Of Rajahs and Hornbills: A timeline of Brooke Sarawak

[Al-numbers]

Well, for the Philippines with regards to ATL, you need to take away OTL bias. Majority of the 19th century rebellions were led by Creoles or Pure spanish blood while the Indios were reluctant to even lead until 1890s.

1896-7, is mostly an Indio rebellion while the creoles and the insulares were a bit reluctant.

An example would be: Had this succeeded http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrés_Novales

Philippines would be independent around the same time as Mexico led by a dictator like Mexico's Santa Ana. So it totally depends on how you want to butterfly Philippines away or retain as its OTL form.

Hmm... I've actually been thinking of a shrunk Philippines lately; with Sulu and Maguindano under foreign protection and Palawan ceded to a different colonial power in exchange for independence ala. Bakumatsu Japan.

I might need to do a PM once the week is over.

The difference is that Sarawak is being run by a white guy. And to 19th-century Europeans, that's a big difference.

As for the Philippines being a western nation, that would have required that the British, French, Dutch and Americans (plus the Germans, once they unified) actually regard Southern Europeans as properly white people. At best, they qualify higher on the racial hierarchy than their neighbors, but still well below proper North European stock.

You know, I'm pretty sure the number of White Guys in the Philippines is higher than that of an adventurer-kingdom in Borneo.

I do get what you mean though; the Philippines aren't exactly the first choice an European would point to as an independent or "civilized" polity. Nevertheless, the sheer length of Spanish rule and it's effects might just swing in the Filipino's favor. Besides, there are other ways to gain influence and money without outright colonization.

 

[SunDeep]

Hmm... I've actually been thinking of a shrunk Philippines lately; with Sulu and Maguindano under foreign protection and Palawan ceded to a different colonial power in exchange for independence ala. Bakumatsu Japan.

I might need to do a PM once the week is over.



You know, I'm pretty sure the number of White Guys in the Philippines is higher than that of an adventurer-kingdom in Borneo.

I do get what you mean though; the Philippines aren't exactly the first choice an European would point to as an independent or "civilized" polity. Nevertheless, the sheer length of Spanish rule and it's effects might just swing in the Filipino's favor. Besides, there are other ways to gain influence and money without outright colonization.

True. No reason why the USA can't just keep pursuing the 'banana republic' route in the Philippines that it did everywhere else up until the Spanish-American War.

 

[Namayan]

The difference is that Sarawak is being run by a white guy. And to 19th-century Europeans, that's a big difference.

As for the Philippines being a western nation, that would have required that the British, French, Dutch and Americans (plus the Germans, once they unified) actually regard Southern Europeans as properly white people. At best, they qualify higher on the racial hierarchy than their neighbors, but still well below proper North European stock.

That is under the assumption that Philippines retains OTL history. Please remember that all rebellions in the Philippines before 1896 in the 19th century were lead by a disgruntled Spaniard born in the Philippines. It just so happened that OTL 1896-1898 rebellions were being lead by the Indio caste.

This is also under the assumption that Spain's power declines much like OTL to even be recognize as the weak link of the West.

Like I said in my previous post, you got to take away OTL bias when it comes to 19th Century Philippines as one decision changed or an earlier successful rebellion could butterfly the whole OTL Philippines.

Hmm... I've actually been thinking of a shrunk Philippines lately; with Sulu and Maguindano under foreign protection and Palawan ceded to a different colonial power in exchange for independence ala. Bakumatsu Japan.

Chopping part of the Philippines would depend on which part especially in mid 19th century. If you want to chop Guam or Marianas out of the Philippines much like in OTL, this possible due to how far it is from Manila or lack of colonial presence in those islands.

With regards to Sulu and Maguindanao, this is highly possible to create them as a separate state as they functioned as a separate state in OTL 19th century.

 

[wannis]

That is under the assumption that Philippines retains OTL history. Please remember that all rebellions in the Philippines before 1896 in the 19th century were lead by a disgruntled Spaniard born in the Philippines. It just so happened that OTL 1896-1898 rebellions were being lead by the Indio caste.

