The reason I did so for Rumsfeldia is that it has a reputation outside of AH.com as utterly implausible, and I just wanted to see how AH.commers view it.
Right, but that doesn't make it any less mean-spirited, especially as you've put this here of all places, when it's a discussion topic for books and media or non-pol chat.
But for my two cents, it's a Timeline in which each update builds upon the last, and eventually diverges to the point where it becomes implausible. There are certain breakages in plausibility, particularity Rummyhorror, but generally
@Drew has done a good job of showing how things get there.
To paraphrase CalBear, however, it's one of those cases where the further it's drifted from the PoD, the more it's become creative writing. Which isn't bad, cause it's well written, but there are points where, to be honest, plausibility is skewed for the narrative.