(Poll)In Alt histories, how do you prefer Ireland?

Various Irelands

  • United and independent

    Votes: 14 40.0%
  • United and in Union with Great British

    Votes: 18 51.4%
  • Divided with the North to Great Britain

    Votes: 3 8.6%
  • Divided with North NOT with Great Britain

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    35
Status
Not open for further replies.
For me it's a toss up between an independent United Ireland and one that is still with Great Britain
 

Ryan

Donor
united Ireland in the UK.

with Ireland united and in the UK it doesn't suffer the economic damage that was caused by dividing the Ireland otl. the unionists are happy and IIRC the Irish themselves were happy enough being in the UK, they just wanted home rule, until the Easter rising so there shouldn't be too many problems.

ideally the UK would be reformed into some sort of federal structure so the Irish get the home rule they want, whilst the unionists have nothing to complain about because the whole country is getting the same treatment and thus they won't feel like they're being ignored/abandoned.

united independent Ireland is my second option, again due to map tidiness and prevention of economic damage, preferably with some sort of federal structure as well to make the unionists happy (or at least less angry)
 
United and Independent is my first choice.

That said... I'd be OK with United and proper Home Rule. Home Rule, I see as gradually becoming more and more until we're like a closer version of Canada :D Which I'd be totally fine with.
 

Ryan

Donor
oh yeah, its a chat subject.

if you want you'll have to repost in the chat forum without a poll.
 
oh yeah, its a chat subject.

if you want you'll have to repost in the chat forum without a poll.
I have see Questions like this posted here before, and they were never moved. Just search "favorite" and you'll see why I thought it was OK to put this here.
 
I think this sort of poll is not allowed.

oh yeah, its a chat subject.

if you want you'll have to repost in the chat forum without a poll.

You could argue that since it's a discussion of how to see Ireland in alternate history, that's not the same as saying that it'd be a more desirable arrangement for the real world. There's also way more Naziwanks than people who actually think the Nazis should have won, of course.
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top