This is also under the assumption that Spain's power declines much like OTL to even be recognize as the weak link of the West.

Like I said in my previous post, you got to take away OTL bias when it comes to 19th Century Philippines as one decision changed or an earlier successful rebellion could butterfly the whole OTL Philippines.

I think if sketchdoodle limits his PoDs to Borneo, nothing much will change concerning the overall decline and geopolitical position of Spain. OTOH, a succesful rebellion on the Philippines that leads to an earlier independence certainly would have repercussions back in Spain, probably changing the sequence of coups, revolutions, and civil wars during the 19th century.

 

[Al-numbers]

I think if sketchdoodle limits his PoDs to Borneo, nothing much will change concerning the overall decline and geopolitical position of Spain. OTOH, a succesful rebellion on the Philippines that leads to an earlier independence certainly would have repercussions back in Spain, probably changing the sequence of coups, revolutions, and civil wars during the 19th century.

This is one of the biggest problems I'm facing with this TL, actually: The influence of Bornean PoD's on the wider world and the world's responses to these PoD's. This is coupled by the fact that I have reasonable knowledge of Sarawak and Malaysia, but almost nothing about the outside world at this time . I'm trying to learn as much as I can about world history, but it's getting to be an insanely complicated business. Oh well, take one thing at a time...

In relation to the above, I'm already planning on three worldwide PoD's that will affect the rest of the world in the 18th century; one in Europe, and two in the Asia-Pacific. All of them involve leaders, and they will lead to an...interesting SE-Asia, to say the least (and Europe, and Africa, and-you get the idea ).

 

[Al-numbers]

‘Abdurrahman Khan’, War and Peace in Colonial Borneo (Kenyalang Publishing; 1985)

It could be said that the 1850s was a time of great change for the Kingdom of Sarawak, not just in terms of general development, but in wars and peace as well. From 1853 to 1862 the nation underwent not one, but two simultaneous rebellions along with an uprising that threatened to unravel everything that James Brooke and his allies created. Along with changing the way the Brooke kingdom waged war, the upheavals of the 1850s would also change the way the Dayaks were treated by their overlords, leading to the modern state that exists today.

The first, and most famous, of the 1850s upheavals was the Rentap Rebellion which rocked the new Simanggang Division and reevaluated Brooke policy toward the Sarawak Dayaks. The rebellion is named so after the Iban chieftain that headed it, Libau Rentap. He was born in the early 1800s and became one of the leading Manok Sabong – fighting men – of his tribe during his youth, leading war expeditions deep into Dutch Borneo. Over the years, his martial prowess and tribal warring earned him great respect among the Ibans of Batang Lupar and the surrounding rivers, resulting in the man being appointed chief of his tribe upon his predecessor’s death.

As the Rajah James Brooke began expanding his powers deep into Sarawak, the English adventurer’s policies soon began to conflict with the ways of the Iban. The British Royal Navy was combating piracy up and down the Bornean coast, branding the warring Dayak subgroup as ‘pirates’, a term that rankled Rentap who saw the labeling as undeserved. Then there was the decision to build forts up and down the rivers to patrol the movement of the Sarawak Dayaks, a move that infuriated Rentap as now the tradition of war expeditions became all but impossible. The final straw was the ban on headhunting enacted by the White Rajah, whom the Iban saw as an affront to their faith and their way of life. Even with the relaxation of the rule by James, the chieftain had made up his mind. He gathered his forces, sent word to his allied tribes, and planned for war.

A possible sketch of Libau “world-shaker” Rentap. There are no photographs of him and what physical features he has is distorted due to native aggrandizement. This is the closest we will ever get to the enigmatic chieftain.​

Libau Rentap had fought against James Brooke and his allies before the 1850s, but it was during the decade that truly defined the war for the Simanggang Division. In March 1853, the chieftain assembled a group of warriors and tried to attack Fort James. The attack, though unsuccessful, did result in the death of a British officer, a move that shocked the new administration in Kuching. In response, James traveled to Bandar Brunei and appealed before the sultan for annexation of the area, as well as heading an anti-headhunting expedition up the Batang Lupar River in June. His expedition was a failure as much as Libau Rentap’s had, though considering his explorations into Sentarum and claiming it for Sarawak, it could also be said as an unexpected success (an amused Charles Brooke would later write of this as “…searching for sharks and catching gold”).

