Charlie MacDonald, Strange States, Weird Wars, and Bizzare Borders, (weirdworld.postr.com, 2014)
…I think that if someone made a graphic of how much interest academics have on the progress of the Great War, the months of July to September 1905 would stick out like an explosion in a grain field. The fact that the German Empire suffered a military scandal, a royal death, and political pressure all without jumping into war speaks to the unseen fluidity of pubic perception, while also laying bare how low would nations, and people, go.
But I’m going to break with most dunderheads and begin this topic from an angle that most people are uncomfortable with: The Unger Accusations, and what it meant for Wilhelm and his beloved army.
And to do that, let’s make one thing clear: The Kaiser. Wasn’t. Gay.
Wilhelm liked men. He enjoyed men. Heck, he thought his military service was the best thing that ever happened in his youth! But all in all, he preferred their company and friendship instead of boning them behind closed doors, like what so many conspiracy nuts believe nowadays.
However, he was aware that there were gay and effeminate men serving the empire beside him, and by all accounts and from his own words, he was pretty okay or “meh” about it all, which is far more that can be said for him than for some others during the period. [1] Of course, there could be the chance that the Kaiser was bisexual but that’s not the point here!
Here’s the main issue: when journalist Matthäus Unger made the list of military brass, NCO’s, political figures, and German princes that he thought were homosexual in June 1905, it was done with the intent of
helping the Kaiser [2]. A pro-monarchist, Unger saw the coming rainstorm of the Great War earlier than most and believed that Germany may be better served if ‘effeminate’ men were to be discharged from positions of power. And before you all scream about him, his view of gay men was actually pretty consistent with what most ignorant Germans believed of the community at that time. He wasn’t even disgustingly homophobic to the point of some of the groups that emerged later on. He simply thought that the monarchy and the army would be better run if effeminate men were replaced with what he called, “more capable figures”. [3]
However, Unger didn’t know that the Kaiser did not care for his views or for his list whatsoever. Unfortunately, the public did. What many casual historians (and many normal folk) forget about 1905 Germany was that public hysteria reached a fever pitch during that summer. No matter where and no matter what, the Great War was on all minds. Support for Austria-Hungary was
everywhere in Germany: rallies and donation drives were hosted in every major city, the windowsills of many neighbourhoods were draped in Austro-Hungarian flags, and every family would discuss of their neighbour down the street who ran off to volunteer in Galicia, or Tyrol. German patriotism was high, and so was adulation of German culture and German customs. Everyone thought the German government would ask for war, and everyone thought the Kaiser would allow it.
Unger wanted to post his list to the military brass in Berlin, but was denied. However, a copy of it slipped from his hands and ended up in the house of Berlin’s leading broadsheet newspaper in late July. War fervour was high. The public wanted a fight. And the rest… well… was history.
Well, not quite. While Unger was caught flat-footed at the document’s publishing, he quickly saw it as a way to weaponize popular opinion and call for the removal of various officials for, as he called it, “the weakening of our military and the indolence of our government”. The German government answered by arresting him. The public responded by swarming the prison. During his trial, he was acquitted, and though he would be later arrested that fall for inciting mob violence, the summer of 1905 would be Matthäus Unger’s to take. His imprisonment also stoked the more homophobic parts of society, and they named names that weren’t on Unger’s list, from the lowest conscripts to the highest of the General Staff. Calling them weak, effeminate, even… un-German.
I’ll not talk about the public reaction to them. I’ll not talk of the hysteria, fueled by the reports of battles and spies caught across the border. I’m not digging deeper into the mob beatings and the witch-hunts. I’m not going to talk about the 10 NCO’s who hanged themselves in their barracks. Or the head of the Munich Inspectorate who shot himself in his room. I’ll not talk about the pictures, or the letters, and the way homophobic groups used them in their campaigns. I’m not talking about Cäsar Henze, or Oliver Künstler, or Sandro Krehl, or the many other heterosexual soldiers whom were misblamed and saw their brothers-in-arms turn against them and made their lives hell, and ultimately to the grave. I will not talk about that, for their memories shouldn’t be defined by the vile ways society treated them. Just typing this paragraph made me feel like vomiting.
