List of US Presidents in a CSA wins TL

1861: Abraham Lincoln (Republican)
1865: George B. McClellan (Democrat)
1869: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1873: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1877: Winfield Scott Hancock (Democrat)
1881: Frederick W. Seward (Republican)
1885: Samuel J. Tilden (Democrat)
1886: Grover Cleveland (Democrat) [1] [2]
1889: Grover Cleveland (Democrat)
1893: Mark Hanna (Republican)
1897: Charles Francis Adams Jr. (Republican)
1901: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican)
1902: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party of the USA) [Chicago Government]
1902: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican) [Washington 'legitimate' government]
1902: William Jennings Bryan (Democrats) [New England Government]
1902: Hiram Johnson (Progressive Party of the USA) [Sacramento government]
[3]
1910: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [4]
1914: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [5]


[1] President Tilden died in office and was succeded by his vice president Grover Cleveland
[2] Cleveland was living in Massachusetts.
[3] The disastrous war with the Confederacy and her European allies led to the rise of four government claiming to be the true USA, in addition to the various local authorities and the occupied territories throughout the country. The loss of Maine and parts of Washington state are especially resented.
[4] The Second Civil War ends with the Reds on top. A new constitution is ratified, and Debs serves as head of state and government, as the President of the Council of People's Secretaries. (Like OTL's South African president, the President of the USSA is elected by the legislature)
[5] Debs is reelected by the Parliament with 100% of the votes. Some talk of lifetime presidency as the major People's Reforms really take off....
 
1861: Abraham Lincoln (Republican)
1865: George B. McClellan (Democrat)
1869: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1873: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1877: Winfield Scott Hancock (Democrat)
1881: Frederick W. Seward (Republican)
1885: Samuel J. Tilden (Democrat)
1886: Grover Cleveland (Democrat) [1] [2]
1889: Grover Cleveland (Democrat)
1893: Mark Hanna (Republican)
1897: Charles Francis Adams Jr. (Republican)
1901: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican)
1902: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party of the USA) [Chicago Government]
1902: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican) [Washington 'legitimate' government]
1902: William Jennings Bryan (Democrats) [New England Government]
1902: Hiram Johnson (Progressive Party of the USA) [Sacramento government]
[3]
1910: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [4]
1914: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [5]
1918:
Eugene Debs (Socialist Party)


[1] President Tilden died in office and was succeded by his vice president Grover Cleveland
[2] Cleveland was living in Massachusetts.
[3] The disastrous war with the Confederacy and her European allies led to the rise of four government claiming to be the true USA, in addition to the various local authorities and the occupied territories throughout the country. The loss of Maine and parts of Washington state are especially resented.
[4] The Second Civil War ends with the Reds on top. A new constitution is ratified, and Debs serves as head of state and government, as the President of the Council of People's Secretaries. (Like OTL's South African president, the President of the USSA is elected by the legislature)
[5] Debs is reelected by the Parliament with over 90% of the votes. Some talk of lifetime presidency as the major People's Reforms really take off....
 
1861: Abraham Lincoln (Republican)
1865: George B. McClellan (Democrat)
1869: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1873: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1877: Winfield Scott Hancock (Democrat)
1881: Frederick W. Seward (Republican)
1885: Samuel J. Tilden (Democrat)
1886: Grover Cleveland (Democrat) [1] [2]
1889: Grover Cleveland (Democrat)
1893: Mark Hanna (Republican)
1897: Charles Francis Adams Jr. (Republican)
1901: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican)
1902: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party of the USA) [Chicago Government]
1902: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican) [Washington 'legitimate' government]
1902: William Jennings Bryan (Democrats) [New England Government]
1902: Hiram Johnson (Progressive Party of the USA) [Sacramento government]
[3]
1910: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [4]
1914: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [5]
1918:
Eugene Debs (Socialist Party)
1919:
Upton Sinclair (Socialist Party) [6]


[1] President Tilden died in office and was succeded by his vice president Grover Cleveland
[2] Cleveland was living in Massachusetts.
[3] The disastrous war with the Confederacy and her European allies led to the rise of four government claiming to be the true USA, in addition to the various local authorities and the occupied territories throughout the country. The loss of Maine and parts of Washington state are especially resented.
[4] The Second Civil War ends with the Reds on top. A new constitution is ratified, and Debs serves as head of state and government, as the President of the Council of People's Secretaries. (Like OTL's South African president, the President of the USSA is elected by the legislature)
[5] Debs is reelected by the Parliament with over 90% of the votes. Some talk of lifetime presidency as the major People's Reforms really take off....
[6] Sinclair becomes President on Debs' assassination by an anarchist revolutionary.
 