Undaunted, James launched expeditions on the surrounding rivers to catch the wily chieftain, eventually battling with him on the Battle of the Lang River in 1854, of which Rentap lost. The chieftain and his followers retreated upriver to Mount Sadok and built a strong fort with extra walls and fortifications to hamper off any British assault. From this base, Rentap would launch raid after raid upon the forts of Simanggang and any Iban village that sided with the Brookes, leading to the area being in a perpetual state of unrest up until 1861. Rentap also gathered allied chieftains from other communities to his side to join the fight, confounding the Brooke’s efforts by conducting surprise raids from various rivers in the Division.

It was also around this time that another leader decided on rebelling against the new and rising power in Kuching. This time, it was a Bruneian lord by the name of Sharif Masahor, a man of Hardrami and Melanau roots and rumored to be a descendent of the Prophet Muhammad. From his base in the town of Sarikei, Masahor viewed the upstart Kingdom of Sarawak with wariness and suspicion; he was rankled by James’ rising influence around Brunei and in the Rajang River basin, especially with the building of fort Emma in Kanowit, an area that was supposed to be outside the Kingdom of Sarawak’s jurisdiction. As with Libau Rentap, Masahor gathered his forces and sent word to his allies of his plans – with the exception that he was influential enough to bring not just the coastal Malays to his side, but native Iban and Melanau tribes as well.

A romantic sketch of Sharif Masahor. Note the cannon that lay beside his feet; ordinary lords do not stand that close to such a weapon.​

Taking advantage of the White Rajah’s emergency departure to Singapore in 1855 (the English Parliament grew wary of the English adventurer’s actions in Borneo and wanted to question James on his behavior), Masahor rallied a force of 150 Perahus and launched attacks on Fort Emma and the Brooke-allied towns of Maling, Mukah, Oya and Saratok, causing the deaths of several more British officers. With the absence of Rajah James, Masahor quickly took control of the Rajang Delta and expelled any remaining Bruneian lords that sided with the White Rajah, forcing many of them to flee to safety in Sarawak. The Bruneian lord also began conspiring with other like-minded men to launch an attack on Kuching village, wanting to oust the White Rajahs from Borneo for good.

Surprisingly, the one man who arguably started it all – Pangiran Indera Mahkota – did not want to get involved in the rebellions and related affairs, either for Rentap or for Masahor. Ever since the English adventurer took the position of Governor in Kuching back in 1842, the Bruneian noble has led a drastically unassuming life in Bandar Brunei, composing poetry and advising senior ministers on state affairs. Contemporary accounts from both the court and the Royal Navy described the former lord of Kuching as an old man, humbled by his life and his experiences throughout it. After the formation of the Kingdom of Sarawak, several Bruneian lords rallied around the nobleman as a symbol of the oppressing British, but soon abandoned him once he proved to be nothing more than a lame duck.

The Bruneian lord’s poems (here published under his alternate title: Pangiran Shahbandar) are still studied by Sarawakian and Bruneian schoolchildren today, even the verses that are anti-British in character. ​

The last and most surprising of all the upheavals was the Kuching Uprising of 1857. The Chinese minority in Sarawak had a tumultuous start, beginning with the exodus of Chinese miners from Dutch Borneo in 1851 as a result of inter-clan warfare. These miners soon found themselves under the employ of the Kingdom of Sarawak, mining the antimony and gold deposits underneath the mountains of Bau and Lundu. However, the mining communities soon began assembling among themselves, forming secret societies and trading opium illegally from the nearby Sambas Sultanate and the port of Singapore.

