Ocean of Storms: A Timeline of A Scientific America

XIII: Mischief Managed
Mischief Managed

uEySwCs.png

Image Credit: Nixonshead
15 February 1971

Apollo 14

MET: T+ 147:23:12

Orbital Inclination: 86°

Callsign: Endurance



Thomas Wheaton was able to watch the interview from his office. NBC had won the draw, so it was their reporter on the loop. The monitor in his office just showed Al Worden sitting alone in the command module’s left seat. It had been 8 months since they’d managed to get an astronaut on primetime television. He was relieved to be getting some positive publicity.

The review board for Apollo 13 had been necessary, boring and sympathetic. There was no grand foul-up, no great mistake. Just a bit of bad luck 240,000 miles from home. The House had tacked on a token hearing, just to clear the air and get their faces on television, but by then, it was a formality. The agency had survived without taking on blame. All things considered, it could have gone far worse, in every possible way.

The interim moratorium had allowed the brass to reevaluate the plan for what was unofficially being thought of as Apollo: Phase II. The engineering-style flights had come and gone, serving their purpose well. NASA had proven it could land on the moon, land with pinpoint accuracy, and land accurately on interesting terrain, and return crews safely (“safely” being a relative term when it came to spaceflight operations).

Still, all that was over now. It was time for the return to flight, and Apollo 14 was a new type of mission, for a new vision of what Apollo would do.

Just as Apollo 8 had served as something of a trail-blazing flight for Apollos 11 through 13; Apollo 14 was now going to accomplish much-needed objectives for Apollos 15 through 20.

Apollo, armed with newfound public attention and support, was becoming supersized. One week ago, Colonel Alfred Worden and his “Mission Specialist” had launched from Cape Kennedy. By outward appearance, the launch was just like any other Saturn V that had come before.


After the TLI burn, the Endurance, a perfectly-named ship if ever there was one, undocked and flipped end-over-end. Worden had docked, not with a LEM, but with a “Mission Module” (not that anyone at NASA really used that term). The module, called Farsight, would never land on the surface, and, in fact, had no propulsion system to speak of.

Farsight, unofficially, represented the very best that the Air Force could offer in terms of an orbital imaging platform. The cameras and sensors housed within the module would allow for much more accuracy and detail than anything previously flown. It had been a nightmare just to get the Air Force to let NASA use them in the first place. The idea of giving such technology to a civilian agency was anathema to most military minds. And then to have the mission staffed by an international astronaut…

Still, right now, NASA had a lot of pull, both politically and with the general public. Orders had been given even before Apollo 13 had launched. The Air Force’s cameras had been brought in under the strictest secrecy and there were rumors that any photos released to the public after the flight would be delayed or degraded so as not to compromise the capabilities of military intelligence satellites.


Wheaton turned his attention back to the interview.

“Commander Worden, is it true that this flight will set a record in terms of total mission time?”

Worden uncanned his answer, “Yes, that’s right. We launched last week and we’ve still got a long way to go. Literally. We’re spending a month in lunar orbit. That’s going to allow us to test out new life support systems and to see how Apollo hardware fares in extended periods. We’ll need to know these things if we want to establish outposts on this new frontier.”

“Why so long in orbit?”

“It takes 28 days for the Moon to orbit the Earth. During the course of those 28 days, the sun passes over every spot on the surface and we get 14 days worth of sunshine to make photographs and take readings. Staying here for a month will allow us to be able to photograph every site several times and from different angles. The images we bring back will be the basis for the most accurate maps of the Moon that we’ve ever had.”

“And I understand your crewmate has a speciality in lunar imaging?”

Worden nodded, which was a little strange in zero gravity, “Farouk is one of NASA’s leading experts in lunar geology. He knows the Moon’s terrain, arguably, as much or more than anyone else alive. He’s here so that we can find the things we don’t even know to look for. Farouk and I are the scouts for the landing missions to come. We’re going to find new features and places that can be explored from the ground.”

“And what is it about your mission that could not be accomplished by unmanned ships?”

