No First Amendment As We Know It!

What if there were further restrictions on religious liberties and the freedom of speech, How does it change the US and the world?
 
It depends on how you accomplish this. In OTL, you had the establishment clause because the various state establishmented religions wanted assurances that the feds wouldn't interfere with them. Likewise freedom of speech was already a cause celebre. Look at the ratification debates, you'll see that both brooked large.

So if your POD is to get rid of the state religious establishments early, that's a big social and ideological change that's going to have other effects. If its to get rid of the Printer's Case, that will have other consequences too, though maybe not as many. If you have the Federalists renege on their promise to pass a Bill of Rights, well, that means a very early end to the Federalists and a Bill of Rights anyway.
 
Last edited:
Without the freedom of religion part you will not be able to attract the colonies with their various denominations, many which from below had the establish churches removed. Though some found it for the best as they then got more donations and people going on their own free will. As for the freedom of speech it would have been unheard of to not have it after the Revolution. No way the Constitution would have been ratified without at least putting them on the Bill of Rights.
 
Top