"Our Struggle": What If Hitler Had Been a Communist?

A gripping chapter! Almost like our own election nights. One is almost there with the characters, feeling their same restlessness, fragile hope and then teeth-clenched resignation.

Looks like Ernst’s favorite strategy of hopping on the perceived bandwagon hasn’t paid off. Yet.

The reactions throughout the headquarters consisted first of denial then of cursing the Bavarian royal for his arrogance in not standing down in favour of Marx.

“How does he dare to not just roll over and let us walk all over him without anything in exchange? Can’t imagine a more selfish person!”

They will struggle to be unified on every vote, especially on the controversial decisions, and with the state of the economy they will have to make such choices. In the meantime it’s our role to make that even more difficult for them than it needs to be. For every vote.

Riiight… Because there is absolutely no way that idea can backfire horribly. I mean, you are just proving to the skeptics that the system won’t let itself be changed from the inside. And there’s only one conclusion that the Communists are going to get from all this.

Hitler: “So they won’t let even now be it heard, the voice of the working-class majority… Two seats of difference may as well be two hundred! The game was rigged from the start, there’s no possible way for us to win! Not as long as we follow the rules of our oppressors. Very well then! We’re going to fill those two seats with our new representatives: German and Ideology. Time for the next phase of the plan.”

And beautiful wikibox! Makes it much more easier, to picture in your head the situation. Now that’s a divided Parlament!
 
Chapter XCI
In solving these problems, we must never forget that the developments in this or that socialist land may take different courses. That is the result not only of different national conditions. The socialist society is still young. It is at the moment in the process of great transformations in the Soviet Union and other socialist nations. Despite all the gloomy predictions of people who understand nothing, absolutely nothing, about the laws governing human society, those who would happily bury socialism, I want to say clearly and firmly that the world is turning not in the direction of capitalism, but in the direction of socialism. That is unchangeable fact.

~ Erich Honecker





1593260538652.png







“Comrades, a new dawn has broken has it not?”


The crowd cheered in a thunderous roar that echoed throughout the city, even over the noises of reconstruction that predominated in every quarter of the capital. Amidst the acclaim Rosa Muller felt like covering her ears before instinctively joining in the applause being directed at the figure in the distance. Erich Zeigner had arrived to take up residence in the Presidential Palace.


Sitting on the shoulders of Ali Hohler, Rosa had a better view of the man than most but even then the size of the crowd left him an unclear figure in the distance who had to be aided by several loudspeakers to carry his speech across the gathering.


Hohler had told her the man speaking was the new President and, for the first time, their President. He was a man to be cheered because he had their interests at heart. The massed crowd was truly larger than anything Rosa had seen and the people that made it up, whether turned out in their Sunday best or come directly from the building sites across the city, were workers. The new President seemed to acknowledge this.


“For too long this republic, built on the sacrifices of the worker, has distorted democracy for the benefits of the privileged few. No more! We have seen where that led us, Schleicher, Hohenzollern, and their cabal will all be made to pay for their crimes but we will go beyond that. We shall ensure such a plot can never happen again. We will tear asunder all institutions that enabled them and rebuild them in the name of our democracy. This should already have been done in 1918! From now on the work will not stop until we can truly call this republic our own. Yes my friends, a workers republic at last!”


The distorted echo from the loudspeakers amidst another cheer was loud enough to resemble an unknown force of nature. It was made the entire scene surreal to Rosa. She patted on Hohler’s head to let her down from his shoulders.


“Do you think my mother will be back yet?” She shouted amidst the applause.


“Hold on.” Hohler said distracted, still looking ahead.


Rosa was now unable to see anything other than the people immediately around her but she could still hear the President echoing.


“Comrades, I now have the great privilege of revealing our new Chancellor. This is a man who helped to expose the Schleicher plot, who aided the unification of the workers of this country in deposing his cabal, and will now lead our redoubled efforts in marching to the progress promised to us by Socialism. He is a close friend and heroic revolutionary fighter. It is a privilege for me to appoint him to such a position. Comrades, I give you, Paul Levi!”


There was another loud cheer but it was more muted than before. Some in the audience looked disappointed, Ali seemingly among them.


