Photos from Featherston's Confederacy/ TL-191

8c1aad9f-c98a-4568-8983-bca90c1fa8f8_text.gif

Controversial film Braveheart was accused of promoting Stolen Valor mythisism in the skein of Scotland's rebellion against the British.

The quote "Freedom! Freedom! Freedom!" remains a rallying cry for many southern politicians.

Attempts to 'reclaim' it in the North have not gone well.
I was referencing this: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLwCiRao53J1y_gqJJOH6Rcgpb-vaW9wF0.

Also good to know that Braveheart is still criticized, albeit for the wrong reasons. I would like to see how The Patriot would be in tl-191.
 
Maybe it would probably to rehabilitate the South's image after the Second Great War.
The film Patriot received a positive reception from critics but was lambasted by reviewers. It was accused of attempting to whitewash the South by showing a pro-abolitionist southern plantationer as the protagonist and hero of the story. Many founding fathers, themselves southerners, were talked about favorably. Americans compare the film and others like it to propaganda films. To rehabilitate the southerner as a civil brother. The role of the French was diminished, the British villanized, and the character Friedrich Wilhelm enjoyed a larger-than-life portrayal fighting with and for the Revolutionary army.

In the South, Confederates regard the film as pro-American/anti-Confederate. It villanizes their former allies, promotes the role of Germany in resisting British oppression, shows a former slave earning the respect and equal to the whites. Slavery, while not said to be bad, is not encouraged. Critics say the film tries to 'Americanize' the southern rebellion.

The film has been used by Birth of A Nation conspiracists who say the southern states were attempting their own rebellion away from the northern states during the Revolution.


TL;DR: The Patriot is critically acclaimed, but despised by Americans and Confederates for 'vilifying' or 'revising' their sides. Opposite sides of the same coin.


Also included a new idea, that the southern independence movement didn't begin with the Civil War, but earlier during the revolution but the south was bullied into fighting the northerner's war. Ooh, new idea, Washington's image is 'rehabilitated' as a Virginian who didn't want to fight the revolution against his British heroes, but when the role was thrust on him he could not refuse. Basically Lee.
 
Last edited:
Population Reduction Victims:

Blacks: approximately 10 Million
US Civilians: 9.7 Million (excl 2.3 Million Blacks)
US POWs: 3.8-5.3 Million
Haitians: 2.8-4 Million
Melungeons: approximately 601,000
Quebecois: 430,000 - 1 Million
Bermudian: 100,000 - 225,000
Seventh-Day Adventists: 89,230
Disabled People: 62,000
Homosexuals: around 7,000 (excl around 1.1 Million Blacks)
Spanish Monarchists (in exile): 6,300
Mexican Popular Revolutionaries (in exile): approximately 900
 
Population Reduction Victims:

Blacks: approximately 10 Million
US Civilians: 9.7 Million (excl 2.3 Million Blacks)
US POWs: 3.8-5.3 Million
Haitians: 2.8-4 Million
Melungeons: approximately 601,000
Quebecois: 430,000 - 1 Million
Bermudian: 100,000 - 225,000
Seventh-Day Adventists: 89,230
Disabled People: 62,000
Homosexuals: around 7,000 (excl around 1.1 Million Blacks)
Spanish Monarchists (in exile): 6,300
Mexican Popular Revolutionaries (in exile): approximately 900
Umm, wasn't Quebec neutral at the time? And I'm pretty sure that France, a Confederate ally, would be pissed AF if they were to find out.
 
Population Reduction Victims:
Blacks: approximately 10 Million
Fans estimate of the Reduction Afro-Confederate victims is over 6-10 million killed during 1941 to 1944, people can I say that it’s over 6 million because of general parallelism and relatively want some slave labor for the war against the US but I could argue that black are more vulnerable and more viewable than with the Jews of the color of their skin.