Again, Worden knew a softball when it was lobbed to him, “Having men up here allows us to adapt to things that a satellite image can’t reveal. We can see what looks out of place. Respond to a glint on the horizon, or a shadow that’s intriguing. With satellite imagery, we’ll be able to get detailed images, but you can’t always see the subtleties of a landscape. Farouk and I are looking for the things that machines don’t know how to look for. To say nothing of the fact that, even with the best sensors and cameras, a naked human eye can still get a sense of the landscape in a way that no image on a screen or a map ever could convey.”

“Can you tell us more about this special module?”

“Sure. Instead of the LEM, on this trip, we’ve got something new. The module is actually in two parts. The bigger piece, which we call Farsight, has a suite of cameras and sensors recording everything we can see from up here. It’s also got a small alcove with a big window where Farouk or I can float and take observations directly. Honestly, only one of us can really fit in there at a time. It’s more of a closet than a cockpit. But it’s got the best view on the ship. There are a couple of access panels that allow us to do some maintenance on the recording equipment, but hopefully, we won’t be needing them. Now, that’s Farsight. Attached to Farsight, on the other side, is a small communications satellite, which we’ve taken to calling Gossip.”

Worden allowed the interviewer to prompt him, despite the communication lag of a 2 light-second distance.

“Why Gossip?”

Gossip is a relay satellite which will be used on future missions that land on the far side of the moon. Its job will be to relay signals from Earth to the lunar surface and vice versa. Since all it really does it hear things and repeat them, we thought Gossip was a pretty good name.”

“I see. And Gossip will remain in orbit after you leave, yes?”

“That’s right. At the end of our mission here, early next month, we’ll detach Gossip and Farsight before we fire our Service Module Propulsion System, or SPS as we call it. Gossip has a small motor on board that will push it into a high-elliptical orbit to give it a much greater time over the lunar farside.”

Wheaton breathed a sigh of relief that Worden hadn’t referred to it as a Molniya orbit, which was the Russian name for it. The Russians had been using orbits like that for years to give them greater coverage of their own territory.

“And what will happen to Farsight?”

“It will remain here in our current orbit. The onboard power systems will keep sending data back to Earth for a while and it will serve as a secondary platform for relaying signals to and from the Moon.”

That was the optimistic idea. Technically, Farsight would be too low to relay much of anything unless a mission happened to be underneath it at just the right time. Still, technically, it would be capable (at least for a time) and it was better not to mention that it would become humanity’s latest piece of space trash, though around the Moon this time.

There were a few questions to go about particular bits of interest regarding life about Endurance and Wheaton breathed a sigh of relief when the interview concluded. The reporter had not asked about the crew selection process for this flight.

The original flight crew for what had been planned as the final H-mission had Dave Scott as the mission commander, with Worden as his CMP and Jim Irwin flying right seat on the LEM. Then there had been a bit of a row.

A German stamp collector had propositioned Scott and Irwin about smuggling postage stamp covers (whatever that was) aboard the LEM and then selling them off as lunar souvenirs after the crew returned from the Moon. Technically, that was a violation of NASA protocols, (though unofficially, it wasn’t the first time something like that had happened).

The problem came when the NASA brass got wind of it. Scott and Irwin had been quietly reassigned to a later flight, which, it was understood, would never happen. Worden, despite being on the same crew, had been under suspicion but was eventually cleared of any wrongdoing in a quiet, unofficial, internal investigation. The overeager stamp collector had approached Irwin and Scott while they were on a separate surface training assignment and the two astronauts hadn’t yet had a chance to ask Worden, though he would likely have gone along with it.

The whole situation was messy and something less than right. It had seemed unfair to Thomas to punish men for trying to find a way to make some money harmlessly. And being taken off a lunar landing was arguably worse than a death sentence for many astronauts. On the other hand, it could be said that any man who was lucky enough to be assigned a landing should count his blessings and not look for a profitable upside.

At any rate, the H-mission was swapped in favor of this, the first and only I-mission of the program. The geologists were overjoyed at the chance for a complete and comprehensive lunar mapping mission and had gotten one of their own assigned to it, as a bonus.

Farouk El-Baz was a world-class geologist and knew more about the Moon than almost anyone. His assignment on the flight had been a beautiful solution to a public relations quagmire. The first flight of an international astronaut on an American ship, to say nothing of the first non-White man to fly on an American vessel. The stories done on El-Baz’s personal history, his family and his career were all stories that would otherwise have been aimed at the stamp controversy. It was also a quiet signal to the average American that even a non-astronaut like El-Baz could survive and contribute to a real Apollo mission. Surely a few more people had become members of Pan-Am’s “First Moon Flights Club” as a result. Wheaton couldn’t help but chuckle at the thought.

