Planet of Hats
Donor
"The law is clear, and all I desire is consistency with the law," a long-suffering Tariq ibn Mujahid repeated for what must have been the thousandth time that day. "Riba is haram and we cannot call ourselves Muslims if we allow Muslims to carry it out."
"No one is disputing that, Hajib," came the equally long-suffering reply from the gallery. "But you realize that there are dhimmi who live by different laws."
"Yes, of course-"
The discussions with the Majlis always took this tone - a headbutting between the world through his eyes and the world through theirs. Privately, Tariq wished he could hurl the lot of them out a window, and their barely-Islamic innovations along with them.
Doing that will not help anything, he reminded himself - again, not for the first time. Certainly the Majlis stood on nothing more than a foundation of tradition, legitimate only because his grandfather had assembled them and his uncle had relied on them for advice. In theory, Tariq should have been able to send them all home. But it was not lost on him that he himself stood on a flimsy foundation. These people, for all their degeneracy and impiety, were leaders of their communities - communities Tariq himself claimed to govern with little save a de facto claim based on the fact that a few people who liked him had paid a man to strangle and drown his cousin.
The people of Isbili had already begun to grumble about the circumstances of his installation. Sending the Majlis home would only spread the grumbling. Holding on to the seat of the Hajib would require him to dance this little aggravating dance with them, at least for awhile longer.
"This is not only a matter of laws," pointed out the Wali of Gharnatah, hands folded on the table before him. "It is a matter of travel. Many of our people now are merchants who must sail long distances. They depend on the services of those dhimmi who hold and lend money. It is unappetizing, to be sure, but surely there are ways for these transactions to be conducted amongst Muslims without riba - and in any event, shall we truly expect the People of the Book to behave as Muslims? Their conduct is permissible."
"I would add that the moment we try to prohibit those activities, our people sail south to Labu and Tekrur and we lose a lot of good merchants." That was the Wali of the Kaledats, a thorn in Tariq's side as much as ever.
Tariq scowled daggers into the cluster of old men, practically feeling his heavy beard bristle with frustration. "Then help me, damn your eyes," he all but hissed. "You are wise men, are you not? Help to solve this problem. Find a way for us to be Muslims without all your degenerate friends--"
An uproar immediately burst through the room. "--all your degenerate friends," Tariq shouted over the protests, "from pulling up their robes and stomping off in a huff at being asked to obey the law as written!"
"That is a total slander!" shouted someone near the back
"Excuse me a moment, everyone," a louder voice broke over the crowd - that of Abu Qays Abd ar-Rahman ibn Hassan al-Barshiluni, the respected Wali of the northeast. As the rabble died down, the heavy-set man waved a hand towards Tariq. "We have been over this territory. Many times, in fact. Shouting at each other will not achieve anything. May I suggest we leave these issues to the scholars for now and focus on what we can accomplish, Hajib. And gentlemen as well."
Tariq's scowl eased, and he looked down into his lap for a moment. Sometime in the last couple of minutes, one of the cats had climbed up there - the black one with the white paws that looked like stockings. He'd been so engrossed in yelling at the Majlis that he had barely noticed.
"We can come back to this issue," the Hajib finally decided, albeit grudgingly. "Fine. Very well." With a huff, he shooed the cat away with a sharp flick of two fingers. He had no time for feline follies right now.
"Then we move on," he determined. "I'm considering what we need to improve our network of roads...."
Excerpt: The People's Faith: A History of Modern Islam - Abu Najib ibn Abd al-Aziz al-Mufaji, AD 2007
The brewing conflict between Hajib Tariq and the Majlis would have made for a fairly anemic conventional civil war. An exchange of gunfire was hardly likely in the early going. Rather, the battle between the Usulid Hajib and the majority Ghimarid Majlis would be decided through policy, politics and often-brutal court maneuvering.
At the heart of the Hajib-Majlis conflict was a simple fact: Neither institution was truly legitimate. On the one hand, the Majlis was a simple advisory body with authority derived almost entirely from Al-Nasr's political stunting on behalf of his son Abd ar-Rahim, who maintained the council's relevance primarily for image purposes. In theory, Tariq could have dismissed the council at any time - but his own position was precarious, coming to power as he did on the back of a suspicious death and at the suffrance of minority reactionaries at court, in the face of a population that did not share his rigorist views on faith and behaviour.