A cartoon drawn during the Ungern Accusations, portraying the Prussian coat of arms fronted by two effeminate and out-of-shape figures, signifying the decay of Prussian society by homosexuals.[4]
And the thing is,
it could’ve been worse. The depth of German reaction during that summer is documented to hell and back, but not many realized that French and Russian nationals also kept the ears on the latest in Berlin gossip, and it was from this that we get perhaps the most disgusting act of subterfuge France and Russia had for the German Empire: the Leclair Plot. Planned by the French ambassador to Russia, it would involve French and Russian agents intentionally planting false information to bring down the German military command and disrupt the army. And the false info? Homosexuality. As Paul Leclair* himself stated in a letter to his ministry in Paris: “For this war to be won, the circus of Berlin
must not end.”
Thankfully, the plan was not carried through.
Also, a tangent: False rumours weren’t the only thing talked amongst the German people. In mid-August, a Russian spying operation was uncovered in Vienna, yet the information they collected managed to be sent abroad before they were captured. Ten days later, newspapers containing damning passages were circulated across the Galician Front. How damning? For a start, Crown Prince Rudolf said of the Kaiser as “a demented dog,” while Franz Ferdinand retorted how Wilhelm “…has the mind of an ox crossed with a howling swine.” I won’t post Franz Joseph’s legendary passage, but suffice to say, it was damning. The Habsburgs were never really warm with Wilhelm II, seeing his bellicose ways as destabilizing and reckless, but they always made sure their disdain were vented behind closed doors and in secret letters. Now, it was out.
The reactions to this are manifold, but we’re sticking with Wilhelm, and how all of this reached into his innermost circle. The Habsburg comments were originally dismissed as slander, which is until Crown Prince Rudolph made an appeal to the Vojvodinan Serbs in late August and made a
faux-pas, saying “if you seek my honesty, look to the Galician papers.” While the rest of the family apologized, it was the first time Wilhelm discovered how much his imperial German neighbours actually thought of him. It planted a seed in his mind, and it never really left.
Closer to home, the names implicated by Unger didn’t just went up to the Imperial Military Cabinet, but also to his closest and dearest. Not just that, but some of the men charged were those that the Kaiser didn’t like much, but respected deeply for their long service to Germany, such as Kuno von Moltke. As the General of Infantry, he would have been the last person to be convicted of homosexuality. Yet, the rumours that he dressed in tutus and danced to the pleasure of other men (a practice that Wilhelm
did force upon some officers, which amplified gossip when it came out [5]) were implacable. Despite all the royal protection of the Kaiser and the power of the libel and defamation laws, there was nothing he could do to stop Moltke from being dragged through the mud and into court, hounded all the while by his own wife who accused him of being sexually cold to her. [6]
And let’s think about all of this for a moment. Imagine you are the emperor of Germany. Your nation is at a pivotal moment in history. Your military might could be an unquestioned one if the right decisions are made. But then… comes a man stating names and things that struck very close to home. Your friends suddenly become suspect, and you hear howls in the streets as fellow Germans bayed for blood or removal. You see your army, your
beloved army whom you saw as a second home, starts to murder and hound itself. You hear men being beaten, and officers hanging themselves or putting pistols to their skulls. Your appointed inner circle comes under trial. And lastly, you found out – and begin to believe despite their assurances – that the very allies whom you want to help really think of you as a bully. Worse, a dangerous bully.
Oh, and your eldest son is dying through it all, and not just dying peacefully, but from the worst of diseases. After influenza, cholera, and dysentery, tuberculosis was one of the deadliest diseases in the Western World during the 19th and early 20th centuries, ravaging healthy men and women without mercy. The infected would suffer for months before finally passing on, and the potential for airborne spread through coughing and touch was so high that hotels and restaurants would kick potential patients out into the streets. There was no scientific cure. Despite the extreme measures set up at Potsdam for the Crown Prince, Wilhelm himself remarked that, “death is close to everyone here.” Indeed, many aides during the summer noted how the bellicose Kaiser could be silenced “just by mentioning consumption”, as one said it.
And the final blow was yet to come. In early September, while the imperial family was in mourning, a new name was mentioned for accusation; someone at the very heart of the Hohenzollern family: Wilhelm Eitel Friedrich, the Kaiser’s second son and (now) heir. [7]
A French propaganda postcard of Crown Prince Eitel Friedrich, with womanly hips and a large arse. The caption below reads "One of the ways of getting volunteers into Eitel Fritz’s regiment."
You can imagine how he reacted.
Germany couldn’t go to war while everyone else did. Not in this state.
