The issue here is the way you expressed your views is incendiary and not welcoming. We should welcome newcomers while encouraging them to work harder. My problem isn't that you said "fuck," it's calling his map completely shite in the quote. This is not a good way to get newcomers to listen to advice. And you're right: it is exactly what everyone else said, which deflates your argument that relying on a random member's response is unrepresentative of your own views. I think when it comes to bad maps, everyone is thinking the same thing. Unless the cursing is a necessary ingredient, then you can let others speak for you. Don't worry, I'm not reporting anyone.