10 March 1971

Apollo 14

MET: T+ 704:18:35

Orbital Inclination: 86°

Callsign: Endurance


Farouk looked over and verified that the transmitter wasn’t on VOX before he spoke.

“You promised me this wouldn’t happen.”

“I know. I know.”

“You said, ‘It’ll be a month of observations and floating. You won’t have to do any crazy astronaut stuff.”

Worden sighed as he finished rigging the suit hoses, “I know.”

“What are we doing now Alfred?”

“Crazy astronaut stuff.”

“Plan well executed, yeah?”

“It’s not like we didn’t know this could happen.”

“All I wanted was a lot of good photographs. I’d be back in my office, going over albedo numbers…”

“Hey, it’s just me doing the crazy astronaut stuff. All I need you to do is stay here in your seat and keep talking to Houston.”

“In a space suit!”

“Yeah… believe me, you don’t want to do this without one.”

“When we get back I’m going to find whatever technician installed this thing and…”

“It happens, buddy. There’s nothing for it. I know what to do and how to do it. Try to relax. Two hours from now, it’ll all be over and done with.”

“You want to rephrase that?”

Worden let out a clipped laugh, “I’ll be back inside, and we’ll break into the chocolate bars. Okay?”

El-Baz sighed as Worden sealed his helmet, “It’s not like I have a choice.”

“True,” Worden switched over to VOX, “Houston, Farouk and I are suited up. We’re ready to begin cabin depressurization. I’ve got my tool kit together and we’re in good shape.”

Bill Anders had the friendly voice of CAPCOM today, “Copy that Al. We’re going to have you begin depressurization after LOS. Do not, repeat, do not egress until we have acquisition over the pole on your next pass. The hatch will not be opened until after we have a good signal.”

“Copy, Houston. Endurance will be squared away as we come around the horn.”

Forty-five minutes later, Alfred Worden emerged from the open hatch of the Endurance over crater Anaxagoras.

Farouk looked out of window 1 with wide eyes as Alfred made his way out of the spacecraft. The Farsight had been fitted with handholds for this very purpose. The idea being that the handholds were low-weight and would be very useful in the event of an EVA.

Gossip’s release mechanism had been considered a problem area. Gossip and Farsight were designed separately, built separately, and only within the last 6 months before launch had their respective engineering teams been able to coordinate their efforts.

Worden surveyed the ship as he climbed towards it. Gossip was more or less a can with an antenna on the sides, a single engine at the rear, and a coating of solar cells on the outside. Its main dish (a smaller version of Endurance’s high-gain antenna, was pointed uselessly back at Endurance for the moment. Once he got it freed from the lattice-truss structure that mated it with Farsight, the antenna would independently acquire a signal from Earth and would get instructions to fire the engine into a high parking orbit.

Worden clipped safety lines to two separate hand holds at the top of Farsight’s cylindrical shell. He then diagnosed the issue at hand.

Gossip’s pyros had fired on time, but one of the four had failed to completely sever its connecting bolt. What was left of the bolt was holding the satellite on, like the victim of a botched guillotine execution with an infernal death grip.

Worden radioed the situation in. The truss was tricky to get at with a wrench and he honestly thought he’d have a better chance of prying the thing loose by just pushing on the base of Gossip and hoping that the strain would tear what was left of the bolt in two. Houston wasn’t wild about the idea and told him to try the wrench anyway.

Worden had studied Aldrin’s work on Gemini XII and knew how to anchor himself properly for using a tool in zero gravity. He checked his safety lines again and stuck a booted foot into a third handhold.

After a few failed attempts to get the wrench into place, he finally got a proper grip and turned the bolt. In his excitement at freeing the wretched piece of metal, his foot slipped and Worden became the victim of Newton’s laws, his motions transferred from the freed metal into himself, spinning him slowly off of Farsight’s grips.

“Whoa, oaah!” said the Air Force colonel as he slowly floated away from his spacecraft, much to the panicked eyes of his crewmate.

