"Our Struggle": What If Hitler Had Been a Communist?

Chapter LXX
"Soldiers, the cause of peace is in your hands! Do not allow the counter-revolutionary generals to frustrate the great cause of peace, place them under guard in order to avert acts of summary justice unworthy of a revolutionary army and to prevent these generals from escaping the trial that awaits them. Maintain the strictest revolutionary and military order."

~ Vladimir Lenin



MV5BMGVjMDNkNDgtMWM1YS00YTJkLTg0NWQtNDM1OThlOTcyNjEyXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMzM4MjM0Nzg@._V1_.jpg






From the darkness of the early autumn morning the brightly lit hive of activity stood out amongst the Russian nighttime scenery. If those who could notice this feature on the landscape could have moved even closer they would have heard urgent shouts of German and the grunts and roars of unatural mechanical beasts. The local population had been told by their own representatives that fraternisation was to be avoided with the militaristic foreigners and their contraptions. After all, they were technically not there and soon that fiction would be a reality.

The air of emergency that abounded within the Kama tank school was only matched by that of confusion. The reason as to why several years of successful cooperation between the Reichswehr and the Soviets were at an end were greatly puzzling to many in the facility. The tank school had been the most promising development of the cooperation, even it had only been operating for a year.

Peter Klompf stood amongst his fellow officers and tankers in the mess hall, where the tables had been cleared away to the sides. Some swayed warily; their rest having been abruptly broken, whilst others whispered in intrigue as to what might be going on. The most bizarre rumours had been emanating from the fatherland over the last few days; of coup d'etat and revolution, treachery and plots. This had remained speculation as the base locked itself down, there were no longer any Russians in sight and no-one had seen a newspaper since they had last been present.

Peter, his friends Franz and Klaus, and the rest of the regulars had had to cancel their clandestine reading circle out of fear all of this was in their honour. They had known the risks of discussing Marxist texts in the midst of senior officers paranoid of Bolshevik infiltration. Such men might not have considered isolating and now closing off the base to have been too drastic if they had become aware that there was talk of Lenin and Hitler amongst the junior officers.

Awaiting the reasons for why all Reichswehr personnel had been summoned to the canteen, those involved in the late night activities stood awkwardly apart from each other, wary of common association and suspicious as to who if anyone had sold them out. Peter's heart sank when Major Joseph Harpe, "Hacher", or chopper, to his underlings when he wasn't in their presence, entered the canteen. The man was rabidly anti-communist and keen to sniff out any signs that the base situated deep within the Soviet Union might be being influenced from the outside. Filing through the room, Peter felt his heart skip and Harpe stared directly at him momentarily, before walking past without a word and standing on top of a table to face the assembled men.

To the surprise of Peter and many others, Harpe's face broke out into a smile.

"Gentlemen, it gives me great pleasure to announce that we are leaving this godforsaken land. We are going home to heed the call of our Fatherland in its hour of need."

Harpe paused to let the declaration sink in, although inwardly Peter was more relieved than shocked. It looked like this wasn't about the reading group after all.

"To the surprise of very few, the Republic has finally ceased to function at a time of national crisis. Chancellor Von Shleicher and President Hindenburg have taken the necessary steps to ensure the survival of our nation, and this will be via the return of its sacred imperial traditions, those which united Germany and made her great!"

Harpe looked slightly pertrubed that this news had evoked more surprise than rousing celebration, even as he carried on.

"We progress towards a new era, but there remains the cancer in our midst. The Communists and the Social Democrats have joined hands in an attempt to reduce our country to one of anarchy and Bolshevism. It is clear that they have been planning this for some time, and we must play our part in eliminating them. Although their allies have launched their assault on the Fatherland, the Russians have let us leave in return for copies of some of our own innovations here. They are treacherous, even towards their own ilk. For all the good it will do them! We shall crush their 'comrades' and protect our homeland so that, from inside or without, they may never threaten Germany again!"

There was some cheering now and Peter joined in too, keen to avoid any suspicion that he might be part of the 'cancer'. He noticed some of those who had attended the reading group doing the same.

"German industry", Harpe continued, "will be able to begin large-scale production of tanks almost as soon as we return home, and this is directly due to the testing conducted here. We should be proud of ourselves but soon there will be no need to hide in the shadows. We now have a Government that will make good on the Versailles betrayal of the November criminals and then, at home, we can develop an armoured force that will be the envy of the world and the dread of our enemies!"

