Give Peace A Chance: The Presidency of Eugene McCarthy

Chapter Fifty-Eight - Part Three - Two Tribes
“I bet I wouldn’t be doing so well if I hadn’t campaigned as half as liberal as I really am.”

  • Senator Dale Bumpers to his wife, Betty Bumpers, election night 1984



"Hello, we’re back with more Decision ‘84 coverage of this year’s presidential election. Senator Dale Bumpers has a clear lead in both the popular vote and electoral college thus far, with President Paul Laxalt trailing behind him.

We can project that Dale Bumpers has won the state of Pennsylvania. This seems to be a realigning election or America. Senator Bumpers has portrayed himself as a new kind of Democrat, a type of Democrat he has portrayed as pragmatic, reasonable, and bipartisan, who will be able to work with Congress to pass American and liberal priorities. Coming in now, we can also project that Dale Bumpers has won the District of Columbia. We can also report in the South that Dale Bumpers has won in Tennessee. The South remains competitive but Bumpers is in a clear lead there. Northeast, in New England, Dale Bumpers has won Connecticut, he has won Connecticut. That state has eight electoral votes, which gives Bumpers over two hundred electoral votes. As we’ve said, a candidate needs two hundred and seventy to win. In the southwest, Paul Laxalt has won Oklahoma.

We can also report that Delaware has gone for Bumpers. Delaware is one of those states that last voted for the Democrat in 1964 with Lyndon Johnson.

The results in the South are interesting. President Laxalt was hoping to hold on to the South, were social issues, like busing and the death penalty, were generally considered to hold the most sway. Senator Bumpers does not have the clearest record on busing, having spoken against it in Arkansas but voted in favour of busing measures in the Senate. Likewise, Bumpers had seemingly written off the death penalty as a non-issue when it was abolished by the Supreme Court. This didn’t stop Paul Laxalt however, as he campaigned extensively on social issues in the South, and promised to appoint Supreme Court Justices who would overturn certain rulings of the court. Of course, there was a certain expectation that Dale Bumpers, being a Southerner himself, would do better in the South than previous Democrats such as Gene McCarthy and Mo Udall. Not only has Bumpers made some gains in the South, but he has won most Southern states. There are still a few Southern states that have yet to be called, namely Maryland, Louisiana, North Carolina, and Bumper’s home state of Arkansas, but if Bumpers, Senator Bumpers continues his performance in the South thus far, he won’t have anything to worry about.

Some more news coming from the western states. Paul Laxalt has won in South Dakota, and Nebraska. While this is good news for the Laxalt camp, these were considered safe states for the President, and do not particularly change the trajectory of the election. In the South, we project that Dale Bumpers has won Maryland, as well as his home state of Arkansas. While this isn’t necessarily a surprise, it does put Dale Bumpers that much closer to the winning number of two hundred and seventy electoral votes. Right now he’s at two hundred and twenty-three, and many high value states, such as Illinois, New York, and California, have yet to come in. Right now, polling has closed in Illinois and New York, but it’s still open in California.

We’ll be back after this commercial break.


We’re back. We have more coverage to share with you, and it’s big news. Results have come in from the rest of the South: Dale Bumpers is the winner in Louisiana and North Carolina. North Carolina, the home of Senator Jesse Helms, a staunch supporter of Paul Laxalt, was considered a key part of any sound re-election strategy for the President.

Dale Bumpers has swept New England, winning Maine, Vermont, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island. Earlier tonight, he also won New Hampshire and Connecticut.

With Rhode Island moving into the Democratic column, we can confirm that Senator Dale Bumpers of Arkansas will be the next President of the United States. Dale Leon Bumpers, age fifty-nine years old, Senator for Arkansas, is now the President-elect of the United States. The Bumpers ticket has made history tonight: Thomas Bradley, Governor of California, age sixty-seven, is now Vice President-elect, and, when sworn in, will be the first African American Vice President in US history.

But that’s not all. We have more results coming in from the Midwest. Dale Bumpers has also won in Illinois, he’s won in Wisconsin, he has taken Minnesota, and Iowa. Further northeast, the results are in, and we can confirm that Bumpers has won in New York. With the exception of Indiana, and with the results still coming in from Missouri, President-elect Dale Bumpers has done a clean sweep of the Midwest.

