"Our Struggle": What If Hitler Had Been a Communist?

Chapter LXXXII
In reality the ‘crisis’ of fascism is not new. It has always existed. Once the contingent reasons that maintained the unity of these anti-proletarian groups ceased, it was inevitable that their latent disagreements would quickly flare up. The crisis, therefore, is nothing other than the clarification of pre-existing tendencies.


~ Antonio Gramsci, The Two Fascisms




1591717481783.png











“You need to go outside!”


“But I don’t want to!”


“Don't you want to see the snow?”



Rosa Muller grumbled and put her head in her arms. The motion was meant to dissuade the woman looking after her. Eva, for her part sighed and began to hum until the 10 year old got over herself. They had been cooped up in the safehouse in Mitte ever since the Reichswehr had seized control of Berlin. Now, at last, the soldiers were leaving.

There was no radio in the cramped rooms in which far too many people dwelled in secrecy. Eva had dyed her hair blonde upon advice from her boyfriend but now he was likely dead and her brown roots were returning.

Still the rumours rippled through that the alliance the Communists had made with the Social Democrats was paying off. Those who brought food and messages said the alliance was defeating the Reichswehr across Germany and that was the reason their troops had been pulling out of the city; they couldn’t spare the manpower any longer.

It was encouraging news and Eva embraced it without reservation. There were others who warned these were only rumours and the Reichswehr departing the city was merely a sign that resistance had ceased outside of it but she felt such a thing would have been delivered with more fanfare. Either way if the Reicshwehr departed then she need only worry about the police or the blackshirts and neither of them possessed the surgical efficiency in hunting down left-wing journalists those departing the city had. She could go outside and try and see if she could buy some food. Or peroxide.

She wanted the little girl to come with her, the thought of a child not being able to go outside to see the snow awakened a reverence for her own childhood. In the safehouse all did their bit to look out for each other (one needed to have a proven commitment to the cause to be there after all) but the only person especially interested in the child was the woman she had arrived with, Christina, and she had gone away on party business.

“If we go outside I can try and find us some chocolate, how does that sound?” There was no immediate change in the girl’s pout but Eva thought she noticed a reaction.

“The bad men are still out there” Rosa finally replied.

“But there are less of them and they’re scared now as well. If we’re careful we can avoid them.”

“If we can avoid them then why can’t my mum come back?”

Eva paused at the awkwardness of the question, she only vaguely knew of the child’s mother but there weren’t many safehouses in Berlin and if she hadn’t come back to her daughter then the odds were she wouldn’t be coming back at all.

“Maybe she’s out there looking for you just now,” Eva argued in a clumsy attempt at reassurance, “and she would want you to be getting some exercise at any rate!”

Rosa looked up at last and finally nodded, lumping on the heavy coat she had arrived in.

At least someone had been prepared for a protracted civil war Eva thought to herself, longing for the furs she had been forced to leave back at her apartment. Wearing a summer jacket in December was hardly going to be ideal but she wagered it wouldn’t be too bad with the sun strong in the sky and a brisk walk.

Eva and Rosa stepped out of the sleepy basement hand in hand but not before Eva had peeped her head out to see if there was anyone with eyes on them. There was no-one guarding the exit at this hour and there didn’t seem to be anyone watching the street either.

Perhaps the notion of going out for a wander was more banal than her need for adventure had implied?

She felt the coolness of the light covering of snow on the soles of her shoes and breathed in the crisp, fresh air like a draught of beer on a warm summer's day. After so long stuck inside a stuffy set of grey apartments Eva delighted in the little things. Rosa seemed more cautious of the world around her, sheepishly keeping herself close to her grip on Eva’s arm, and so Eva took them both forward towards the nearby park, trying to avoid the burnt down wreck of Karl Liebknecht Haus or thoughts of her boyfriend Johann, who she had last seen taking up arms to defend the building.

The Communists offered excellent stories to an aspiring photojournalist but their man tended to be rather gruff with harsh accents, some of them Eastern European or even Jewish. Johann had been her diamond in the rough amongst them all and had made her pursuit of stories far more interesting. She had found a fellow adventurer in him and now he was likely dead she wondered what ties she really had to the party. Their leader Hitler certainly had an allure to him, but like many Communists he had that annoying habit of clapping along with the crowd while making a speech. Still, if the Communists were going to win this war that meant opportunities for those connected to the party as well and she was confident she would find someone new, perhaps a war hero. In the meantime it seemed the little girl had acquiesced to being her friend and as such she’d take her to the Kleiner Tiergarten park where she and Johann would sometimes wander. Perhaps the flea market was still there.