It took months to weed out the rumours. Months to clear out all the trials and courts. Months to reappoint or replace the men whom were removed from their positions, willingly and otherwise. Months to drum up and implement new codes, laws, and policies to wind down the summer hysteria. Months to repair back the image of the monarchy and the army. Eventually, the vomit of public disgust sputtered down, and the hysteria was over by early October. The meatgrinder of the Galician front – where over 200,000 Russian and Austro-Hungarian soldiers perished just for Lemberg – put some cold water on the patriotic fervor, and the bloodbath that was sweeping Crete upturned the stomachs of even those who thought effeminate men were disgusting.
And all the while, there was Wilhelm, trying to keep it all together. Many observers noted that the Kaiser became less bellicose as the autumn came into being. He was still reactionary, but there was less loudmouthing in the halls of Potsdam, less of the wrangling and irritability that had once characterized the man. His closest aides all noted of him being more methodical and calm, though still impatient. Even his wife noted that her husband became “more interested in maps and diagrams of the war around around the world, than for affairs close to home. ”
Perhaps the death of his son and heir affected the man. Perhaps the Accusations went a little too close to home for a Kaiser who enjoyed male company and adored the army. Perhaps it was the knowledge that said army could be toppled not by guns but with the flash mob. Perhaps it was the truth that the Habsburgs held him in contempt; the recently declassified documents from Vienna explicitly stated that the family finally told the honest truth to Wilhelm after he demanded it in October (which is kinda gutsy, considering how Wilhelm could’ve easily took the disdain to waging war against them). Perhaps it was all of the above, or perhaps it was none of those at all.
We don’t know. We may
never know. The biggest problem with all these guesses is that we don’t have the wartime documents and journals of Wilhelm in the public domain. It is frustrating that after this long since the Great War, the Hohenzollerns are still keeping his wartime papers private! The family is hiding something, and perhaps the wartime enigma of Wilhelm II remains too sensitive to be revealed to the world. We can only guess. There was definitely no more officer-tutu parties afterwards, that’s for sure.
The Great War saw suffering and death on an untold scale, but there was one group that truly suffered in this period: the German gay community. These were men whom believed in their government and in their country, and sought to showcase that by joining the colours in defence of their homeland. But instead of being honoured for their service, they were spat on, beaten, and sometimes forced to take the final way out. The army was no longer a safe place to hide for them, and the hysteria of 1905 set back sexual progress in Germany for at least a generation.
A few years back, some of Kaiser Wilhelm’s
post-war journals were released to the public. On one page in September 1912, he remarked, “I sometimes wonder of the people whom we lost in 1905. Not the ones in the battles, but the men and boys whom served with us with their utmost pride, and paid the most unfair of dues in recompense, by our own society…”
____________________
Notes:
:: *Why yes, that is a man whom some of you have seen in another timeline.
1. IOTL, there is a lot of discussion regarding Wilhelm’s fondness towards men, and there is a consensus that he
must have known about homosexuality among his inner circle and in the army, especially since some of his friends were not discreet about their likings (looking at you, Eulenberg). ITTL, the Kaiser is a somewhat different person (his birth was normal, saving the world the worst of his erratic bellicosity) yet he is brought up to be a reactionary conservative by his tutors, and shares some of his OTL self’s militaristic views.
2. Matthäus Unger is an ITTL character, though he is based – in some levels – on the OTL journalist Maximilian Harden. Unger shares Harden’s early views towards the monarchy and sees the Kaiser more as an emperor surrounded by manipulative people, instead of Wilhelm possessing poor judgement and low merits in his own right. However, Unger is less sympathetic to homosexuality in general, whereas Harden was stated to personally favour decriminalization. Not that that stopped him from using it as a political weapon.
3. Those who are keen-eyed can already guess that this whole situation is an alternate Harden-Eulenberg Affair, which is an OTL scandal that rocked the German Empire in 1908 and saw the dismissal and court-martial of several armed officers from Wilhelm’s inner circle, with a few even going on trial.
4. The cartoon of the Prussian coat of arms also came from the time of the OTL affair.
5. Oh yes, Wilhelm really did force officers to dance in women’s clothing and in tutus IOTL, though he was also partly influenced into doing so by some of his partners in his inner circle (looking at you again, Eulenberg).
6. This was OTL. Kuno’s former wife of nine years, Lilly von Elbe, disparaged of him during trial, stating that their marriage was only consummated on their first and second nights and feeling sexually unfulfilled. She even claimed to have attacked her husband, only for him to defend himself and not strike back, which many Germans thought was proof his “effeminate” ways.
7. Though he was married with children, Prince Ethel Friedrich was rumoured to be gay during the time IOTL. And yes, the postcard really did exist and was a propaganda depiction of him being effeminate by the French during WWI.