Nazi Population Policies

Thrawn

Banned
Thrawn, you've confused the extremely rare exceptions who survived only because Nazi Germany was defeated with a change in Nazi policy. None of the 'essential workers' would have survived the war being prolonged another 6-12 months, let alone a Nazi victory.

In addition, had economic needs ever been given priority something on the order of 10-15 million civilians(Jews, Poles, Ukrainians, Russians...) would have survived the war by providing all manner of useful labor.


The comparison between Hitler's final solution and the Russians, Chinese or Mongols exists only in your own mind. Presenting the 300+ year slaughter of the Native Americans as a single accident is morally obscene.

1. The death of the indigenous people of America done by the Europeans was done by some 90% through diseases. And lastet perhaps 50 years.

The slaughter of the North American Indians done by the Americans, that was a campaign that took some 300 years and was done intentionally.

2. Of those 10 to 15 Million many millions were killed by Stalin and the NKVD also since it didnt happen we do not known how many people would have died if no one of the Russians/Poles/Jews would have been used as slave workers.
 
Thrawn, I'm not confusing Stalin's death toll with Hitler's, least of all the Poles and Jews who were outside the Soviet border.

We certainly do know what the fate of those 'essential' workers would have been given an extension of the war as we know the fate of so many of the other such 'essential' workers.
 
Nonsence - never heard that one before. [about Michel Van remark about open-air museum ]

In his table talks Hitler says this and im quoting the original:


Ein großer Teil von ihnen ist germanischen Ursprungs und kann eingedeutscht werden![1]

Wenn man daher heute alles Gefährliche in der Tschechei rücksichtslos beseitige und die Tschechen sonst gut behandle, so sei das die richtige und für das Großdeutsche Reich selbstverständliche Taktik den Tschechen gegenüber.[2]

Bei fester Führung des Protektorats müsse es daher gelingen, in 20 Jahren die tschechische Sprache wieder auf die Bedeutung eines Dialekts zurückzudrängen.[3]

[1] Hitler, Monologe im Führerhauptquartier S. 244

[2] Picker, Hitlers Tischgespräche S. 452

[3] Ebenda S. 459



Translation (correct I hope):

First one:

A large part of them are of German origin and can be germanized.

Second:

If anything harmufull is destroyed in the Czech lands and all other Czechs treated well, that would be the correct thing to do for the benefit of the Third Reich and the correct thing to treat the Czechs well.

Third:

By strict leaderspic it should be possible to reduce the Czech language into a dialect within 20 years.

the Translation is correct

the story to make from change the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia to open-air Museum
is in allot of book and Webpage about The Third Reich
the oldes version of story tell to transform City of Prag to open-air museum by Top Nazi
or is this story a Urban legend ?
 
1. The death of the indigenous people of America done by the Europeans was done by some 90% through diseases. And lastet perhaps 50 years.

The slaughter of the North American Indians done by the Americans, that was a campaign that took some 300 years and was done intentionally.

2. Of those 10 to 15 Million many millions were killed by Stalin and the NKVD also since it didnt happen we do not known how many people would have died if no one of the Russians/Poles/Jews would have been used as slave workers.

Actually it took somewhere around 100-150 years. And there were multiple pandemics that usually wiped out 30 percent of the population at once. But sorry to nitpick.
 
I am sorry but you are wrong. The Nazis were quite flexible with their classification. You know that actually JEWS served in the Wehrmacht? Even a few blacks and muslims.

Even an irrational dictatorship/ideology has to surrender before economic logic.

They served in the Wehrmacht for one of a couple very special reasons. Some had high powered protectors like say Goering and NONE of them did so openly. I believe he said something to the effect, "I say who is jewish."

You are seriously trying to point at a few INDIVIDUALS compared to MILLIONS OF DEAD?!?

The stated policy was kill them all, the policy carried out certainly liked like the stated policy. Would the Germans get them all? Of course not but they would get ALOT OF THEM. Especially under war time conditions.

The idea that the Nazis would let economic logic get in the way of slaughtering their racial enemies is naive. If that was the case why did any of the Jews die at all? Seriously they were the most productive on a person basis of the German economy before the Nazi's came to power.

Michael
 
Thrawn, you've confused the extremely rare exceptions who survived only because Nazi Germany was defeated with a change in Nazi policy. None of the 'essential workers' would have survived the war being prolonged another 6-12 months, let alone a Nazi victory.

In addition, had economic needs ever been given priority something on the order of 10-15 million civilians(Jews, Poles, Ukrainians, Russians...) would have survived the war by providing all manner of useful labor.



The comparison between Hitler's final solution and the Russians, Chinese or Mongols exists only in your own mind. Presenting the 300+ year slaughter of the Native Americans as a single accident is morally obscene.


The idea that Logic alone would stop the Nazi's is really all there is to be said.

Michael
 
What left of the jewish population will probably try to get in Italy, till the surrender the italian zone of occupation were a reasonable safe zone for the jews and except for type like Farinacci the great majority of the italian people thinked of the racial law as a WTF?
In the long term the thing can create a diplomatic problem for Mussolini, so he probably try to get rid of the jews sending them on libya or other place but if this fail he surely send them back to their doom.
 
Top