The walk to the park took them about half an hour, they walked slowly to avoid slipping on any ice hidden underneath the snow but they had also gone a deliberately longer route than they might otherwise have taken. It would have been quicker to walk past the military drill grounds but Eva was wary of Rosa seeing any soldiers and that was the one place there were guaranteed to be some Reichswehr, she wasn’t too enamoured with the prospect herself.

There was little conversation between the two of them, the nearly vacant streets had a ubiquitous silence that imposed itself on the pair making things even more awkward. Seeing the bare trees in the park was a relief for Eva even if many of them appeared to have been cut down as at least she could see people amongst them. There was a strong smell of stock in the air and Eva’s belly rumbled at the thought of a proper meal. What was made available in the safehouse was provided with much care and consideration but it never amounted to a satisfied stomach. She put the thoughts of peroxide out of her mind and pursued the smell instead. Rosa seemed to be apprehensive to see so many new faces but Eva pulled her along regardless. The girl needed a proper meal more than she did.

The wares on offer on the market stalls were rather strange, but the vendors appeared to be doing well for themselves. A man wearing a womens fur coat and mink looked more than a little ridiculous but he held a crowbar in his hand he would bash on every sack he had gathered around him every time he made a sale. A sign painted crudely alongside him appeared to be of his own design:




PEAT - BEST OFFER - NO TIME WASTERS


He nodded at Eva, smacking the sack of a crowbar again with greater emphasis. She shuddered and walked past him, only to see a woman flogging rabbits wearing what appeared to be a duvet, in lieu of an eyebrow pencil she seemed to be using charcoal as a substitute. She had two men of her own around her both carrying clubs. Again; best offer, no time wasters. Eva tried to stay focused on the smell, avoiding such people and holding Rosa close to her in the process.

Finally she arrived at the stall where the stew was being dished out by a thin man who hung over the pot like a lamppost, his long arm ladelling out the stew bore a number of expensive watches. Inside the man's tent was the carcass of a dead horse poorly covered along with several other boxes and bundles. She had no idea how such a stick insect of a man intended to move everything at the end of the day and wondered if he was eating what he was serving up to others.

There had been a small queue around the stand but it shortened quickly, people either handing over some bundles in exchange for several ladelfulls into pots they were carrying, or being turned back after short, bitter, exchanges. When they had arrived at the front the thin man eyed Eva suspiciously, seeming confused to why she carried nothing but a small bag.

“Two bowls of stew please,” Eva said confidently, trying to ignore the man’s puzzlement.

“What have you got to trade for it?” He snapped back.

“Well,” she muttered while digging out her purse, “how much is it for two bowls?”

“Eh?” He exclaimed and then shook his head. “Don’t know where you’ve been little bear but that paper’s not worth anything to me. And you should have brought your own containers as well, this isn’t a restaurant. Got any jewelry on you?”

“For a bowl of horse meat?!” Eva shook her head at the absurdity of the situation but the vendor seemed relaxed.

“Clear off then,” he said sharply, already looking at the person carrying a large bag behind them. Rosa was tugging at Eva’s hand to leave as well but Eva wanted to give the man a piece of her and proceeded to…


There were a few pops in the distance, and then a few more. Followed by shouting.

More crackling noises came from other directions and the people around the stalls began to vacate the park. Everyone knew what that noise meant by now.

The vendor began hurriedly gathering up his takings for the day and Rosa now tugged on Evas hand more urgently. Eva stood there blankly, considering what could be going on.

Could the Communists be in the city already?

A number of Reichswehr trucks following a staff car came to a halt near the park causing those leaving to abandon any sense of calm, people were running in various directions. A bald head leaned out of the staff car momentarily and Eva was struck by the man’s resemblance to Kurt Von Schleicher.

“I want to go back!” The girl cried.

People began screaming and the car sped away, troops began dismounting from the trucks, and arranging themselves around the trees still standing. From the other side of the park Blackshirts were running to do the same at an alarming pace. The stew pot tumbled down from the stand spilling its contents all over the grass and Eva jumped to avoid the hot liquid, losing grasp of Rosa in doing so. The girl ran back in the direction they had come and Eva ran after her. She had no idea what was going on, another crackdown? All this for her and a little girl? Was the stew ladeller Trotsky in disguise?

She caught up with Rosa and lifted her up into her arms, the little girl protested until she realised Eva was still sprinting fast. Both sides started to fire on...each other? Eva came to the conclusion in a panic but even amidst the hail of bullets she suddenly stopped.

Have I got my camera?

The impact of a round brought her flying to the ground. The shock of it was disorientating and she couldn’t feel where she had been hit, only to see the little girl run off on her own again. She felt her left temple and looked back at her hand. Time seemed to freeze on that image and it began to blur.

The image switched back to the little girl, frozen in the same place, then back to her hand again. An old nursery rhyme from her youth began to hum in her head. The image, even blurrier, went back to the little girl. Then back to her hand. The noise of the nursery rhyme got louder and louder, seeming to make things even blurrier.