The cheering broke out once again, even as Peter began to wonder if he would returning home on the right side. With the bloodlust being heightened amongst his fellow Reichswehr officers, he realised he would have to do his best to hide his hesitation to the world.

The homecoming would not require a long wait. With ruthless efficiency the base was stripped and packed ready to journey back to Germany under Soviet supervision. The friendships and relationships built, formally and private, between the Germans and the Soviets were left by the wayside amidst the new German regime, one that was eager to cut itself away from the Soviet state that had been the Weimar Republic's closest thing to a friend.

From Moscow, Stalin grudgingly had to face the reality that the Soviet Union would be alone in the world once more. His next move was a source of great apprehension, as the Germans returned home to a land tearing itself apart.


---


The still is from Pearl Jam's Do The Evolution.
 
Hmm. The Fascists are getting experienced tankers. But might the reds be getting technical equipment by way of Moscow?

Well, the Reds can certainly lay claim to defectors from the Kama school. Methinks Stalin will wait.
  1. Hitler needs to actually prove he has the popular support and ability to get an urban revolt going, not just the little brushfires he ignited along the Ruhr.
  2. Hitler's been too independent for Stalin's taste, better to let him feel a little danger before "saving" him from it.
However he can't wait too long, we know the German civil conflict will last only 3 years (1933-36).
 
Well, the Reds can certainly lay claim to defectors from the Kama school. Methinks Stalin will wait.
  1. Hitler needs to actually prove he has the popular support and ability to get an urban revolt going, not just the little brushfires he ignited along the Ruhr.
  2. Hitler's been too independent for Stalin's taste, better to let him feel a little danger before "saving" him from it.
However he can't wait too long, we know the German civil conflict will last only 3 years (1933-36).
The
German Civil War won’t last three years. It would exhaust Germany and her people and we know that WW2 or the opening war that evolves into WW2 starts in 1936. So Hitler will need a couple of years to rebuild and prepare for war, as well as purge the military and restructure a Red Germany.

I’m guessing it’ll last a few months to a year.
 
Given the fact there will be a German internal conflict, I just realized a German white movement will form from the defeated right wing. Granted I actually think in terms of continental europe, a comintern victory is likely in this timeline, or a stalemate in europe that leaves the comintern with the most land given the joint industrial might of the USSR and Red Germany. Can't see world revolution though. I think the German Right Wing, much like the Russian, will flee to previously hated France (keep in mind many white Russian Exiles worked for nazi Germany hoping to defeat the now "greater enemy" in their eyes, "bolshevik usurpers", so I think anything is possible) or britain. konrad adenauer should he get into exile will pursue a francophile exile path, while perhaps certain Prussian Far Right exiles fleeing instead to britain, however should France go very far right, I could see those assisting their previously hated enemy, because as I said, Far Right fascists have a habit of dropping their shallow nationalism when it suits them (such as the Russian White Movement) and shifting their ethnic and territorial nationalism to hardcore anti communism.
 
Actually I find the French using Konrad Adreuner as a Rhenish Nationalist proxy plausible within this war. I do believe much like in Russia, capitalist powers will support the white armies regardless of their abuses and excesses, for obvious reasons. Granted given the short span of this war, its likely what will kill it for the German White army is disunited aims (monarchists, fascists, liberals, rhenish nationalists or other regionalists) plus a army out of touch with the worker/peasant. Naturally, like in Russia as I said, those white generals who managed to escape will likely find protection among another reactionary power, one that was perhaps their previous enemy. I sort of rephrased, but I really feel I worded it better here. I feel the real downfall of the German whites will be much like the OTL Russian Civil, disillusioned rank and file and a lack of central control.
 
Another great update as always! I look forward to seeing how the German civil war plays out, and whether the bulk of the troops stationed in the Soviet Union will side with the restored monarchy or with the reds - it certainly seems as though some of them will.
 
The civil war will be interesting. Reichswehr very well trained force, yet Germany doesn’t yet have good armor or airpower! France will probably lend some tanks to the whites despite their German nationalist orientation, the French will probably view it as stopping socialism as well as believing Germany will just be too damaged to be a threat post war after a white victory. Stalin I am sure will send Soviet tanks to the German reds, as a testing ground sort of. I could expect some leftist internationalist volunteers.

The whites too may have foreign volunteers, from simply bloodthirsty adventurist to bitter Russian white exiles (the all Russian military union fought in the spanning civil war for example, though in this they can get an earlier war) seeking a score to settle with their communist enemies.

