Plausibility Check: President Charles Lindbergh

Charles Lindbergh getting elected President of the United States seems to be an AH cliché, especially in works depicting a fascist takeover of the U.S. and/or an Axis victory in World War II. But was such a scenario even plausible? Would Lindbergh be willing to run for President? If so, how difficult would it be for the Republicans to nominate him? (They’re the only party that would be willing to choose him.) Could he defeat FDR (assuming he ran in 1940) in the general election?

And that’s not even getting into what a Lindbergh presidency would look like. I doubt it would lead to fascism, though his antisemitism and support for eugenics could lead to some extreme policies being implemented. Since Lindbergh would have no prior political experience, he could find himself deep in over his head trying to be President.

As for foreign policy, I don’t see Lindbergh allying the United States with the Axis powers. Probably just pursuing neutrality and staying out of “foreign entanglements.” There could still be a war with Japan depending on how Lindbergh views that situation and whether or not he issues an oil embargo.
 
Lindbergh is too isolationist for the US public, I think. It's very telling that both candidates in 1940 were pro-preparedness.

Could he defeat FDR (assuming he ran in 1940) in the general election?

Hell naw. He'd lose to Cordell Hull as well, for that matter.
 
A Lindbergh administration is doable in 1940, but it requires a really perfect storm, where the Democrats just fall flat on their faces.
 
That's sort of what I meant.

If France survives, there will be less fear of Hitler--but also less fear that the US will be dragged into the war. So I'm not sure that it will help Lindbergh. It will probably help Dewey most. After the fall of France, there was a joke that Dewey, then an anti-interventionist, was the "first American casualty of the Second World War." (It was not so much because pf his anti-interventionism but because his youth and inexperience in world affairs became more serious hanicaps than they had been.)
 
Top