Beyond the circumstances of his ascent, however, Tariq had to contend with the nature of the Hajib's office as a mere representative of the Caliph. As much as the Umayyads had long been sidelined - indeed, then-Caliph Al-Musta'sim was in his late seventies and stricken with dementia, stubbornly refusing to die yet barely able to weigh in - the Hajib role nevertheless relied on an age-old legal fiction of Caliphal consent and delegation. In Abd ar-Rahim's time, a younger Al-Musta'sim had praised the Majlis as the voice of the ummah. To dismiss them could have been seen as a drastic overreach by a Hajib at odds with both the Caliph and society.
Despite his desire to return society to its traditional Islamic roots, Tariq was obliged to maintain the fictions on which his office stood, both to bolster his legitimacy and prevent court factions from removing him the same way he had removed his cousin. The Majlis remained in session as he pushed into his term.
A key early achievement for the precariously-perched Hajib was his campaign against the Sheresh wine industry, an underground sector of the economy that had long supplied high-quality wine to Andalusians and Berbers of means. On paper, vineyard owners in the area were well-known for their bounty in "grapeseed oil" and "raisins," while actually producing alcohol under the table - and raking in immense profits. Those who operated openly were largely Christians supposedly limited to selling to other Christians, but it was common for Muslims to buy it. Tariq, a well-known teetotaller, viewed the open secret of the wine production as a flagrant violation of the sunnah, and he ordered several well-known vineyard owners arrested and tried.
The move provoked rapid backlash in the form of the Sheresh Wine Riots, in which large numbers of protesters rioted in the city and surrounded city guardsmen sent to arrest prominent vineyard owners. Fighting quickly broke out between protesters and traditionalists. Some accounts suggest citizens broke into a vineyard and smashed dozens of barrels of wine, draining the contents into the river. Regardless of the exact details, the Wine Riots prompted a coarsening of attitudes towards Tariq among many in the public, and as word spread of the actions, merchants in other cities raised protests into what they claimed was a draconian edict by the Hajib. Family of some of the arrested vineyard owners similarly protested, alleging that many of those accused weren't actually winemakers, but actual producers of grapeseed oil.
Stung by the public backlash, Tariq seems to have tried to strike a less confrontational tone in his efforts to try and assert a more rigorist form of Islamic law. Among his edicts, he re-affirmed the ban on utilizing printing presses to reproduce the Quran, insisting that they only be produced by the hands of classically-trained scribes. He similarly moved to hire additional tax collectors to police the dhimmi, increasing the overall tax revenue of the Asmarid Empire to an extent but evoking intense frustration among non-Muslim communities, particularly in the Christian north.
By far the area where Tariq had the most influence was abroad, where he sought to restore the Asmarids' perceived Islamicity by renewing the jihad. His areas of focus were primarily overseas in the Gharb al-Aqsa, especially in Quwaniyyah. While the north of the peninsula had been effectively brought under Asmarid control, much of the inland south remained effectively independent despite Asmarid claims to control the entire isthmus. In particular the K'iche Maya of the Kingdom of Q'umarkaj, or Jakawitz, remained outside Asmarid domination despite ghastly losses to endemic diseases and ongoing kishafa raids.
Tariq sought to rebuild his legitimacy and strengthen the faith by directing the jihad into the jungles of the Isthmus, at the expense of the K'iche. From 1536, he arranged for a series of seasonal campaigns out of northern Quwaniyyah aimed at extending Asmarid control to the southern coast. These campaigns were largely conducted by volunteers armed with blackpowder weapons and shipped to the Gharb al-Aqsa annually.
By and large, the southern Mayan campaign was expectedly successful in bringing the key population centres in the area under Asmarid domination. As with many campaigns in this period, the Asmarids utilized relatively small forces - rarely more than 2,000 men to an army. While some elements among the Maya had begun to adopt captured horses and even the occasional crossbow or blackpowder weapon, a massive technological disparity still existed. Mayan traps and ambush tactics inflicted their share of casualties, but in direct battle the defenders inevitably suffered ghastly attrition to numerically inferior Asmarid armies equipped with modern weapons and armour.
