Curious how the New Britain campaign is going.

I wonder, where are the Japanese Kongou-class battlecruisers? They sound like the best option for dealing with British cruisers harassing the convoys.
Well, half of them are on the bottom of the ocean already...

Hiei is still undergoing her reconstruction and won't be recommissioned for some time.

That just leaves Kongo, which as Japan's only fast BB at this point is being held in reserve.

Fortunately (for them) Japan's super dreadnoughts are still fast enough to escort even a "fast" convoy. May not be fast enough to chase down the pesky cruisers, but eh as long as the convoys are getting through that last bit doesn't really matter.
 
How does the deployment of capital units as convoy escorts impact Japanese fuel usage? Is it a significant constraint on future operations?

Is it viable to add Renown to the interdiction cruiser force? Admittedly, I'm not terribly sanguine about exposing her 9" belt to 14" shells that it cannot stop, but there you go.

Has the IJN put more emphasis on ASW than in OTL WW2?
 
How does the deployment of capital units as convoy escorts impact Japanese fuel usage? Is it a significant constraint on future operations?
That'll depend on if the Soviets continue holding up their end of the deal.

Is it viable to add Renown to the interdiction cruiser force? Admittedly, I'm not terribly sanguine about exposing her 9" belt to 14" shells that it cannot stop, but there you go.
I'll look into it.

Has the IJN put more emphasis on ASW than in OTL WW2?
Japan took ASW very seriously -so late into the war that it didn't matter. At this point they aren't anywhere near the meassures they were taking by late war iOTL, but they're definitely doing a lot more than they were doing early war iOTL.
 
Well, half of them are on the bottom of the ocean already...

Hiei is still undergoing her reconstruction and won't be recommissioned for some time.

That just leaves Kongo, which as Japan's only fast BB at this point is being held in reserve.

Fortunately (for them) Japan's super dreadnoughts are still fast enough to escort even a "fast" convoy. May not be fast enough to chase down the pesky cruisers, but eh as long as the convoys are getting through that last bit doesn't really matter.
In addition to that of the other 6 Battleships

Fuso is being rebuilt - OTL 'deep' refitting from 1937 not ready till 1941

Both Ise and Hyūga are available having been deep refitted in the mid 30s

Both Nagato and Mutsu were also refitted by 1937 so should be available - Mutsu was OTL placed into reserve between Dec 1938 and Nov 1939 but this is post the POD so I am not sure if this would greatly impact her serviceability and crewing in this TL?

So disregarding annual refits etc Japan has 1 BC and 5 BB available
 
Last edited:
I think that is extremely difficult for the events mentioned in India as you mentioned. The Police after the Government of India Act 1935 was still not given completely over to the elected government and was largely controlled by the provincial governors and therefore causing sucha crackdown is not possible. The best he can do is organize mobs and make the police look the other way. But importantly he did not have a majority in the legislature and if he tries anything silly then simply his government collapses. Haq was an Islamist personally but a secular man politically and had good relations with several Hindu nationalists like Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, who was a RSS member. RSS was a minor organization that could hardly pose a threat. Basically Haq was an indecisive man who cannot pull such a thing off. And as far as Communist trade unions are concerned it is a great feat that one was found. Bengali Communism arose in the 1950s and in the 30s they had nothing in Bengal and Communists in general were hated in many parts of the Indian society. For the Bengali army why do you consider only the Calcutta Police reserve? The Bengal Police was a seperate department and had its own large reserve in addition to the Eastern Frontier Rifles who could form the core of such an army.
 
The curse continues! I mention battleships, I need to do revisions!

I think that is extremely difficult for the events mentioned in India as you mentioned. The Police after the Government of India Act 1935 was still not given completely over to the elected government and was largely controlled by the provincial governors and therefore causing sucha crackdown is not possible. The best he can do is organize mobs and make the police look the other way. But importantly he did not have a majority in the legislature and if he tries anything silly then simply his government collapses. Haq was an Islamist personally but a secular man politically and had good relations with several Hindu nationalists like Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, who was a RSS member. RSS was a minor organization that could hardly pose a threat. Basically Haq was an indecisive man who cannot pull such a thing off. And as far as Communist trade unions are concerned it is a great feat that one was found. Bengali Communism arose in the 1950s and in the 30s they had nothing in Bengal and Communists in general were hated in many parts of the Indian society. For the Bengali army why do you consider only the Calcutta Police reserve? The Bengal Police was a seperate department and had its own large reserve in addition to the Eastern Frontier Rifles who could form the core of such an army.
Thank you for bringing this to my attention, such criticism is kindly appreciated. I'll see about cleaning it up. Do you think there's a way to get something broadly similar to happen or would I be best off axing that portion entirely?
 
