Napoleonic stalemate

Very intersting scenarios. I wonder if anyone will be able to conjure up a map of some similar scenario, with Europe carved up between French and Russians?
 
@Thande: I think that America will not go to war with Britain in this ATL. In OTL the impressment and trade barriers were some the major causes of the war and with a peace between Britain and France in 1810, presumably American merchants will once again be able to trade with the Continent and the British navy will no longer quite so many sailors. Plus I doub the administration at that time would really want to pick a fight with the full might of the British Empire.

However, we are still left with the northwest territories. here we have to conflicting goals between the British/Native Indians and the Americans/Southeast tribes, The British and their Northwestern Indian allies wanted to create some kind of Indian state in the Northwest, for the British as a buffer between America and Canada, and the Indians for independence. The Americans obviously wanted complete control of the Northwest territory and the Southeastern tribes were old enemies of the tribes of the Ohio valley.

So here, we have a tinderbox. The British supplied guns to the tribes of the Northwestern territory, thereby angering the American settlers, and fueling the feeling among the northwestern Indians that they could in fact stop the Americans. Whether or not the British get involved, the Indians of the area will get in a war with America, probably led by Tecumseh and Tenskwatawa. The question comes down to whether the British will get involved with them, or simply let the Americans and the Tecumseh's Confederacy duke it out. Unfortunately I don't really know enough about early eighteenth century British politics to really know.
 
Very intersting scenarios. I wonder if anyone will be able to conjure up a map of some similar scenario, with Europe carved up between French and Russians?

There's one burried in the Map Threads somewhere.

I have a personal copy, so I'll see if I can fish it out...

EDIT: there are actually two of them. I think they're both by EUIO.

I happen to have USCised versions I made myself, just because :)o)...

Here's number one:

Anglo-French Cold War #1.PNG
 
Last edited:
The thing that strikes me about the Napoleonic Wars is Napoleon's refusal to compromise combined with Britain's refusal to compromise. Naopleon's megalomania is, I think, the easier problem. Lets say he falls off his horse in 1810 and breaks a leg, giving him a greater awareness of his own mortality. He turns his policy towards seeking stability, wanting to leave his successors a strong Empire. In a situation where he doesn't invade Russia but instead falls back on consolidating his Empire in Western Europe (i.e. France and the satellite states) can Napoleon achieve stability?

The most important factor is, I think Britain- the basic tenet of British foreign policy was to ensure that Western Europe was never under the dominance of any single power. With Napoleon consolidating in Western Europe and avoiding costly adventures, can Britain be convinced to cease it's economic campaign against France? IOTL Britain heavily subsidised Napoleons Continental enemies and so long as it was prepared to do so, Napoleon had to keep fighting them.

Without a Russian campaign in 1812 can a more cautious Napoelon either (i) descend in force on Iberia and drive the British into the sea or (ii) be willing to draw the line at the Pyrenees leaving Britain, Spain and Portugal as effectively maritime colonial powers and leaving France as the master of mainland Europe?
1807-Napoleon dies leaving his brother Louis as successor. Spain undergoes turmoil and eventually Ferdinand rises to power, albeit under the eye of the French.
1809-Russia and Austria declare war on France. Austria is crushed by French armies and Russia advances up to Elbe.
1810-Russian armies are bloodied in Western Poland and East Prussia. Both sides come to a truce at Vilnius. Also of note a failed landing on the Sheldte estuary by British troops.
1811-The Treaty of Amsterdam ends the Napoleonic Wars stipulating the withdrawal of French troops from Prussia and Austria as well as the recognition of the Rhine borders by all parties and the Confederation of the Rhine. It also provides that the French open all Continental ports to British goods and vice-versa.
 
Top