Out of these generals who was the best

[Gustavus Adolphus]

Like it says who was the best genius


Suvorov
Napoleon
Alexander
Caesaer

 

[Petete123123]

I'm between Suvorov and Napoleon, but I will choose Napoleon

 

[Gustavus Adolphus]

I'm between Suvorov and Napoleon, but I will choose Napoleon

Why? suvorov crushed Napoleon Badly in Italy, I mean seriously the Fremch Army was literally curbstomped, Swiss Alps, Italy everywhere, oh here's some news on Nappys Russia campaign Nappy had no control of his troops in the Battle of Bordino Napoleon did not give orders the troops just fought after that Napoleon lost All control of his army and they went Rampant ...... Cfazy no...

 

[Lord Grattan]

Why? suvorov crushed Napoleon Badly in Italy, I mean seriously the Fremch Army was literally curbstomped, Swiss Alps, Italy everywhere, oh here's some news on Nappys Russia campaign Nappy had no control of his troops in the Battle of Bordino Napoleon did not give orders the troops just fought after that Napoleon lost All control of his army and they went Rampant ...... Cfazy no...

Did you ask the question just so you could shoot others' answers down if they choose someone other then your favorite?

 

[Grey Wolf]

Suvorov was undefeated IIRC, but he died before he could face the real test of a victorious iimperial France

The army Na]oleon could field in the revolution's dying days was not the same as the one he had at his height

Best Regards
Grey Wolf

 

[Gustavus Adolphus]

Did you ask the question just so you could shoot others' answers down if they choose someone other then your favorite?

Oh no I just want to hear others opinions I'll add more people to make it fair srry
Aleksandre Nevesky
Gustavus Adolphus
Cnut the Great
Heralclien
Belisaurus
Calph Abu bekr
George Washington


How about now

 

[Jester]

... kind of too broad a list.

Generals really do have to be compared with their contemporaries.

 

[Gustavus Adolphus]

... kind of too broad a list.

Generals really do have to be compared with their contemporaries.

Ok so what if Suvorov faced off against Napoleon in a pitched
battle.. who would emerge victorious......

 

[archaeogeek]

Suvorov was defeated at Zurich.

 

[TheHumblePoet]

I dont think Abu Bekr ever led armies.

 

[Gustavus Adolphus]

Suvorov was defeated at Zurich.

To man what you on... Can I get some... In Switzerland Suvorov was only checked he never lost the battles it's what made him famous, he was the Hannibal at the time at his brilliant escape, he had no choice his aides were defeated and he relized his army would be destroyed it's proven he has never lost a single battle in his life....