Nazi Architecture madness

Status
Not open for further replies.
031.jpg


Giant Lenin sees your Nazi architecture, before destroying it with his laser eyes.

That looks like the tallest building in Warsaw, and Moscow, minus the giant Lenin though.
 

Deleted member 43582

Seriosuly as a Berliner I have to say that I don't get the criticism that gets thrown at the Holocaust memorial.
We are talking here about a GENOCIDE memorial not a WAR memorial. There is a big difference. Even if the war has included war crimes of the most atrocious kind there is still a diffrence between a war and a genocide. The memeorial is incredibly effective in showing the horror, the utter senselessness of the holocaust. If you walk among those THINGS and visit the underground museum (or if you REALLy want to mess with you emotions do it in reverse) I dare you to not be emotionally crushed. I really hits home and achieves its goal. I think it was one of the best additions to my city in teh past decade.
 

Deleted member 43582

I honestly find the designs aesthetically pleasing.
On paper yes they do look ridicoulously awesome.

In practice it depends on execution. Tempelhof for example would look quite good if it werent so extremely big. The German Finance Ministry in contrast looks rather nice, mostly because it is surrounded by not nazi building therefore taking the whole over top aspect away. The fact that it has a really nice garden probably helps.
 
031.jpg


Giant Lenin sees your Nazi architecture, before destroying it with his laser eyes.

If he can see it, remember the weather patterns in Moscow mean that on most days the bottom of the clouds would have been somewhere around the bottom of Lenin's jacket
 
Makes no sense to put that giant ugly statue up there. But hey, personality cults gonna personality cult.

Here are some other entries into the competition:

8506637076_319530a97a_z.jpg


bznEHmX.jpg


soviets.jpg
 
Makes no sense to put that giant ugly statue up there. But hey, personality cults gonna personality cult.

Here are some other entries into the competition:

I like Le Corbusier entree
6766831873_06330e6b46_z.jpg


The Irony about giant ugly lenin statue (to 75 meter high) do bad weather in Moscow, the Soviets would see most time of year only Lenin feet, the rest is obscure by the clouds...
 
Buildings do not exist in a void like works of art. They respond to a demand by society, and are usually built in an existing environment. A building like this, that was built because a dictator wanted to enlarge his penis, and that damaged its environment beyond repair, is horrible architecture, regardless of what you think about its esthetics -that I find abhorrent too, but that's up to each one's taste.

I have to agree with you on this.

You cannot make a memorial to the Holocaust and have it be nice. That would be insulting. Having it be ugly and senseless is exactly to the point.

640px-Jerusalem%2C_view_at_Yad_Vashem_museum.JPG


The Holocaust museum in Israel begs to differ.

It's just a plain building with pictures and relics in it. Nothing appealing or impressive, but "nice" enough to make people willing to visit it.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Dr. Strangelove.

Jewish Museum in Berlin, by Daniel Libeskind
Vtacia_perspektiva_Jewish_Museum.jpg


Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe, in Berlin. by Peter Eisenman and Buro Happold.
HolocaustMahnmalLuft.jpg
 
Something from the latest GeoEpoche a German magazine. They used 3D modeling for some really nice pictures. To bad I found only two in the net:

germania_eisenbahn_39824718.jpg
 
Sorry. Feasibility aside, I like grandiose totalitarian architecture. Plans and designs in Stalin's Russia were just as outlandish, and there is even a hint of totalitarianism in public works architecture built in the USA during the 1930's. Really, is what the Nazis proposed worse than the hideous glass and steel phallic monuments to money going up in Dubai, Shanghai, Malaysia, and throughout the West?

My real concern, if I was a German living in Germania in 1950, would be the fact that the plan for Germania and other German cities would irrepreprably harm the historic setting of these places. On the other hand, the possibility exists that Allied bombing before the great victory might have already destroyed much of the historic city centre, so there wouldn't be all that much to salvage. Nonetheless, I'd lobby the Nazis to build entirely new regional centres and a monumental capital to embody the ideals of the New Germany and honor the ancient German cities of the Reich by restoring them to their prewar beauty.
 
Something from the latest GeoEpoche a German magazine. They used 3D modeling for some really nice pictures. To bad I found only two in the net:
First: A train that large is impractical.
Second: I give the steam locomotive 15 miles tops before something bad happens. I don't see side tanks or a tender.
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top