In the mid-1850s, the Kuching government finally began discussion on raising taxes among certain goods and managing the flow of illegal opium trade coming from Dutch Borneo. This rankled the Chinese mining communities for the supposed ‘intrusion’ on their rights and immediately began agitating among each other for an uprising against the White Rajah. Boats and sampans were kept away from prying eyes while several Royal Navy officers reported having their rifles stolen. The apocryphal announcement of the Chinese Commissioner in Canton in 1856 of paying thirty Dollars for the head of an Englishman certainly aided to the cause. Despite all of this, the rebellions in Simanggang and the Rajang Delta kept Rajah James and his cousin Charles looking elsewhere while the miniscule European community in the capital thought of such an event as simply implausible.

At 12:00 midnight on February the 26th 1857, the Chinese made their move. Groups of miners traveled down the Sarawak River under the darkness and attacked several small forts upriver from Kuching, overpowering the guards and setting the structures ablaze before reaching the capital. Rajah James was forced to flee from his residence while the small European community fled to take shelter in a missionary school, watching the capital burn up in flames. The Chinese were surprisingly cordial to the foreign men and women, allowing all but a few government ministers to leave Kuching by the next morning; partly due to the understanding of what will happen if European women and children got harmed in a foreign uprising.

A drawing made by a missionary showing the wives of British officers looking in horror at the burning bungalow of Rajah James.​

At the same time, Charles Brooke was heading back to the capital from Simanggang on his war-boat along with a thousand Brooke-allied Dayak warriors, unaware of what has happened. By the evening though, the younger Brooke and his allies found themselves battling with the miners, expelling them from Kuching and ending the Uprising no less than 48 hours after it began. The following weeks saw a brutal crackdown on Chinese secret societies and clamping of the illegal opium trade, much to the consternation of Batavia as Chinese criminals streamed their way across the border into the Sambas Sultanate, causing more than a few disturbances once they arrived.

The rest of the 1850’s was devoted to rebuilding Kuching, re-establishing public order and combating the rebellions of Rentap and Sharif Masahor. The Brookes used every available contact they had to secure weapons and goods for their kingdom; gun-boats from the Royal Navy, supplies from their enthusiasts in England; a large loan by Baroness Burdett-Courts; and so on. Brooke-allied Dayaks were also used as additional troops, swayed by the Rajah’s Semangat and the promise of plunder and enemy heads (the headhunting ban was waived in times of battle). Rajah James also bit the bullet and requested to London of his kingdom becoming a protectorate of the British, though with the Indian Rebellion of ’57 diverting the attention of Parliament, his requests were rejected and – in an idiotic move – the Kingdom of Sarawak’s status of independence was shunted aside.

A drawing by a British officer, showing Brooke-allied Dayaks using blowpipes against a Masahor-allied war fleet. ​

Libau Rentap would be the first to fall. After a series of battles against the Dayak chieftain, James Brooke personally led an attack on Rentap’s base fort on Mount Sadok in 1861. During the attack, the Iban chieftain’s gunpowder stores for his cannons caught fire and exploded, killing the man in a fiery blaze. As for Masahor, his status as the lord of Sarikei was revoked by the Bruniean Sultan and he was eventually captured at Mukah before being deported to British Malaya. James Brooke also annexed the entire Rajang River and its headwaters from Brunei, wanting to prevent another large-scale incident from ever happening again.

And thus, the fledgling Kingdom of Sarawak survived through the most tumultuous decade of its entire history. Not only did it survived against two major rebellions and a successful short-lived uprising, it also survived against British public opinion, the disinterest of Parliament and denial by Britain of being an independent state. There would still be Dayak uprisings long after the era, but none would be as big or as far-reaching as those of the 1850’s…

An anachronistic map of Sarawak during the hights of the two rebellions and the Kuching Uprising, circa 1857​

__________
Footnotes:

1) Both Libau Rentap and Sharif Masahor were actual figures that did rebel against Brooke rule, and in their rebellion’s peak controlled large parts of Sarawak and Brunei.

