If the Jews were persecuted in a facist Russia (Which is the same size as OTL in 1914) and their is a holocaust, but Russia is ultimatly defeated in an ALT WW2 would a jewish homeland still be possible?
Yeah; it's not like Israel just popped out one day from Zeus's head, fully formed. Zionism stretches back a good bit into the 19th Century, and there was already a lot of agitation for the Brits to make one as soon as they set up the Mandate of Palestine.
This whole thread is ASB.