if Union Stays whole in Civil war, but not a requirement.

* Bonus points for style along the lines of "United Federal Empire of A"
 
I would say this is pretty much impossible. The Jacksonian Era has only enhanced the public's fondness for democracy and the voting practices which go along with it (it's during Jackson's rise to prominence and tenure that Congressional nominating caucuses for the Presidency are replaced by national conventions and suffrage is further increased) and ideas of monarchism have been thoroughly discredited alongside the defunct Federalist Party. Considering a significant portion of the United States' identity is derived from the civic virtues embodied by the Constitution and the Republican system, you would need to fundamentally change the way Americans view government and its role in society. The imposition of a puppet monarch by a foreign power also seems equally unlikely for much the same reasons.

Prior to Jackson, I could see the possibility of some type of monarchy taking shape on the heels of a Federalist Hegemony (excluding the rather overdone scenario by which Washington agrees to become a monarch). Say the lame duck Congress of 1801 uses the electoral dispute between Jefferson and Burr to its advantage and keeps Adams as President indefinitely (presumably under the pretext of a national emergency) crushing any attempts at dissent. The Judiciary firmly controlled by Federalists and the precedent of Judicial Review having yet to be established, there is no possibility for such edicts being rendered unconstitutional.

The resulting Civil War (Governor Monroe was prepared to march on Washington in OTL at the head of the Virginia militia in the event Adams attempted to prevent Jefferson's ascension to the Presidency) further concentrates the powers of the Federal Government (now in the hands of Hamilton and the Essex Junto, Adams either quietly removed or otherwise made complacent), the Executive given a lion's share of powers by a rump Congress in order to successfully prosecute his duties as Commander-In-Chief. The President thus morphs into a Dictator and with Hamilton's urging, the office is morphed into a type of quasi-Monarchy (parallels could likely be drawn with Napoleon's France). Somewhat implausible, but provided the circumstances it's the best thing I could conjure.

Either that or Jackson himself manages to make himself a monarch, but I don't see this as happening (though it would certainly lend a degree of legitimacy to depictions of 'King Andrew I' by the Whigs).
 
Top