“Okay then, let’s go find Comrade Muller.”


Hohler, apparently having lost interest in the celebratory rally, escorted Rosa from the massed crowd who were now focused on the words of the old Spartacist who was now their Chancellor..


The trams were running again which provided relief from having to walk the distance of one of the largest cities in the world. The creamy yellow tramcar provided a view of the city returning to life as the omnipresent sounds of rebuilding became clear images. Ali cracked a joke about how despite the Volkisch Bund’s promises the final battle between the Reichswehr and Blackshirts had been the only thing the Third Reich had done to tackle unemployment in the city.


Although the elections, much like the Civil War, were now over there were posters and flags adorning nearly every wall and window still standing. They had taken over the old places where more banal advertisements had usually featured, like new flowers in spring. Approaching Mitte, Rosa froze at the sight of a large number of soldiers in strange uniforms approaching the Reichswehr drill grounds that Eva had made her avoid during their time of hiding.


“It’s alright,” Hohler reassured her, seeming to notice that something was wrong, “they’re on our side, like the President.”


Rosa felt the world was turning upside down. Her mother had always told her to avoid men in uniform other than those of the Red Front, now here were soldiers marching down the street and they were purportedly on her side. The strange nature of it all was eased somewhat by seeing passersby clapping and cheering the soldiers whilst they marched. If people who were much like her were happy to see them then maybe Ali was right.


They alighted from the tram at Bulowplatz into the familiar square that contained the Communist Party Headquarters at Karl Liebknecht Haus. Here there was also a great amount of building work being undertaken. The square, particularly the headquarters, had been wrecked in the early days of the fascist takeover of Berlin. It was still a traumatic memory for Rosa who had been told by her mother’s friend Christina that she wouldn’t be able to see her mother for a while. The same had now become true for Christina herself.


Since Rosa had met Ali, Christina hadn’t returned for her. She had feared it would be the same with her mother. Ali had managed to get news that she was alive and in Hamburg but couldn’t come to Berlin immediately. The new President seemed to have changed all that. The sign indicating they were in Bulowplatz that hung from the wrecked Babylon Cinema had had ‘Rosa Luxemburg Platz’ written over it in red paint. Her mother had told Rosa stories about the woman she had been named after and it felt like a fitting name for the square as well. This was a safe place once again.


Inside Karl Liebknecht Haus the new Chancellor’s speech came through statically on the radio. A dark haired woman was trying to adjust the volume so that she could hear the speech amongst the various construction noises going on inside and out.


The woman turned around and both she and Rosa let out a small shout of surprise. The woman had her mother’s face, it was paler than Rosa remembered but she hadn’t seen her in so many months that she couldn’t even be sure. Gerda quickly embraced her as if to allay any doubts Rosa might have had. There was much to rebuild and not just structurally.


“I thought I’d lost you,” Gerda gasped and Rosa realised she was crying. Throughout everything she had never seen her mother cry before. Tears began to well up in her own eyes.


“I thought you’d left me!” Rosa began to cry as well, she was angry and relieved at the same time. Gerda broke off from her at that and held her by the arms. The tears had reddened her white face.


“No, I’ll never leave you again. Ever.”


Rosa found comfort at the determination in her mother’s eyes.


“I have a new job now. I won’t always be in Berlin but whenever I have to leave you’ll come with me. How does that sound?”


Rosa simply nodded as she wiped the tears from her eyes.


“What’s your new job?”


Her mother hugged her again.


“Do you remember when I told you about how I grew up on a farm?”


---


The painting is Raising a Flag over the Reichstag by Alyse Radenovic after the photo by Yevgeny Khaldey
 
With all the shit that's about to happen, I betcha "What if Wilhelm Marx had won?" as a PoD is going to be exploited to death ITTL's alternate history community...

