Luftwaffe produces only Daimler-Benz engines

  • Thread starter Deleted member 1487
  • Start date

Deleted member 1487

And this is a good thing how exactly?
Who said this would be good in the moral sense? The point of the thread is about what changes would result from a given POD rather than making a moral judgement about the effects of the POD.

More Allied aircrew get killed, more civilians perish in the ground fighting or the death camps, and the third A-bomb assembled is dropped somewhere over Germany. This is your concept of an improvement?
Overall no, I'm saying it would result in an improvement of the Luftwaffe's performance during the war. If you want to make moral judgements about PODs I suggest you set aside a huge block of time to criticize about 2/3rd of What Ifs ever written.
I'm asking a question about the effects of a specific action, not whether that action would result in an overall moral good, that's a discussion beyond the scope of this forum and this thread.
 
Who said this would be good in the moral sense? The point of the thread is about what changes would result from a given POD rather than making a moral judgement about the effects of the POD.


Overall no, I'm saying it would result in an improvement of the Luftwaffe's performance during the war. If you want to make moral judgements about PODs I suggest you set aside a huge block of time to criticize about 2/3rd of What Ifs ever written.
I'm asking a question about the effects of a specific action, not whether that action would result in an overall moral good, that's a discussion beyond the scope of this forum and this thread.


Yes I've noticed that, you keep posting these 'technical' threads that involve having the Germans do better and yet never address the consequences; hence my questions.
 

Deleted member 1487

Yes I've noticed that, you keep posting these 'technical' threads that involve having the Germans do better and yet never address the consequences; hence my questions.

I'm floating various ideas for a TL in the future; I'm working out the various butterflies that would result from an initial POD and am using the forum as a sounding board for various potential ones. The TL is not going to be a happy one that will result in a morally better world, but rather is one where I'd like to explore some themes and scenarios that would result from a different WW2 and aftermath.
When has this forum ever been about moral judgements on TLs and ideas? I've seen people discuss the effects of unrestrained nuclear war and biological weapons without this question being raised, so why now? Are you offended by the questions I'm asking or think that I'm a Nazi because of my technical threads?
 
I'm floating various ideas for a TL in the future; I'm working out the various butterflies that would result from an initial POD and am using the forum as a sounding board for various potential ones. The TL is not going to be a happy one that will result in a morally better world, but rather is one where I'd like to explore some themes and scenarios that would result from a different WW2 and aftermath.
When has this forum ever been about moral judgements on TLs and ideas? I've seen people discuss the effects of unrestrained nuclear war and biological weapons without this question being raised, so why now? Are you offended by the questions I'm asking or think that I'm a Nazi because of my technical threads?

I simply wanted to find out what your objectives were, and now I know, thanks.
 
Top