alternatehistory.com

Here's the two examples of a scenario where the Pilgrims (and/or subsequently, Puritans) settled in alternate locations:
1. AHC by Hobelhouse
2. AHC by Umbric Man
3. Plymouth: The City than Never Sleeps

How this alternate settlement of the Pilgrims (and/or Puritans) affect the history of the United States? Who would settle the Northern Appalachian region, which is known as New England in OTL?
Top