There are a lot of paths that could be taken with it, Hitler rejects the result and restarts the Civil War, or tries to only for the KPD-aligned People's Guard to be crushed by the Reichswehr and non-KPD People's Guard, similar to what happened in the Ruhr in 1920. Or Hitler keeps his powder dry and Marx appoints Ernst to the Chancellorship on the basis of a centrist cabinet (Ernst is an obscure figure so AH writers ITTL might use someone more prominent unless they've really done their reading) and it goes as well as Ernst hoped, or it's a disaster. Or there's the Ed Thomas option of the TL ending on a happy note note as Marx is reelected having successfully steered the country out of the depression with democracy intact only for an epilogue set years later where there's now a Fourth Reich that's conquered much of Europe and now has a bizarre alliance of the US, UK and USSR bearing down on it.

Also other PoDs would be like “What if the Third Reich had won the Battle of Hamburg or the railroad junctions or both?” See a monarchist-fascist Imperial Germany would be interesting as it would curious to see if it ever expands outwards or if it breaks down into rival factions and has another civil war.

I suppose you'd have arguments about whether or not the monarchist coup would have even happened if Von Schleicher had effectively crippled the People's Guard and beheaded the United Front. He might have been seen as unassailable like he expected he would be upon the success of said operations. At any rate I think a Third Reich controlled by the Crown Prince likely would have been expansionist, he basically infers this to Ciano, but I think it's more likely Von Schleicher would have neutered him and slowly dismantled the Volkisch Bund. Perhaps the more fanatical elements would have been sent to Spain in a reverse of the Blue Division.

A gripping chapter! Almost like our own election nights. One is almost there with the characters, feeling their same restlessness, fragile hope and then teeth-clenched resignation.

Thanks! There have been nine nationwide elections or referenda in Scotland over the last six years so I at least have an idea of how Ernst might be feeling.

“How does he dare to not just roll over and let us walk all over him without anything in exchange? Can’t imagine a more selfish person!”

I'm not a fan of spoiler arguments at the best of times but when it comes to the issue of independence campaigns it becomes especially dubious.

"How could you do this to Germany?!"

"I'm literally a Bavarian you idiot!"

Riiight… Because there is absolutely no way that idea can backfire horribly. I mean, you are just proving to the skeptics that the system won’t let itself be changed from the inside. And there’s only one conclusion that the Communists are going to get from all this.

Hitler: “So they won’t let even now be it heard, the voice of the working-class majority… Two seats of difference may as well be two hundred! The game was rigged from the start, there’s no possible way for us to win! Not as long as we follow the rules of our oppressors. Very well then! We’re going to fill those two seats with our new representatives: German and Ideology. Time for the next phase of the plan.”

Noske was never one to tread softly when it came to Communists, then again he was never made to regret not doing so.

Minister of Agriculture?

You're not far off. :)
 
Oh I LOVED this...how do you manage to make me fall in love, or at least relate with every single character you write? It's better than all Dutch, and some English/German litereature I've read...how?!

Kudos to you, my dear friend
 
Oh I LOVED this...how do you manage to make me fall in love, or at least relate with every single character you write? It's better than all Dutch, and some English/German litereature I've read...how?!

Kudos to you, my dear friend

That's such a kind thing to say, thank you. It really means a lot.


How has the Soviet Union, UK, and France reacted to the United Front winning the election?

The Soviets are relieved that their largest trading partner and closest thing to an ally hasn't suddenly gone fascist but it's a bit awkward given that Hitler cut off the KPD from the Comintern and was denounced in kind, especially now that he's shown a united front can defeat fascism. It's an awkward situation. The British are happy the civil war is over but less happy the United Front won the election, the governing Labour party is slowly tearing itself apart and this isn't helping. The French are similar but even more wary.
 
I have question, what kind of situation is happening in Yugoslavia? If anything in this timeline we will not get slaughterhouse that was OTL.
 
Chapter XCII


And this be law, that I'll maintain until my dying day, sir
That whatsoever king may reign, Still I'll be the Vicar of Bray, sir.

~ Unknown, The Vicar of Bray





1593441823755.png







The door slammed shut with deliberate aggression, causing Johann to sigh with relief at finally getting the chance to stretch his legs underneath the stocky table. He understood that the Reichswehr had crafted their men to act like automatons with a perpetual stick up their behinds but he never would have guessed they would have designed such uncomfortable office furniture to instill that in them.

“I don’t think we’ll be hearing from Major Von Manstein again.” Lars observed.