These really are astounding results. As described in the past, American presidential elections have either been squeakers, or they’ve been blowout landslides. This has clearly turned into a blowout landslide for Bumpers and the Democrats, after getting absolutely trounced in 1980 nd 1976, and barely winning in 1972 and 1968. Senator, President-elect Bumpers may well establish an even bigger landslide than Lyndon Johnson did in 1964 in the popular vote, but we’ll have to wait for the results to come in from the more western states to confirm that. In the electoral vote, Bumpers’ margin of victory isn’t quite as big of that of Lyndon Johnson’s, but it is sizable nevertheless.

Looking at the popular vote now, Dale Bumpers has dropped slightly to fifty-nine percent, with Paul Laxalt at forty-one percent. This is still liable to change, but in comparison, Lyndon Johnson holds the record for the popular vote at sixty-one percent in 1964, while Jim Rhodes managed to get sixty point five percent in 1980, just four years ago. Quite the dramatic shift.

We’ll be going to commercial break, but afterward we’ll see how the other states shape up. Senator Dale Bumpers of Arkansas, President-elect of the United States, and Governor Tom Bradley, Vice President-elect, and first African American Vice President-elect of the United States."

 
Election Night: 1984!

please-stand-by-test-screen-vector-id918675332


Join us at 9:30PM EST for more election coverage.
 
Chapter Fifty-Eight - Part Four - Two Tribes
“I’m sorry Paul. If it wasn’t for that darned recession, you would have had this one as a shoe-in. We know the ideas can win. Just not this year.”

  • Press Secretary Ronald Reagan, informing President Paul Laxalt of his electoral defeat, election night, 1984
“Hello, we’re back tonight with more election coverage. Fairly early on in the night, we were able to project Senator Dale Bumpers of Arkansas as the next President of the United States. It’s shaping up to be a landslide, and we have still more results coming in.

With that we can report that Missouri has gone for Bumpers. In the western states, President Paul Laxalt has won Wyoming. This has been a bad night for the President, in a clear rebuke of his administration. Bumpers is also the projected winner in New Mexico, and in Colorado.

This puts the electoral vote at three hundred and eighty-three for Bumpers, and a mere sixty for Laxalt.

There is a jubilant attitude in Little Rock, Arkansas, where Dale Bumpers is headquartered. Bumpers himself is expected to come out to speak to the audience very soon, but for now the stage is being held by regional campaign manager and assistant legal advisor Bill Clinton, who has been the go-between for Bumpers and the audience at his headquarters.

The mood is not nearly as celebratory in Laxalt headquarters at Ormsby House, in Carson City, Nevada, although they’re still trying to keep good cheer. President Laxalt used to own Ormsby House, and was embroiled in a scandal this election cycle on accusations of previous embezzlement of the hotel and casino. The President has categorically denounced these accusations as a political smear. Paul Laxalt sold Ormsby House before he became President, but that didn’t stop him from renting the facilities in defiance of his accusers as his election night headquarters. A full inquiry into the charges of embezzlement are still ongoing.

In Congress, the election results are good news for the Democrats. It looks like the Democrats will be expanding their majority in both the House and the Senate from their results in the 1982 midterms. It also looks like Congress will have strong influence from a liberal philosophy. On the Republican side, there is a fairly even split between supporters and detractors of guaranteed employment, although those in favour of guaranteed employment We also have many gubernatorial races going.

We have another states coming in, and Paul Laxalt has won in Utah. Utah’s a very conservative state that almost always goes Republican. Laxalt has also won in Montana. Laxalt has done very well in the western states, but unfortunately for him that has not applied to the rest of the country.

We are steadily moving westward this election night. The states that have yet to come in are as followed: Idaho, Arizona, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, California, Alaska, and Hawaii.

This election will have interesting ramifications on America’s foreign policy. Although foreign policy polled quite low on voter priorities, President Laxalt and President-elect Bumpers have very different ideas about how to handle foreign affairs. Bumpers has called for a negotiated nuclear disarmament with the Soviet Union, or at least a nuclear freeze, and called for working with the United Nations to bring a peaceful conclusion to the war between Iran and Iraq.

More results coming in from the west, Paul Laxalt has won in Idaho. We can also project that Paul Laxalt has won his home state of Nevada.