You seem to have the belief of the ladder but I could say that this one seem to high ibh as the black population in CSA is likely in the tens of millions so CSA somehow going over 10 million will be unlikely (I know this is SV we talking about but still) plus they still fighting a war and they are not like Germany even know the novels pretty much act like they are in the last war against the CSA and the US.

But I think the Afro-Confederate victims will be over 6 to 9,000,000 ( Mine is 8 mill)
US Civilians: 9.7 Million (excl 2.3 Million Blacks)
US POWs: 3.8-5.3 Million
Kinda problem with that is we don’t know the treatment of CSA occupation in Ohio, as well as the prisoners there, but I think it’s very harsh with the fresh defeat by the Unionist in the First Great War but not at the same scale as Nazi treatment of Soviet civilians, and POWs will be far less plausible. They are still related as Anglophone and while they don’t like each other, I don’t think they will Massacre other at the same scale as the Nazi and Soviet did in Eastern Europe. Also I think that Afro-Unionists will be maybe on 1 million or half of million because the annexation of the Kentucky after World War I.

The only thing that resembling the atrocities and war crimes in Eastern Europe will be in The Caribbean with black countries
Haitians: 2.8-4 Million
The Haitian population of 1941 is over 2,707,000 and killing over 4 million Haitian will be unlikely because that be all the population in Hispaniola but I could see definitely half the population, or even most of them got killed by the Featherstone genocide
Melungeons: approximately 601,00
I think this unknown as the last estimate of the Melungeons in the 1950s of over 200,000 but with no current estimates in modern times and plus 80 years of CSA we might see some more of them especially in Kentucky. So the estimation of them will be likely 200,000 or over 601,000 in you are estimation somewhat similar to Romani death toll in the Holocaust
Quebecois: 430,000 - 1 Million
Quebecois is far away from any CSA control so likely all of the Québécois are going to be a prisoner of war, but even still, I don’t think they were genocide them at the same attention as blacks because they have France as allies and they have their own people who are French in the CSA. Cajuns who are descended from Acadians by the British during the French and Indian war’s who settled in Louisiana. So likely they will support wireless partially support Featherstone ideology as well as Action franchise.
Bermudian: 100,000 - 225,00
The current population of Bermuda is over 60,000 and that’s including all the other races, with whites. In 1939, the population of Bermuda was over 30,000 people and the black community was 19,000 people in 1939 so what do you want to be Grimm here? Then most of the black population, or even will die by CSA occupation.
Seventh-Day Adventists: 89,230
Disabled People: 62,000
Homosexuals: around 7,000 (excl around 1.1 Million Blacks)
Spanish Monarchists (in exile): 6,300
Mexican Popular Revolutionaries (in exile): approximately 900
Everything here is ok with the estimate of the Freedomite killing
 
Adding to this post: https://www.alternatehistory.com/fo...federacy-tl-191.185493/page-286#post-23956492

390px-Troops_in_Jayuya.jpg

Picture of Spanish Nationalists forces entering Jayuya, Puerto Rico, ca. early 1942.

Following the Spanish Civil War, Spanish Monarchists fled to Puerto Rico. King Alfonso XII declared Puerto Rico independent. Exhausted from years of war, the newly formed Spanish dictatorship met with Monarchists in San Juan in October of 1939. The treaty of San Juan stated that Puerto Rican independence and the newly formed government in mainland Spain is recognized.

During the Second Great War, especially after the Bahamas, Haiti, and Bermuda were in Anglo-Confederate hands, the Spanish government announced that the treaty of San Juan was now void. With help from the British and the Confederacy, Puerto Rico fell into Franco's hands in early 1942.

Puerto Rico would be faced with violence for the next couple of years, until 1975, when Spain recognized Puerto Rican independence following Franco's death and under pressure from the United States.
 
Blacks: approximately 10 Million

I think that Black genocide victims would are bit lower since part of them would be slaves on some places and CSAs had too put resources to frontlines so it hardly is able to kill so much only in three years. Perhaps 6 - 8 millions is closer.

