No operation Barbarossa does Germany still try to kill the Jews and Slavs

Say no operation Barbarossa and World war 2 ends in with an armistice or a peace treaty

Would Germany still try to kill the Jews and Slavs in its borders
 
... um, yes. If anything, Generalplan Ost in Poland is going to be put on an accelerated timetable in order to make room for the German farmer-soldiers who are supposed to be feeding the Reich and the much higher concentration of military force/attention in the significantly smaller area under their control.
 

Deleted member 1487

Say no operation Barbarossa and World war 2 ends in with an armistice or a peace treaty

Would Germany still try to kill the Jews and Slavs in its borders
Look at what happened in Poland from 1939-41 pre-Barbarossa:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einsatzgruppen#Invasion_of_Poland
Initially numbering 2,700 men (and ultimately 4,250 in Poland),[13][16] the Einsatzgruppen's mission was to kill members of the Polish leadership most clearly identified with Polish national identity: the intelligentsia, members of the clergy, teachers, and members of the nobility.[10][17] As stated by Hitler: "... there must be no Polish leaders; where Polish leaders exist they must be killed, however harsh that sounds".[18] SS-BrigadeführerLothar Beutel, commander of Einsatzgruppe IV, later testified that Heydrich gave the order for these killings at a series of meetings in mid-August.[19] The Sonderfahndungsbuch Polen — lists of people to be killed — had been drawn up by the SS as early as May 1939, using dossiers collected by the SD from 1936 forward.[10][20] The Einsatzgruppen performed these murders with the support of the Volksdeutscher Selbstschutz, a paramilitary group consisting of ethnic Germans living in Poland.[21] Members of the SS, the Wehrmacht, and the Ordnungspolizeialso shot civilians during the Polish campaign.[22] Approximately 65,000 civilians were killed by the end of 1939. In addition to leaders of Polish society, they killed Jews, prostitutes, Romani people, and the mentally ill. Psychiatric patients in Poland were initially killed by shooting, but by spring 1941 gas vans were widely used.[23][24]

The final task of the Einsatzgruppen in Poland was to round up the remaining Jews and concentrate them in ghettos within major cities with good railway connections. The intention was to eventually remove all the Jews from Poland, but at this point their final destination had not yet been determined.[30][31] Together, the Wehrmacht and the Einsatzgruppen also drove tens of thousands of Jews eastward into Soviet-controlled territory.[22]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_ghettos
The conditions in the ghettos were generally brutal. In Warsaw, the Jews, comprising 30% of the city overall population, were forced to live in 2.4% of the city's area, a density of 7.2 people per room.[7] In the ghetto of Odrzywół, 700 people lived in an area previously occupied by five families, between 12 and 30 to each room. The Jews were not allowed out of the ghetto, so they had to rely on smuggling and the starvation rations supplied by the Nazis: in Warsaw this was 253 calories (1,060 kJ) per Jew, compared to 669 calories (2,800 kJ) per Pole and 2,613 calories (10,940 kJ) per German. With the crowded living conditions, starvation diets, and insufficient sanitation (coupled with lack of medical supplies), epidemics of infectious disease became a major feature of ghetto life.[10] In the Łódź Ghetto some 43,800 people died of 'natural' causes, 76,000 in the Warsaw Ghetto before July 1942.[11]
 
The invasion of the Soviet Union is generally credited with radicalizing the Nazi regime to the point of going through with the Holocaust. If Barbarossa hadn't happened for whatever reason, the anti-Semitic policies of the Nazi regime would undoubtedly still have been nasty. The specifics, however, are difficult to discuss without knowing how the Final Solution was avoided.
 
6-Protokoll-20-1-42-6.jpg


Above: The Wannsee Protocol's estimate of Jewish populations in Europe. Subtracting the USSR, the UK, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia and Spain gives a total of 5.6 million.