Which reminds me...
Considering the otl white emigre movement, which while it did have divisions, was mostly united against their hated Bolshevik enemy, it is probably going to go the same way with German exiles (they have a common enemy of the new workers state and all will embrace reactionary ideology to once again control the workers) so people from social democrats, Rhenish nationalists, and blood and soil proto fascists will work together as happened in the Russian white emigre.

Honestly I can’t see a defeat of the Comintern given joint industrial power plus assuming Roosevelt gets elected, lack of American interest (Roosevelt has a massive admiration for Stalin, I really have an issue with this but oh well it was fact) I think it will either be a European Comintern victory or a stalemate and Cold War on steroids.
 
German exiles (they have a common enemy of the new workers state and all will embrace reactionary ideology to once again control the workers) so people from social democrats, Rhenish nationalists, and blood and soil proto fascists will work together as happened in the Russian white emigre.

And this ideological kinship would also cross ethnic lines. Could be the basis for some powerful world organizations, especially if it recruits other communist-country emigre groups. They might even get some American/British political parties to align with them.
 
So what is the difference between this timeline and the book?
If I know something about how Sealion Press works, the book probably comes with suplementary maps and other complementary material. Also, has a more organized structure and is very likely that it comes with all kinds of references and corrections
 
Hmm. The Fascists are getting experienced tankers. But might the reds be getting technical equipment by way of Moscow?

The Kama school has played a small role in developing the mighty T-26 which the reactionaries may well soon regret.

Another great update as always! I look forward to seeing how the German civil war plays out, and whether the bulk of the troops stationed in the Soviet Union will side with the restored monarchy or with the reds - it certainly seems as though some of them will.

Thanks! As is usually the case many soldiers can feel conflicted in being the enforcers of a particular regime, especially in instances of Civil War where the impetus is often based around a battle for the "soul" of the nation, as it is here. The more patriotic, Right Oppositionist tendencies of German Ideology have made it easier for small cells to develop amongst the Reichswehr in opposition to the official propaganda classes that officers and soldiers are officially drilled with.

So what is the difference between this timeline and the book?

If I know something about how Sealion Press works, the book probably comes with suplementary maps and other complementary material. Also, has a more organized structure and is very likely that it comes with all kinds of references and corrections

Pretty much, the TL here is essentially a "first draft" with art and videos added on. The book The Red Fuhrer and its sequel (TBA) comes with much more detailed chapters and additional analysis. There are also some existing scenes featured here which are changed or filled in a bit better, or complimented with new scenes entirely depending on how they're received. For example, the discussion that spikes up every now and then about Hitler's antisemitism ITTL led to more emphasis on that issue in the book.
 
So what is the difference between this timeline and the book?
I’d recommend getting the book. It made me go from having a passive interest in the story to being a dedicated fan. Quick read packed with info and good story.

I’m itching to get my hands on the sequel. If anything just make my re-read faster and have the extra bits thrown in to spice and enrich it.
 
I’d recommend getting the book. It made me go from having a passive interest in the story to being a dedicated fan. Quick read packed with info and good story.

I’m itching to get my hands on the sequel. If anything just make my re-read faster and have the extra bits thrown in to spice and enrich it.

Thanks! Hopefully it won't be too long in coming now.

In the meantime I've gotten around to adding threadmarks at long last, hope this makes things a bit easier to follow and navigate for first time readers and those who want to re-read.
 
It depends on the TL, really. The Reds! timeline is being constantly revised and updated so the SLP book is an outdated version by comparison.
 
It depends on the TL, really. The Reds! timeline is being constantly revised and updated so the SLP book is an outdated version by comparison.

I suppose the difference is that the SLP version of this work is aimed at being the "finished" product with the TL being the "draft" which I'm not really sure was the plan for Reds!, as you say it depends on the writer. The SLP version of Reds! is still well worth a read though.
 
Chapter LXXI
“Who did the council fight?"

"It split in two and fought itself."

"That's suicide!"

"No, ordinary behaviour. The efficient half eats the less efficient half and grows stronger. War is just a violent way of doing what half the people do calmly in peacetime: using the other half for food, heat, machinery and sexual pleasure. Man is the pie that bakes and eats himself, and the recipe is separation."



~ Alasdair Gray, Lanark




63ae7194d073aa662c2838f414142526.jpg




The city stretched to the horizon, black and forbidding. The gloom of the lengthening nights that came at the turn of every year was settling in amongst the city's inhabitants as they mainly opted to stay within the confines of their own homes, safe from the night and those who dwelled outside. Blackouts were alien to the city, a modern, industrial capital that had been used to electric light for a generation. Even during the First World War amidst the advent of aerial bombing of cities there hadn't been blackouts.