For a long moment, as the universe spun before his eyes, Worden felt a fear like nothing he’d experienced as a fighter pilot. What he could not know was that Farouk felt much the same fear, lacking in any way the confidence to fly Endurance home from the Moon on his own.

When the safety lines tugged taut and he came into a slow rebound, relief rushed over both men, the likes of which they would never again experience.

Worden got a grip on one of the lines and slowly reeled himself in. The flight surgeon was kind enough not to comment on the heart rate of either man in mission debriefings later that month.

An hour later, true to his word, Worden and El-Baz celebrated the successful firing of Gossip’s rocket engine with two Hershey bars and a view of the Earth rising over the lunar north pole.

 
Last edited:
Sorry for taking so long with this post. I've had a case of writer's block the size of Tycho crater. With any luck, I'll get back to a semi-regular schedule in the near future.
 
Sorry for taking so long with this post. I've had a case of writer's block the size of Tycho crater. With any luck, I'll get back to a semi-regular schedule in the near future.

It's fine. Great update as usual, and I'm just loving how you are going with this.
 

Archibald

Banned
Pretty cool indeed. One of the worst injustices in Apollo related to Gene Shoemaker: the father of Apollo geology, he couldn't become an astronaut because he found he had Addison disease (same as JFK)
 
XIV: Blue and Grey
Blue and Grey

1IykdDp.jpg

Image Credit: Nixonshead

31 July 1971

Apollo 15

MET: T+ 325:14:38

18°34′26″S 155°22′51″W

Callsign: Enterprise


“Hornet Recovery one, this is the Enterprise. Hornet Recovery one, this is the Enterprise. Do you read? Over.”

Jack Crichton was barely able to get the words out. He was actively suppressing seasickness; and the harness straps were cutting into his shoulders pretty bad.

This really had to stop happening.

Crichton had been the pilot of Gemini VIII with Dave Scott. Gemini VIII had ended with an emergency undocking and a splashdown hours away from the recovery vehicles. They had sat in Pacific swells for more than 4 hours, waiting for rescue, fighting off nausea from the fumes of the heat shield and leftover RCS fuel.

If there was ever an experience that could put an astronaut off of spaceflight, that had to be close. But, likely as not, there was no rough ride that could deter an aviator from wanting to go to space.

Now, 5 years later, he found himself, once again, floating in a quiet corner of the Pacific Ocean, waiting for a rescue by surface ships that were steaming to reach his bobbing spacecraft.

Despite this relatively ignominious end, the flight itself had gone beautifully.

Crichton and Bill Anders had piloted the Orion down to a soft, pinpoint landing near a wrinkle ridge in the Sea of Serenity. On their first EVA, they had deployed an ALSEP, planted the 4th American flag on the lunar surface, and had presented a relatively enjoyable hour of television, live from Serenity base. Later that afternoon, back inside Orion, they’d had a conversation with John Chancellor and Frank McGee on the NBC Nightly News.

The next morning, Jack Crichton, in full view of a live television audience and an extremely nervous flight director back in Houston, attached a climbing rig to his A7L spacesuit.

Since the announcement of the moon landing goal 10 years ago, every geologist on the planet had been excited about the chance to study lunar surface samples. Now, after only 3 landing missions, the geologists weren’t just satisfied with regular old regolith anymore. No, the rockhounds wanted samples from deeper down.

The landing point for Orion was a ridge on Serenity base. This geological feature was indicative of magma movement in the past. Volcanic activity had shifted the basalt crust in this area and the ridge that resulted now offered a chance to get at the secrets of the interior workings of the Moon.

After securing the harness and checking (for the 4th time) the anchoring of the rope line on which his life would depend, Jack Crichton began a slow descent down the ridge. Truthfully, he found the experience less exciting than it would have appeared to an outside observer. While the ridge was tall, the slope of it wasn’t overly imposing. He guessed that, should the worst happen, he could figure out a way to scramble up the incline and return to the safety of Orion. Worst case scenario, he planned to walk along the ridge until he found a shallower place to climb up.

He had a shoulder mount for the television camera and the geology boys were seeing what he was seeing. They would have him pause every 10 feet or so and he could hear the whirr of the camera zooming in and out. He did his best to report anything unusual that he saw. For the most part, the surface looked standard-issue, but he generally understood that by descending the ridge he was seeing layering in the surface that revealed things about the Moon’s past.