Accordingly, the war was short, brief and brutal. In 1538 a force of about 1,200 men arrived in the K'iche capital of Jakawitz and handily defeated a much larger army of warriors to seize the city. The last Mayan king of the city was put in chains and taken aboard a ship at Ekab to be shipped back to Isbili, but died along the way. The conquerors otherwise beheaded a large number of priests and military leaders before installing an Islamic government and parcelling out choice land to veterans of the conflict.
In theory, the conflict should have strengthened Tariq's legitimacy in the eyes of the traditionalists. In reality he mostly succeeded in exporting hundreds of supporters among the commons to plots of land overseas. Most of those who volunteered for campaigns in the jungles were those invested in the idea of the external jihad, and with new lands well in hand following the war, their economic desires were more or less sated, at the cost of removing them from the body of locals on hand to support the Usulids in the ongoing social unrest at home.
That unrest would flare up again in 1539 in the form of events around the person of Sanjula bint Hamdin al-Anjylyni.
Sanjula, a daughter of a powerful merchant of the Banu Angelino, was the most well-known representative in her time of a wave of Berber and Andalusi women known for flouting many older traditions of dress and behaviour. She is described as refusing to wear the veil in public, is noted to have been unmarried at age 21, and she has left behind a few letters to friends and relatives that show exceptional fluency in both Andalusi and classical Arabic as well as some minor skill in poetry. A number of commentators from the period have written on her, largely because of the scandal that emerged around her during Tariq's reign.
In the spring of 1539, the merchant Abu Yasin ibn Gharsiya al-Zammuri accused Sanjula of attempting to seduce another man while being involved with him at the same time. The matter was brought to the qadi, who deemed that Sanjula had committed zina. As an unmarried woman, she was deemed to not be muhsan and sentenced to a public lashing - a sentence objected to fervently by both Sanjula and her father, Hamdin, who insisted Sanjula was never involved with Al-Zammuri at all. The two further noted that the crime had no witnesses beyond the testimony of Al-Zammuri, whose family's business interests competed with the Banu Angelino's. They asserted that the accusation constituted qadhf, a false accusation of zina, and stood on flimsy grounds.
Hamdin, a member of the Majlis, immediately appealed to the Hajib to intervene. Tariq refused and ordered that Sanjula be flogged in public for fornication.
The punishment was carried out before a crowd split between horrified Ghimarids and jeering Usulids. Contemporary chroniclers report a defiant Sanjula refusing to cry out while the lashes were administered despite being in obvious pain. They also report several members of the extended Asmarid family in the crowd, among them Tariq's cousin Uthman ibn Abd ar-Rahim, one of the late ex-Hajib's youngest sons, who was in the company of the Banu Angelino delegation.
The flogging remained fixed in the public consciousness when it later emerged that Al-Zammuri had fabricated the allegations as part of a plot to intimidate and discredit Hamdin - not only had Sanjula never been with Al-Zammuri, but the other man in his accusation never actually existed. Further, the qadi who tried the case was the brother of a leading Quranic scribe active in the Usulid movement. The Banu Angelino accused Tariq of flagrantly skewing the law against them, and prominent Ghimarids in Isbili began to speak out more vocally against what they perceived as a streak of vindictive rigorism, with some going so far as to denounce Tariq as a Kharijite.
Outcry remained confined to the realm of political speech and backrooms, sparing Tariq the potential for violence - save towards Al-Zammuri, who he was obligated to order tried. The merchant was eventually found guilty and lashed, which seemed to quell the most immediate frustration.
Sanjula, however, would not be out of Tariq's life for long. By 1540, she eventually found someone she did want to be with: Tariq's cousin, Uthman, who was beginning to emerge as a prominent Ghimarid within the Asmarid family.
"No one is disputing that, Hajib," came the equally long-suffering reply from the gallery. "But you realize that there are dhimmi who live by different laws."