2) The Chinese Uprising was an actual uprising that occurred in 1857 due to an increase in taxation and the clamping of the illegal opium trade.

3) The Brooke government had several gunboats in their possession in OTL, some loaned from the British Navy while others coming from (spoilers!)

4) Other than changing the dates of the events, some of the details of the battles (most notably Rentap’s death ITTL) and the arrival of the Chinese in Sarawak, almost everything about the 1850’s were OTL.

5) Pangiran Indera Mahkota really did compose poems in his life; most notably the Syair Rakis, which talks about the dangers of accepting foreign rule.

 

[Unknown]

Good update.

Waiting for more...

 

[Al-numbers]

Good update.

Waiting for more...

Thanks! Rereading the update, I think I might have overdone it in several parts . Regardless, the military situation of Sarawak had to be noted because it's effects were so wide-ranging on the state that it changed how the Brookes ran their country in the long term.

Also, anyone have any questions about the update? Things that needed clarifying? Stuff that you don't understand? I find it best thinking up questions if I have the Notepad program enabled alongside the update and writing things down.

 

[ramones1986]

Are the Chinese who loved in Sarawak mostly came from Southern Fujian?

 

[Archangel]

Good update.

Waiting for more...

Seconded!

 

[FleetMac]

Sweet update, sketch! I suppose when the cat's away, the mice will play as Rentap has proven. However, I think it's all for the best if it means that there'll be a greater sense of stability from this time forward. Granted it meant running back to Britain for help and/or recognition, but in the long run I don't think it'll mean turning Sarawak into an exploitable colony per se (at least, as long as the Brookes and their people have anything to say about it...).

Out of curiosity, how do you think the Dutch would think about recent events on the isle? Are they looking to expand, or just accept that Sarawak's a separate entity and leave well enough alone?

 

[Jonathan Edelstein]

I hadn't realized that the Brookes' position was so precarious in the 1850s - it reminds me a bit of Brazil in the 1830s, trying to keep together with rebellion cropping up everywhere. Brazil came out of it stronger, though, and I suspect the Brookes also will, especially with Rentap's earlier death.

Will we hear more of Masahor? In OTL he continued to take part in intrigue after being exiled to Malaya.

 

[Al-numbers]

Seconded!

Thanks for reading!

Are the Chinese who loved in Sarawak mostly came from Southern Fujian?

Well, it's a bit complicated to say the least. Some records show that a part of the Chinese minority did arrive as traders from Guangdong, Fujian, Hainan, and the other coastal provinces of China. On the other hand, some of the Chinese miners in Sarawak came from either Singapore or from Dutch Borneo, with the latter case being more likely since the West Bornean sultanates have employed the Chinese as miners since the late 18th century (which somewhat explains why was there a Chinese Republic in Borneo during that same time period).

Sweet update, sketch! I suppose when the cat's away, the mice will play as Rentap has proven. However, I think it's all for the best if it means that there'll be a greater sense of stability from this time forward. Granted it meant running back to Britain for help and/or recognition, but in the long run I don't think it'll mean turning Sarawak into an exploitable colony per se (at least, as long as the Brookes and their people have anything to say about it...).

Out of curiosity, how do you think the Dutch would think about recent events on the isle? Are they looking to expand, or just accept that Sarawak's a separate entity and leave well enough alone?

Well, the absence of the White Rajahs did lend a certain hand in influencing Rentap and Sharif Masahor's decisions. The only thing they were missing was powerful contacts (and no, Brunei doesn't count. )

As for the Kingdom's independence, it's actually one of the more weirder tales concerning the history of Sarawak (but then again, since when did Sarawak ever resemble anything normal in history? ). When James Brooke became Rajah of Sarawak in OTL, the British press and public somewhat accepted this fact, but the British Parliament didn't grant it any recognition of independence at all! Only the U.S and Brunei acknowledged it as a sovereign state and even then it was begrudgingly followed for the sake of international trade. It wasn't until 1863 that Britain finally said "Okay, you are an independent country", and even then it was because the other European powers began having colonial ambitions.