“Another one bound for South America no doubt,” Johann muttered whilst fishing out a packet of cigarettes from his new uniform, “we really should be getting some sort of commission from the Argentinian tourism department.”

Lars laughed at that as did the third man on the panel.

“Well, they can’t all be as enlightened as me,” Klaus added.

Johann liked Klaus, as did Lars, everyone in the Bendlerblock seemed to ever since they had set up in the old Reichswehr defence ministry. It might have been enough to make Johann suspicious of how a man who both he and Lars had fought against at Lehrte had managed to install himself so well into the People’s Guard. Then again, a year ago he was rioting in a Berlin park and now here he was within the Bendlerblock, in charge of the fates of men he had spent the last ten years fighting.

Since the United Front had officially disbanded the Reichswehr the People’s Guard was now in the process of supplanting it, raking through the remnants of their former enemy to see if there was anything left of value that might help them better establish themselves as an army that could defend Germany and her workers.

The job of their three man panel specifically was to interview old Reichswehr officers not currently under investigation for direct participation in Von Schleicher’s Third Reich. Johann found this definition ridiculous, if they were officers in the Reichswehr then of course they were involved, but it had been a concession brought about by the liberals in the Reichstag who had made their support for the disbanding reliant on it. Technically the People’s Guard was now combined with the Reichswehr and everyone had the chance to keep their positions. Johann cursed the fact the United Front had to rely on the support of the German Democratic Party for decisions such as this.

Most of the old Reichswehr men hadn’t even bothered to show up, perhaps out of contempt for the process or fear that it was an elaborate ploy to get them arrested. Most of the senior leadership was already in custody, excluding those who had fled to foreign lands. It was believed that the trials of Schleicher, Goering and Hugenberg were to be exhibitions of the new justice system and who knew where that would end?

Those who had shown up had often done so only to tell them to go screw themselves, albeit often in less diplomatic ways. Then there were those who had shown up merely to go through the motions out of some respect for the old institution only to storm off the moment the meeting was done, such had been the case with Major Von Manstein. Genuine believers in a workers Germany who had ended up in the Reichswehr by circumstance such as Klaus were incredibly rare it seemed. The closest thing to it tended to be careerists, men who had few scruples in the name of their advancement, whether that meant the Reichswehr or the People’s Guard. Many of these men could talk a good game only to then flounder on closer inspection and suddenly storm out with a newly found sense of principle. Then there were those who had been just as amoral but had proven to have some promising skills that could be an asset.

Johann wasn’t particularly happy with this set-up. He had seen Feder die full of ideological zeal and now his sacrifice had led to men with no principles applying to fill his place. Lars had tried to placate him by remarking that such men could always develop a conscience whilst on the job.

“So, who’s next?” Lars now asked.

Johann stubbed out his cigarette on the already overflowing ashtray and looked briefly at the list in front of them before calling out to those waiting outside the door.

“Major Heinz Guderian!”

The Major entered and nodded to them cordially before his face turned to a sneer upon seeing the ashtray. Without saying a word he grabbed it and proceeded to empty its contents into the wastepaper basket in the corner of the room.

“Have a seat Major,” Lars didn’t seem phased by the introduction. Johann guessed it would be best for him to do the same. There was no point giving such men a reaction.

The Major sat down by lowering his legs, his back still upright. He placed the empty ashtray back on the table.

“I feel this interview should be conducted by men of equal or superior rank to myself.” He finally commented.

“I am Lars Nayer of the People’s Guard and this is my superior Johannes Fischer of the Citizen’s Defence Council. Alongside us we have Captain Klaus Marcus of the Federal Reclamation Committee. Our remit here is to see whether or not would be applicable for service in the People’s Guard and to determine whether your current rank would be fitting.”

Johann enjoyed his friend dressing down these officers but Guderian, bizarrely, smiled as well.

“Two revolutionaries and a Captain of the Heer. I feel like I’ve heard the one about you gentlemen walking into a bar.”

“You were at Gottingen. Correct?” Lars asked.

“I was, briefly.”

Whilst Klaus, Johan and Lars had fought on different sides in the battle of Lehrte a similar battle had unfolded at Gottingen for the railhead there. Unlike in Lehrte the Reichswehr had initially succeeded, only to have to retreat due to the People’s Guard success elsewhere.