"Yes, of course-"
The discussions with the Majlis always took this tone - a headbutting between the world through his eyes and the world through theirs. Privately, Tariq wished he could hurl the lot of them out a window, and their barely-Islamic innovations along with them.
Doing that will not help anything, he reminded himself - again, not for the first time. Certainly the Majlis stood on nothing more than a foundation of tradition, legitimate only because his grandfather had assembled them and his uncle had relied on them for advice. In theory, Tariq should have been able to send them all home. But it was not lost on him that he himself stood on a flimsy foundation. These people, for all their degeneracy and impiety, were leaders of their communities - communities Tariq himself claimed to govern with little save a de facto claim based on the fact that a few people who liked him had paid a man to strangle and drown his cousin.
The people of Isbili had already begun to grumble about the circumstances of his installation. Sending the Majlis home would only spread the grumbling. Holding on to the seat of the Hajib would require him to dance this little aggravating dance with them, at least for awhile longer.
"This is not only a matter of laws," pointed out the Wali of Gharnatah, hands folded on the table before him. "It is a matter of travel. Many of our people now are merchants who must sail long distances. They depend on the services of those dhimmi who hold and lend money. It is unappetizing, to be sure, but surely there are ways for these transactions to be conducted amongst Muslims without riba - and in any event, shall we truly expect the People of the Book to behave as Muslims? Their conduct is permissible."
"I would add that the moment we try to prohibit those activities, our people sail south to Labu and Tekrur and we lose a lot of good merchants." That was the Wali of the Kaledats, a thorn in Tariq's side as much as ever.
Tariq scowled daggers into the cluster of old men, practically feeling his heavy beard bristle with frustration. "Then help me, damn your eyes," he all but hissed. "You are wise men, are you not? Help to solve this problem. Find a way for us to be Muslims without all your degenerate friends--"
An uproar immediately burst through the room. "--all your degenerate friends," Tariq shouted over the protests, "from pulling up their robes and stomping off in a huff at being asked to obey the law as written!"
"That is a total slander!" shouted someone near the back
"Excuse me a moment, everyone," a louder voice broke over the crowd - that of Abu Qays Abd ar-Rahman ibn Hassan al-Barshiluni, the respected Wali of the northeast. As the rabble died down, the heavy-set man waved a hand towards Tariq. "We have been over this territory. Many times, in fact. Shouting at each other will not achieve anything. May I suggest we leave these issues to the scholars for now and focus on what we can accomplish, Hajib. And gentlemen as well."
Tariq's scowl eased, and he looked down into his lap for a moment. Sometime in the last couple of minutes, one of the cats had climbed up there - the black one with the white paws that looked like stockings. He'd been so engrossed in yelling at the Majlis that he had barely noticed.
"We can come back to this issue," the Hajib finally decided, albeit grudgingly. "Fine. Very well." With a huff, he shooed the cat away with a sharp flick of two fingers. He had no time for feline follies right now.
"Then we move on," he determined. "I'm considering what we need to improve our network of roads...."
~
Excerpt: The People's Faith: A History of Modern Islam - Abu Najib ibn Abd al-Aziz al-Mufaji, AD 2007
2
TARIQ, UTHMAN AND SANJULA
TARIQ, UTHMAN AND SANJULA
The brewing conflict between Hajib Tariq and the Majlis would have made for a fairly anemic conventional civil war. An exchange of gunfire was hardly likely in the early going. Rather, the battle between the Usulid Hajib and the majority Ghimarid Majlis would be decided through policy, politics and often-brutal court maneuvering.
At the heart of the Hajib-Majlis conflict was a simple fact: Neither institution was truly legitimate. On the one hand, the Majlis was a simple advisory body with authority derived almost entirely from Al-Nasr's political stunting on behalf of his son Abd ar-Rahim, who maintained the council's relevance primarily for image purposes. In theory, Tariq could have dismissed the council at any time - but his own position was precarious, coming to power as he did on the back of a suspicious death and at the suffrance of minority reactionaries at court, in the face of a population that did not share his rigorist views on faith and behaviour.