As we’re moving on to the West Coast, we’ll have to see how things shape up there. California has been a swing state that has gone with the winning candidate in every election since 1912. Polling in that state has indicated a California victory for Bumpers. Governor Tom Bradley, now Vice President-elect Tom Bradley, is popular in that state and campaigned significantly there along with campaign surrogates. Dale Bumpers, a man who many pundits didn’t take all too seriously, who was accused of not having any clear substance to his politics, has proven his critics wrong with this overwhelming landslide. It looks like Bumpers is on his way to crack over four hundred votes in the electoral college.

We have more results coming in from the west. Paul Laxalt has won Arizona. Arizona, the home state of Barry Goldwater, now once again the Secretary of Defense, although he'll be leaving with the rest of the Laxalt Administration following next year's inauguration.

Indeed, as we were just talking about it, we have the definitive results from the West Coast. Dale Bumpers has captured all three of the West Coast states: California, Oregon, and Washington.

We likely won’t be getting the results from Hawaii and Alaska until much later, as polls are still open there, but this night is a great victory for Dale Bumpers, Tom Bradley, and the whole Democratic Party. I’m sure the Republican Party will have to do some soul-searching. There’s already talk that former Secretary of Defense Alexander Haig, who gave President Laxalt a spirited primary challenge, is the likely Republican nominee four years from now, but Mister Haig has not commented on that this evening.”

 
Republican soul searching is always scary, because it does tend to lead them to people like Al Haig. On the other hand, the Democrats have Bradley, who I have no problems with but can't help but feel will cause some big problems during the Bumpers administration. I sense a major internal conflict coming up for the Democrats over social issues, specifically gay marriage.

Will there be a 58 part 5?
 
This is awesome. Let's hope - and I believe there is some ground for this hope ITTL - that the neoliberal agenda has now been discredited so thoroughly that it remains confined to the fringes of Western political landscapes. Of course there will always be parties and movements and currents which will cater to the interests of the wealthy and the privileged, and I couldn't credibly stand up for the material interests of the unpropertied if I denied the propertied their own political representation. But the ideological popularity (and its hegemony within Economics as a science, for example) of the whole agenda of the Chicago Boys of OTL is certainly not without alternative.

Both parties apparently will continue to be broad tents, and that will have its own set of problems for the strong Democrats now, for sure. But I like it a lot this way. And, yes, your electoral coverages are great reads.
 
I just have to say that I absolutely love the way you do elections.
Thanks! The original inspiration is actually from the long-defunct timeline "America After FDR: Dewey Wins in 1944" by inactive user @Presbyman. That Timeline didn't get much further as the election night coverage itself before tapering off, but I liked their presentation, expanded on the format for my own Timeline.

https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/america-after-fdr-dewey-wins-in-1944.152446/
 
Chapter Fifty-Eight - Part Five - Two Tribes
“...and I want you also to know that, throughout all of my life, because of all the religious training that started at my mother’s apron strings, I have always recognized that no matter what I did in life wasn’t solely because of me, or my energy, or my efforts, or the hard work I may have put into it; I look to the Lord, because I think that’s where we must find that kind of strength, that kind of security.”

  • Vice President Tom Bradley on the evangelical television program “Hour of Power with Bobby Schuller”


“Hello. We now have the full results of this week’s elections, after some delays tallying the total amounts.

As we already know, the Democratic ticket of Senator Dale Bumpers of Arkansas and Governor Tom Bradley of California has won a landslide victory over incumbent President Paul Laxalt of Nevada, and his running mate Senator Ted Stevens of Alaska. While Senator Stevens will be returning to the Senate and presumably continuing in his position as Senate Minority Leader, President Laxalt is expected to return to private life, although he will be facing many legal challenges that have emerged from accusations of embezzlement, as well as potential complicity in the Butz-Cabinet Scandal.

In Congress, the Democrats have expanded their majority in both the House and Senate. New members of the House for the Democrats have a distinctly liberal characteristic, which some have called the Recession Wave. These freshman representatives are likely to work closely to the agenda of President-elect Bumpers. It is expected that the President-elect will be meeting with Democratic Congressional leadership to plan the coming term. The President-elect will also be briefed by the President on essential matters of national security.

The President-elect has been congratulated by world leaders. A joint statement has been issued by the co-leaders of the Soviet Union, Premier Andrei Kirilenko and Chairman Mikhail Gorbachev, that new agreements could be reached with a new administration in the United States. There is also calls by the international community for the United States to negotiate a peaceful resolution to the Iran-Iraq War.

