Rarename91
Banned
If there was no holocaust or anti jewish law and instead hitler gather support from the jews how would this effect the nazi party performance in election and how would it effect the war as well?
Not-zis.If there was no holocaust or anti jewish law and instead hitler gather support from the jews how would this effect the nazi party performance in election and how would it effect the war as well?
If there was no holocaust or anti jewish law and instead hitler gather support from the jews how would this effect the nazi party performance in election and how would it effect the war as well?
Well a lot of people think antisemitism can't be removed from Nazism, I disagree, we could easily have a Nazism movement who have all it's Lebensraum and make Germany great again attitude, but wasn't ideological antisemitic. The result would likely have been that German/Yiddish speaking Jews outside Germany would be seen as a kind of Volkdeutsche. Economic it mean that Germany have fewer resources to plundered at home before the war, but I doubt it really made a big difference. What really mane a difference are that there will be large number of Jews in Eastern Europe which can be recruited into the German army. USSR will likely deport it Jewish population to Siberia together with its German minorities, while if Germany still lose, the Jews will join the other Volkdeutsche in fleeing the Red Army.
Nazism requires the hate of a foreign and domestic untermensch to rally the masses against. If not Judeo-Bolsheviks then who?
Well a lot of people think antisemitism can't be removed from Nazism, I disagree, we could easily have a Nazism movement who have all it's Lebensraum and make Germany great again attitude, but wasn't ideological antisemitic.
There cannot be a Nazi movement with the critical mass without antisemitism. That was what kept the party together long enough for Adolf to grab power.
For the record, the Nazis' anti-Semitism does appear to have given the Nazis some electoral gains:Well a lot of people think antisemitism can't be removed from Nazism, I disagree, we could easily have a Nazism movement who have all it's Lebensraum and make Germany great again attitude, but wasn't ideological antisemitic. The result would likely have been that German/Yiddish speaking Jews outside Germany would be seen as a kind of Volkdeutsche. Economic it mean that Germany have fewer resources to plundered at home before the war, but I doubt it really made a big difference. What really mane a difference are that there will be large number of Jews in Eastern Europe which can be recruited into the German army. USSR will likely deport it Jewish population to Siberia together with its German minorities, while if Germany still lose, the Jews will join the other Volkdeutsche in fleeing the Red Army.
I think because of the hindsight of the Nazi actions (Krystalnacht and the Holocaust) we overestimate the importance of Antisemitism earlier for the party. The Jews was a useful scapegoat, but the Nazi could have found other scapegoats instead for the stab in the back myth.
As for his to make Hitler less antisemitic, let him serve on the East Front instead. I think if the main pro-German civilian he could interact with had been the local Jewish populations some of his Vienna antisemitism could have disappeared, and he would have ended up seeing Ashkenazi as a kind semi-Germans.
I think because of the hindsight of the Nazi actions (Krystalnacht and the Holocaust) we overestimate the importance of Antisemitism earlier for the party. The Jews was a useful scapegoat, but the Nazi could have found other scapegoats instead for the stab in the back myth.