---



Rosa wasn’t trying to think about the dead woman behind her but focused on getting out of the park, she was too terrified to do anything else.

They were still firing at each when she got clear of the park and she tried to remember which way she had gone, the streets all seemed to have crossroads all of a sudden and she couldn’t remember it being that way before. She felt herself getting more and more tired before she tripped. It was then she started to cry. She just wanted her mum but had no way of finding her and now she couldn’t even find the place she had told her to stay.

“Now, now, what’s all this?” She breathed in heavily as two hands hoisted her up in the air. A grinning face with short, parted hair met hers. His hair matched the colour of his uniform.

“Put her down and get out of here.” The face turned into a snarl as the man turned his attention from Rosa to someone behind her. He laid her down and she stood there paralysed with fear. The blackshirt raised his hands gently and began calmly pacing back.

“You don’t know what you’re dealing with do you?”

“I can smell scum like you a mile off,” The other man retorted, his arm had a bizarre number of tattoos around it, in his hand there was a pistol.

“We’re in control of Berlin now and I know your face. You’ll be made to regret that.” The Blackshirt still had his hands raised but he was grinning again, leering, like a hungry wolf. Rosa moved instinctively towards the tattooed man and the Blackshirt broke off into a sprint.

“Sorry if I upset you,” the tattooed man leaned down and smiled, “but you don’t want to be in the company of people like him.”

A man paused for a moment, a sign Rosa had seen on the faces of adults before. Something had clicked inside.

“Hey, you’re Comrade Muller’s daughter aren’t you?” Rosa nodded gently and smiled, her face was still red with tears but she felt safer now.

“Albrecht Hohler, at your service. My friends call me Ali.” He reached out his hand and Rosa shook it.

“Rosa, but my friend’s call me ‘Comrade Muller’s daughter’.

Ali laughed as he stepped back up and began to walk with her.



“Well then, Comrade Muller’s daughter, let’s get you home. The jackals are tearing each other to pieces, we meek ones shouldn’t disturb them.”








---



The painting is Rotes Elisabethufer by Ernst Ludwig Kirchner
 
Last edited:
Chapter LXXXIII
The war destroys the appearance which leads us to believe in peaceful social evolution; in the omnipotence and the untouchability of bourgeois legality; in national exclusivism; in the stability of political conditions; in the conscious direction of politics by these “statesmen” or parties; in the significance capable of shaking up the world of the squabbles in bourgeois parliaments; in parliamentarism as the so-called center of social existence.

~ Rosa Luxemburg, In The Storm





1591889247043.png






The brilliant winter sun dazzled the scenery whilst it rose into the sky, causing Johann to pause during his new morning ritual of warming his hands on a can of watery but boiling coffee and look outward towards the east.



Berlin lay out there somewhere past the shapes currently on the horizon. He wondered how long it would be before it would appear on the landscape itself. In his own mind he felt assured that the capital would see the final act of this war play out and give him a chance to go head to head with those who had laid the Red Front low, this time on equal terms. He was confident of what the result would be when the rematch came.

The success of the People’s Guard in holding the railways had enabled the industries of the Ruhr to be consolidated by the United Front and for said industries to begin spewing out weapons much like they had done during the Great Imperialist Slaughter. Those same victories had also brought new recruits with which to provide the arms to.

Training these volunteers was a more difficult process, Johann only had his own guerilla experiences to work off and most in the Communist, Social Democratic, and Trade Unionist militias couldn’t even claim that. They were a bit of a rabble all in all but they had spirit and devoted what time they had to basic training and instilling cohesion within the new ranks. Even from inside their current encampment in and around the town of Hopfgarten Johann could see a large group having exercises barked at them by a shop steward who had been a non-commissioned officer fifteen years beforehand.

The clopping of horses took his mind back to the present and he witnessed several artillery pieces being towed towards the front. The offensive actions currently being prepared had a special significance all of their own.

Weimar, the birthplace of the republic he had spent much of his adult life trying to bring down, and which he was now dedicated to rescuing, was due its liberation.

The Reichswehr had evidently chosen to make a stand in the city according to reconnaissance patrols; perhaps for political significance, perhaps to act as a roadblock to assist the retreat of their comrades from Leipzig until a proper defensive line could be reestablished. The city of Erfurt which had been taken by the enemy shortly before the desperate battle of Lehrte but was now in the hands of its workers again. It seemed the Reichswehr didn’t trust the population not to rise up in such a former KPD stronghold but either way they had abandoned it shortly after Leipzig had fallen.

In Weimar, however, they were digging in and so Johann was also here, sipping his watered down coffee with the rest of the Citizens Defence Council appointees in a town on Weimar’s outskirts.