Berlin was not quite pitch black but where the lights remained, they often did not offer much hope

Only once before had modern Berlin endured such dark nights, when a general strike had left the German capital without electricity. It was the same now. In 1920 the strike had successfully brought down the right-wing militarists who had installed themselves in power, now the Einheitsfront of Communists, Socialists, and Trade Unionists hoped that history would repeat itself. Their enemies however, were confident they had learnt their lessons. They had been planning this ever since the last putsch had failed, after all.

It was perhaps for this reason that Kurt Von Schleicher had installed generators within the Reichstag.

The new Chancellor's office was a testament to Prussian efficiency and grandeur. Von Schleicher couldn't help but feel the historians of the future already remarking on how it was a fitting testament to the Chancellor who would remould Germany in his own image amongst the black, minimalist furniture and the portrait of Otto Von Bismarck that drew the eye whenever one stood in his presence. The man who unified Germany and the man who saved her. The latter gazing upon the former with divine inspiration whilst the great man nodded and smiled at his protege. It might make a stunning piece of art itself one day.

The portrait had adorned President Hindenburg's office until very recently but with the President now taking a well earned rest over the events of the past few weeks, Von Schleicher was certain he wouldn't mind it finding a new home. Hindenburg would be on his way out soon, a constitutional necessity meant that if the President retiring it would be the Chancellor who would have to relinquish control to the Crown Prince after order had finally been restored. Order would be restored but restoring the German Empire wasn't necessarily of the greatest priority once the dust had settled.

Von Schleicher had many tasks to accomplish but one burned at his energies more than any other. The Trae Unions turning against had been factored into his plans as a possibility but it was still a disappointment, he had genuinely hoped that those he had built relations with over the previous years could be brought on side into creating his new Germany, perhaps there was still time for them to see sense. For now though, their allies were the Communists and as such their strike had to be broken by force before it descended into full on civil war. He was a Bismarck, not a Kapp, after all and he would not blink.

His allies, on the other hand...

Von Schleicher had no doubt the presumptive Emperor would have no need for a portrait of Bismarck. More fitting would be one of his father, the one whom Bismarck could never tame. Von Schleicher would make sure that mistake would never be made again.

The Crown Prince was an idealist at heart, for all of his manouevering the Hohenzollern heir ultimately saw himself as having been delivered to Germany's aid via divine providence and that gave Von Schleicher an edge over him. Such men could be relied upon to never truly have both their feet on the ground as they looked up at the heavens. The correct reassurances could make them malleable to all sorts of influence that they would be blind to whilst being led to believe their own destiny was being reaffirmed. The Crown Prince would reign as a titular monarch, but the real power would be his. The new constitution he was drafting would ensure that, so long as the Wilhelm not-quite-the-third could be kept in the dark until his own Volkisch Bund deputies could force it through the neutured Reichstag.

It was for this reason that Von Schleicher shuddered when an aide announced that the Crown Prince had arrived to check the progress of his prospective Chancellor. Von Schleicher had aliented many people in his past, but he always satisfied himsef that such individuals only came to this conclusion about him after they'd already outlived their usefulness. The man was keen to get his hands on his birthright, Von Schleicher could understand that, but as a man who had had to climb the ladder from military obscurity to major statesman, he could not abide the Crown Prince's impatience.

Such wasn't all that surprising for a man whose life had been spent surrounded by wealth and privilege, patience was a virtue for the lower orders. Paegentry, on the other hand, was entirely within such a person's nature. His potential for disruption at this critical moment was vast however, and as such both had to be tolerated.

The Crown Prince had taken to wearing the uniform of the Prussian Hussars ever since Von Schleicher had become Chancellor, the culmination of a takeover they had planned for six years. For the Crown Prince's part, the uniform was likely to emphasise the nature of the emergency and the role of the military in dealing with it but it made the man look like he had just returned from an Opera. Just returned from starring in an opera, more specifically. The man towered over Von Schleicher with the aid of his busby hat adorned with the traditional skull and crossbones but the Chancellor bowed in deference all the same.

"I have come, Von Schleicher, to get your thoughts on this news of Hindenburg. I have confidence in you as my Chancellor but I must know how this will affect our plans." The Crown Prince's tone was concerned rather than irritable but even when impatient the royal could uphold a casual reserve built up by the assurances that he would get what he wanted eventually. It had its limits though.

"There is no need for worry your excellency. I advised Hindenburg that this would be the best course of action, because it is." Von Schleicher attempted to go on but the Crown Prince sighed warily even as he remained upright.

