Updating the Forgotten No More list:
1789-1793: Artemis Ward (Independent - MA)/Richard Henry Lee (Independent - VA)
def. 1788: an assortment of candidates
1793-1794: William Few (Federalist - GA)/Richard Henry Lee (Independent - VA)
def. 1797: an assortment of candidates
1794-1797: William Few (Federalist - GA)/vacant
1797-1801: Henry Lee III (Federalist - VA)/John Langdon (Federalist - NH)
def. 1796: Spencer Roane (Republican - VA)/George Clinton (Republican - NY)
1801-1805: George Clinton (Republican - NY)/Spencer Roane (Republican - VA)
def. 1800 Henry Lee III (Fed.-VA)/Theodore Sedgwick (Federalist - MA)
1805-1809: Charles Lee (Fed.-VA)/Theodore Sedgwick (Federalist - MA)
def. 1804: Charles Pinckney (Republican - SC)/Nicholas Gilman, Jr. (Republican - NH)
1809-1813: Henry Lee III (Federalist - VA)/James Hillhouse (Federalist - CT)
def. 1808: James Garrard (Republican - KY)/Thomas Sumter (Republican - SC)
1813-1817: William Eustis (Republican - MA)/Rufus King (Peace Federalist -NY)
def. 1812: Henry Lee III (Federalist - VA)/Thomas Robertson (Federalist - OH), James Iredell (Republican - NC), James Hillhouse (Peace Federalist - CT), John Randolph (Quid Republican - OH)/Joseph Desha (Quid Republican - KY)
def. 1816: Harrison G. Otis (Federalist - MA)/Humphrey Marshall (Federalist - KY), George Madison (States' Rights - KY)/Thomas Sumter (States' Rights - SC)
1821-1825: Philip J. Schuyler (Federalist - NY)/Humphrey Marshall (Federalist - KY)
def. 1820: John Armstrong, Jr. (Republican - NY)/John Williams (Republican - TN), Joseph Desha (States' Rights - KY)/Nathaniel Macon (States' Rights - NC)
1825-1829: Franklin Boyd (Republican - WF)/Francis S. Key (Republican - MD)
def. 1824: Humphrey Marshall (Federalist - KY)/Louis McLane (Federalist - DE), Thomas Spalding (States' Rights - GA)/John A. Cocke (States' Rights - KY), Philip J. Schuyler (Liberty - NY)/John T. Carter (Liberty - VA)
1829: Edmund J. Lee (Federalist - VA)/Peter B. Porter (Federalist - NY) †
def. 1828: Edward Livingston (Republican - NY)/Thomas H. Benton (Republican - TN), Augustine Clark (Liberty - VT)/Lewis Tappan (Liberty - NY), Charles F. Mercer (Constitution - VA)/Charles Polk, Jr. (Federalist - DE)
1829: Peter B. Porter (Federalist - NY)/vacant
1829: Peter B. Porter (Federalist - NY)/Charles Adams (Federalist - MA)
1833-1841: William Hendricks (Federalist - IN)/Charles Adams (Federalist - MA)
def. 1832: Thomas H. Benton (Republican - TN)/Samuel Bell (Republican - NH)
def. 1836: Oliver H. Perry (Republican - RI)/William R. King (Republican - EY)
1841-1845: William L. Marcy (Republican - NY)/John Tyler, Jr. (Republican - VA)
def. 1840: John Bell (Federalist - TN)/Rufus Choate (Federalist - MA), Joseph Smith (Christian Democratic - OH)/Peter Cartwright (Christian Democratic - WA), Lewis Tappan (Liberty - NY)/various
1845-1849: William L. Marcy (Republican Sensible Government - NY)/Edward Everett (Federalist Sensible Government - MA)
def. 1844: Joseph Smith (Christian Democratic - OH)/Peter Cartwright (Christian Democrat - WA), John McLean (American - NJ)/Lewis Tappan (American - NY)
1849-1857: Rufus Choate (Federalist - MA)/James Acker (Federalist - VA) 1849
def. 1848 William H. Roane (American - VA)/Thurlow Weed (American - NY), Joseph Smith (Christian Democratic - OH)/Lyman Beecher (Christian Democratic - NY), James J. Roosevelt (Republican - NY)/Thomas J. Rusk (Republican - SC)
def. 1852: Fernando Wood (American - NY)/Stephen A. Douglass (American - VT), Joseph Smith (Christian Democratic - OH)/George C. Washington (Christian Democratic - MD), John McLean (Libertine American - OH)/John Brown (Libertine American - MA), Robert Rhett (Southern Republican - SC)/David R. Atchison (Southern Republican - KY)
1857-1858: Fernando Wood (American - NY)/Alexander D. Bache (American - PA) î
def. 1856: James Acker (Federalist - VA)/John J. Crittenden (Federalist - KY), Joseph E. Davis (Southern - WF)/Robert B. Rhett, Sr. (Southern - SC), Samuel H. Smith (Hard Christian Democratic - OH)/John Whitmer (Hard Christian Democratic - WI), Andrew Johnson (Populist - TN)/William C. Rives (Populist - VA), Levi D. Boone (Soft Christian Democratic - WA)/Lyman Beecher (Soft Christian Democratic - NY)
1858: Alexander D. Bache (American-PA)/vacant
1858-1861: Alexander D. Bache (American - PA)/George S. Boutwell (American - MA)
1861-1865: Robert E. Lee (Federalist - VA)/Horace Maynard (Federalist - TN)
def. 1860: Alexander D. Bache (American - PA)/George S. Boutwell (American - MA), Henry W. Halleck (Populist - -LK)/Joseph Holt (Populist - KY), Solomon Levi (Patriot - RI)/John Brough (Patriot - OH)