US Civilians: 9.7 Million (excl 2.3 Million Blacks)
US POWs: 3.8-5.3 Million

Whilst Confederates didn't like their northern cousins I can't see them being genocidal against white Anglo-Americans. Why they would are? And it would be strongly counterproductive since there was surely lot of sympathic pro-Confederates too.

Haitians: 2.8-4 Million

Population of Haiti in 1950 in OTL was only bit over 3 millions so this hardly is possible.

Melungeons: approximately 601,000

Would there be so many Melungeons around on that point anyway?

Quebecois: 430,000 - 1 Million

Were Confederates even close of Quebec at this time. Surely there was Quebecois troops on the front but I can't see them being captured in such numbers. And why Confederates would had persecuted Quebecois? Furthermore I am pretty sure that French would had hated that.

Bermudian: 100,000 - 225,000

Wasn't Bermuda British colony during SGW? So why CSA would be there? And population of Bermuda is much lower even nowadays than what is victims of their actions.

Seventh-Day Adventists: 89,230

Did Featherston ever bother with religious groups?

Disabled People: 62,000
Homosexuals: around 7,000 (excl around 1.1 Million Blacks)

Not really sure if Featherston would had been that harsh with them. He seemed bothered speciality with blacks not so much with other groups. You seems trying make him just complete copy-paste of Hitler.

Spanish Monarchists (in exile): 6,300
Mexican Popular Revolutionaries (in exile): approximately 900

What they even did in Freedomite CSA?
 
220px-Flag_of_Canada_Pantone.svg.jpg

Flag of the Canadian Independence Party (CIP) (1967-present).

On July 1, 1967, the 100th anniversary of the creation of the Dominion of Canada, this was used as the official symbol of the CIP. While the Maple Leaf symbol had more associations with Quebec, a nation that the CIP says will not conquer by force if Canada became independent from the United States, this flag was chosen to honor the Canadian Expeditionary Force, Canadian soldiers that were taken to fight in the Western Front in the First Great War.
 
Last edited:
Population Reduction Victims:

Blacks: approximately 10 Million
US Civilians: 9.7 Million (excl 2.3 Million Blacks)
US POWs: 3.8-5.3 Million
Haitians: 2.8-4 Million
Melungeons: approximately 601,000
Quebecois: 430,000 - 1 Million
Bermudian: 100,000 - 225,000
Seventh-Day Adventists: 89,230
Disabled People: 62,000
Homosexuals: around 7,000 (excl around 1.1 Million Blacks)
Spanish Monarchists (in exile): 6,300
Mexican Popular Revolutionaries (in exile): approximately 900
I just can't see them killing that many U.S. civilians. I mean when the Confederate authorities found out that Mr. Driver was an American citizen, they exchanged him, his father, and several other American civilians for several Confederate civilians who caught behind the lines when the war began. Wouldn't that kind of put a stop on those kind of exchanges?
 
ap21121862884583_custom-fcb1ee8c.jpg

Picture of May Day protests, Los Angeles, May Day 2023.

Following the Second Great War, May Day demonstrations occurred throughout the United States, even after worker reforms were passed in past Socialist administrations. The Socialist Party sponsors these demonstrations. In a Democratic administration, demonstrations are used to criticize them, especially if they are anti-labor. In Socialist administrations, they are used to show the President that they can do so much more to improve workers' rights.
In former Canada and the CSA, May Day is one of the federal holidays to protest American rule over their homeland.
 
View attachment 828434
Picture of May Day protests, Los Angeles, May Day 2023.

Following the Second Great War, May Day demonstrations occurred throughout the United States, even after worker reforms were passed in past Socialist administrations. The Socialist Party sponsors these demonstrations. In a Democratic administration, demonstrations are used to criticize them, especially if they are anti-labor. In Socialist administrations, they are used to show the President that they can do so much more to improve workers' rights.
In former Canada and the CSA, May Day is one of the federal holidays to protest American rule over their homeland.

Question: Why do so many use masks on the picture? Did COVID-19 pandemics (or something similar) still occur?
 
Top