Sorry, I have to respond to this. I have no wish to get in on this argument but I want to clarify something. I don't recall XFE making any criticism of any genres here. You don't have to agree with XFE's argument but there is no reason to believe his criticism is done for any ulterior motive.
An understandable claim, and I think were all wanting to move on from this. To be clear however, we are both arguing from the crowd, while the actors themselves have more or less exited stage right as it were.
My statement of his distaste may be incorrect, however I am proposing that his intent comes from his own biases to the contrary, which only occurs based on my
own perception of his posts, combined with a lack of refutation on XFE's part, by which I mean
More than one person has perceived his negative view of Pipcards maps in the same light I have, and XFE has deigned not to provide a disagreement.
In other words I will continue to have the belief, based on my own judgement of XFE's statement, Until they directly state that my belief is incorrect. When that occurs I will apologize and alter my judgement accordingly.
I do however apologize for being a tad too Hamfisted, and reductive in my description of the situation, as it looks to have left a negative impact on your experiences here.
And with that I am now removing myself entirely from the matter.