Is Nazi rule worse than colonial conditions?

Is Nazi rule in mainland Europe worse than colonial rule in the Raj, Africa and Southeast Asia?

  • Worse than colonialism.

    Votes: 297 92.5%
  • Same as colonialism.

    Votes: 16 5.0%
  • Not as bad as colonialism.

    Votes: 8 2.5%

  • Total voters
    321
Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not the same, Nazis were much worse in practice, but Nazi ideologues justified Lebensraum and Generalplan Ost by Referencing things like Manifest Destiny.

One could argue that Lebensraum was in fact a settler colonial scheme like any other, the difference is that the technology in the 1940s allowed for it to by systematic and industrialized in a never-before-seen scale, with horrifying consequences.
 

TDM

Kicked
I think I can

https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/concentration-camps-1933-39

Interesting one option too many early people in the early 1930s in concentration camps was to leave Germany immediately. This was not offered late.

Concentration camps are not a Nazi invention and have been used by other people eg the British.


The concentration camps changed over time, but there is definitely a progression between early 30's and the final solution 42+ and there was plenty of intent to kill in between. Again Akton T4 and then Action 14f13 show that intent (and progression). It was understood by Hitler and the nazis that they would have to ease people in general into genocide and being at war helped with that (this point is made several times in the links I gave earlier). How the concentration camps were run was instrumental in how the inmates ended up.

You right the Nazis didn't invent the concentration camp, but not all concentration camps are equal and not all were used for the same purpose. (don't get me wrong 48k ish died in the British ones in SA, 100k+ in the US ones in the philippines)
 
Last edited:
From the Nuremberg Military Tribunal of the mobile death squads in its judgement stated the following:

[The facts] are so beyond the experience of normal man and the range of man-made phenomena that only the most complete judicial inquiry, and the most exhaustive trial, could verify and confirm them. Although the principal accusation is murder, [...] the charge of purposeful homicide in this case reaches such fantastic proportions and surpasses such credible limits that believability must be bolstered with assurance a hundred times repeated.

...a crime of such unprecedented brutality and of such inconceivable savagery that the mind rebels against its own thought image and the imagination staggers in the contemplation of a human degradation beyond the power of language to adequately portray.
The number of deaths resulting from the activities with which these defendants have been connected and which the prosecution has set at one million is but an abstract number. One cannot grasp the full cumulative terror of murder one million times repeated.

It is only when this grotesque total is broken down into units capable of mental assimilation that one can understand the monstrousness of the things we are in this trial contemplating. One must visualize not one million people but only ten persons — men, women, and children, perhaps all of one family — falling before the executioner's guns. If one million is divided by ten, this scene must happen one hundred thousand times, and as one visualizes the repetitious horror, one begins to understand the meaning of the prosecution's words, 'It is with sorrow and with hope that we here disclose the deliberate slaughter of more than a million innocent and defenseless men, women, and children.'
 
It's not the same, Nazis were much worse in practice, but Nazi ideologues justified Lebensraum and Generalplan Ost by Referencing things like Manifest Destiny.

One could argue that Lebensraum was in fact a settler colonial scheme like any other, the difference is that the technology in the 1940s allowed for it to by systematic and industrialized in a never-before-seen scale, with horrifying consequences.
True, lebensraum by the Nazis was basically the first attempted settler-colonization of a (previously) densely populated area.
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top