That wqould probbly be better for nazis, with no one big murder that would cause the jews to finally realise that europe hates them, they will slowwly be killed in pogroms or become christians to avoid said pogroms.
That wqould probbly be better for nazis, with no one big murder that would cause the jews to finally realise that europe hates them, they will slowwly be killed in pogroms or become christians to avoid said pogroms.
German when spoken with an Austrian accent would sound charming and folksy.
Originally Posted by I Blame Communism
Urgh. Typical of the reflexive anti-Polonism on this site.
If you think you can draw moral equivalency between pogroms and quotas for Jews, well, that's a bit ridiculous.
Now you're starting to sound like Hurgan or one of our (thankfully) long-gone Pole-trolls.
![]()
No anti-Polonism, just some stating of the fact that Poland was admittedly not one of the most Jew-friendly parts of Europe.
The post-WWII stuff I remember reading about sounded a bit worse than "I'm a poor refugee and I won't have a house at all if I don't leave the house that belonged to a Jewish man with a number on his arm who now wants it back."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kielce_pogrom
This is old-school blood libel here.
And Rabbi Foxman, head of the ADL, remembers hiding in the basement on Good Friday to avoid being attacked by Catholics stirred up about the Crucifixion and looking for Jews to blame. This was before the Holocaust.
. There may be no Holocaust as such, but other nations might have launched pogroms (especially in connecting Jews to Communism). As others mentioned, Pilsudski's Poland is one such country.
Had Ormanians, or Greeks(who also lived in Poland) made up 1/3 or so students, law regarding them would also be made-the Polish government after century of foreign occupation was trying to create a Polish middle and enlarge numbers of Poles with higher education. While of course their were anti-semitic sentiments associated with this, there is no doubt that in situation where other minority would be in the same situation, similiar laws would be made. Such were the times then.Quotas of Jews in Universities was only anti-semitic law in interwar Poland
Perhaps Nazi Germans on the borders, do that no?
Ze'ev Jabotinsky-founder of Jewish Self-Defense in Odessa, Jewish Legion and founder of Irgun.
Had Ormanians, or Greeks(who also lived in Poland) made up 1/3 or so students, law regarding them would also be made-the Polish government after century of foreign occupation was trying to create a Polish middle and enlarge numbers of Poles with higher education. While of course their were anti-semitic sentiments associated with this, there is no doubt that in situation where other minority would be in the same situation, similiar laws would be made. Such were the times then.
What?
Are you saying that Nazism caused "deicide"-induced violence (or at least the threat thereof) in Poland BEFORE the war?
The Nazis didn't hate the Jews because they allegedly "killed Jesus," they hated the Jews because they thought they were an evil race undermining Germany, controlling the banks, whatver.
Poland was partitioned under Germany and Austra as well.So Tsarist Russian rule led to an unfair and disproportionate advancement of the Jews? That's silly.
Poland was partitioned under Germany and Austra as well.
I don't know what led to disproportionate distribution of Jews in higher studies on Polish territories though. Maybe the enforced settlement of Jewish population into Congress Poland by Russian Empire after 1864 combined with anti-Polish repressions and restrictions on Polish education? Or mainly agricultural character of Polish society? Anyway this disproportion existed, and certainly the century of foreign occupation didn't provide opportunities for Polish education.
Or we could maybe look at the simple fact that Jews was a urban mechant minority with high literacy rates and where status to a large degree came from education, while Poles, Belarussian and Ruthenians was mostly rural and the majority was first serf and later rural workers, where status to large degree came from owning property.
Suuuure, you're not a troll.Why do I bother? Nobody ever accuses bloody Hitler of being a Zionist, but look at me.
Of course there is also the fact that without Pale of Settlement and forced settlement of Jews within Poland by Russian Empire the Jewish minority would be smaller. And Polish education would be in far different condition if not for Partitions and all the restrictions regarding Poles.
Suuuure, you're not a troll.![]()
Don't forget about Argentina. At this time Argentina was one of the main destinations for Jews .
...I can see many more coming. Specially Russian and Polish Jews
...as well as being seen as a possibility for the Jewish State by Theodor Herzl.
Personally I don't see a Jewish State in Argentina, .
So now you are suggesting that Poles gained antisemitism in their DNA because of Catholicism? How would you explain Jewish emigration from Germany into Catholic Poland in XVI-XVIII centuries then, Sherlock?