1861: Abraham Lincoln (Republican)
1865: George B. McClellan (Democrat)
1869: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1873: Horatio Seymour (Democrat)
1877: Winfield Scott Hancock (Democrat)
1881: Frederick W. Seward (Republican)
1885: Samuel J. Tilden (Democrat)
1886: Grover Cleveland (Democrat) [1] [2]
1889: Grover Cleveland (Democrat)
1893: Mark Hanna (Republican)
1897: Charles Francis Adams Jr. (Republican)
1901: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican)
1902: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party of the USA) [Chicago Government]
1902: Theodore Roosevelt (Republican) [Washington 'legitimate' government]
1902: William Jennings Bryan (Democrats) [New England Government]
1902: Hiram Johnson (Progressive Party of the USA) [Sacramento government]
[3]
1910: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [4]
1914: Eugene Debs (Socialist Party) [5]
1918:
Eugene Debs (Socialist Party)
1919:
Upton Sinclair (Socialist Party) [6]
1920: Anarchist Temporary Cabal [Pittsburgh quasi-government]
1920: John Pershing (Nationalist) [Denver government]
1920: Blair Lee (Democratic-Republican) [Washington government] [Confederate puppet] [7]


[1] President Tilden died in office and was succeded by his vice president Grover Cleveland
[2] Cleveland was living in Massachusetts.
[3] The disastrous war with the Confederacy and her European allies led to the rise of four government claiming to be the true USA, in addition to the various local authorities and the occupied territories throughout the country. The loss of Maine and parts of Washington state are especially resented.
[4] The Second Civil War ends with the Reds on top. A new constitution is ratified, and Debs serves as head of state and government, as the President of the Council of People's Secretaries. (Like OTL's South African president, the President of the USSA is elected by the legislature)
[5] Debs is reelected by the Parliament with over 90% of the votes. Some talk of lifetime presidency as the major People's Reforms really take off....
[6] Sinclair becomes President on Debs' assassination by an anarchist revolutionary.
[7] President Sinclair strikes back against the anarchists, who revolt. The anti-socialist West also rebels, causing the Confederates to march into Washington and establish a puppet government.
 
The bats are in great numbers tonight :p
That's not even the worst part. The West is anti-socialist? Jeesh, just because mountain states are conservative now doesn't mean they were always so. In fact, the mountain states were very left-wing then, to the point that it was a common refrain among journalists to say that the miners, loggers and workers were "all red out here".
 

Wolfpaw

Banned
I'm going to start a new list since the US doesn't seem to exist anymore in the previous one.

1860: Abraham Lincoln/Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour/George H. Pendleton (D)
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

 
This is a rough idea of the list for a TL in preparation (War and Peace).

1861: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1865: George B. McClellan / George H. Pendleton (D)
1869: George B. McClellan / Samuel J. Tilden (D)
1873: Salmon P. Chase / Cassius Marcellus Clay (R)
1873: Cassius Marcellus Clay (R) [1]
1877: Winfield Scott Hancock / Thomas A. Hendricks (D)
1881: Winfield Scott Hancock / Grover Cleveland (D)
1881: Grover Cleveland (D) [2]
1885: Grover Cleveland / Samuel J. Randall (D)
1889: James G. Blaine / John Sherman (R)
1893: John Sherman (R) [3]
1893: David B. Hill / Alton B. Parker (D)
1897: David B. Hill / Woodrow Wilson (D) [4]
1901: William McKinley Jr / Robert M. Lafolette Sr (R)


[1]: Becomes president upon the death in office of his predecessor.
[2]: Becomes president upon the assassination of his predecessor
[3]: Sherman becomes president upon the death in office of Blaine.
[4]: ITTL, the hometown of Wilson has been annexed to Western Virginia after the armistice of 1865.
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.

 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]
1884: James G. Blaine / Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. (R) [3]

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
[3] To ensure smooth reconstruction in Kentucky and West Virginia, Blaine ran for reelection. John Kelly, who was accused of stealing the Democratic nomination, led many Democrats to endorse the incumbent president. President Blaine won the biggest landslide since 1820.
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]
1884: James G. Blaine / Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. (R) [3]
1888: Washington Bartlett/ John L. Mitchell

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
[3] To ensure smooth reconstruction in Kentucky and West Virginia, Blaine ran for reelection. John Kelly, who was accused of stealing the Democratic nomination, led many Democrats to endorse the incumbent president. President Blaine won the biggest landslide since 1820.

 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]
1884: James G. Blaine / Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. (R) [3]
1888: Washington Bartlett / John L. Mitchell
1892: Thomas Brackett Reed / William McKinley (R) [4]

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
[3] To ensure smooth reconstruction in Kentucky and West Virginia, Blaine ran for reelection. John Kelly, who was accused of stealing the Democratic nomination, led many Democrats to endorse the incumbent president. President Blaine won the biggest landslide since 1820.
[4] The Civil Rights Act of 1894 was passed by both houses and was ruled constitutional by the Supreme Court in a lawsuit against the Reed administration in 1895. Blacks were given the right to vote, segregation has since then been outlawed. Reed announced that he would not be running for reelection due to poor health.
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]
1884: James G. Blaine / Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. (R) [3]
1888: Washington Bartlett / John L. Mitchell
1892:Thomas Brackett Reed / William McKinley (R) [4]
1896: William McKinley / Gerret Hobart (R)

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
[3] To ensure smooth reconstruction in Kentucky and West Virginia, Blaine ran for reelection. John Kelly, who was accused of stealing the Democratic nomination, led many Democrats to endorse the incumbent president. President Blaine won the biggest landslide since 1820.
[4] The Civil Rights Act of 1894 was passed by both houses and was ruled constitutional by the Supreme Court in a lawsuit against the Reed administration in 1895. Blacks were given the right to vote, segregation has since then been outlawed. Reed announced that he would not be running for reelection due to poor health.
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]
1884: James G. Blaine / Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. (R) [3]
1888: Washington Bartlett / John L. Mitchell
1892: Thomas Brackett Reed / William McKinley (R) [4]
1896: William McKinley / Gerret Hobart (R)
1900: William McKinley / Hiram Johnson (R) [5]

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
[3] To ensure smooth reconstruction in Kentucky and West Virginia, Blaine ran for reelection. John Kelly, who was accused of stealing the Democratic nomination, led many Democrats to endorse the incumbent president. President Blaine won the biggest landslide since 1820.
[4] The Civil Rights Act of 1894 was passed by both houses and was ruled constitutional by the Supreme Court in a lawsuit against the Reed administration in 1895. Blacks were given the right to vote, segregation has since then been outlawed. Reed announced that he would not be running for reelection due to poor health.
[5] Gerret Hobart incapacitated.
 
1860: Abraham Lincoln / Hannibal Hamlin (R)
1864: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)

1868: Horatio Seymour / George H. Pendleton (D)
1872: Clement Vallandigham / Jeremiah Black (D)
1876: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [1]
1880: James G. Blaine / James A. Garfield (R) [2]
1884: James G. Blaine / Theodore Roosevelt, Sr. (R) [3]
1888: Washington Bartlett / John L. Mitchell (D)
1892: Thomas Brackett Reed / William McKinley (R) [4]
1896: William McKinley / Garret Hobart (R)
1900: William McKinley / Hiram Johnson (R) [5]
1904: William Jennings Bryan / Alton B. Parker (D)

[1] Due to increasing Southern aggression, public sentiment began to turn against the pacifist Democrats. Blaine defeated Vallandigham by a landslide.
[2] Defeated the Confederates in the War of the Plains. Managed to win the western part of Virginia back, a place that commonly revolted against the CSA government; and Kentucky, which was as reluctant to secede as Tennessee. His one failure was not decisively beating the CSA.
[3] To ensure smooth reconstruction in Kentucky and West Virginia, Blaine ran for reelection. John Kelly, who was accused of stealing the Democratic nomination, led many Democrats to endorse the incumbent president. President Blaine won the biggest landslide since 1820.
[4] The Civil Rights Act of 1894 was passed by both houses and was ruled constitutional by the Supreme Court in a lawsuit against the Reed administration in 1895. Blacks were given the right to vote, segregation has since then been outlawed. Reed announced that he would not be running for reelection due to poor health.
[5] Garret Hobart incapacitated.
 
Top