Beyond the circumstances of his ascent, however, Tariq had to contend with the nature of the Hajib's office as a mere representative of the Caliph. As much as the Umayyads had long been sidelined - indeed, then-Caliph Al-Musta'sim was in his late seventies and stricken with dementia, stubbornly refusing to die yet barely able to weigh in - the Hajib role nevertheless relied on an age-old legal fiction of Caliphal consent and delegation. In Abd ar-Rahim's time, a younger Al-Musta'sim had praised the Majlis as the voice of the ummah. To dismiss them could have been seen as a drastic overreach by a Hajib at odds with both the Caliph and society.
Despite his desire to return society to its traditional Islamic roots, Tariq was obliged to maintain the fictions on which his office stood, both to bolster his legitimacy and prevent court factions from removing him the same way he had removed his cousin. The Majlis remained in session as he pushed into his term.
A key early achievement for the precariously-perched Hajib was his campaign against the Sheresh wine industry, an underground sector of the economy that had long supplied high-quality wine to Andalusians and Berbers of means. On paper, vineyard owners in the area were well-known for their bounty in "grapeseed oil" and "raisins," while actually producing alcohol under the table - and raking in immense profits. Those who operated openly were largely Christians supposedly limited to selling to other Christians, but it was common for Muslims to buy it. Tariq, a well-known teetotaller, viewed the open secret of the wine production as a flagrant violation of the sunnah, and he ordered several well-known vineyard owners arrested and tried.
The move provoked rapid backlash in the form of the Sheresh Wine Riots, in which large numbers of protesters rioted in the city and surrounded city guardsmen sent to arrest prominent vineyard owners. Fighting quickly broke out between protesters and traditionalists. Some accounts suggest citizens broke into a vineyard and smashed dozens of barrels of wine, draining the contents into the river. Regardless of the exact details, the Wine Riots prompted a coarsening of attitudes towards Tariq among many in the public, and as word spread of the actions, merchants in other cities raised protests into what they claimed was a draconian edict by the Hajib. Family of some of the arrested vineyard owners similarly protested, alleging that many of those accused weren't actually winemakers, but actual producers of grapeseed oil.
Stung by the public backlash, Tariq seems to have tried to strike a less confrontational tone in his efforts to try and assert a more rigorist form of Islamic law. Among his edicts, he re-affirmed the ban on utilizing printing presses to reproduce the Quran, insisting that they only be produced by the hands of classically-trained scribes. He similarly moved to hire additional tax collectors to police the dhimmi, increasing the overall tax revenue of the Asmarid Empire to an extent but evoking intense frustration among non-Muslim communities, particularly in the Christian north.
By far the area where Tariq had the most influence was abroad, where he sought to restore the Asmarids' perceived Islamicity by renewing the jihad. His areas of focus were primarily overseas in the Gharb al-Aqsa, especially in Quwaniyyah. While the north of the peninsula had been effectively brought under Asmarid control, much of the inland south remained effectively independent despite Asmarid claims to control the entire isthmus. In particular the K'iche Maya of the Kingdom of Q'umarkaj, or Jakawitz, remained outside Asmarid domination despite ghastly losses to endemic diseases and ongoing kishafa raids.
Tariq sought to rebuild his legitimacy and strengthen the faith by directing the jihad into the jungles of the Isthmus, at the expense of the K'iche. From 1536, he arranged for a series of seasonal campaigns out of northern Quwaniyyah aimed at extending Asmarid control to the southern coast. These campaigns were largely conducted by volunteers armed with blackpowder weapons and shipped to the Gharb al-Aqsa annually.
By and large, the southern Mayan campaign was expectedly successful in bringing the key population centres in the area under Asmarid domination. As with many campaigns in this period, the Asmarids utilized relatively small forces - rarely more than 2,000 men to an army. While some elements among the Maya had begun to adopt captured horses and even the occasional crossbow or blackpowder weapon, a massive technological disparity still existed. Mayan traps and ambush tactics inflicted their share of casualties, but in direct battle the defenders inevitably suffered ghastly attrition to numerically inferior Asmarid armies equipped with modern weapons and armour.