"You love to explain, man! But I do not appreciate being spoken down so often. You convinced me that I would have to accept Hindenburg standing in as regent, an affront to my family which has ruled Prussia for four centuries, even if it was only to be for a brief term. I accepted the wisdom of your advice but now you tell me that is not necessary, indeed it's preferable that it does not happen? This is all very embarrassing."

"I apologise for any embarrassment caused Excellency, but this situation-" he motioned to the blackened city behind him, "requires a more direct approach. The enemies of Germany have been exposed in their treacherous conspiracy but until it is fully snuffed out we cannot bother ourselves with constitutional niceties."

"Niceties." The word seemed to hang on the Crown Prince's lips as he interrupted Von Schleicher once more. "You considered it prescient to remove Hindenburg though, leaving yourself Head of Government and Head of State until he can be replaced."

Von Schleicher looked down at his desk and tried not to make a show of the fact he'd just bitten his lip. There was too much distrust in the air, reminding him more of the time he'd stared down the barrel of Hitler's gun in the Ruhr rather than the sweet nothings the heir to the German throne could usually be placated with.

"Beyond your divine right, Hindenburg was the only leader for this country but his health is not what it once was. You are ready to replace him now Excellency, and you have the momentum behind you now, but the framework doesn't exist. Constructing the Third Reich as we see fit requires a man who is loyal to you alone and is in his prime. Hindenburg doesn't help us in that regard any longer. He's an eighty two year old man who has sworn an oath to the Republic and is now surplus to our requirements. I, however, fit that criteria."

"Goering would as well" The Crown Prince remarked rhetorically, Von Schleicher chose to ignore the bait but it caught him off guard all the same.

"I assure you, you will be named Emperor soon enough but for now the name will have to wait." Von Schleicher gulped, realising he'd mispoke even as the Crown Prince's eyes narrowed. The affable posture was gone altogether now but replacing the impatience was something uncharacteristic of the royal, a sort of petulant smirk."

"I fear, Von Schleicher, that we may have underestimated one another."

The two men smiled at each other, a feeble act of composure, before either could speak an aide chapped hurriedly on the office door.

"Chancellor, er, and Your Excellency, there is a situation, the-"

"Ah, good, let the troops know my men mean them no harm, this is all for the Chancellor's benefit." The aide looked puzzedly to Von Schleicher, who despite his own confusion simply nodded. The Crown Prince threw open the doors of the office balcony, beckoning the noise of stomping boots and singing from outside. Shadows were dancing on the walls of the blacked out city.

"They're here to support their Head of State" he shouted, as he beckoned Von Schleicher to join him outside

Marching torches appeared as columns of blackshirts marched forward, singing their anthem; the Volksstimme. Amidst the river of flame, rhythmic marching and the unified chant Von Schleicher could only observe that the Crown Prince's taste for the theatrical was not restricted to the uniform. He focused on keeping himself composed, it seemed the few Reichswehr troops observing from the ground were attempting to do the same.

Von Schleicher felt confident that the blackshirts wouldn't do anything stupid with their leader by his side just as he was confident that the Reichswehr would put them down if necessary. The Volkisch Bund might have styled their anthem on their Italian brethern as they had done with their uniforms but this was Germany and he would not allow their leader to become another Mussolini. There could only can be one Duce after all.

The assembled blackshirts continued to sing triumphantly, chanting their anthem's refrain one last time-


Volksdeutsche, volksdeutsche
Es klirrt die Sklavenkette heute noch im Land.
Es kommt der Tag, da sie zerbricht,
Feige Knechte sind wir nicht!



-before silence engulfed them in unison.


The thousands of faces looked up at their Emperor with adoration, and to their Chancellor with indifference. Before the torchlight gave way to thousands of fascist salutes.

And amidst the heat and the glow, Von Schleicher refused to blink.


---



----


The photomontage is Father and Son by John Heartfield

It would be remiss of me not to mention that Alasdair Gray passed away recently, Lanark is a fantastic read and I'd strongly urge everyone to give it a go.
 
Oh dear. It seems like this may be a set up for either the Crown Prince or Von Schleicher to turn against the other.

All the better for Hitler and the communists, I suppose.
 
Oh dear. It seems like this may be a set up for either the Crown Prince or Von Schleicher to turn against the other.

All the better for Hitler and the communists, I suppose.
My money is on the Crown Prince getting the drop on Schleicher and then the commies emulate the Bolsheviks and take out the Royals.
 
Last edited:
Top