As for the Dutch, let's just say they have a few problems of their own that would keep themselves busy.

I hadn't realized that the Brookes' position was so precarious in the 1850s - it reminds me a bit of Brazil in the 1830s, trying to keep together with rebellion cropping up everywhere. Brazil came out of it stronger, though, and I suspect the Brookes also will, especially with Rentap's earlier death.

Will we hear more of Masahor? In OTL he continued to take part in intrigue after being exiled to Malaya.

And again, you have made me realize just how little I know about the world . I can see the similarities with Brazil, and the Brookes will come of this more stronger than before. The question is how much.

As for Masahor, I think this would be the last we hear of him, and his life will turn out more or less like OTL; serving in the Selangor royal court, backing the wrong horse in a rebellion, and ITTL either perishing n battle or dying a pardoned man.

 

[Diez Mil Cantos]

Could we get a map post-Rajang annexation? Sarawak really is getting big, and hopefully doesn't attract too much dutch ire down the road. Will there be any sultanates of the native kind that survive dutch domination in the DEI ITTL?

 

[Al-numbers]

Could we get a map post-Rajang annexation? Sarawak really is getting big, and hopefully doesn't attract too much dutch ire down the road. Will there be any sultanates of the native kind that survive dutch domination in the DEI ITTL?

A map of post-1861 Sarawak is in the cards, but not for another two or three updates. We still haven't looked at how Brunei and the Dutch are faring in the 1850s, and Sarawak was doing more than just fighting rebellions during that period either.

As for the sultanates in Dutch Borneo, I have one or two candidates that might be able to gain some autonomy compared to their neighbors, but after 1861 the Bornean sultanates are basically screwed.

 

[ramones1986]

On the other hand, some of the Chinese miners in Sarawak came from either Singapore or from Dutch Borneo, with the latter case being more likely since the West Bornean sultanates have employed the Chinese as miners since the late 18th century (which somewhat explains why was there a Chinese Republic in Borneo during that same time period).

Well, the founders and leaders of the Lanfang Republic were Hakka.

 

[Al-numbers]

Well, the founders and leaders of the Lanfang Republic were Hakka.

Ah, if you mean just how ethnically diverse Sarawak's Chinese population was during the 1850s... that's nearly impossible to know. Most records and journals of early Sarawak simply clump together the Hakkas, Teochews and Cantonese together as "Chinese" or "Christian Chinese", at best.

However, given that the Hakkas were already predominant in Borneo before James' arrival and that they were already in the mining business, I'd say most of Sarawak's Chinese population were Hakka miners with a Cantonese and Teochew trading minority.

 

[Al-numbers]

Heads up! I'll be having an exam this Saturday so no updates this week. I'm open for any questions or discussions though. Thanks for reading!

 

[Silver]

I'm open for any questions or discussions though.

Well, just how big will the Brookes' Bornean Empire be, especially that will be long lasting (i.e. up to the present day)? Will it consists of OTL Sarawak, OTL Sabah (including the island of Labuan), and perhaps even parts of OTL Brunei and/or OTL Indonesian Kalimantan? Please let me know. Thank you.

 

[Al-numbers]

Well, just how big will the Brookes' Bornean Empire be, especially that will be long lasting (i.e. up to the present day)? Will it consists of OTL Sarawak, OTL Sabah (including the island of Labuan), and perhaps even parts of OTL Brunei and/or OTL Indonesian Kalimantan? Please let me know. Thank you.

Ah, now that is a secret . I will say that the Kingdom of Sarawak's (KoS') decisions from 1875 to 1885 will mayyybe make the state more known to the world compared to OTL, where it remained as an open secret among the European nations.

In terms of size and land area, this Sarawak is already bigger than it's OTL counterpart. TTL's Sarawak has the Sentarum Floodplains while OTL Sarawak didn't get the area at all. This will have a long-term impact towards the area's Dayaks, but I'm keeping my lips sealed .