Castithians seem a lot like the "Nordic" aliens of flying saucer mythos. If liberata are nitrogen-breathers, how do they coexist with oxygen-breathing irathients and sensoths on the same planet? (I mean, if it's an oxygen-nitrogen atmosphere with each taking their bit, don't see why they'd need atmospheric planetforming here on earth).
I really have no idea how the mechanics of their biology works. I'm *assuming* that they live in a fairly similar atmosphere to Earth, because otherwise the near-human Votans (not the gulanee) wouldn't be able to survive in Defiance, and vice versa. Official canon is that Arkfall turned Earth into a mix of Daribo, Irath, and Earth, but I don't know how exactly it works, and since I'm more interested in the geopolitical aspect of it, I'm more willing to ignore/handwave biological details like that. Could be nitrogen is more involved in liberata breathing than with the others? That's something from the game, anyway, I think. I never played it.
So the Liberata are space-Jews?
Yeah, pretty much. That's canon, though. I find a bit silly.
Similarities to certain OTL events are
entirely coincidental.
There were already similarities with canon, I just took them to their logical conclusion.
So this is all show canon? (Venus has potential? really?)
I don't think you need an FTL ship at all: a bigger and better version of our 2017 planet search methods probably could do the trick. (With the larger Jovians, we've detected planets out to 13,000 light years).
Sort of. The Kaziri was stranded in canon (big part of the first 2 seasons, IIRC), and the Votans didn't know that Earth was inhabited. I needed a reason why they didn't know Earth was inhabited, and ansibles seemed to do the trick. That, and how the Kaziri got there thousands of years before the rest of the Arkfleet. The canon omecs had FTL, and there had to be
something leftover from the Votan-omec war, so voila.
The Votans had Earth on the shortlist of planets they could detect, but they weren't positively sure Earth was easily xenoformable, and they didn't want to risk hundreds of millions of lives on the chance, and they didn't want to ruin their chances of Votan survival by going 'well, it
might be habitable'.
Didn't most Gulanee stay because they thought they could survive the crisis?
Most did, yes. Some didn't.
Not sure most democracies have the power to do this. A massive security system like the US, sure, but would the government of the Netherlands or Switzerland or Iceland have the same capability? As long as only a few high-powered observatories can detect them, the news could be contained, but once small-scale installations can do so...
The EMC did everything it could to discredit this information, or to nationalize telescopes where they could, or to shutter telescopes not under their control. This provided great fodder for conspiracists and those who are suspicious of governments in general, but the EMC actually managed, despite all odds, to keep the Votan fleet an equivalent to chemtrails or frog-gayifiers until the early 2010s.
So what's Rayetsuism exactly?
A monotheistic religion similar to Abrahamism. Mostly followed by castithans. Rayetsuism is another word for Shirivanawo, which English speakers find annoying to pronounce.
That sounds...wrong.
I
think that's canon. I could just be imagining it.
Why use them on civilians when you have imprisoned maybe possibly terrorists to test them on?
They didn't have enough Votan prisoners of war to achieve meaningful results, and when you have a leadership that largely sees Votan lives as less than human lives, and a preponderance of irathient citizens...
Sort of, yeah.
Did the Votans have a way to neutralize atomic weapons, or just very good antimissile tech?
Both, mostly the latter.
I imagine you're making the show a bit more realistic here.
I love Defiance, but it has its problems with realism.
Now is that from New York city or New York State? NY city seems likely to have been pretty hard hit by funky climate effects, not to mention being an obvious military target during the Pale War.
It was, on both counts. Columbia is trying to revitalize it for bragging rights, 'we're powerful enough to restore pre-war life!', that sort of thing.
Northern Mexico seems rather depopulated: was it a major combat front between the US/world alliance and the Votans?
Yes.
No out of control terraforming efforts in Votanis territory? No local xenoforming engines under Ark control when Arkfall happened?
There are plenty, but for my own sanity, the majority of the xenoforming devices were pointed at human-held territory, as a dead man's switch to be used in case the humans managed to destroy the Arks. When an act of sabotage/horrific accident destroyed the Arks in orbit, well...
I really didn't want to draw the whole world fucked up by Arkfall, so most of the changes in the world are on the interior.
Aquitaine? That wee little country in SW France?
Yes. It holds a good portion of the pre-Arkfall French military, and is more populated than you would think.
I'm a touch confused here: did the ice thaw out? If not, what are the human slaves eating?
Nutrient paste. Designed to be easily created in all environments. Usually flavorless, but can grow in almost any temperatures with just biomass of some sort and sunlight. There are no shortages of corpses in France, and still plenty of sunlight.