As he reached the maria floor, he disengaged the rope harness and left it on the ground. About 20 yards away was the equipment bag and hand-held drill that he and Bill had tossed down near the end of yesterday’s EVA. The drill would allow him to get several samples in the ridge’s face near the surface (theoretically the oldest and most interesting part of the ridge) and the plan was to get as many samples as the equipment bag could hold before Anders hauled it up on a second rope that he would toss down when Crichton was finished with his observations.

Jack looked up and gave a wave to Anders as he stood on the crest of the ridge 30 or 40 yards above him. Bill’s suit was silhouetted against the blackness of open space and Crichton took a moment to snap a photo of that. The grey surface, the white suit and the black sky. The word he couldn’t think of at the moment was “iconic.”

One thing that he could not see clearly was Orion. This was a problem with an interesting solution. The EVA suit radios relied on repeaters in the LEM to communicate with mission control. Since Jack could no longer see Orion, his radio signal was blocked by the ridge.

During his descent, Anders had toggled a switch on his radio that provided a repeating loop for Jack’s transmissions. The signal from Houston to Crichton and vice versa was relayed through Bill Anders’s antenna. As long as Anders maintained visual contact with Crichton, then the loop would be secure and both astronauts would be able to talk to Houston.

For the next 2 hours, Anders and Crichton walked for half a mile along the ridge Crichton below, Anders at the top. They made observations, took dozens of photographs and gathered samples. As the mission clock demanded, they wrapped up the walk on-time and Anders tossed down a new line to haul up Crichton’s rocks. He relayed the ease of the task to Houston and the commentators reminded everyone watching about the 1/6th lunar gravity.

After listening to Anders secure the equipment bag, Crichton realized that he was no longer hearing calls from the ground.

“Bill, I’m not hearing Houston. Can you check your relay?”

“The switch is good here. I’m still reading them. I think it’s the repeater itself.”

“Ah, dang. I had a feeling it’d crap out on us sooner or later.”

“Glad it’s later. Must have been from all that movement in hauling up the bag. Houston, this is Anders. Jack is no longer reading you. Do you have his transmissions, over?”

Scott Keller replied from a quarter million miles away, “Negative, Bill. We did not reacquire Jack after you moved to stow the bag. We lost the TV as well.”

“Roger that, Houston. I’ve still got a strong signal from you both. We’ll do a manual relay until we get him back up the hill and I’ll let you know what he’s saying. We’re ready for his ascent here if you’re go down there.”

A slow, gingerly climb brought Jack Crichton back in view of Orion and, as he crested the ridge, Houston regained his signal just as expected. An hour later, they concluded their surface activities. They'd even had time to toss a football back and forth a couple of times, much to the delight of the folks back home.


The next morning, Stu Roosa monitored the ascent of Orion from the left hand seat on the CSM Enterprise. Enterprise was Jack Crichton’s second choice for a callsign. He had preferred Sirius, Orion’s faithful dog, but was overruled as the worry was that Sirius could be confused for “serious” in the event of a crisis situation. The public relations guys had been thrilled with the new name though. Star Trek was nearing the end of its 5 year run on NBC and the crews of both Enterprises were to have a splendid photo-op together after they returned to Houston.

That was hard to think about at the moment though. Crichton looked out the hatch window at the Pacific Ocean and sky next to it. Not above it, next to it. The image would have turned his stomach, if it hadn’t already been turned.

Twenty-four hours before entry interface, a typhoon had begun to develop just east of their splashdown zone. By the time meteorology had gotten a total sense of the weather system, it was too late to reroute the surface ships before the storm would be on them. Enterprise would have no trouble avoiding the storm, however. A small impulse from the SPS, only a few inches per second, was more than enough to change their trajectory and move their landing site hundreds of miles away from the danger area. Houston had ordered Enterprise to adjust course accordingly, but with the caveat that the crew would have to wait on the surface for the recovery craft for several hours.

