Carl: That is very insightful. I was under the impression that Mac was loved by the popultation, by and large, and adored by the politicians.
Mac's strategic abilities: It is of course great to attack where it is least expected. However, thre is a reason for nobody to expect an attack at that spot then. Either it is a strategic cul-de-sac, or it is just too tough or something else.
Just because it is un-expected does not equate to success in all instances.
On Overlord after all, there were only so many option (2 really).
Did Mac have any redeeming qualities in terms of strategic management?
Even if Marshall is retiring some of the older generals, I think it could be difficult to overlook Mac, even if we read Carl's comments.
Ivan