Industrial revolution anti-cavalry methods.

Faeelin

Banned
Assume that, for some reason, an industrial revolution takes off in sung china, medieval europe, etc.

Gunpowder is still relatively primitive, however. What could be produced to put an end to cavalry as the dominant weapon of war? (Light, mongol cavalry, and european heavy cavalry).
 
Disciplined phalax-like formations of pikemen?

Any sort of light, strong polearm, coupled with a good method of countering archers.
 

NapoleonXIV

Banned
A steam-powered multiple arrow launcher, firing up to 300 arrows per minute with a power about twice that of any bow of the day. As long as its portable enough to take the field that should nicely trounce about any non-gunpowder cavalry I can think of.

Disciplined Pikemen did defeat just about any European Cavalry sent against them long before the Industrial Revolution. The keyword here is not 'Pike' (as in lighter, stronger) but 'disciplined' as in disciplined to fight in formations. The pattern of medieval warfare made training for formation fighting of any kind very difficult.
 
Last edited:
Farming to pikes

The key would probably be more efficient agriculture. You then have more surplus people for a permanent military--thus you can get the diciplined, well trained pikemen that can stop cavalry. The lords that can afford this will win major battles, and so their realms will grow.
 
Shock cavalry are relatively easy, you don't need a technological fix: discipline is the key. Pikes, longbows, crossbows, fieldworks, wagon-laagers, they'll all do the job if the discipline is there. Song Chinese writers were convinced that crossbows well-handled could stop a charge by any cavalry they knew, and they experimented (as had various other Chinese dynasties) with war-wagons as well.

Steppe light cavalry are harder, especially on their own ground, as much for logistic reasons as anything else: they can avoid battles they don't want to fight, and in the steppes "a small army is beaten, a large army starves".

Even without an IR, the Song had a huge well-equipped army that should on paper have been able to defeat any barbarian cavalry invasion, though perhaps not take the fight into the steppes. But it was underpaid, poorly disciplined and despised.

If we're not talking firearms, some technofixes you might consider are:

- Mass-produced man-portable obstacles to stop a cavalry charge, sort of Swedish-feather style, maybe chain-linked

- Mass-produced war-wagons, iron-plated and carrying multi-arrow ballistae

- Dionysios of Alexandria's chain-driven repeating ballista

- Bicycles, or tricycles. Hideously uncomfortable without pneumatic tyres, but could they be developed into an early-industrial form of infantry mobility? Mass-produced pedal-driven war-wagons, or even supply-wagons?
 
Top