Scott Carpenter had landed about 250 miles off course back in 1962 and the Navy had spent a few panicky hours searching until they found him floating towards Puerto Rico. In 1965, Crichton himself had waited with Dave Scott for rescue after their Gemini VIII had developed a problematic thruster, necessitating an emergency landing. But in both cases, the spacecraft had the decency to land upright. Several Apollos had come back in Stable II configuration. Noses down into the water, the curved heat shield pointed at the sky. It was a simple procedure to inflate airbags near the top of the cone that would right the ship. The problem came when one of the three bags failed to inflate and, rather than a gentle flip onto her back, instead, the Enterprise listed to one side and rocked gently on one side, with the crew held into their seats at an awkward angle, still mostly head-down.

It had been about an hour since splashdown. Holding back his nausea, Jack Crichton tried the radio again. “Hornet Recovery One, this is the Enterprise. Do you read?”

The radio crackled to life and all three astronauts felt a rush of relief, “Roger, Enterprise. This is Hornet Recovery One. We have visual contact and are 5 minutes out. What’s your status?”

Crichton looked over at his crewmates and nodded before keying the microphone, “Hornet Recovery, we are okay, but Enterprise has failed to reach stable one or two over. Repeat, we are listing awkwardly at this time. Please be aware of that as you approach, over.”

There was a moment’s pause as the helicopter’s crew conferred amongst themselves. Their acknowledgment came a moment later.

Crichton brought out his copy of the recovery checklist and was about to start it when Bill Anders tapped him on the shoulder.

“Jack,” Anders said, and pointed out of the hatch window.

“Oh, you gotta be kidding me…” Crichton looked out of the window and saw a grey fin that, while aerodynamic, had no business near his spacecraft. The sharks of the South Pacific had a bad habit of finding lost mariners. The crew of Apollo 15 was no exception. Fortunately, a spacecraft that could keep out the hard vacuum of the universe would have no problem separating a shark from a tasty trio of astronauts.

“Rescue One, this is the Enterprise. You’re not gonna believe this...”
 
Last edited:
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Nixonshead for his attention to detail and his stunning artwork.

And I'd also like to thank my wife, who, while I was workshopping this latest piece and asked her what would be a good problem for astronauts on a lunar mission, replied, "Sharks!"
 
Again, another nice update with this so far BowOfOrion. There's something just really fantastic with this timeline that you are doing.
 
Apologies for the double-post, but in rereading it, is the Jack Crichton cameo a nod to that of Farscape if I might inquire?

Also I'm weirdly wondering about Clifton C. Williams, Michael J. Adams, and Robert Lawrence ITTL if they are still alive and are on any of the potential crews for any of the future Apollo lunar landings...
 
Apologies for the double-post, but in rereading it, is the Jack Crichton cameo a nod to that of Farscape if I might inquire?

Congrats Usili! I was wondering how long it would take for someone to find that reference. I'll say that it's the easier of the 2 sci-fi references that I've thrown in so far (aside from the obvious ones). I'll be very impressed if anyone else manages to find the other one. I'm not expecting it to be found at all.

As far as CC Williams and the others. I honestly haven't considered their fates, but I may need to go back and take another look. Thanks for the idea. If anyone else has other suggestions like that, please give a comment or 2 here. I'm always looking for untraveled roads.
 
My subscription above allowed me to come back and read this timeline in it's entirety. Wow! Very, very good. The detail is impressive and the writing style is easy to read and carries an air of authenticity. Please keep up the great work.

To this day I shake my head at the lost potential of Apollo. We spent billions developing an interplanetary transport system and then after a few missions threw it away. Contrary to popular belief, the Apollo/Saturn system was very adaptable and so much more could have been done with it. E of Pi and his collaborators showed that in the excellent Eyes Turned Skyward, and I am looking forward to this different take on Apollo. Personally, I think if we should have gone the way of the proposed AES/ALSS programs. This would have provided us with a robust lunar program, and when combined with a AAP/Skylab style earth orbit station we could have easily done all we wanted to do in the 1970's for pity's sake, instead of trying to recreate it all 40 years later.

I have one personal request. Please butterfly back into existence Elliot See and Charlie Bassett. See in particular has been handed a bad rap by historians and deserves better. True he made a mistake on his final day, but several of the other astronauts made mistakes too (i.e. Gene Cernan and the helicopter incident) and weren't pilloried by historians. See was a good aviator and an excellent engineer and no less than Neil Armstrong himself thought highly of him. Charlie Bassett was considered to be one of the stronger rookie astronauts and if he had lived would have most likely gotten a shot at a moon landing.

Thanks again!
 
Top