His longtime comrade Feder was now his senior in the Citizens Defence Council and was technically in charge, it was an ad hoc arrangement but one that nonetheless left his friend excitedly gossiping with a motorcycle courier who had brought a large number of leaflets and was now haggling over them like he had printed them himself. Johann’s coffee was still lukewarm by the time the man had sped off back to Erfurt with a sleeve of cigarettes pushed on him. Apparently it paid to be the messenger on occasion.

The officers gathered round in curiosity at what the nature of the exchange had been, Feder began to read one of the leaflets out loud:

“To the heroic fighters of the People’s Guard, our enemies are turning on each other! Amidst the usual mix of lies and insanity spewed from the fascist propaganda, reports from the international press have confirmed the rumours of our agents on the ground. Kurt Von Schleicher, the insidious would-be Duce, has been forced to flee Berlin, the victim of a coup led by the would-be Kaiser Wilhelm Hohezollern. The so-called Third Reich is crumbling in the face of our victorious advance. All that is needed now are the final blows! With best efforts, forwards!”

There were gasps of excitement and laughter at the good news, any apprehension about the coming attack seemed to be lifted amongst Johann’s comrades..

“I might be an atheist but this,” announced Feder holding the leaflet aloft, “is manna from heaven.”

Those around him began to take bundles of leaflets for themselves. This was a message that everyone was eager to distribute. Johann looked back to the city in the distance and smiled.

“We can use this!” He declared to his colleagues.

“Yes! Once this news ripples out morale will be through the roof! We should go today!” Feder affirmed and handed Johann a stack of leaflets of his own.

“Get these handed out and then we get ready to go!”

The news rippled through the camp like a wave of energy, individual soldiers started to demand marching on Weimar and Johann was happy to tell them it was all in hand. Soon ammunition was being handed out instead of leaflets

By midday the sun hung over them in the sky. Thousands of People’s Guard fighters were gathered in something resembling formation. A handful of armoured cars revved in front of each column alongside those carrying red and republican banners. The artillery Johann had seen began firing and they could see it impacting throughout the city in the distance. Feder stood at the head of the assembled force, keen to be seen as leading from the front ever since Lehrte. Johann stood watching the bombardment with this friend Lars, their companies stood behind them. Both were trying to follow Feder’s example.

Their focal point amidst the columns was a great steam train, armed with a large accompaniment of troops alongside the driver and fireman. Hopfgarten was linked to Weimar by rail and this way they could charge directly into the city with a momentum the Reichswehr would struggle to handle. Particularly if they had heard their own Kaiser had stabbed them in the back.

“Part of me wonders if we should check to see whether they know,” Lars pondered out loud. “it might be enough to get them to quit.”

Johann wondered if the understandable nerves before any assault were getting to his friend.

“It could also have the opposite effect, coming from us it could rile them up. Especially if they think we’re taunting them.” He replied under his breath, he didn’t want such doubts to spread.

Lars didn’t have a chance to answer him before the armoured cars began to rev their engines. Fresh from the Ruhr they were now resembling the genuine article than the monstrosities they had been depending upon in Lehrte. It seemed the Reichswehr had planned to start mass producing armour the moment the workers had been put down, instead it was now being rolled out against them.

The train screeched and growled before beginning to shunt towards Weimar at low speed. The People’s Guard formations followed, marching at a brisk pace around the belching engines of the armoured cars and the train. A small brass column began to start up, blaring out above the shunting of the train, the roar of engines, and the sound of so many boots.

They played Dem Morgenrot Entgegen, a socialist anthem that had been popular amongst both the Social Democrats and Communists before the United Front and thus one that had caught on easily when they had begun to fight together.

Johann felt the energy rising through him. The bombardment ceased, the train started to gain pace rapidly in the wake of it.

Reichswehr forces dug in ahead of them opened fire.

The People’s Guard charged.

Johann ran with his pistol in hand, attempting to be first in amongst the Reichswehr forces even whilst people around him were cut down.

In the distance he could see Feder was in his element standing out in the open willing the men on, chanting above the din of battle how victory would soon be theirs.

A jolt out of nowhere put Johann off balance and turning to the cause of it he saw only dirt falling where his friend had been standing a moment beforehand.

More mortar shells fell with similar impacts, throwing Johann off-guard in trying to process what had just happened. He ran towards his friend even whilst those around him surged forward into the city, following the train in smashing through the outer defences.

Feder’s body lay ragged on the ground, shrapnel had torn through his People’s Guard uniform into his torso, his peaked cap had been blown off revealing hair that was strangely grey. His skin was turning a similar colour whilst he stared at the sky without blinking.

Johann clapped his face gently trying to get a reaction and was relieved when Feder rolled his eyes towards him. He rasped with great effort, coughing up little specks of blood.

