alternatehistory.com

What if Matthew Ridgway was appointed the commander of the airborne forces for Operation Market Garden instead of Fredrick Browning? OTL Ridgway arrived in Holland after the operation began but only observed.

According to Wikipedia the British hinted that they wanted a British commander for MARKET. What if Eisenhower decides that if Monty wants the operation to go he has to go with Ridgway whose XVIII Airborne Corps was providing two American divisions: the 82nd and 101st. He was also more experienced. (Holland would be his 4th airborne operation).

Ridgway had just turned over command of the 82nd to Jim Gavin so they could work together. Maxwell Taylor of the 101st had come out of the 82nd also and the two divisions had just come through Normandy together. Later on in Korea Ridgway wasn't scared of MacArthur so I think he could have stood up to Monty.

So if Ridgway was in command would he have changed anything with the plan? More important is if Ridgway was on the ground from day one on September 17 could he have taken better control of the situation? I am not saying that he could have made Market Garden succeed by himself but could he have done more to save the 1st Airborne Division at Arnhem? Also would Ridgway be relieved of his command like Browning or would it help his post war career more?

BONUS: No offense to Dirk Bogarde but maybe Ben Gazzara gets a role in A Bridge Too Far as General Ridgway.
Top