Accordingly, the war was short, brief and brutal. In 1538 a force of about 1,200 men arrived in the K'iche capital of Jakawitz and handily defeated a much larger army of warriors to seize the city. The last Mayan king of the city was put in chains and taken aboard a ship at Ekab to be shipped back to Isbili, but died along the way. The conquerors otherwise beheaded a large number of priests and military leaders before installing an Islamic government and parcelling out choice land to veterans of the conflict.
In theory, the conflict should have strengthened Tariq's legitimacy in the eyes of the traditionalists. In reality he mostly succeeded in exporting hundreds of supporters among the commons to plots of land overseas. Most of those who volunteered for campaigns in the jungles were those invested in the idea of the external jihad, and with new lands well in hand following the war, their economic desires were more or less sated, at the cost of removing them from the body of locals on hand to support the Usulids in the ongoing social unrest at home.
That unrest would flare up again in 1539 in the form of events around the person of Sanjula bint Hamdin al-Anjylyni.
Sanjula, a daughter of a powerful merchant of the Banu Angelino, was the most well-known representative in her time of a wave of Berber and Andalusi women known for flouting many older traditions of dress and behaviour. She is described as refusing to wear the veil in public, is noted to have been unmarried at age 21, and she has left behind a few letters to friends and relatives that show exceptional fluency in both Andalusi and classical Arabic as well as some minor skill in poetry. A number of commentators from the period have written on her, largely because of the scandal that emerged around her during Tariq's reign.
In the spring of 1539, the merchant Abu Yasin ibn Gharsiya al-Zammuri accused Sanjula of attempting to seduce another man while being involved with him at the same time. The matter was brought to the qadi, who deemed that Sanjula had committed zina. As an unmarried woman, she was deemed to not be muhsan and sentenced to a public lashing - a sentence objected to fervently by both Sanjula and her father, Hamdin, who insisted Sanjula was never involved with Al-Zammuri at all. The two further noted that the crime had no witnesses beyond the testimony of Al-Zammuri, whose family's business interests competed with the Banu Angelino's. They asserted that the accusation constituted qadhf, a false accusation of zina, and stood on flimsy grounds.
Hamdin, a member of the Majlis, immediately appealed to the Hajib to intervene. Tariq refused and ordered that Sanjula be flogged in public for fornication.
The punishment was carried out before a crowd split between horrified Ghimarids and jeering Usulids. Contemporary chroniclers report a defiant Sanjula refusing to cry out while the lashes were administered despite being in obvious pain. They also report several members of the extended Asmarid family in the crowd, among them Tariq's cousin Uthman ibn Abd ar-Rahim, one of the late ex-Hajib's youngest sons, who was in the company of the Banu Angelino delegation.
The flogging remained fixed in the public consciousness when it later emerged that Al-Zammuri had fabricated the allegations as part of a plot to intimidate and discredit Hamdin - not only had Sanjula never been with Al-Zammuri, but the other man in his accusation never actually existed. Further, the qadi who tried the case was the brother of a leading Quranic scribe active in the Usulid movement. The Banu Angelino accused Tariq of flagrantly skewing the law against them, and prominent Ghimarids in Isbili began to speak out more vocally against what they perceived as a streak of vindictive rigorism, with some going so far as to denounce Tariq as a Kharijite.
Outcry remained confined to the realm of political speech and backrooms, sparing Tariq the potential for violence - save towards Al-Zammuri, who he was obligated to order tried. The merchant was eventually found guilty and lashed, which seemed to quell the most immediate frustration.
Sanjula, however, would not be out of Tariq's life for long. By 1540, she eventually found someone she did want to be with: Tariq's cousin, Uthman, who was beginning to emerge as a prominent Ghimarid within the Asmarid family.
SUMMARY:
1536: The Sheresh Wine Riots break out when Hajib Tariq attempts to crack down on the southern Andalusian wine industry.
1538: Asmarid forces conquer the Kingdom of Q'umarkaj.
1539: Public outcry flares up when a trailblazing Andalusi woman, Sanjula bint Hamdin, is publicly flogged for accusations of fornication. It later emerges that the accusations were falsified to try and undermine the Banu Angelino, but the trial was put through as a public show of vindictiveness against a known Ghimarid woman.
Last edited: