I guess the complains about France giving back Saarland are based on the idea of the German population there being outnumbered/deported and the region being well integrated, which doesn't seem to be the case, and which doesn't seem like a neccesary outcome, given that the area is home to several million Germans. The demand seems far from unreasonable, it's a big chunk of the heart of Germany we're talking about. Even IOTL, Germany needed decades to abandon their claims to the eastern lost parts. I don't understand the negative reaction.
Said that, I'm enjoying a lot the glimpses of the Postwar world (the part about the Phoenix Vault is one of those reasons why I love Alternate History), and I hope many more parts of the world are covered.
It's because you don't pretend that much territory back plus the ok for reunification otherwise the treaty is history, expecially if:
- you don't have that much economic bargain
- you have been readmitted to the human race much later
- after more than half of century, sorry but after that time people have move on in this territory so there will be a big minorities of French and Netherlanders in that territory.
- the economies of that land after this time will be more integrated with the new nations.
- The massive deportation were already planned in case of this kind of annexation, as i said earlier that was part of the reason Netherland nixed that idea as it will create a new humanitarian emergency but here there will be less reason to do it.
- In OTL the German reunification raised some worries so that UK and FS will be so OK regarding that will be difficult.
- Nation don't like to be blackmailed in this manner (frankly even Italy will have some problem with that as that can be some request over South Tyrol) so expect that the EU will goes on without the German Confederation that frankly here is not so essential as is economical less powerfull.
- After WWII change of border are considered very very very bad, as that can mean a new round of hostilities.