1865: Robert E. Lee (Federalist - VA)/Andrew Johnson (Populist - TN) †
def. 1864: /John Adams II (Federalist - MA), Henry W. Halleck (Populist - LK)/, Fernando Wood (American - NY)/John Brown (American - MA)
1865: Andrew Johnson (Populist - TN)/vacant
1865-1869: Andrew Johnson (Populist - TN)/Lovell H. Rousseau (Populist - IN)
1869-1877: Nathaniel P. Banks (American - MA)/Austin Blair (American - MI)
def. 1868: Samuel P. Lee (Federalist - VA)/Thomas A. Hendricks (Federalist - IN), Andrew Johnson (Populist - TN)/Lovell H. Rousseau (Populist - IN), John Brown (Radical American - MA)/Horace Greeley (Radical American - NY), Marcus Livingston (Valentine League - FK)/Boris Mayard (Valentine League -GA), John Wentworth (Anti-Lee Federalist - WA)/James A. Bayard, Jr. (Anti-Lee Federalist - DE), George Meander (Democratic - WA)/Gregory Mansfield (Democratic - NY)
def. 1872: Wendell Phillips (National Workers Front - MA)/Gregory Mansfield (National Workers Front - NY), Samuel P. Lee (Federalist - VA)/Lewis D. Campbell (Federalist - OH), Henry W. Halleck (Populist - LK)/Levi D. Boone (Populist - WA)
1877-1881: Henry B. Whipple (Workers - MN)/William R. Taylor (Workers - NY)
def. 1876: Nathaniel P. Banks (American - MA)/Austin Blair (American - MI), Benjamin H. Bristow (Federalist - KY)/Thomas F. Bayard, Sr. (Federalist - DE)
1881: Frederick T. Frelinghuysen (Federalist - NJ)/William B. Allison (Federalist - SK) †
def. 1880: William R. Taylor (Workers - NY)/William A. Wheeler (Workers - NY), Emerson Unferhow (American - CL)/Roscoe Conkling (American - NY), John Russell (Prohibition - MI)/Gideon T. Stewart (Prohibition - OH), Wilford Woodruff (Christian Democratic Revival -UT)/various
1881: William B. Allison (Federalist - SK)/vacant
1881-1885: William B. Allison (Federalist - SK)/Thomas F. Bayard, Sr. (Federalist - DE)
1885-1889: David B. Knickerbocker (Workers - MN)/Edward Cooper (Workers - NY)
def. 1884: William B. Allison (Federalist - SK)/Samuel J. Randall (Federalist - PA), Edward Blake (Lib.Ref.-HU)/Robert B. Roosevelt (Lib.Ref.-NY), Thomas F. Bayard, Sr. (Liberal Federalist - DE)/John H. Gray (Liberal Federalist - NB), Robert Smalls (American Remnant - SC)/Samuel B. Callahan (Federalist - EY), Givens T. Stewart (Prohibition - OH)/John P. St. John (Prohibition - PL)
1889-1896: George A. Custer (Federalist - OH)/Eli M. Saulsbury (Federalist - DE)
def. 1888: David B. Knickerbocker (Workers - MN)/Edward Cooper (Workers - NY), Samuel Levi (Independent - RI)/Charles B. Farwell (Liberal Reform - WA), Samuel Levi (Independent - RI)/Benjamin S. Turner (American Remnant - EY), David B. Knickerbocker (Workers - MN)/John P. St. John (Prohibition - FK)
def. 1892: Isaac P. Gray (Workers - IN)/William H. Felton (Workers - GA), John B. Gordon (Constitution - GA)/Richard H. Wilmer (Constitution - TN), /John R. Lynch (American Remnant - WY), Fitzhugh J. MacManus (Prohibition - WA)/John P. St. John (Prohibition - FK), Uriah S. Stephens (Soqualist-Labor - PA)/Samuel Levi (Soqualist-Labor - RI)
1896: George A. Custer (Federalist - OH)/vacant
1896: George A. Custer (Federalist - OH)/vacant
def. 1896: Henry G. Davis (Federalist - VA), Washington Gladden† (Workers - OH)/A. R. Kitisen (Workers - WA), Joseph C.S. Blackburn (Constitution - KY)/Joshua F.C. Talbott (Constitution - MD), Edward Bellamy (Soqualist Labor - MA)/Chris Tuttrup (Soqualist Labor - WI), Thomas B. Reed (Peace Federalist - ME)/various, Robert E. Pattison (Liberal Federalist - PA)/various
1896-1900: George A. Custer (Federalist - OH)/John P. Stockton (Federalist - NJ)
1900: George A. Custer (Federalist - OH)/vacant Î
1900-1901: Arthur P. Gorman (Federalist - MD)/Thomas E. Watson (Workers - GA)
1901-1905: Thompson H. Murch (Workers - ME)/Walter Rauschenbusch (Workers - NY)
def. 1900: Charlemagne Tower, Jr. (Federalist - PA)/P. B. S. Pinchback (Federalist - WF), Hernando D. Money (Constitution - WF)/Charles B. Aycock (Constitution - NC)
1905-1913: Nelson A. Miles (Federalist - MA)/George W. Ross (Federalist - HU)
def. 1904: Walter Rauschenbusch (Workers - NY)/Terrence V. Powderly (Workers - PA), Henry A. du Pont (Constitution - DE)/Fernifold M. Simmons (Constitution - NC)
def. 1908: Terrence V. Powderly (Moderate-Labor Workers - PA)/George E. Chamberlain Sr. (Moderate-Labor Workers - CL), Augustus O. Bacon (Constitution - GA)/William T. Hamilton (Constitution - MD), Josiah Strong (Social Gospel Workers - WA)/John W. Leedy (Social Gospel Workers - MN)