“You can breathe right? Course you can, see? You’re going to be fine.” Johann said pleadingly

“I’m not surprised you never finished university,” Feder rasped back sardonically, hacking up more blood.

“Now go and fight, let me die under a workers sky.”

Johann looked up having momentarily forgotten about the battle raging around them, the People’s Guard forces were already engaging the outer defences, the train was through, but his comrades around him stood uneasy. Johann held Feder’s hand and squeezed it. He didn’t get a response.

Trying not to dwell on it he urged those around him forward.

“He’ll be fine, we still have a city to liberate.”

The train had collided with the Reichswehr defences inside the city and their columns surged through with the same vigour that had been conjured in them with the news of the fascists splintering, Johann was animated instead by anger and he had to calm himself in taking cover at more mortar rounds emanating from craters caused by their own artillery. He felt himself giving in to the red mist growing around him and ran over the commander of one the armoured cars. The machine was pinned down by fire from barricades and narrow alleys. The learning process was a two-way street it seemed.

Johann hammered on the door of the imposing vehicle, a small hatch opened up at the driver's seat and an inquiring face met his.

“My troops are going to take out that mortar fire, you’ll cover us.”

“That ground is too uneven,” The driver protested, “we need to clear a way through this barricade.”

“This is an order from the Citizens Defence Council! We’re taking out those mortars.”

The driver cursed and slammed the hatch shut, the armoured car reversed and began crawling towards the ruins, Johann and his troops following behind it. The mortar crews seemed to realise and shortened their range but too late, they were on them. Johann took a grenade from his satchel and threw it from the cover of the armoured car, his comrades followed suit.

A series of loud bangs followed screams, then to his horror, the armoured car began to kick up dirt. Its bulk rose and then sagged. The crew inside could be heard shouting their alarm, before it toppled into a crater. From its exposed side he could see it was covered with bullet holes and now they were without cover. The mortar crews and those protecting them, those who had survived the grenades at least, seemed to be as surprised as they were, and Johann stood there staring at them for a moment. Slowly they started to raise their hands.

Those around him started to open fire and he did as well.

The shooting stopped when the last of them fell to the ground. The sudden lull felt off and even the sounds of gunfire in the distance had gone quiet. Johann realised he was hyperventilating and keeled over, vomiting on the ground.

I hope you’re happy.

He looked up and saw Feder in his old beige Red Front uniform grinning at him menacingly, his face clean, his body untarnished but his eyes still the way they had been in his friend’s final moments.

Their cold, passive glance.

Johann shut his own eyes, trying to rationalise what he was seeing.

“Listen to me! I hope you’re happy, my machine’s totalled thanks to you making me drive into a shitting trench!Look at me!” Feder was gone and in his place stood the driver, blood pouring over his face from a large gash in his head,

“I’m still in command here,” Johann barked back, regaining his composure, “and there’s still a fight on. Grab what you can from over there,” he gestured to the fresh pile of corpses they had just created, “and follow me.”

They advanced along the route of the train, now paused in the city centre. The Reichswehr seemed to be faltering at the intensity of the assault but Johann’s mind was blank, until he saw a white tablecloth fall from an old building next to the city’s main steeple.

Slowly, relieved cheering broke out. The Reichswehr forces from inside what was actually the Wilhelm Ernst gymnasium filtered out. It appeared their senior officers had made off shortly after the outer defences were broken.

The republican flag was soon flying from the gymnasium’s roof, though throughout the town the red flags seemed more prominent. The People’s Guard weren’t just hanging flags, the leaflets of the morning decree were being plastered on the walls of the city for all to see. The denizens of the city emerged from cellars and churches, some doing so warily, some with great relief. Many were ecstatic, joining in the impromptu celebrations. Some of the better dressed amongst the population looked up at the shivering Reichswehr prisoners longingly as they were marched off but even they were already beginning to piece back their lives.

Many of the defenders wandered around in a frightened daze, struggling to form a line. Johann shot his pistol into the air and they jumped.

“Party’s over lads!” Johann jeered and those escorting the prisoners hurried them along. It wasn’t exactly clear who was in charge any more and if the person who had a claim to such a role was going down a certain road, it was better the prisoners were out of sight and out of mind.

Lars seemed to arrive in reaction to the shot, holding out a beer for Johann to take with the hand he currently had his pistol in. Johann observed the frosty black bottle and reluctantly holstered the weapon, drinking it down.

The draught was cool and sweet, a reminder that he had lived another day.

“I’m sorry for your loss, Feder was a good comrade. I wish he was here to see what he achieved today.”

“I wish he was here for us going over the Elbe,” Johann exhaled, he had drank the beer too quickly but it at least had a certain numbing effect.

“I’m sure we can cross that bridge when we come to it, and it won’t be long now, but tonight we can celebrate and remember.”

“They’ll be establishing new defences now, as we speak. We can only hope they’re thorough in tearing each other apart, otherwise we’re going to have a long winter ahead of us.” Johann replied coolly

Lars put his arm around him and led him away from the prisoners. “Let’s get a few more beers and you can’t tell me some of your made-up stories. Hey, how about that one where you flew a plane?”

Johann wished he was in the sky again, not having to be living amongst all of this. To have to dwell on all of this.


With Feder at his side he had a connection to his old adventures, now that was severed and all that was left was the future.



---


The painting is simply Untitled by Juliusz Lewandowski
 
Last edited:
Hey, at least Feder got to die in a war, instead of the tragedy of dying in a war within a war like Eva.

This is probably the part where the fascists start fleeing for East Prussia, so Poland may be entering the story soon to occupy Danzig and give the exiles safe passage.
EDIT: On second thought, there's no way Schleicher and Wilhelm want to share a place of exile, if they even individually have the prestige anymore to lead an exile movement. I guess Poland might like Schleicher more because his troops are (marginally) less likely to say mean things about Slavs but the exile state was marked Deutsches Reich on the Tsar of New Zealand map. I do think that both of these guys no longer have the power to make their own choices; the East Prussian exile state will probably be very reliant on Polish aid.
 
Last edited:
I’ve come to the conclusion that The Red is actually George RR Martin and is killing his characters off one by one.

Hitler is taking what he wants with Fire and Blood.
 
Last edited:
Hey, at least Feder got to die in a war, instead of the tragedy of dying in a war within a war like Eva.

This is probably the part where the fascists start fleeing for East Prussia, so Poland may be entering the story soon to occupy Danzig and give the exiles safe passage.
EDIT: On second thought, there's no way Schleicher and Wilhelm want to share a place of exile, if they even individually have the prestige anymore to lead an exile movement. I guess Poland might like Schleicher more because his troops are (marginally) less likely to say mean things about Slavs but the exile state was marked Deutsches Reich on the Tsar of New Zealand map. I do think that both of these guys no longer have the power to make their own choices; the East Prussian exile state will probably be very reliant on Polish aid.
Maybe one of Wilhelm’s younger brothers or a cousin takes the throne to try and unite the two halves of the government. Von Schleicher probably dies and the Kaiser will get counter-couped and the next Reich government will be a constitutional monarchy with a figurehead Kaiser and a military-backed Chancellor.
 
Hey, at least Feder got to die in a war, instead of the tragedy of dying in a war within a war like Eva.

This is probably the part where the fascists start fleeing for East Prussia, so Poland may be entering the story soon to occupy Danzig and give the exiles safe passage.
EDIT: On second thought, there's no way Schleicher and Wilhelm want to share a place of exile, if they even individually have the prestige anymore to lead an exile movement. I guess Poland might like Schleicher more because his troops are (marginally) less likely to say mean things about Slavs but the exile state was marked Deutsches Reich on the Tsar of New Zealand map. I do think that both of these guys no longer have the power to make their own choices; the East Prussian exile state will probably be very reliant on Polish aid.
The official name of the weimar republic was Deutsches Reich
 
I’ve come to the conclusion that The Red is actually George RR Martin and is killing his characters off one by one.

Hitler is taking what he wants with Fire and Blood.
Nah, Hitler is Joeffry: he is going to die halfway through, with a vengeful Rosa ruling Germany afterward and somehow doing more damage.
 
Last edited:
Chapter LXXXIV
The fate of a national movement, which is essentially a bourgeois movement, is naturally bound up with the fate of the bourgeoisie.

~ Joseph Stalin, Marxism and the National Question






1592063297890.png




The city was a half-ruin and even weeks after the battle that had unfolded the efforts of Hamburg’s citizens were still aimed towards recovery. In this regard they were being assisted by many former Reichswehr soldiers. Many of those who had been captured during the advances of the People’s Guard were being made to work to repair the damage their comrades had caused.

Such was the official line, the great fires that engulfed Hamburg’s docks and subsequently spread to much of the city centre were the cause of the Reichsmarine; a petulant and spiteful atrocity brought about by them burning their own ships in the face of being driven back by the workers of Hamburg and finding themselves trapped up river. It was a fascinating story but if one were to ponder some of its finer points, or indeed speak to anyone directly involved, the details became hazy. The surviving Reichsmarine and Reichsheer personnel working on the repairs didn’t want to talk about it at all.

Many Reichswehr personnel had been brought to Hamburg to help in the repairs, an initiative which seemed to deliver a certain catharsis for the civilian population who had survived the attack and the resultant fires. Others, however, were here of their own volition, trying to make amends and to find a place for themselves in the new reality while doing so

Peter Klompf leant on the shovel as he wiped his brow, despite the temperature and how many layers he was wearing the exertion was still causing him to sweat. He had been provided with civilian clothes and a heavy coat when he first arrived in Hamburg and had to acquire more since. His boots were the only thing retained from his old Reichswehr uniform and he was happy for them, standing in several inches of mud and clay amidst a shallow trench. Repairing the water supply had been made the top priority of those involved in the rebuilding of the city. People were still having to queue with buckets in the freezing cold at pump hydrants. Whilst they waited they could at least look upon the Reichswehr personnel working at the problem and satisfy themselves that someone had it worse.

These former soldiers were being kept in the Fuhlsbuettel prison which despite having had many of its former anarchist and communist inhabitants released in the opening days of the city’s takeover was now reportedly cramped far beyond capacity. Johann didn’t want to dwell on it too much. Rehousing was a problem for thousands in the aftermath of the fires and the requisitioning of many bourgeois properties that had previously been left alone had reminded Peter of what happened to his own family during the Bavarian Soviet when he was just a child. His own present situation could have been worse, Klaus’ story of them both being diehard communists with links to Soviet intelligence had paid off and in return for their information on Reichswehr troop movements and armoured warfare they were instead being billeted in a cosy guesthouse within the city.

They had continued their reading group with just the two of them when they could and Klaus had been insistent on them both officially joining the Communist Party at the first opportunity. Peter had done so gladly, even if there was something off about the General Secretary that he couldn’t quite place. It had felt like a release after warily reading left-wing literature under the noses of their superiors in the tank school. Now, to be amongst Hamburg’s citizenry who were sticking together in the face of adversity and building a better society amongst them; it seemed the world envisioned by the texts they were reading was unfolding in front of them.

Klaus had gone a step further, agreeing to record radio broadcasts and write leaflets for the United Front’s elaborate propaganda network and to involve himself ever more closely with the People’s Guard. In this Peter wasn’t too happy to play along, he wasn’t sure if he’d been built to be a soldier and wasn’t the best suited to speeches either. He preferred to work in a way his upbringing hadn’t allowed him to do, a proper day's work in rebuilding the city where he could rest easy at the end of the day having made a positive material difference in front of him. Propaganda and military staff work were far more ephemeral and in regards to the latter, he would have been terrified of his parents finding out.

Peter’s parents had despised Communists ever since they had forced them to have destitute people sleep in their home during the tense time of the Bavarian Soviet. It seemed they were safe from a similar fate for now; the nearest People’s Guard units were still only at the outskirts of Bavaria but he was sure they would be panicking already without having to know their son had joined the expropriators.

That said, the news of the blackshirts turning on Von Schleicher made him more confident in justifying his decision to them when the time came. He had been fighting for the wrong cause and if they thought otherwise he could point to the fact that this way he was liable to have influence on whoever might want to have their house occupied or his father's business seized. That was if the business, and the house still existed when this was all over.

He put such thoughts out of his mind and got ready to return to the laying of new water pipes.

“That’s no job for an officer.” Peter looked up to face the heckler.

His friend Klaus stood there decked out in his new People’s Guard uniform. Has clearly quite chuffed with himself. He did seem to look the part with his muscled figure, angular face and straight jaw even if his untidy mop of brown hair looked more like it would fitting on a Marxist academic. The combination of the uniform from the world war and the republican armband made Peter think back once again to the militias of the Bavarian Soviet who had used troops who had returned from Belgium to move down and outs into his family home.

“Pretty good, eh?”

“Not bad, here’s hoping you aren’t wearing this one the next time you decide to burst into flames.” Peter jeered back.

“Very good...” Klaus responded absentmindedly, perhaps trying to put the thought of what had happened in Lehrte out of his mind.

“You’re from Munich right?”

“Born and bred, how come?” Peter wondered if Klaus had somehow read his mind.

“There’s something you’re going to want to hear,” Without explaining further Klaus beckoned Peter to a cafe that was still barely standing. No drinks were being served but it still had a radio set and provided an outlet for workers to rest amidst the rebuilding. However all of them were now gathered around the radio attentively. Peter gathered that whatever was on must have been important but as Klaus and he nestled themselves amongst the group it quickly became clear they weren’t listening to Radio Einheitsfront. If anything it seemed to be the reverse.

A regal albeit grizzled voice was decrying the United Front, condemning their contempt for the existing legal procedures and harkening back to the Bavarian Soviet Republic and similar revolts, casting allusions to the Soviet Union.

“Have you ever heard of Crown Prince Rupprecht?” Klaus murmured.

“Of course, he was the son of the last King of Bavaria, is that him speaking?”