A. K. Fazlul Huq
The crackdown began with those involved in the massacre. Then those involved with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. Then anyone advocating faith based nationalism. Then trade unionists affiliated with the Congress or the Communists. Then dissidents opposed to the emergency crackdown. In this way the dragnet continued to grow, as did Huq’s grip on power.

With some key members of the opposing parties behind bars and the excuse of emergency measures at his disposal he passed some additional acts. Some of these were mundane, like a law that all signs and store frontage must be in Bangla.[8] One of them though allowed for the seizure and redistribution of the property of gentry who had given patronage to “agitators”.

Many in the colonial administration were uneasy about these changes, but Delhi remained set on letting a local actor engender whatever blowback would result from this. To his enemies, Huq was the devil incarnate. To a beaten and battered India, he seemed a beacon of stability and effective governance to be celebrated and emulated.[9]
I can easily seen him being remembered far less fondly than in OTL due to his brutal methods and collaborating with the British.
 
Thank you for bringing this to my attention, such criticism is kindly appreciated. I'll see about cleaning it up. Do you think there's a way to get something broadly similar to happen or would I be best off axing that portion entirely?
It depends on what you want. For example the death of the Odia person could start large riots that spiral out of control and may possibly take a religious angle. If it does take a religious angle then the Haq government collapses. The Bengal Legislative Assembly of the time was full of a large number of parties, independents and a very large group of Europeans and the Haq government was held on by the Congress, the Europeans and some other groups and anyone pulling support would collapse the government and similarly he starts repression on a large scale or uses the police in a communal manner then the Governor-General of the Governor of Bengal would dissolve the government. The British were disliked in varying degrees by the different sections of Indian society but were seldom hated and such acts brew hatred towards the British which they tried to avoid whenever possible by using all sorts of subtle means. If you want riots and chaos this is how it would generally go. The Government of India Act was really "a machine with strong brakes but no engine" as said by Jawaharlal Nehru

If you want to improve the image of Haq then you could have him optimize production and distribution and organize Home Guard units(unarmed) and with a stretch provincial militia. The production and distribution part is achievable with the British not hindering the efforts but for armed Home Guard units and militia a lot more British cooperation would be required. OTL the British refused it as they feared that the units could be used against them and they could do nothing to stop it with them being stretched across the globe but ITTL the stretch is less and India is slightly less discontent that the British didn't drag them into a war but were dragged in themselves again there was significant antipathy towards the fascist regimes of Europe(naturally racist ideologies are hated by colonial subjects who experience racism daily) but Japan was looked upto as the ideal Asian country that had beaten the Europeans. Although I expect the Japanese war crimes to come into the news soon eradicating that sympathy. But for that you need a competitive person in charge of India unlike inept people like Lord Linlithgow and some realist and competent person like Anthony Eden. He would probably also utilise India's industrial capacity more efficiently unlike OTL where Americans helped and nudged them to do so and proper utilisation started only in 1943.
 
Last edited:
I've decided to axe the Indian section of the last update. I'll try to devise a new way to expand the Indian Internal Conflict in time for the 1 year mark of the war (where I intend to do an overview of what has changed in the two empires over the course of the fighting).

edit: or maybe I can salvage something of it...
 
Last edited:
To me it's amusing that this is going pretty much into worst case scenario that the Royal Navy envisioned. As a conflict of Japan in the far East draws away Royal Navy strength, followed by Italy into the the war stretching British strength, finally followed by the most dangerous by proximity the German navy. Looking forward to more.
 
To me it's amusing that this is going pretty much into worst case scenario that the Royal Navy envisioned. As a conflict of Japan in the far East draws away Royal Navy strength, followed by Italy into the the war stretching British strength, finally followed by the most dangerous by proximity the German navy. Looking forward to more.
Cant see either nation joining a lost war
 
To me it's amusing that this is going pretty much into worst case scenario that the Royal Navy envisioned. As a conflict of Japan in the far East draws away Royal Navy strength, followed by Italy into the the war stretching British strength, finally followed by the most dangerous by proximity the German navy. Looking forward to more.
Problem with that line of thinking is that the UK is on a war footing a year earlier with any international treaties effectively ripped up and the purse strings totally undone, production ramping up and so the 'window of opportunity' that Germany had OTL is now much much smaller.

So things are actually worse for them not better.
 
Problem with that line of thinking is that the UK is on a war footing a year earlier with any international treaties effectively ripped up and the purse strings totally undone, production ramping up and so the 'window of opportunity' that Germany had OTL is now much much smaller.

So things are actually worse for them not better.
It's the RN's perception, regardless of reality. The reason why the Japanese kept most of their battleships at dock IOTL was to wait for the "decisive battle". I have no doubt that the RN was the more adaptable and professional branch, but the thought of another war might've caused the RN to hold back both out of fear and budgetary concerns (the Brits did run out of financial assets IOTL and they didn't know if anything like Lend lease was going to happen.
 
Top