Germans start fighting a defensive war Sept 1942 (plus level HE177)

Deleted member 1487

I don't know about that, the first few chapters would be interesting but then the rest of the book would be them basically telling the other how they don't know what they're talking about.
When you get to the point of not agreeing on basic facts, you're left with nothing else.

Interesting that two such well informed and well read (on the subject of WWII on the Eastern Front) fellows can disagree so much with each other.
I usually end up leaving these threads both informed and a bit confused at the same time.
Hint: I'm right ;)

Later I'll have the time to respond to him.
 
Later I'll have the time to respond to him.

I unfortunately probably won't be able to get a serious reply to any until Wednesday due to work.

(The Wiking - Obsessed debate is interesting as usual. Those two should take all these posts from the board and edit them into an interesting book. I bet it would sell)

Someone, I think it was The Red, was on the verge of shipping us together once. We both basically told him "Hell No", albeit in different ways, and he didn't.
 
Last edited:
Top