The ice is being maintained by cryogenic engines run amok.
Hard to see what's going on in the map: perhaps a closeup map (or two?
)
Is that area in SW France and NW Italy a Votan state?
Probably a pretty good idea, actually. I might do a Q-Bam of the area. After the Worldwar/Defiance crossover, of course.
That's the territory held by the Rhone ark-brain. Technically a Votan (AI), so I put it down.
That would seem to be a guarantee for a failed reconstruction and permanent impoverishment: the UK is not bountifully supplied with raw materials, and is going to be rather dependent on trade if it intends to grow its economy past 19th century standards. Or does Votan tech to some extent make up for that?
Yes, on both counts. There's very much a stiff upper lip mentality, and most people are sort of forced to pretend that their quality of life hasn't changed that much, or else they'll face ostracization/imprisonment depending on how loud they are about it. By and large, there's still air conditioning and the like, but fuels are very, very strictly rationed, and there's barely ever publicly-owned cars on the road. Votan tech makes it better than it would have been, and the UK wasn't hit too hard by the Pale Wars, but I wouldn't want to live there.
Might want a more distinctive color for Romania, make it stand out more from the Lodz block.
I'll fix that should I ever do a sequel. Color schemes aren't my best point.
I'd imagine there would be at least jeep-usuable (in dry weather) roads between the two: do the Russian wilds have a Mutant Monster or Warlord problem messing with communications?
Yes. It's not as bad as in the Russian Wastes or in the Storm Divide, but Karyazhmo and Omsk have a lot of problems with raiders, mutated wildlife, and poor infrastructural conditions.
I'm surprised the Votans didn't take out the Aswan dam - a Genocide Too Far? (I mean, it _looks_ like genocide: due to most of the population being along the Nile, conquering regimes have usually managed to maintain control of Egypt throughout most of its history: there's nowhere for rebels to run to. The facts that the Votans don't occupy the area and that there are no organized states large enough to see implies that there is, in fact, nobody to see.)
There are communities there, they just haven't yet gotten beyond three-or-four villages level, and aren't tied at the hip to any major power, so they aren't on the map. Egypt gave the Votans a hell of a fight, and as a reward, it got to descend into post-apocalyptic anarchy.
What goes on in Northern Nigeria?
An Islamist authoritarian state desperately hoping Sulos has forgotten they existed. Think something along the lines of OTL Afghanistan, with the Taliban types largely replaced with more banal raiders.
I imagine the surviving Jews, Israeli or otherwise, form a vocal part of the anti-Votan lobby in those areas.Speak of your second Holocausts...
Definitely. Most focus their anger on the Collective, rather than Votans themselves. There was actually this really interesting character in Defiance, an irathient Jew raised by human parents. Cai didn't get enough screen time.
Hmm: Iran was a _fairly_ unified country back when there were no railroads or roads worth a damn. If they want to rejoin, I'd think that those solidly Iranian two states south of the Caspian would be at worst "loosely incorporated provinces" rather than separate states at this point, unless those common borders we see on the map aren't really there.
It's complicated. Yazd could enforce power within those borders if it needed to, and those borders are internationally recognized, but their actual degree of control over those areas is spottier than you'd think. They'd like to reunify, but they don't have the infrastructure yet to do so.
I'm not entirely sold on that state's borders...I think I'll take a look-see as to what it looks like with OTL borders overlaid.
That's fair. The borders are meant to be chaotic, in that they're the result of shifting borders from the largest war in history, where Afghanistan was largely used as a staging ground/resource bank anyone could withdraw from.
Needs a little rewriting to make it clearer that the _military_ led a coup, not the Muslims, I think.
Good idea. I'll edit that.
The Lhasa Earth Republic should extend a bit further east, I think: Lhasa, which is north of Bhutan, is at best
right around the eastern tip of the state as shown.
Whoops. Thought Lhasa was further east. I'll fix that should I ever redo the map, but the LER might not exist in its current form in ten years, so it won't matter for the sequel.
Could you clarify a little as to what goes on in the darker red and red striped areas respectively?
General anarchic rebellion against any form of government.
Do they have nukes or something?
A few, but they haven't used them against fellow human states. They're just good at taking advantage of infrastructural and geographical realities, as well as Chongqing's split focus.
I'd imagine it probably benefited from it's relative insignificance: no military threat to the Votans, well down their "to do" list. And surrounded by Votan-soaks.
Definitely.
A formidable effort. Bravo!
Thank you very, very much.