We’ll have to see what Dale Bumpers does, as he prepares for inauguration and assembles his cabinet.

And now, the weather.”


Voter Turnout: 57.8% (Up 5.7%)
genusmap.php

Democratic - Dale Bumpers/Tom Bradley - EV 451 - 59.6%
Republican - Paul Laxalt/Ted Stevens - EV 87 - 41.2%
Voter Turnout: 53.3% (Up 0.7%)
genusmap.php

Republican - Ronald Reagan/George Bush - EV 525 - 58.8%
Democratic - Walter Mondale/Geraldine Ferraro - EV 13 - 40.6%
 
A Change is Gonna Come?
Well, I've had a particularly busy week, but I'm glad I was able to put out the conclusion to the Election of 1984! Now, something to discuss with my audience that (I assume) worships the ground I walk on.

In its current form, Give Peace A Chance was always written with the intention of it being a serialized first draft. The second intention was to abide by a quote attributed to Neil Gaiman: "the purpose of the first draft is to finish it."

Rather than just working on it on my own and probably losing motivation, I decided to write and publish each chapter on a semi-regular basis so that I would have exterior motivation of continuing a story for an audience. The original mission statement was to write to at least the conclusion of the McCarthy Presidency, and to the present day if I was ambitious. Well done, me! I finished the McCarthy Presidency! As I continued into the Rhodes Presidency, I privately decided that Give Peace A Chance would end in 1999, at which point I would revise it into a Completed Timeline version, then do a sequel Timeline from 1999 to Present titled Remember Love: The Legacy of Eugene McCarthy, as well as a pop culture-centric spin-off timeline titled The Pop Culture of Eugene McCarthy. I still intend to do this. However, I have begun to feel that this first draft version is beginning to go as far as it can. There are so many new ideas, suggestions, retcons, narrative additions, and corrections to make that I can't simply go back and edit previous chapters (as long-time readers will remember I occasionally did during brief 'corrective periods').

So, I now have two options before me.

I have a pretty good idea of how the rest of the Timeline is going to go. I could easily keep writing McCarthy at about the same pace I've been doing (roughly one chapter a week), but it would be a deeply flawed product, and I haven't had quite the same motivation since I finished the McCarthy part of McCarthy. Nonetheless, it would be done, and I would be able to go into a private second, third, etcetera, draft before posting the final draft in Completed Timelines.

The other option is I take my first real hiatus (as opposed to the two or three semi-hiatuses I've done) to read the stack of research I've yet to read, finish the Master List of congressmen, and write the Timeline from the top in an objectively improved form in a Give Peace A Chance 2.0/Redux/Second Coming thread. I'm inclined to this option, but I think you guys deserve some input too.

So that's the situation. No matter what you all say, I greatly appreciate your comments, suggestions, and time in regularly reading this thing. I'm very proud of my work on McCarthy, but, what I'm most proud of is the noticeable increase in Eugene McCarthy related content here on the forums since I started this Timeline. One of the main reasons I staked out Eugene McCarthy as my first project is because there was only one other McCarthy TL, and it unfortunately didn't get very far (The Color of Your Dreams). To be honest, the pick was mostly out of vanity: I liked the idea of exclusively 'owning' a historical figure that had never been seriously looked at by the rest Alternate History.com. But, now I think I like the idea even more of having introduced an important, underrepresented historical figure to so many people on this site.

That's all for now.
 
Personally I would prefer to see you finish this thread up to 1999, then edit the finished timeline version as you please. But I would be happy to see a reboot, especially if we get to see more of who is in Congress.
 
So, I now have two options before me.

It seems like you guys are inclined towards Give Peace Another Chance, but I'll leave some more time for commentary before coming to a final decision.
From where I'm sitting, it seems like you very much prefer one of the two options. And if you prefer an option, it stands to reason you'll enjoy writing it more and the end product will be of a higher quality. So fire ahead with your revised version - it should be worth the wait.
 
From where I'm sitting, it seems like you very much prefer one of the two options. And if you prefer an option, it stands to reason you'll enjoy writing it more and the end product will be of a higher quality. So fire ahead with your revised version - it should be worth the wait.
Noted.

For Give Peace Another Chance, are there particular things you guys would like to see more of in the Timeline? I already know how I'm going to change the style of writing, but, are there certain events or people that I might've missed, or that anyone would like covered in more detail?
 
Top