alternatehistory.com

What if there was no population exchange between Greece and Turkey after the Greek invasion of Anatolia was repelled?

How might this have come about in the first place? Perhaps the League of Nations had a little more backbone, and stepped in to avoid a catastrophic exchange of entire populations. Or Greece and Turkey might have postponed their goals of creating "ein volk" nations in order to rebuild after the Great War?

What would life in both countries be like in the long run? I'm predicting the following:

* There would be some very ugly pogroms and civil violence in the interwar and WW2 years, especially in Turkey. Already in OTL we had Turkish minorities shipped off to work camps during the Second World War, anti-Jewish riots provoked by extreme nationalists, an Istanbul "Kristallnacht" in 1955, and so on. Also, the Greco-Turkish War between 1919 and 1922 had caused massacres of both Turkish and Greek citizens, by armies and irregulars of both sides. I'm sure the grievances would be harder to forgive with "them" still living with "us." Ultimately, such conflicts might even lead to a Balkanization of western Anatolia, a-la Cyprus.

* The same as above would go for Greece, albeit in a smaller scale. Salonica would still be a (paranoid, high-tension) cosmopole, along with Smyrna, and the various cities on the Black sea coast. One interesting development would be that of Turkish Sabbateans in Salonica. Doubtless they would prosper in the interwar years. But what would the German invasion spell for them? Not something good, in my opinion.

* Could the inter-community strife in Turkey lead to a civil war, or an insurrection? Would this event tip Turkey into the Axis side?

* Things would get more "interesting" after WW2. The remaining Greeks in Anatolia would be one more pawn to play in the great game between the Allies and Russia. In OTL, persecution of the Kurds gave rise to numerous extreme leftists movements that were in practice pro-Kurdish insurrections. I'm certain that there would be some left-wing Greek banditry as well. The period leading up to the 1980 coup would be a lot more bloody.

* After the fall of communism, it's all a big question mark. Would both countries be "better off" and more comfortable with their history once the dust had settled? With a large Greek population, perhaps there would be more pressure for Turkey's E.U. membership. Or more problems, if they weren't treated properly.
Top