Peter had vague memories of being taken to the King’s funeral when he was a boy. He had never seen the streets of Munich so crowded. At the time he hadn’t really understood why there couldn’t be a new King to replace him. Wasn’t there a Prince? His father had blamed Communists for this as he was wont to do but also explained that although there was a Prince he didn’t want to become King just now but that was alright because he was also a war hero and had a lot of work to do.

“Apparently so,”

“I thought using the radio for propaganda was only a United Front thing?”

“Not anymore it seems, he said he’s broadcasting from your hometown. He’s really letting us have it.”

Us, the assumed identity of a revolutionary republican was still somewhat jarring to Peter, particularly when he knew his father would undoubtedly be applauding the Crown Prince’s speech if he were listening

“What did you expect?” Peter responded indifferently, trying to cover his anxiety with disinterest.

“No, that’s not the point, he’s letting Hohenzollern have it too,” Peter raised an eyebrow and continued the listen, understanding why Klaus had been so intrigued. The condemnation of the United Front continued for a while but then the Crown Prince did indeed start rallying against what he was decrying as ‘Prussian chauvinism:’



“The empire of Bismarck was one of allied states and therein lay its strength. The attempt of a Prussian monarch to impose his authority over the Bavarian state represents the same tyrannical encroachment coming from Hamburg.

We are Bavarians, we are accustomed to think in centuries of our history and act in the interests of the Bavarian people. That means acting also in resisting the imposition of the foreign yoke of ephemeral ideals upon the Bavarian soil. We are opposed to the centralising tyrannies of Berlin and Hamburg and thus we elect to disassociate ourselves from both of these states.”



“What the hell is he banging on about?” One of those sat around the radio set complained. Others began to agree before being shushed by Klaus, his uniform helping to impose silence.



“On behalf of the Bavarian people, in accordance with the stated will of their representatives in the Bavarian Landtag and of the Bavarian Minister-President, I am announcing today the reestablishment of the Kingdom of Bavaria with myself as regent until such a time, God willing, sanity returns to our German brothers. Until that time I implore all Bavarians to pledge their loyalty to their homeland and take up arms only in its defence.

This is indeed a moment anchored in our history. Today, we look forward to the time when this moment will be seen as a turning point: the day when democracy was renewed in Bavaria, when we revitalised our Kingdom.”



“Did he just say Bavaria was leaving Germany?” The man who had been complaining about the Crown Prince’s vague language seemed to have cottoned to what he was saying.

“Good riddance,” another of the group sneered, “bunch of bumpkins and papists. They might not want a German Mussolini but they don’t seem to mind taking orders from Rome.”

Whether it was the anxiety of his thoughts of home, or the confusion of what the Crown Prince had said, Peter grabbed the man from the back of his collar and grabbed him up off of his seat near the radio. Before the man could react Peter had him slammed against the doorway.

“I’m as German as you are my friend but if you have such a distaste for Catholics I’d advise you get back to work.” With that Peter shoved him out of the door. The man nearly lost his balance but recovered it and glared for a moment but then sheepishly went back to the trench. Peter stepped back in to see Kalus had already taken the man’s seat.

“It’s a bluff.” his friend remarked whilst passing around a pack of cigarettes to the assembled listeners, the Crown Prince having now been replaced with a choral version of the Bayernhymne on the radio. “There’s been chaos in Baden ever since Hohezollern’s coup, and things aren’t much better in Thuringia. We’re on the march in both directions and the more chaos he sows in front of Bavaria the more he can disrupt our advance to buy him time.”

“Time for what?” The confused man from before now asked.

“Who knows, a settlement between ourselves and the Reichswehr? More autonomy after the revolution? Maybe he even wants to replace Hohenzollern. His ancestors have been kings of Germany beyond just Bavaria before. All I know is, it’s a play, “this momentous time in history” is just the usual royal self-indulgence.”

“And if it isn’t?”

“Well, that means Klompf here could be arrested on suspicion of being a foreign agent after all.” The listeners turned to laugh and Peter was relieved to see it was more jovial than the contempt the man he had escorted outside had displayed. Peter smiled and took a cigarette.

Inside any certainties he had reached were currently unravelling.

All this time he had worried of being disowned by his family, now his homeland had done it for them.


---



The painting is The Soldier Drinks by Marc Chagall
 
Well that's a plot twist, now the situation in southern Germany is a complete mess. If we didn't saw the map of the German Workers Republic in 1936, i would have presumed that the Second World War might have started for Bavaria.
 
Interesting development. The chapters from the future make me doubt the Bavarians will succeed. However the attempt being made will probably result in Bavaria leaving Germany for good if/when Red Germany looses the war.
 
Exellent.

Of course, Rupprecht was also the Stuart Pretender to the UK throne. Don't know what the author has planned in that direction.
 
Top