I agree with the above: ghettoization was well underway by June 1941, and people were already dying in the tens of thousands, but the Einsatzgruppen and mass organized deliberate murder started only after Barbarossa. Given Hitler's January 1939 "prophecy" -- that a world war would lead to the annihilation of the Jewish 'race' in Europe (die Vernichtung der Judischen Rasse in Europa) -- I think the Final Solution always was, at some level, one of Hitler's chief war aims. It will happen without Barbarossa, although it would take on a different form. Giving a good answer to the WI requires, IMO, a date for the armistice, so I'll presume the end of the war occurs between 22 June and 7 December of 1941. It looks something like this: the UK retains all territory, including the Channel Islands. France, less Alsace-Lorraine, is nominally independent with a reduced military under a provisional government headed up by Pétain and Laval, with (free) elections scheduled for 1946, 5 years on. All of Poland that was once part of Germany is restored to the Altreich, Czechia remains annexed, but the Generalgouvernement will remain occupied territory until 1951. All of Central and Eastern Europe is under either Nazi or Soviet control, and relations are such that no satellite state dares to interfere with the Final Solution. The Wehrmacht would withdraw from occupied territories in 6-12 months from the date of armistice -- unless, of course, the Hitler-aligned leaders of a country requested the Wehrmacht to stay for "security reasons." The Waffen-SS would remain, making up virtually the entire military in the EBGs (ehemals besetzen Gebieten, formerly occupied territories).

I suppose that whole paragraph is OT, but I do think it's necessary to describe what the armistice would be like in order to comment on how the Final Solution would unfold.

Now, OTL Barbarossa was the event that "radicalized" the Nazi regime to mass deliberate murder rather than death by overwork, malnutrition and disease. Also IOTL, when the war began to go badly the Nazis stepped up the pace, and even when it was almost over they organized death marches. ITTL, the trigger would be different, but it would happen. IMO, the approaching end of the war is what causes these Nazis to begin "frenzied killing" of the sort OTL saw with the Einsatzgruppen and the Hungarian Jews. So it is the same trigger -- the end of the war -- but ITTL the Nazis are the victors.

In Poland, the Nazis could murder the Jewish population at their own pace, but Auschwitz and the Operation Reinhard camps would still be built. (Most Nazi victory TLs, for whatever reason, butterfly away the assassination of Heydrich, so perhaps Operation Gustloff.) The Nazis would have all the time they needed to kill the Polish Jews, so it's even possible they would operate only a single death camp, probably Auschwitz-Birkenau. If the OP intended the Germans to be Notzis, which I don't think was the intent, then mass sterilization and death by ghetto would be the way the Final Solution was conducted.

By 1944, as IOTL, the Jewish population of Poland would be some 10% of the 1939 level. By 1946, without fanfare, the Nazi leadership would be able to say Poland was Judenfrei. Only a handful (thousands, if not hundreds) of Partisaner and Prominenten would remain alive and, as even the elite would be sterilized, the Jewish birth rate would reach zero. So, in a way, the Holocaust in Poland would be more complete than it was OTL, although the Soviet-occupied territory would not be affected, unless of course Stalin decides to pursue a Final Solution of his own, which is not entirely impossible.

The frenzied killing I mentioned would be seen in France and the Low Countries, primarily. Germany, having agreed to withdraw from those countries within 6-12 months, would set up Einsatzgruppen just as we saw in the East. Their modus operandi would be a little different -- once the Einsatzgruppen arrived at a village or town, they would lead the people to a remote spot and do the killing there. In larger cities, and as a supplementary method in the rural areas, mass deportations would occur. The destination would be the ghettos of Poland, then to the death camps when those were ready. Depending entirely on deportation is a possibility as well.

ITTL, would Sonderaktion 1005, the exhumation and burning of corpses and general destruction of evidence of the Holocaust, have happened? IOTL it began May 1942, a time in which Nazi victory was plausible (to them). I suspect ITTL it would be limited to France and the Low Countries.
 
Top