No Panic of 1907 or Federal Reserve Act

Say the Panic of 1907 never happens and the passing of the Federal Reserve Act is delayed for a decade or two. Is this enough to prevent/butterfly away the Great Depression of the 1930s or will a similar economic downturn occur during the 1910s or 20s?
 
Panics

The main problems that caused the 1929 crash- rampant stock speculation,
defaults by Germany on loans due to hyperinflation, foreign markets for American goods drying up weren't run or influenced by the Fed.
Even thinking the Fed has anything vaguely to do with that presupposes monetarist theory (manipulating interest rates) which didn't really arrive until the 1950's courtesy of Milton Friedman.
What boned the Federal Reserve system from the Harding Administration on
was lax oversight and enforcement of reserve requirements for banks.
 

mowque

Banned
The main problems that caused the 1929 crash- rampant stock speculation,
defaults by Germany on loans due to hyperinflation, foreign markets for American goods drying up weren't run or influenced by the Fed.
Even thinking the Fed has anything vaguely to do with that presupposes monetarist theory (manipulating interest rates) which didn't really arrive until the 1950's courtesy of Milton Friedman.
What boned the Federal Reserve system from the Harding Administration on
was lax oversight and enforcement of reserve requirements for banks.

All of this plus protectionism.
 
While we always list bad investment practice as the primary cause of the Great Depression, there is another major factor, one connected to a simpler case of supply and demand. The crash hit America last, and part of the reason was that railroads were still growing and finally saturated the populated parts of the country in the late twenties. When expansion suddenly slowed down, shock waves hit industry, starting with steel.
 
Top