“And how would you feel being in an army you had previously fought against?”

“Well I got a good impression of your set-up. You fought hard and caught us by surprise when you used armoured vehicles of your own to destroy the rail lines. That was a nasty shock. Our armour was better of course, even if some of our leadership was poor.”

Johann didn’t want to look but he was sure he could feel Klaus blush.

“And what do you think of the United Front, Major?” Johann asked.

“I don’t think you’re Bolsheviks. But I have spent time in Russia. I’m not one of these secret converts, that apparently did exist after all,” he glared at Klaus, “but I realised the Russians were willing to accommodate white officers to improve their national defence when such men proved themselves competent.”

“This isn’t Russia, Major.” Lars stated.

“No but the principle is the same. You want to know if I’m competent? I would hope my actions at Gottingen would prove that. You want to know if I’m a secret Bolshevik? A pointless exercise, I’m a white who’s smart enough to see we didn’t lose on the strength of our ideas nor did you win on the strength of yours. You won on the basis of cohesion and innovation. That is what Germany needs right now, in Bolshevik form or otherwise, and as I am a patriot I am willing to join the army who is carrying that out.”

“We are conducting the interview Major,” Johann interjected.

“And you’re doing so poorly,” Guderian continued.

“You can discern my loyalty based on your competence gentlemen. If that extinguishes itself then the time has come to purge me.”

There was a bewildered silence in the room.

“I think that’s all we need for now Major.” Lars said finally.

“Good!” Guderian said jovillay, rising from his seat.

“Then you’ll excuse me, Gentlemen. I have another interview tomorrow morning in Sweden and I have a flight to catch.”

“It’s Comrades.” Johann replied.

“Sorry?”

“We prefer ‘Comrade’ to ‘Gentlemen’, for future reference.”


Guderian’s smile broadened at that.


“We have nothing to lose but our chains.”




---



The painting is War Cripples by Otto Dix
 
I've normally enjoyed the quotes you've put at the beginning of your posts but not sure about this last one. Doesn't seem to fit the rest of the update.
Interesting...I thought it suited the idea of the careerists staying on with the new regime despite how different it was than the previous. Similar to the Vicar of Bray going from Protestant to Catholic and back again.
 
I have question, what kind of situation is happening in Yugoslavia? If anything in this timeline we will not get slaughterhouse that was OTL.

Like many of Germany's major trading partners the collapse of the country into civil war has exacerbated the depression in Yugoslavia and the result of the Civil War has seen a regime come into power in Germany that for some reason is a bit wary of monarchist dictatorships. This has deepened the political tensions in the country who have a clear figure to blame for the nation's economic woes and in response reforms are made, including a constitutional convention which will allow the potential for a return to democracy, of a sort. In the meantime some political prisoners are released in the name of clemency, including a man who some will come to know as 'Walter.' King Alexander despairs over the misfortune of the last year and pines for a holiday. Perhaps a jaunt to the south of France.

Huh, looks like some OTL Wehrmacht are willing to go along for the ride.

Yeah, you won't see many of the familiar faces but there will be one or two.

Time to see if Guderian has as sad an end as Tukhachevsky.

Both could still get done for allegedly being German agents.

Wonder how many IOTL-significant Germans will end up in the United States...

It depends, there aren't that many who wouldn't be welcome in neither the DAR or East Prussia but then again there are those who might feel the Atlantic provides a bit more safety than the Danzig Corridor.

I've normally enjoyed the quotes you've put at the beginning of your posts but not sure about this last one. Doesn't seem to fit the rest of the update.

Any particular reason? I was basically going for what @NukeZeit said, that Johann is annoyed about having to admit careerists rather than genuine ideological converts but comes across one who is at least honest about being the former.

that was amazing writing here bravo easpically loved the last line

Thanks!

I wonder how Rommel will do?

I could see him going for it and being accepted although similar to Speer his career trajectory IOTL was fairly dependent on a personal relationship with Hitler that's unlikely to materialise here. Hitler might put up with having former Reichswehr men in the People's Guard but I doubt that would extend to his personal bodyguard.
 
Top